HomeMy WebLinkAboutDAQ-2025-0019551
DAQC-359-25
Site ID 10355 (B5)
MEMORANDUM
TO: CEM FILE – PACIFICORP GADSBY PLANT
THROUGH: Harold Burge, Major Source Compliance Section Manager
FROM: Rob Leishman, Environmental Scientist
DATE: April 9, 2025
SUBJECT: Source: Gadsby Power Plant Units 1-6
Contact: Tom Wiscomb – 801-220-2373
Leah Tiberius – 801-220-7708
Location: Gadsby Power Plant, Salt Lake City, Salt Lake County, UT
Test Contractor: Mostardi Platt
FRS ID#: UT0000004903500068
Permit/AO#: Title V operating permit #3500068006 dated January 30, 2024
Subject: Review of RA/PST Report dated October 10, 2024
On October 15, 2024, Utah Division of Air Quality (DAQ) received a Relative Accuracy/Performance
Specification Test (RA/PST) report for the Gadsby Power Plant Units 1-6 in Salt Lake City, Utah. Testing
was performed on August 27-29, 2024, to determine the relative accuracy of the O2, NOX, CO2, and CO
monitoring systems. The DAQ-calculated test results are:
RA/PST EVALUATION:
Unit 1
NSPS RATA - Test Date - 8/26/2024
Primary
Channel Manufacturer Serial No. Units CEM
Value
RM
Value
Relative
Accuracy Status
CO2 Thermo 41iQHL-ABN 12305124129 % 6.800 6.640 2.9% Passed
NOx Thermo 42iQLS-ACBNN 12309525996 ppm @ 3% O2 120.650 116.358 1.8% Passed
lbs/MMBtu 0.146 0.140 5.0% Passed
lbs/hr 69.500 66.524 2.0% Passed
Stack Test Deviation Report
There were no deviations observed during testing.
Calibration gases were in date and met performance specifications.
1 8 2
2
Unit 1
Acid Rain Tests - Test Date - 8/26/2024
Primary
Channel Manufacturer Serial No. Units CEM
Value
RM
Value
Relative
Accuracy Status Testing
Frequency
NOx Thermo 41iQHL-ABN 12305124129 lbs/MMBtu 0.146 0.140 5.20% Passed Annual
CO2 Thermo 42iQLS-ACBNN 12309525996 % 6.800 6.647 2.89% Passed
Equation - Di (Rmi – CEMi)
Rmi = 0.1402
CEMi = 0.1464
Di = 0.0062 Passed
Unit 2
NSPS RATA - Test Date - 8/26/2024
Primary
Channel Manufacturer Serial No. Units CEM
Value
RM
Value
Relative
Accuracy Status
CO2 Thermo 41iQHL-ABN 12305124128 % 6.130 6.020 3.0% Passed
NOx Thermo 42iQLS-ACBNN 12309525997 ppm 70.622 71.664 0.7% Passed
lbs/MMBtu 0.144 0.148 4.1% Passed
lbs/hr 96.611 99.190 2.1% Passed
Stack Test Deviation Report
There were no deviations observed during testing.
Calibration gases were in date and met performance specifications.
Unit 2
Acid Rain Tests - Test Date - 8/26/2024
Primary
Channel Manufacturer Serial No. Units CEM
Value
RM
Value
Relative
Accuracy Status Testing
Frequency
NOx Thermo 41iQHL-ABN 12305124128 lbs/MMBtu 0.144 0.148 5.10% Passed Annual
CO2 Thermo 42iQLS-ACBNN 12309525997 % 6.130 6.062 2.89% Passed
Equation - Di (Rmi – CEMi)
Rmi = 0.1483
CEMi = 0.1438
Di = 0.0045 Passed
Unit 3
NSPS RATA - Test Date - 8/27/2024
Primary
Channel Manufacturer Serial No. Units CEM
Value
RM
Value
Relative
Accuracy Status
CO2 Thermo 41iQHL-ABN 12305124127 % 6.450 6.290 2.9% Passed
NOx Thermo 42iQLS-ACBNN 12309525998 ppm @ 3% O2 82.664 86.254 5.2% Passed
lbs/MMBtu 0.099 0.105 6.7% Passed
lbs/hr 75.889 80.692 6.5% Passed
Stack Test Deviation Report
There were no deviations observed during testing.
Calibration gases were in date and met performance specifications.
3
Unit 3
Acid Rain Tests - Test Date - 8/27/2024
Primary
Channel Manufacturer Serial No. Units CEM
Value
RM
Value
Relative
Accuracy Status Testing
Frequency
NOx Thermo 41iQHL-ABN 12305124127 lbs/MMBtu 0.099 0.105 6.90% Passed Annual
CO2 Thermo 42iQLS-ACBNN 12309525998 % 6.456 6.299 2.87% Passed
Equation - Di (Rmi – CEMi)
Rmi = 0.1052
CEMi = 0.0989
Di = 0.0063 Passed
Unit 4
NSPS RATA - Test Date - 8/28/2025
Primary
Channel Manufacturer Serial No. Units CEM
Value
RM
Value
Relative
Accuracy Status
NOx Thermo 42iQLS-ACBNN 12318428624 ppm @ 15% O2 2.736 2.480 7.2% Passed
lbs/MMBtu 0.010 0.009 11.1% Passed
lbs/hr 2.533 2.316 1.4% Passed
O2 Thermo 48iQ-ABC 12305124124 % 16.070 16.200 1.2% Passed
CO Thermo 48iQ-ABC 12305124124 ppm @ 15% O2 1.990 1.091 9.2% Passed
lbs/hr 1.122 0.620 1.9% Passed
Stack Test Deviation Report
There were no deviations observed during testing.
Calibration gases were in date and met performance specifications.
Unit 4
Acid Rain Tests - Test Date - 8/28/2025
Primary
Channel Manufacturer Serial No. Units CEM
Value
RM
Value
Relative
Accuracy Status Testing
Frequency
NOx
Thermo
42iQLS-
ACBNN
12318428624 lbs/MMBtu 0.010 0.009 11.90% Passed Annual
O2 Thermo
48iQ-ABC 12305124124 % 16.078 16.199 0.12% Passed
* NOx Relative Accuracy Tests that exceed 7.5% and has a deviation that is ± 0.015 lb/MMBtu passes and qualifies for
annual testing.
Equation - Di (Rmi – CEMi)
Rmi = 0.0089
CEMi = 0.0100
Di = 0.0011 Passed
4
Unit 5
NSPS RATA - Test Date - 8/28/2024
Primary
Channel Manufacturer Serial No. Units CEM
Value
RM
Value
Relative
Accuracy Status
NOx Thermo 42iQLS-ACBNN 12305124117 ppm @ 15% O2 3.163 3.390 8.5% Passed
lbs/MMBtu 0.012 0.012 8.3% Passed
lbs/hr 3.056 3.309 1.4% Passed
O2 Thermo 48iQ-ABC 12305124125 % 16.220 16.200 0.4% Passed
CO Thermo 48iQ-ABC 12305124125 ppm @ 15% O2 2.038 1.709 3.5% Passed
lbs/hr 1.200 1.015 0.8% Passed
Stack Test Deviation Report
There were no deviations observed during testing.
Calibration gases were in date and met performance specifications.
Unit 5
Acid Rain Tests - Test Date - 8/28/2024
Primary
Channel Manufacturer Serial No. Units CEM
Value
RM
Value
Relative
Accuracy Status Testing
Frequency
NOx Thermo 42iQLS-ACBNN 12305124117 lbs/MMBtu 0.012 0.012 6.60% Passed Annual
O2 Thermo 48iQ-ABC 12305124125 % 16.222 16.205 0.02% Passed
Equation - Di (Rmi – CEMi)
Rmi = 0.0125
CEMi = 0.0117
Di = 0.0008 Passed
Unit 6
NSPS RATA - Test Date - 8/29/2024
Primary
Channel Manufacturer Serial No. Units CEM
Value
RM
Value
Relative
Accuracy Status
NOx Thermo 42iQLS-ACBNN 12309525999 ppm @ 15% O2 2.438 2.336 3.3% Passed
lbs/MMBtu 0.009 0.009 0.0% Passed
lbs/hr 2.289 2.207 0.6% Passed
O2 Thermo 48iQ-ABC 12305124126 % 16.270 16.380 1.2% Passed
CO Thermo 48iQ-ABC 12305124126 ppm @ 15% O2 1.509 1.331 2.8% Passed
lbs/hr 0.867 0.767 0.6% Passed
Stack Test Deviation Report
There were no deviations observed during testing.
Calibration gases were in date and met performance specifications.
5
Unit 6
Acid Rain Tests - Test Date - 8/29/2024
Primary
Channel Manufacturer Serial No. Units CEM
Value
RM
Value
Relative
Accuracy Status Testing
Frequency
NOx Thermo 42iQLS-ACBNN 12309525999 lbs/MMBtu 0.009 0.009 2.80% Passed Annual
O2 Thermo 48iQ-ABC 12305124126 % 16.278 16.384 0.11% Passed
Equation - Di (Rmi – CEMi)
Rmi = 0.0086
CEMi = 0.0089
Di = 0.0002 Passed
DEVIATIONS: No deviations were noted in this report.
CONCLUSION: Pacificorp operates the continuous emissions monitor (CEM) on the
Gadsby Power Plant Units 1-6 stacks to measure O2, NOX, CO2, and CO
emissions. The CEMs were audited by the DAQ and found to meet
quality assurance requirements found in 40 CFR Part 60, Appendix B,
Performance Specification 1, and R307-170, Continuous Emission
Monitoring System Program. Quarterly cylinder gas audits and an annual
relative accuracy test audit were conducted in accordance with the
procedures outlined in UAC R307-170.
RECOMMENDATION: The Pacificorp Gadsby Plant Units 1-6 CEM systems were operating as
required in R307-170 and 40 CFR 60.13 at the time of this evaluation.
HPV: No
ATTACHMENTS: RATA Review Spreadsheets.
RATA Report
Yr*sJftsgRP
C,adsby Plant
1359 W€st tlorfi Temde (rear)
Salt l-ake Clty, UT 84116
Re:
Octobr07,2024
Mr. Bryce Bird, Director
State of Utah
Division of Air Quality
Department of Environmental Quality
P. O. Box 144820
Salt Lake City, Utah 841144820
Rob Leishman
2024 Gadsby Plant Units 1-6 RATA Report
Dear Mr. Bird:
The Relative Accuracy Test Audit (RATA) of the Gadsby Plant Units l-6 Gas Monitors has been
completed per the specifications found in 40 CFR Part 60 and 75. The RATAs were conducted
on August 26 - 29, 2024. Enclosed is the RATA report for Gadsby Plant Units I -6.
I am authorizedto make this submission on behalf of the owners and operators for the affected
source or affected nnits for which the submission is made. I certifu under penalty of the law that I
have personally examined, and am familiar with, the statements and information submitted in this
document and its attachments. Based on my inqurry of those individuals with primary
responsibility for obtaining the information, I certifu that the statements and information are to
the best of my knowledge and believe true, accurate, and complete. I am aware that there are
significant penalties for submitting false statements and information or omitting required
statements and infonnation, including the possibility of fine or imprisonment.
Should you have any questions or concerns, please contact Leah Tiberius Dickson at (801) 220-
7708.
Sincerely,
'SU()d,- il4
Plant Manager - Gadsby Plant
Responsible Offrcial
Enclosures
ti '.\+J tlEpAHTt.tEN L
OF AR
Youn Joo Kim - EPA Region VIII w/enclosure
Continuous Emissions
Monitoring Relative
Accuracy Test Audit
Test Report
UJ-(d
frl9.$
o{U
1-{(d+,ao
E
PacifiCorp
Gadsby Power Plant
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3,
Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Salt Lake City, Utah
Project No. M243506
August 26 through 29,2024
mostardii-platt
Continuous Emissions Monitoring
Relative Accuracy Test Audit Test Report
PacifiCorp
Gadsby Power Plant
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3,
Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Salt Lake Gity, Utah
August 26 through 29, 2024
Report Submittal Date
October 2,2024
@ Copyright2024
All rights reserved in
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
I
T
T
T
T
T
I
I
T
T
T
I
I
T
T
T
T
I
I
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1.0 EXECUTTVE SUMMARY............... ............................1
2.0 TEST METHODOLOGY............ ...........5
Method 3A Orygen (Oz)/Carbon Dioxide (COz) Determination......... .............5
Method 7E Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) Determination .....................6
Method 10 Carbon Monoxide (CO) Determination......... ............7
3.0 TEST RESULT SUMMARIES ..............8
APPENDICES
Appendix A - Company AETB Certification ..........40
Appendix B - Ql Certification(s) for Field Personnel.... .............43
Appendix C - Test Section Diagrams ...................45
Appendix D - Sample Train Dia9ram................. .......................52
Appendix E - Calculation Nomenclature and Formulas..... .......54
Appendix F - Reference Method Test Data (Computerized Sheets).. ..........61
Appendix G - Continuous Emissions Monitoring System Data and Plant Operating Data ..................80
Appendix H - Calibration and Response Time Data............ ....................... 143
Appendix I - Calibration Gas Cylinder Data........ .................... 180
Appendix J - NOz to NO Converter Efficiency Test ................192
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
OMostardi Platt
I
T
T
I
T
T
I
T
I
T
I
I
I
T
T
I
I
I
t
1.0 EXEGUTIVE SUMMARY
Mostardi Platt conducted a Continuous Emissions Monitoring System (CEMS) Relative Accuracy
Test Audit (RATA) test program for PacifiCorp at the Gadsby Power Plant in Salt Lake City, Utah,
on the gas-fired boiler stacks, designated as Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6, on
August 26 through 29, 2024. This report summarizes the results of the test program and test
methods used in accordance with the Test Protocol dated June 26, 2024. Mostardi Platt is a self-
certified air emissions testing body (AETB). A copy of Mostardi Platt's self-certification can be
found in Appendix A.
The test locations, test dates, and test parameters are summarized below.
The purpose of the test program was to determine the relative accuracies of Unit 1, Unit 2 and
Unit 3 COz and NO, analyzers; and Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6 the Oz, CO, and NO* analyzers
during the specified operating condition. The test results from this test program indicate that each
CEMS component meets the United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) annual
performance specification for relative accuracy as published in 40 Code of Federal Regulations
Part 75 (40CFR75) and Part 60 (40CFR60).
P@ect No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
TEST INFORMATION
Test Locations Test Dates Test Parameters
Unit 1 August 26,2024
Nitrogen Oxides (NO,) and
Carbon Dioxide (COz)Unit 2 August 26,2024
Unit 3 August 27,2024
Unit 4 August 28,2024
Nitrogen Oxides (NOx), Carbon
Monoxide (CO)and Orygen (Oz)Unit 5 August 28,2024
Unit 6 August 29,2024
'I of 199 OMostardi Platt
UNIT 1 RATA RESULTS
Test
Location Date Parameter Units
Relative Accuracy
Acceptance Criteria
Relative Accuracy
(RA)
Bias Adjustment
Factor (BAF)
Unit 1 8t26t24
NO,lb/mmBtu s 7 5% of the mean
reference value 5.19o/o 1.000
NO,ppmvd @
3o/o Oz
3 20o/o of the mean
reference value 5.11%N/A
NO,lb/hr 320o/o of the mean
reference value 5.32%N/A
COz o/o dry 3 7 .5o/o of the mean
reference value 2.95o/o N/A
I
t
T
I
I
I
I
T
I
T
T
I
I
I
T
I
I
T
I
UNIT 2 RATA RESULTS
Test
Location Date Parameter Units
Relative Accuracy
Acceptance Criteria
Relative Accuracy
(RA)
Bias Adjustment
Factor (BAF)
Unit 2 8t26t24
NO,lb/mmBtu 37.5o/o of the mean
reference value 4.24o/o 1.026
NO,ppmvd @
3% Oz
s 20% of the mean
reference value 4.56%N/A
NO,lb/hr s20% of the mean
reference value 4.32o/o N/A
COz %dry 3 7.5o/o of the mean
reference value 2.93%N/A
UNIT 3 RATA RESULTS
Test
Location Date Parameter Units
Relative Accuracy
Acceptance Criteria
Relative Accuracy
(RA)
Bias Adjustment
Factor (BAF)
Unit 3 8t27t24
NO,lb/mmBtu < 7 .5% of the mean
reference value 6.59%1.062
NO,ppmvd @
3o/o Oz
3 20o/o of the mean
reference value 5.17o/o N/A
NO,lb/hr 3 20o/o of the mean
reference value 6.41%N/A
COz %dry 57.5o/o of the mean
reference value 2.93o/o N/A
Project No. M243506
Unit '1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
2 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
I
I
T
I
I
t
I
I
I
I
T
I
T
I
T
I
I
I
T
Project No. M243506
Unit 1. Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
UNIT 4 RATA RESULTS
Test
Location Date Parameter Units
Relative Accuracy
Acceptance Criteria
Relative Accuracy
(RA}
Bias Adjustment
Factor (BAF)
Unit 4 8t28t24
NO,lb/mmBtu < 0.015 lb/mmBtu
mean difference
-0.001 lb/mmBtu
mean difference 1.000
NO,ppmvd @
15o/o Oz
3 20% of the mean
reference value 13.33%N/A
NO,lb/hr 320% of the mean
reference value 14.49o/o N/A
Oz o/o dry <7.5% of the mean
reference value 1.49o/o N/A
co lb/hr
< 10% ofthe
applicable standard
of 9 lb/hr per
Performance
Specification 6 (PSO)
5.65%N/A
co ppmvd @
15% Oz
S 5 ppm mean
difference plus
confidence
coefficient
0.93 ppm mean
difference + cc N/A
UNIT 5 RATA RESULTS
Test
Location Date Parameter Units
Relative Accuracy
Acceptance Criteria
Relative Accuracy
(RA)
Bias Adjustment
Factor (BAF)
Unit 5 8t28t24
NO,lb/mmBtu s 0.015 lb/mmBtu
mean difference
0.001 lb/mmBtu
mean difference 1.076
NO,ppmvd @
15o/o Oz
3 20o/o of the mean
reference value 9.42%N/A
NO,lb/hr 3 20o/o of the mean
reference value 9.79o/o N/A
Oz o/o dry < 7 .5% of the mean
reference value 0.35o/o N/A
co lb/hr
< 10% ofthe
applicable standard
of 9 lb/hr per PS6
2.2Oo/o N/A
CO ppmvd @
15o/o Oz
s 5 ppm mean
difference plus
confidence
coefficient
0.36 ppm mean
difference + cc N/A
3 of 199 @Mostardi Plaft
UNIT 6 RATA RESULTS
Test
Location Date Parameter Units
Relative Accuracy
Acceptance Criteria
Relative Accuracy
(RA)
Bias Adjustment
Factor (BAF)
Unit 6 8t29t24
NO,lb/mmBtu 37.5o/o of the mean
reference value 4.18%1.000
NO,ppmvd @
15% Oz
s 20% of the mean
reference value 6.77%N/A
NO,lb/hr S 20o/o of the mean
reference value 6.08%N/A
Oz %dry < 7 .5% of the mean
reference value 1.39o/o N/A
co lb/hr
< 10% of the
applicable standard
of 9 lb/hr per PS6
1.66%N/A
co ppmvd @
15o/o Oz
s 5 ppm mean
difference plus
confidence
coefficient
0.29 ppm mean
difference + cc N/A
I
T
T
I
t
T
I
t
I
I
I
I
T
I
T
T
I
I
I
The gas cylinders used to perform the RATA are summarized below.
GAS CYLINDER INFORMATION
Parameter Gas Vendor Cylinder Serial
Number Cylinder Value Expiration Date
NOx Airgas cc262396 5.004 Mar 03, 2026
NOx Airgas cc725287 9.017 May'15,2026
NOx Airgas EB0142043 90.32 Apr 23,2032
NOx Airgas cc257347 183.3 Aug 23, 2029
COz Airgas E80140992 8.904 Apr 09, 2032
COz Airgas 1159610 9.912 Jan 29,2032
COz Airgas E80088900 18.45 4pr22,2032
Oz Airgas 1159610 9.891 Jan 29.2032
Oz Airgas EB0140992 10.5'1 Apr 09, 2032
Oz Airgas EB0088900 22.57 Apr 22,2032
CO Airgas E80091 1 88 4.898 Feb 05, 2029
co Airgas cc116370 4.974 Aug 28, 2031
co Airgas E80007336 10.02 Oct 02, 2031
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
4 of t99 OMostardi Platt
I
t
I
t
I
T
T
I
I
T
T
I
t
I
T
T
I
No deviations, additions, or exclusions from the test protocol, test methods, the Mostardi Platt
Quality Manual, or the ASTM D7036-12 occurred. The specific test conditions encountered did
not interfere with the collection of the data. The identification of individuals associated with the
test program is summarized below.
Copies of the Ql certifications for test personnel are included in Appendix B.
2.0 TEST METHODOLOGY
Emission testing was conducted following the United States Environmental Protection Agency
(USEPA) methods specified in Title 40 of the Code of Federal Regulations, Part 75 (40CFR75)
and 40CFR60, Appendix A, in addition to the Mostardi Platt Quality Manual and the test protocol.
Schematics of the test section diagram and sampling train used are included in Appendix C and
D respectively. Calculation and nomenclature are included in Appendix E. Copies of analyzer
print-outs for each test run are included in Appendix F. CEM data and process data, as provided
by PacifiCorp - Gadsby Power Plant, a Berkshire Hathaway Energy company, are included in
Appendix G.
The following methodologies were used during the test program:
Method 3A Oxygen (Oz)/Carbon Dioxide (COz) Determination
Stack gas Oz and COz concentrations were determined in accordance with USEPA Method 3A,
40CFR60, Appendix A. A Servomex analyzer was used to determine the Oz and COz
concentrations in the manner specified in the Method. The instrument has a paramagnetic
detector and the 02 operates in the nominal range of 0%lo25o/o. The COz operates in the nominal
range of 0% lo 20%. High-range calibrations were performed using USEPA Protocol gas. Zero
nitrogen (a low ppm pollutant in balance nitrogen calibration gases) was introduced during other
instrument calibrations to check instrument zero. High- and mid-range levels in balance nitrogen
were also introduced. Zero and mid-range calibrations were performed using USEPA Protocol
gas after each test run. Copies of the gas cylinder certifications are found in Appendix l. This
testing met the performance specifications as outlined in the Method.
I
T
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
TEST PERSONNEL INFORMATION
Location Address Contact
Test Coordinators PacifiCorp
Gadsby Power Plant
1359 West North Temple Street
Salt Lake City, UT 84116
Tom Wiscomb
Senior Environmental Analyst
(801) 220-2373 (phone)
Thomas. \Mscom b@ Pac ifiCoro. com
Leah Tiberius
Environmental Analyst
(801) 220-7708 (phone)
Leah.Tiberius@PacifiCoro.com
Testing Company
Supervisor
Mostardi Platt
888 lndustrial Drive
Elmhurst, lllinois 60126
Christopher S. Eldridge
Field Operations & Training Lead
630-993-2100 (phone)
celdridge@mp-mail.com
Ql Group V (certified on211812021\
Testing Company
Personnel
Daniel Snader
Test Enoineer
Jacob Anderson
Test Technician
5 of '199 @Mostardi Platt
Method 7E Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) Determination
Stack gas NO, concentrations and emission rates were determined in accordance with USEPA
Method 78, 40CFR60, Appendix A. A Thermo Scientific Model 42i Chemiluminescence Nitrogen
Oxides Analyzer was used to determine nitrogen oxides concentrations, in the manner specified
in the Method. The instrument operated in the nominal range determined by the high-level span
calibration gas.
The Model 42i operates on the principle that nitric oxide (NO) and ozone (Oo) react to produce a
characteristic luminescence with an intensity linearly proportional to the NO concentration.
lnfrared light emission results when electronically excited NOz molecules decay to lower energy
states. Specifically,
[rlQ+Q3+NO2+@2+ fip
Nitrogen dioxide (NOz) must first be transformed into NO before it can be measured using the
chemiluminescent reaction. NOz is converted to NO by a molybdenum NOz-to-NO converter
heated to a minimum of 320"C. The flue gas sample is drawn into the Model 42i through the
sample bulkhead. The sample flows through a capillary, and then to the mode solenoid valve.
The solenoid valve routes the sample either straight to the reaction chamber (NO mode) or
through the NOzto-NO converter and then to the reaction chamber (NOx mode). A flow sensor
prior to the reaction chamber measures the sample flow. Dry air enters the Model 42i through the
dry air bulkhead, passes through a flow switch, and then through a silent discharge ozonator. The
ozonator generates the ozone needed for the chemiluminescent reaction. At the reaction
chamber, the ozone reacts with the NO in the sample to produce excited NOz molecules. A
photomultiplier tube (PMT) housed in a thermoelectric cooler detects the luminescence generated
during this reaction. From the reaction chamber, the exhaust travels through the ozone (Os)
converter to the pump and is released through the vent.
The NO and NOx concentrations calculated in the NO and NOx modes are stored in memory. The
difference between the concentrations is used to calculate the NOz concentration. The Model42i
outputs NO, NOz, and NO, concentrations to the front panel display, the analog outputs, and also
makes the data available over the serial or ethernet connection.
Stack gas was delivered to the analyzer via a Teflon@ sampling line, heated to a minimum
temperature of 250"F. Excess moisture in the stack gas was removed using a refrigerated
condenser. The entire system was calibrated in accordance with the Method, using USEPA
Protocol gases introduced at the probe, before and after each test run. This testing met the
performance specifications as outlined in the Method.
A list of calibration gases used and the results of all calibration and other required quality
assurance checks are found in Appendix H. Copies of the gas cylinder certifications are found in
Appendix l. A direct inject NOz gas converter efficiency test was performed as described in
Section 8.2.4.1 of Method 7E. The NOz to NO converter efficiency test can be found in Appendix
J. This testing met the performance specifications as outlined in the Method.
Project No. M243506
Unit 'l, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
I
T
T
t
I
T
I
T
I
T
I
I
I
I
T
I
I
t
T
6 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
t
T
I
I
I
I
I
t
T
T
t
I
I
I
I
I
t
I
T
Method 10 Carbon Monoxide (GO) Determination
Stack gas CO concentrations and emission rates were determined in accordance with USEPA
Method 10, 40CFR60, Appendix A. A Thermo Scientific Model4Si Gas Filter Correlation Analyzer,
in the manner specified in the Method. The instrument operated in the nominal range of 0 ppm to
20 ppm with the specific range determined by the high-level span calibration gas of 10.02 ppm.
The Model 48i operates on the principle that CO absorbs infrared radiation at a wavelength of 4.6
microns. Because infrared absorption is a non-linear measurement technique, it is necessary to
transform the basic analyzer signal into a linear output. The Model 48i uses an internally stored
calibration curve to accurately linearize the instrument output over any range up to a concentration
of 10,000 ppm. The sample is drawn into the Model4Sithrough the sample bulkhead. The sample
flows through the optical bench. Radiation from an infrared source is chopped and then passed
through a gas filter alternating between CO and Nz. The radiation then passes through a narrow
bandpass interference filter and enters the optical bench where absorption by the sample gas
occurs. The infrared radiation then exits the optical bench and falls on an infrared detector. The
CO gas filter acts to produce a reference beam which cannot be further attenuated by CO in the
sample cell. The Nz side of the filter wheel is transparent to the infrared radiation and therefore
produces a measurement beam which can be absorbed by CO in the cell. The chopped detector
signal is modulated by the alternation between the two gas filters with an amplitude related to the
concentration of CO in the sample cell. Other gases do not cause modulation of the detector
signal since they absorb the reference and measure beams equally. Thus, the GFC system
responds specifically to CO. The Model 48i outputs the CO concentration to the front panel
display, the analog outputs, and also makes the data available over the serial or Ethernet
connection.
Stack gas was delivered to the analyzer via a Teflon@ sampling line, heated to a minimum
temperature of 250'F. Excess moisture in the stack gas was removed using a refrigerated
condenser. The entire system was calibrated in accordance with the Method, using certified
calibration gases introduced at the probe, before and after each test run.
A list of calibration gases used and the results of all calibration and other required quality
assurance checks are found in Appendix H. Copies of the gas cylinder certifications are found in
Appendix l. This testing met the performance specifications as outlined in the Method.
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
7 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
I
I
T3.1 Unit 1
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
3.0 TEST RESULT SUMMARIES
I
I
I
T
t
T
T
I
I
I
I
T
I
I
T
I
Client PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Fuel Type: Natural Gas
Location: Unit 1
Date:8126124
Test Method: 7E, 3A
Fuel Factor: 1040
CO2 based NOx lb/mmBtu RATA
CEM Analvzer lnformation
NO, Monitor/Model:Thermo 42iQLS-ACBNN NO. Serial #:1 2309525996
CO2 Monitor/Mode!:Thermo 41OiQHL-ABN CO2 Serial #:12305124129
1 =acce pt
0=reject
Test
Run Iest Date Start Time End Time RM NOX
lb/MMBtu
GEM NOX
lb/MMBtu
(RMCEM)
Difference
(di)
(RMCEM)
Difference2
(di2)
1 08t26t24 08:09 08:29 0.1 36 0.141 -0.005 0.000025
2 08t26t24 08:39 08:59 o.1v 0.1 39 4.005 0.000025
3 o8t26124 09:07 09:27 0.1 36 o.142 -0.006 0.000036
4 o8,t26t24 09:36 09:56 0.1 39 0.146 -0.007 0.000049
5 08t26t24 10:04 10:24 0.1 40 0.145 -0.005 0.000025
b 08126124 10:33 10:53 0.138 0.145 -0.007 0.000049
7 08126t24 11'.O4 11'.24 0.143 0.'t51 4.008 0.0000&1
0 8 o8t26124 11:33 11:53 0.145 0.1 54 4.009 0.000081
1 9 08t26t24 12:05 12:25 o.147 0.1 53 4.006 0.000036
1 10 o$t26t24 12:U 12'.il 0.148 0.1 56 -0.008 0.0000&r
n 9
(0.025)2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 0.140 RM avq
Mean CEM Value 0.146 CEM avq
Sum of Differences {.057 di
Mean Difference {.006 d
Sum of Differences Squared 0.000 di2
Standard Deviation 0.001 sd
Confi de nce Coefficie nt 2.5% Enor fi -tail)0.001 cc
Relative Accuracv 5.19 RA
Bias Adiustment Factor 1.000 BAF
8 of 199 OMostardi Platt
T
T
I
T
T
I
t
T
I
T
I
I
t
T
T
T
T
I
T
Proiect No. M243506
Unit 'l , Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Client PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Location: Unit 1
DaE:8126124
Test Method: 7E, 3A
NOx ppmvd @3o/o 02 RATA
CEM Analyzer lnformation
NO, Monitor/Model:Ihermo 42iOLS-ACBNN NO, Serial #:12309525996
1=accept
0=reject
Test
Run Iest Date Start Time End Time
RM NOx
ppmvd @ 3
va2
CEM NOx
ppmvd @ 3
o/o2
(RM.cEM)
Difference
(di)
(RMCEM)
Difference2
(di2)
1 1 o8126t24 08:09 08:29 1 13.9 115.9 -2.O 4.00
1 2 08126124 08:39 08:59 111.1 114.2 -3.1 9.61
1 3 08126124 09:07 09:27 113.4 1',t7.1 -3.7 13.69
I 4 ogt26t24 09:36 09:56 't't6.0 120.1 4.1 16.81
1 5 o8t26124 10:04 1O:24 116.7 119.7 -3.0 9.00
1 6 o&t26124 10:33 10:53 116.8 119.4 -2.6 6.76
1 7 08126t24 11 M 11:24 120.2 124.6 4.4 19.36
0 8 08t26t24 11:33 11:53 117.5 126.4 -8.9 79.21
1 I o8126124 12:OS 12:25 118.7 126.3 -7.6 57.76
1 10 ogt26t24 12:?4 12:54 120.3 128.4 -8.1 65.61
n 9
t(0.975)2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 116.W RM avo
Mean CEM Value 120.633 CEM avg
sum ot Drnerences -38.600 di
Mean Difference 4.289 d
Sum of Differences Squareo 202.600 di2
Standard Deviation 2.152 sd
Confidence Coefficient 2.5% Error (1-tail 1.654
Relative Accuracr 5.1 I RA
I of 199 OMostardi Platt
Client PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Planl
Project #: M243506
Location: Unit 1
Date:8126124
Test Method: 7E,2
NO,lb/hr RATA
CEM Analvzer lnformation
NO, Monitor/Model:Thermo 42iOLS-ACBNN NO, Serial #:12309525996
1=accept
0=reject
Test
Run Test Date Start Time End Time RM NOX
!b/hr
cEM NOx
lb/hr
(RM4EM)
Difference
(di)
(RM-CEM)
Difference2
(di2)
1 1 08t26t24 08:09 08:29 u.42 66.70 -2.28 5.1 984
1 2 o8t26t24 08:39 08:59 63.30 65.70 -2.40 5.7600
1 3 08t26124 09:07 09:27 u.44 67.50 -3.06 9.3636
1 4 o8t26t24 09:36 09:56 66.10 69.1 0 -3.00 9.0000
1 5 08t26t24 10:04 10.24 66.69 69.20 -2.51 6.3001
1 b o8t26124 10:33 10:53 65.26 68.70 -3.4 11.8336
1 7 ogt26t24 11'.U 11:24 67.92 71.90 -3.98 15.8404
0 I o8t26t24 11:33 11:53 68.72 73.00 4.28 18.3184
1 I 08t26t24 12:O5 12:25 69.60 72.70 -3.10 9.6100
1 10 o8t26t24 12:34 12:54 70.1 5 74.OO -3.85 14.8225
n 9
t(0.975)2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 66.431 RM avq
Mean CEM Value 69.500 CEM avg
Sum of Differences -27.620 di
Mean Difference -3.069 d
Sum of Differences Squared 87.729 diz
Standard Deviation 0.609 sd
Confi dence Coefficient 2.5o/o Error (1 -tai ll 0.468
Relative Accuracv 5,32 RA
I
I
I
t
I
I
I
T
I
I
I
I
I
I
T
I
I
I
T
Project No. M243506
Unit 1. Unit 2. Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
10 of 199 OMostardi Platt
I
I
I
T
I
T
I
T
I
T
I
I
I
I
T
T
I
I
I Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Client PacifCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Location: Unit 1
Dare.:.8126124
Test Method: 34
CO2o/o (dry) RATA
CEM Analvzer lnformation
COz Monitor/Model:Thermo 41O|QHL-ABN CO, Serial # :12305124129
1=accept
0=reject
Test
Run
Test
Date Start Time End Time RM CO2 %
(drv)
cEM GO2 %
(drv)
(RM-cEM)
Difference
(di)
(RM4EM)
Difference2
(di2)
1 1 08t26t24 08:09 08:29 6.7 6.9 -0.2 0.04
1 2 ogt26t24 08:39 08:59 6.8 6.9 -0.1 0.01
,|3 08t26t24 09:07 09:27 6.7 6.8 -0.1 0.01
1 4 08t26t24 09:36 09:56 6.7 6.8 -0.1 0.01
1 5 08t26t24 10:04 10:24 6.6 6.8 -o.2 0.04
1 6 08t26124 10:33 10:53 6.7 6.8 -0.1 0.01
1 7 08126124 l:44 11:24 o.o 6.8 -0.2 0.04
1 I 08t26t24 11:33 11:53 6.5 6.7 -o.2 0.04
0 I 08t26t24 12:05 12:25 6.5 6.8 -0.3 0.09
1 10 08t26t24 12:U 12:34 6.5 6.7 -0.2 0.04
n 9
t(0.02!2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 6.644 RM avq
Mean CEM Value 6.800 CEM avo
Sum of Differencer -1.400 di
Mean Difference 4.1s6 d
Sum of Differences Squared 0.20 daz
Standard Deviatior 0.053 sd
Confi de nce Coeffi cie nt 2.5o/o Error 11 -tail 0.041 cc
Relative Accuracy 2.9s RA
1 1 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
3.2 Unit 2
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
I
T
T
I
t
I
I
I
I
t
I
I
I
I
t
t
I
I
I
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Fuel Type: Natural Gas
Location: Unit 2
Date:8126124
Tes( Method: 7E, 3A
Fuel Factor: 1040
GO2 based NOx lb/mmBtu RATA
CEM Ana lvzer lnformation
NO, Monitor/Model:Thermo 42iQLS-ACBNN NO, Serial #12309525997
CO2 Monitor/Model:Thermo 410iQHL-ABN CO2 Serial #12305124128
1=accept
0=reject
Test
Run Iest Date Start Time End Time RM NOT
!b/MMBtu
CEM NO,
lb/MMBtu
(RMCEM)
Difference
(di)
(RMCEM)
Difference2
(di2)
1 1 08t26t24 08:09 08:29 0.1 38 0.1 34 0.004 0.000016
1 2 08t26t24 08:39 08:59 0.1 35 o.137 -0.002 0.000004
1 3 08126124 09:07 09:27 o.142 0.'t40 0.002 0.000004
1 4 08t26124 09:36 09:56 0.146 0.143 0.003 0.000009
1 5 08126t24 10:04 'lO:24 o.147 o.142 0.005 0.000025
1 6 o8t26124 10:33 10:53 0.1 50 0.144 0.006 0.000036
0 7 08t26t24 11:04 11:24 0.154 0.144 0.010 0.000100
1 8 o8t26t24 11:33 11:53 0.160 0.1 51 0.009 0.000081
1 o o8t26t24 12:O5 12:25 0.1 57 0.1 51 0.006 0.000036
1 10 08t26t24 12:?l 12'.v 0.1 53 0.152 0.001 0.000001
n 9
t(0.025)2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 0.148 RM avq
Mean CEM Value 0.14 CEM avq
Sum of Differences 0.034 di
Mean Difference 0.004 d
Sum of Differences Squared 0.000 daz
Standard Deviation 0.003 sd
Confi dence Coefficient 2.5o/o Error (1 -ta i l)0.002 cc
Relative Accuracy 4-24 RA
Bias Adiustment Factor 1.026 BAF
'12 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
T
I
T
t
I
I
I
t
I
T
t
t
I
t
T
I
I
t
T
Project No. M243506
Unit 1. Unit 2. Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Client PacifCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Location: Unit 2
DaE:8126124
Test Method: 7E, 3A
NOx ppmvd @3% 02 RATA
CEM Analyzer lnformation
NO, Monitor/Model:Thermo 42iOLS-ACBNN NO, Serial #:12309525997
1=accepl
0=reject
Te$
Run Iest Date Start Time End Time
RM NOx
ppmvd @ 3
o/42
CEM NOx
ppmvd @ 3
o/42
(RMCEM)
Difference
(di)
(RMCEM)
Difference2
(di2)
0 1 08126124 08:09 08:29 90.1 109.9 -19.8 392.U
2 08t26t24 08:39 08:59 113.7 113.2 0.5 0.25
1 3 o8t26t24 09:07 09:27 114.3 115.3 -1.0 1.00
1 4 08126t24 09:36 09:56 114.O 117.9 -3.9 15.21
1 5 08t26124 10:O4 10:24 111.3 117.1 -5.8 33.64
1 6 08t26t24 10:33 10:53 112.2 118.5 6.3 39.69
1 7 oBt26124 11:O4 11:24 112.9 118.9 -6.0 36.00
1 8 08t26t24 11:33 11:53 119.3 123.9 4.6 21.16
1 o 08126124 12:O5 12:25 122.7 124.3 1.6 2.ffi
1 10 08t26124 12:34 12:il 123.3 124.9 1.6 2.ffi
n I
(0.e75)2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 115.967 RM avg
Mean CEM Value 1 19.333 CEM avE
Sum of Differences -30.300 da
Mean Difference -3.367 d
Sum of Differences Squared 152.070 di2
Standard Deviation 2.501 sd
Confi dence Coefficient 2.5% Error (1 -tail 1.923
Relative Accuracv 4.55 RA
13 of 199 OMostardi Platl
Client PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Location: Unit 2
Datet 8126124
Test Method: 7E,2
NO,lb/hr RATA
CEM Analvzer lnformation
NO. Monitor/Model:Thermo 42iQLS-ACBNN NO, Serial #:12309525997
1=accept
0=reject
Test
Run Iest Date Start Time End Time RM NOT
lb/hr
cEM NOx
lb/hr
(RM4EM)
Difference
(di)
(RM-cEM)
Difference2
(di2)
1 1 08t26t24 08:09 08:29 92.77 90.10 2.67 7.1289
1 2 o8t26t24 08:39 08:59 91.30 92.90 1.60 2.5600
1 3 o8126t24 09:07 09:27 96.08 94.80 1.28 1.6384
1 4 08t26t24 09:36 09:56 98.94 96.60 2.v 5.4756
1 5 08t26t24 10:04 10:24 98.91 96.00 2.91 8.4681
1 6 08126124 10:33 10:53 101.56 97.20 4.36 19.0096
1 7 o8t26t24 11:04 11:24 103.73 97.60 6.13 37.5769
0 8 08t26t24 11:33 11:53 107.97 101.50 6.47 41.8609
1 I ogt26t24 12:OS 12:25 106.00 101.90 4.10 16.8100
1 10 o8t26t24 12:34 12:54 103.27 102.40 0.87 0.7569
n 9
t(0.975)2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 99.173 RM avg
Mean CEM Value 96.611 CEM avq
Sum of Differences 23.060 di
Mean Difference 2.562 d
Sum of Differences Squared 99.424 di2
Standard Deviation 2.246 'dConfidence Coefficient 2.5Yo Error (1 -tai ll 1.726
Relative Accuracv 4.32 RA
T
t
T
I
I
T
I
t
I
T
t
I
t
I
I
I
I
I
tProject No. M243506
Unit 'l , Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
14 of 199 OMostardi Platt
T
I
I
I
t
I
T
t
I
T
T
I
I
I
t
T
t
I
t Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Client PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Location: Unit 2
Dale:8126124
Test Method: 34
CO2o/o (dry) RATA
CEM Analvzer lnformation
COu Monitor/Model:Thermo 410iQHL-ABN COz Serial #:12305124128
1=accept
0=reject
Test
Run
Test
Date Start Time End Time RM CO2 %
(drv)
cEM CO2 %
(dry)
(RM-CEM)
Difference
(di)
(RMCEM)
Difference2
(di2)
1 1 ogt26t24 08:09 08:29 6.0 6.2 -0.2 0.04
1 2 08t26t24 08:39 08:59 6.1 6.2 -0.1 0.01
1 3 oBt26124 09:07 09:27 6.0 6.2 -o.2 0.M
1 4 08t26124 09:36 09:56 6.0 6.1 -0.'1 0.01
1 5 08126t24 10:(X 10:24 6.0 6.1 -0.1 0.01
1 6 08t26124 10:33 10:53 6.0 6.1 -0.1 0.01
1 7 o8t26t24 11:O4 11:24 6.0 6.2 4.2 0.04
1 8 ogt26124 11:33 11:53 6.0 6.0 0.0 0.00
1 I 08t26124 12:O5 12:25 6.2 6.1 0.1 0.01
0 10 08t26124 12U '12:14 6.4 6.1 0.3 0.09
n 9
t(0.0251 2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 6.033 RM avo
Mean CEM Value 6.r33 CEM avq
Sum of Differences {.900 di
Mean Difference {.100 d
Sum of Differences Squared 0.170 di2
Standard Deviatior 0.100 sd
Confi de nce Coeffi ci e nt 2.5o/o Error (1 -tail o.o77 cc
Relative Accuracy 2.93 RA
15 of ,l99 @Mostardi Platt
3.3 Unit 3
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
I
I
I
T
T
T
I
T
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
T
T
t
I
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Fuel Type: Natural Gas
Location: Unit 3
Date:8127124
Tesil Method: 7E, 34
Fuel Factor: 1040
CO2 based NOx lb/mmBtu RATA
CEM Ana lvzer lnformation
NO, Monitor/Model:Thermo 42iOLS-ACBNN NO, Serial # :12309525998
CO2 Monitor/Model:Thermo 410iQHL-ABN CO2 Serial #12305124127
1=accept
0=reject
Test
Run Iest Date Start Time End Time RM NO.
lb/MMBtu
CEM NOI
!b/MMBtu
(RMCEM)
Difference
(di)
(RM4EM)
Difference2
(di2)
I 08t27t24 06:35 06:55 0.097 0.092 0.005 0.000025
1 2 o8t27t24 07:02 07:22 0.1 05 0.099 0.006 0.000036
1 3 08t27t24 O7:28 07:48 0.1 04 0.099 0.005 0.000025
1 4 o8t27t24 07:55 08:1 5 0.'t 10 0.1 03 0.007 0.000049
1 5 08127t24 08:22 o8'.42 0.109 0.'t01 0.008 0.000064
1 6 o8t27124 08:49 09:09 0.'t08 0.1 03 0.005 0.000025
1 7 08127124 09:1 5 09:35 0.1 09 0.1 03 0.006 0.000036
0 8 08t27124 09:41 10:01 0.1 09 0.099 0.010 0.000100
1 I 08t27t24 10:07 10:27 0.1 00 0.093 0.007 0.000049
,|'t0 o8t27t24 '10:33 10:53 0.1 03 0.097 0.006 0.000036
n 9
(0.025)2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 0.105 RM avo
Mean CEM Value 0.099 CEM avo
Sum of Differences 0.055 di
Mean Difference 0.005 d
Sum of Differences Squared 0.000 di2
Standard Deviation 0.001 sd
Confidence Coefficient 2.5% Error (1-taill 0.001 cc
Relative Accuracv 6.59 RA
Bias Adiusfrnent Factor 1.062 BAF
16 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
T
t
t
T
I
I
T
T
t
T
T
I
I
I
t
t
t
I
T
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Client PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Location: Unit 3
Dale:8127124
Test Method: 7E, 34
NOx ppmvd @3% 02 RATA
CEM Analyzer lnformation
NO, Monitor/Model:Thermo 42iQLS-ACBNf\NO" Serial #:12309525998
1=accept
0=reject
Test
Run Test Date Start Time End Time
RM NOx
ppmvd @ 3
"/42
CEM NOx
ppmvd @ 3
o/42
(RMCEM)
Difference
(di)
(RM-CEM)
Difference2
(di2)
1 1 08t27t24 06:35 06:55 78.8 75.7 3.1 9.61
1 2 08t27t24 07:O2 07:22 85.7 81.5 4.2 17.U
1 3 08127t24 07:28 07:48 84.8 81.2 3.6 12.96
1 4 08t27t24 07:55 08:1 5 89.1 84.8 4.3 18.49
1 5 08t27t24 08:22 08:42 88.2 83.7 4.5 20.25
1 6 08t27t24 08:49 09:09 87.8 84.8 3.0 9.00
1 7 08t27t24 09:1 5 09:35 88.3 84.3 4.0 16.00
0 8 08t27t24 09:41 10:01 88.7 81.8 6.9 47.61
1 I o8t27t24 10:07 1O:27 81.4 76.6 4.8 23.U
1 10 08t27124 10:33 10:53 u.1 80.1 4.0 16.00
n 9
(0.s75)2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 85.356 F(M avo
Mean CEM Value B'.|..411 CEM avo
Sum of Differences 35.500 di
Mean Difference 3.94 d
Sum of Differences Squared 142.990 di2
Standard Deviation 0.609 rd
Confi dence Coeffi cient 2.5o/o Error (1 -taill 0.468
Relative Accuracv 5.17 RA
17 of '199 OMostardi Platt
Client PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Location: Unit 3
Dare.:8127124
Test Method: 7E,2
NO,lb/hr RATA
CEM Analvzer lnformation
NO. Monitor/Model:Thermo 42iQLS-ACBNN NO, Serial # :12309525998
1 =accept
0=reject
Test
Run Iest Date Start Time End Time RM NOX
lb/hr
cEM NOx
lb/hr
(RM-cEM)
Difference
(di)
(RM-cEM)
Difference2
(di2)
1 1 o8t27124 06:35 06:55 75.4 71.70 3.74 13.9876
1 2 o8t27124 07:02 07:22 80.66 76.1 0 4.56 20.7936
1 3 08127t24 O7:28 07:48 79.53 75.20 4.33 18.7489
1 4 08t27t24 07:55 08:1 5 83.68 78.60 5.08 25.8064
1 5 o8t27t24 08:22 08:42 83.23 77.60 5.63 31.6969
1 6 o8t27t24 08:49 09:09 82.91 78.80 4.11 16.8921
1 7 o8t27t24 09:'15 09:35 83.42 78.50 4.92 24.206/.
0 8 o8t27t24 09:41 10:01 83.87 76.00 7.87 61.9369
1 9 o8t27124 10:07 10:27 76.U 71.30 5.34 28.5156
1 't0 o8t27t24 10:33 10:53 79.78 75.20 4.58 20.976/.
n 9
t(0.975)2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 80.s88 RM avg
Mean CEM Value 75.889 3EM avg
Sum of Differences 42.290 ci
Mean Difference 4.699 c
Sum of Differences Squared 201.624 il2
Standard Deviation 0.603 'dConfi de nce Coefficient 2.5o/o Error (1 -ta i I )0.463 ;c
Relative Accuracv 6.41 RA
t
I
T
I
I
I
I
t
I
t
t
I
t
I
t
I
T
I
I
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
18 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
I
I
I
I
T
I
I
t
T
T
T
T
I
I
t
I
I
I
T
Project No. M243506
Unit 'l , Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Client PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Location: Unit 3
Date:8127124
Test Method: 3A
CO2o/o (dry) RATA
CEM Analvzer !nformation
COz Monitor/Model:Thermo 410iQHL-ABN COz Serial #:12305124127
1=accept
0=reject
Test
Run
Test
Date Start Time End Time RM CO2 %
(dry)
cEM CO2 %
(drv)
(RMCEM)
Difference
(di)
(RM.cEM)
Difference2
(di2)
1 1 08t27t24 06:35 06:55 6.4 6.5 -0.1 0.01
1 2 o8t27t24 07:O2 07:22 6.3 6.4 -0.1 0.01
1 3 o8t27124 07:28 07:48 6.3 6.4 -0.1 0.01
1 4 08t27t24 07:55 08:1 5 6.3 6.4 -0.1 0.01
1 5 o8t27t24 08:22 08:42 6.3 6.5 -o.2 0.04
1 b 08t27t24 08:49 09:09 6.3 6.5 -0.2 0.04
1 7 08t27t24 09:1 5 09:35 6.3 6.4 -0.1 0.01
1 8 08t27t24 09:41 10:01 6.3 6.5 -0.2 0.04
1 I o8t27t24 10:07 10:27 6.3 6.5 -0.2 0.04
0 10 08t27t24 10:33 10:53 6.3 6.5 -o.2 0.04
n I
(0.02sI 2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 6.311 F(M avo
Mean CEM Value 6.456 ;EM avq
Sum of Differences -1.300 li
Mean Difference 4.14 I
Sum of Differences Squared 0.210 di2
Standard Deviation 0.053 d
Gonfidence Coefficient 2.5o/o Error (1 -ta i I l 0.041
Relative Accuracv 2.93 RA
19 of 199 OMostardi Platt
3.4 Unit 4
A Relative accuracy for low enission sources w ith t0, erissions of s 0.200 lbs/nnEltu based on a nean dilference ol
+/. 0.015|bs/nrrtstu for annual RATA testing, or +/- 0.020 lbs/nrrBtu for seni-annual RATA testing.
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
T
I
T
t
T
I
I
T
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Fuel Type: Natural Gas
Location: Unit 4
Date:8128124
Tes{ Method: 7E, 34
Fuel Factor: 8710
02 based NOx lb/mmBtu RATA
CEM Ana lvzer !nformation
NO. Monitor/Model:Thermo 42iOLS-ACBNN NO, Serial #:12318428624
02 Monitor/Model:Thermo 48iO-ABC 02 Serial #:12305124124
1 =a cce pt
0=reject
Test
Run Test Date Start Time End Time RM NOX
lb/MMBtu
cEM NOx
!b/MMBtu
(RMCEM)
Difference
(di)
(RM4EM)
Difference2
(di2)
0 1 o8t28t24 06:35 06:55 0.006 0.008 -0.002 0.000004
1 2 o8t28t24 07:07 07:27 0.007 0.008 -0.001 0.000001
0 3 o8t28t24 07:39 07:59 0.008 0.010 -0.002 0.000004
1 4 o8t28t24 08:12 08:32 0.004 0.005 -0.001 0.000001
1 5 o8t28t24 08:44 09:M 0.011 0.013 {.002 0.0000M
1 6 08128t24 09:1 7 09:37 0.009 0.009 0.000 0.000000
1 7 08t28124 09:49 10:09 0.009 0.010 -0.001 0.000001
1 8 o8,t28t24 1021 1O:41 0.009 0.010 -0.001 0.000001
1 9 o8t28t24 11:03 11:23 0.011 0.012 -0.001 0.000001
1 't0 o8128124 11:35 1'l:55 0.010 0.011 4.001 0.000001
1 11 o1t28t24 12:07 12'.27 0.011 o.o12 -0.001 0.000001
n I
(0.0251 2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 0.009 RM avq
Mean GEM Value 0.010 CEM avq
Sum of Differences {.009 di
Mean Difference {.001 d
Sum of Differences Squared 0.000 di2
Standard Deviation 0.001 sd
Confidence Coefficient 2.5% Enor (1-tail 0.000 CG
Relative Accuracy -APS -0.001 tb/mmBtu difference A
Bias Adiustment Factor 1.000 BAF
20 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
T
I
I
T
T
T
T
I
T
I
I
t
T
t
x
t
T
I
T
Project No. M243506
Unit 'l , Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Client PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Location: Unit 4
DaE:8128124
Test Method: 7E, 3A
NOx ppmvd @ 15Yo 02 RATA
CEM Analvzer lnformation
NO, Monitor/Mode!:Thermo 42iQLS-ACBNN NO. Serial #:1231U28624
02 Monitor/Model:Thermo 48iO-ABC Oz Serial # :12305124124
1=accept
0=reject
Test
Run Test Date Start Time End Time
RM NOx
ppmvd @ 15
o/42
CEM NOx
ppmvd @ 15
o/42
(RMCEM)
Difference
(di)
(RMCEM)
Difference2
(di2)
0 1 ogt28t24 06:35 06:55 1.6 2.1 -0.5 0.25
0 2 08t28t24 07:07 07:27 1.8 2.3 -0.5 0.25
1 3 oBt28t24 07:39 07:59 2.3 2.6 -0.3 0.09
1 4 o9t28124 08:12 08:32 1.1 1.4 4.3 0.09
1 5 08t28t24 08:44 09:04 3.1 3.5 -0.4 0.16
1 6 08t28t24 09:1 7 09:37 2.5 2.4 0.1 0.01
1 7 o&t28124 09:49 10:09 2.5 2.7 -o.2 0.04
1 8 08t28124 1O:21 1O:41 2.4 2.7 -0.3 0.09
1 I 08t28t24 1'l:03 11:23 3.0 3.3 -0.3 0.09
1 10 08t28t24 11:35 11:55 2.8 3.0 -0.2 0.M
1 11 08128124 12 07 12:27 3.0 3.1 -0.1 0.01
n I
t(0.s7s)2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 2.522 RM avq
Mean CEM Value 2.74 CEM avq
Sum of Differences -2.000 di
Mean Difference 4.222 d
Sum of Differences Squared 0.620 ci2
Standard Deviation 0.148 ed
Confi dence Coefft cie nt 2.5o/o Enor fi -tail 0.114 DC
Relative Accuracv 13.33 RA
21 of '199 @Mostardi Platt
Client PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Location: Unit 4
Date:8128124
Test Method:. 7E,2
NO, !b/hr RATA
CEM Analyzer lnformation
NO. Monitor/Model:lhermo 42iOLS-ACBNN NO- Serial #12318/28624
1=accept
0=reject
Test
Run Test Date Start Time End Time RM NO,
lb/hr
CEM NO,
lb/hr
(RMCEM)
Difference
(di)
(RM-cEM)
Difference2
(di2)
0 1 o\t28t24 06:35 06:55 1.45 2.00 -0.55 0.3025
1 2 08t28t24 07:07 07:27 1.44 2.10 -0.46 0.2116
0 3 o8t28t24 07:39 07:59 1.72 2.40 -0.68 0.4624
1 4 o8t28t24 08:12 08:32 1.05 1.30 -0.25 0.0625
1 5 08t28t24 08:44 09:O4 2.88 3.20 -o.32 o.1024
1 6 o8t28t24 09:1 7 09:37 2.32 2.20 o.12 o.o14.r'.
1 7 o8t28t24 09:49 10:09 2.30 2.so -0.20 0.o+00
1 8 o8t28t24 1O:21 1O:41 2.27 2.fi -o.23 0.0529
I I 08t28t24 11:03 11:23 2.77 3.00 -0.23 0.0529
1 10 08t28t24 11:35 11:55 2.59 2.80 -0.21 0.0441
,|11 08t28t24 12:07 12:27 2.77 2.90 -0.13 0.0169
n 9
t(0.97s)2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 2.288 RM avo
Mean CEM Value 2.500 CEM AVO
Sum of Differences -1.910 di
Mean Difference 4.212 d
Sum of Differences Squared 0.598 di2
Standard Deviation 0.155 sd
Confidence Coefficient 2.5o/o Error (1 -taill 0.119 cc
ttelattve Accuracv 14.49 RA
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
T
T
I
I
I
I
I
T
t
T
I
t
T
I
1
T
I
T
I
22 oI'199 OMostardi Platt
I
t
I
I
I
T
t
I
I
I
T
I
t
I
I
T
I
I
T
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
23 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
CIient PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Location: Unit 4
Da!e:8128124
Test Method: 34
Oz % (dry) RATA
CEM Analyzer lnformation
Ou Monitor/Model Thermo 48iQ-ABC Oz Serial #:12305124124
1=accept
0=reject
Test
Run
Test
Date Start Time End Time RM02%
(drv)
cEM 02 %
(dry)
(RMCEM)
Difference
(di)
(RM4EM)
Difference2
(di2)
I 1 08t28t24 06:35 06:55 16.1 16.1 0.0 0.00
1 2 08t28t24 O7:O7 07:27 16.3 16.1 0.2 0.04
1 3 o8t28t24 07:39 07:59 16.3 16.1 0.2 0.04
1 4 o8128124 O8:12 08:32 16.3 16.1 0.2 0.04
1 5 08t28t24 08:44 09:04 16.3 16.1 o.2 0.04
1 6 08128t24 09:17 09;37 16.3 16.0 0.3 0.09
1 7 o8,t28124 09:49 10:09 16.3 16.1 o.2 0.04
0 8 08t28124 1O:21 1O:41 16.3 16.0 0.3 0.09
1 I 08t28t24 1 1:03 1'l:23 16.2 16.1 0.1 0.01
1 10 08t28t24 1 1:35 11:55 16.2 16.0 0.2 0.04
0 11 o8t28t24 12:O7 12:27 16.3 16.0 0.3 0.09
n I
(o.o25l 2.305
Mean Reference Method Value 16.256 RM avo
Mean CEM Value 16.078 cEM avo
Sum of Differencer 1.600 di
Mean Difference 0.178 d
Sum of Differences Squared 0.340 di2
Standard Deviatior 0.083 sd
Confi de nce Coeffi cie nt 2.5o/o Error fi -tail 0.064 CG
Relative Accuract 1.49 RA
Client PacifiCorp Location: Unit 4
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant DaE: 8128124
Project #: M243506 Test Method: 10, 2
Applicable Standard: 9
CO lb/hr RATA
CEM Analvzer lnformation
CO Monitor/Model:Thermo 48|O-ABC CO Seria! #:12305124124
1=accept
0=reject
Test
Run Test Date Start Time End Time RM CO lb/hr CEM CO lb/hr
(RMCEM)
Difference
(di)
(RM€EM)
Difference2
(di2)
1 1 o8,t28124 06:35 06:55 0.64 1.10 -0.46 0.2116
2 o8t28t24 07:O7 07:27 0.70 1.20 -0.50 0.2500
0 3 o8t28t24 07:39 07:59 0.58 1.30 -0.72 0.5184
1 4 08t28t24 08:12 08:32 0.73 1.20 -o.47 o.2209
1 5 ogt28t24 08:44 09:04 0.61 1.10 -0.49 0.2401
0 6 o8t28124 09:1 7 09:37 0.58 1.10 -0.52 o.270/.
7 ogt28t24 09:49 10:09 0.59 1.10 -0.51 0.2601
1 8 ogt28t24 1O:21 10:41 0.59 't.10 -0.51 0.2601
I o8t28t24 '11:03 11:23 0.59 1.10 -0.51 0.2601
1 10 08t28t24 11:35 11:55 0.60 1.10 -0.50 0.2500
1 11 ogt28t24 12:O7 12:27 0.60 1.10 -0.50 0.2500
n 9
t(0.97s)2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 0.628 RM avo
Mean CEM Value '1.122 CEM avo
Sum of Differences 4.450 di
Mean Difference {.494 d
Sum of Differences Squared 2.203 di2
Standard Deviation 0.018 sd
Confidence Coefficient 2.5% Error (1-tail 0.014
Relative Accuracy - APS 5.65 RAA
I
T
I
I
T
I
I
I
T
I
I
o Relatirre accuracy based upon +l- 1O% of applicable standard based on Performance Specification 6 I
I
I
I
t
t
I
t
Project No. M243506
Unit 'l, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
24 ot 199 @Mostardi Plaft
T
T
T
T
T
I
I
T
T
T
I
T
T
T
T
T
I
T
T
A Relatirre accuracy based upon altemate performance standard of +/- 5 ppm CO plus the confidence
coefrcient.
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Client PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Location: Unit 4
DaE:8128124
Test Method: 10, 3A
CO ppmvd @15% 02 RATA
CEM Analyzer lnformation
CO Monitor/Model:Thermo 48|O-ABC CO Serial #:12305124124
O, Monitor/Model:Thermo 48iQ-ABC Oz Serial #:12305124',t24
1=accept
0=reject
Test
Run Test Date Start Time End Time
RM CO
ppmvd @ 15
o/42
CEM CO
ppmvd @ 15
o/o2
(RM4EM)
Difference
(di)
(RM4EM)
Difference2
(di2)
1 1 08t28t24 06:35 06:55 1.1 2.0 -0.9 0.81
1 2 08128t24 07:O7 07:27 1.2 2.2 1.0 1.00
0 3 08t28124 07:39 07:59 1.2 2.2 -1.0 '1.00
1 4 08t28124 08:12 08:32 1.3 2.1 -0.8 0.64
1 5 o&t28t24 08:4 09:04 1.1 2.0 -0.9 0.81
1 6 ogt28t24 09:1 7 09:37 1.0 1.9 {.9 0.81
0 7 ogt28t24 09:49 10:09 1.0 2.0 1.0 1.00
1 I 08t28t24 10:21 1O:41 1.0 1.9 -0.9 0.81
1 9 08t28124 11:03 11:23 1.0 1.9 -0.9 0.81
1 10 o8128124 11:35 11:55 11 1.9 -0.8 0.64
1 11 o8128124 12:O7 12:27 1.1 1.9 -0.8 0.ar
n 9
t(0.975)2.305
Mean Reference Method Value 1.100 RM avq
Mean CEM Value 1.978 CEM avo
Sum of Difference:-7.900 di
Mean Difference {.878 d
Sum of Differences Squarec 6.970 di2
Standard Deviatior 0.067 sd
Confide nce Coefficient 2.5o/, Error fi $il'0.051 cc
Relative Accuracy - APS 0.93 DDm + cc differenceA
@Mostardi Platt
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Fuel Type: Natural Gas
Location: Unit 5
Date:8128124
Tes( Method: 7E, 3A
Fuel Factor: 8710
02 based NOx lb/mmBtu RATA
CEM Ana lvzer lnformation
NO, Monitor/Model:Thermo 42IQLS-ABANN NO, Serial # :12305124117
02 Monitor/Model:Thermo 48iQ-ABC 02 Seria! #:12305124125
1=accept
0=reject
Test
Run Test Date Start Time End Time RM NO,
Ib/MMBfu
CEM NO,
!b/MMBtu
(RMCEM)
Difference
(di)
(RMCEM)
Difference2
(di2)
0 1 o8128t24 06:35 06:55 0.016 0.013 0.003 0.000009
0 2 o8t28t24 07:07 07:27 0.013 0.011 0.002 0.000004
1 3 o8128t24 07:39 O7:59 o.o12 0.0'rl 0.001 0.000001
1 4 o8128t24 08:12 08:32 0.010 0.009 0.001 0.000001
1 5 o8t28t24 08:44 09:04 0.013 0.012 0.001 0.000001
1 6 o8t28t24 09:'17 09:37 0.014 0.013 0.001 0.000001
1 7 o\t28t24 09:49 10:09 0.014 0.013 0.001 0.000001
1 8 08t28t24 10:21 10:41 0.012 0.o12 0.000 0.000000
1 9 08128t24 11:03 11:23 0.013 0.012 0.001 0.000001
1 't0 o8128t24 11:35 11:55 0.013 o.o12 0.001 0.000001
1 11 08t28t24 12:O7 12:27 0.012 0.011 0.001 0.000001
n 9
t(0.025)2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 0.013 F(M avo
Mean GEM Value 0.012 gEM avo
Sum of Differences 0.008 ci
Mean Difference 0.001 c
Sum of Differences Squared 0.000 di2
Standard Deviation 0.000 sd
Confidence Coefficient 2.5% Error (1-taill 0.000 3C
Relative Accuracv -APS 0.001 lb/mmBtu difrerence A
Bias Adius0nent Factol 1.076 BAF
3.5 Unit 5
^ Relative accuracy for low enission sources w ith l.lO, enissions of s 0.200 lbs/firtstu based on a nrean difference of
+/- 0.015|bs/rnr8tu for annual RATA testing, or +/- 0.020 lbs/nrr8tu for seni-annual RATA testing.
Project No. M243506
Unit '1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
t
I
T
T
T
T
I
T
T
t
I
I
t
T
T
I
I
T
I
26 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
I
I
T
I
T
I
I
I
I
I
T
I
T
I
T
T
I
T
t Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Client PacifCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Location: Unit 5
Date:8128124
Test Method: 7E, 3A
NOx ppmvd @15o/o 02 RATA
CEM Analyzer lnformation
NO. Monitor/Model:Thermo 42lOLS-ABANN NO, Serial #:12305124117
Oz Monitor/Model:Thermo 48iQ-ABC Oz Serial # :12305124125
1=accept
0=reject
Test
Run Ie* Date Start Time End Time
RM NOx
ppmvd @ 15
o/o2
CEM NOx
ppmvd @ 15,/42
(RMcEM)
Difference
(d.)
(RMCEM)
Difference2
(di2)
o 1 08t28t24 06:35 06:55 4.2 3.4 0.8 0.64
0 2 08t28t24 07:07 07:27 3.4 3.0 0.4 0.16
1 3 08t28t24 07:39 07:59 3.2 3.0 0.2 0.04
1 4 08t28t24 08:12 08:32 2.7 2.6 0.1 0.01
1 5 o8128124 08:44 09:04 3.6 3.3 0.3 0.09
1 6 08t28t24 09:1 7 09:37 3.8 3.5 0.3 0.09
1 7 08t28124 09:49 10:09 3.8 3.6 o.2 0.04
1 8 08t28124 10:21 10:41 3.4 3.2 o.2 0.04
1 9 08t28124 11:03 11:23 3.6 3.3 0.3 0.09
1 10 08t28t24 11:35 11:55 3.6 3.2 0.4 0.16
1 11 o8t28t24 12:O7 12:27 3.2 2.9 0.3 0.09
n 9
(0.97s)2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 3./til3 RM avq
Mean CEM Value 3.178 GEM avg
Sum of Differences 2.300 di
Mean Difference 0.256 d
Sum of Differences Squared 0.6s0 di2
Standard Deviation 0.088 sd
Confi dence Coefficient 2.5o/o Error (1 -tail)0.068 cc
Relative Accuracv 9.42 RA
27 of 199 OMostardi Platt
Client PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Location: Unit 5
Date:8128124
Test Method: 7E,2
NOr lb/hr RATA
CEM Analvzer lnformation
NO, Monitor/Model:Thermo 42lQLS-ABANN NO, Serial #:12305124117
1=accept
0=reject
Test
Run Iest Date Start Time End Time RM NO,
lb/hr
cEM NOx
lb/hr
(RM-cEM)
Difference
(di)
(RM€EM)
Difference2
(d.1
0 1 o8128124 06:35 06:55 4.11 3.30 0.81 0.6561
0 2 08128t24 07:O7 07:27 3.31 2.90 0.41 0.1 681
1 3 o8t28t24 07:39 07:59 3.09 2.80 0.29 0.0841
1 4 o8t28124 08:1 2 08:32 2.63 2.50 0.13 0.0169
1 5 o8128t24 O8:44 09:M 3.46 3.20 o.26 0.0676
1 6 ogt28t24 09:1 7 09:37 3.72 3.40 0.32 0.1024
1 7 o8t28124 09:49 10:09 3.71 3.40 0.31 0.0961
1 8 o8128124 10:21 10:41 3.34 3.10 0.24 0.0576
1 I o8t28t24 1't:03 11:23 3.45 3.20 0.25 0.0625
1 10 ogt28t24 11:35 11:55 3.47 3.10 0.37 0.1369
1 11 o8128t24 12:O7 12:27 3.10 2.80 0.30 0.0900
n 9
t(0.975)2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 3.330 RM avo
Mean CEM Value 3.056 CEM avq
Sum of Differences 2.470 di
Mean Difference 0.274 d
Sum of Differences Squared 0.714 di2
Standard Deviation 0.067 sd
Confidence Coefficient 2.5o/o Error (1 -ta i ll 0.052 cc
Relative Accuracy 9.79 RA
T
I
I
I
T
I
t
T
I
I
T
I
I
I
I
T
T
I
I
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
28 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
I
T
t
I
T
I
I
T
I
I
T
I
I
T
T
T
T
I
T
Project No. M243506
Unit 1. Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Client PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Location: Unit 5
Date:8128124
Tesil Method: 3A
o,2% ldryl RATA
CEM Ana lvzer lnformation
02 Monitor/Model:Thermo 48iQ-ABC O, Serial #:'t2305124125
l=accepl
0=reject
Test
Run
Test
Date Start Time End Time RM02%
(drv)
cEM 02 %
(dry)
(RMCEM)
Difference
(di)
(RMCEM)
Difference2
(di2)
0 1 08t28t24 06:35 06:55 16.4 16.2 0.2 0.M
1 2 o$t28124 07:07 07:27 16.4 16.3 0.1 0.01
1 3 o8128124 07:39 07:59 16.3 16.3 0.0 0.00
1 4 08t28124 08:12 08:32 16.2 16.2 0.0 0.00
1 5 08t28t24 08:44 09:04 't6.2 16.2 0.0 0.00
I 6 o8128124 09:1 7 09:37 16.2 16.2 0.0 0.00
1 7 08t28t24 09:49 10:09 16.2 16.2 0.0 0.00
1 8 08t28t24 10:21 10:41 16.1 16.2 -0.1 0.01
1 I ogt28t24 11:03 11.23 't6.1 16.2 -0.1 0.01
0 10 08t28t24 11:35 1 1:55 16.1 16.2 -0.1 0.01
1 11 08t28t24 12:O7 12:27 16.2 16.2 0.0 0.00
n 9
t(0.025)2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 16.211 RM avo
Mean CEM Value 16.222 CEM avo
Sum of Differences {.100 di
Mean Difference {.011 d
Sum of Differences Squared 0.030 di2
Standard Deviation 0.060 sd
Confi dence Coefficient 2.5Yo Error (1 -taill 0.046 cc
Relative Accuracv 0.35 RA
29 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
Client PacifiCorp Location: Unit 5
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant Dah: 8128124
Project #: M243506 Tes( Method: 10, 2
Applicable Standard: 9
CO lb/hr RATA
CEM Analvzer lnformation
CO Monitor/Model:Thermo 48|Q-ABC CO Serial#:12305124125
1=accept
0=reject
Test
Run Test Date Start Time End Time RM CO !b/hr CEM CO lb/hr
(RMCEM)
Difference
(di)
(RM-CEM)
Difference2
(di2)
0 1 o8128t24 06:35 06:55 1.07 1.30 -0.23 0.0529
1 2 ogt28t24 07:07 07:27 1.10 1.30 -0.20 0.0400
I 3 08128t24 07:39 07:59 1.14 1.30 -0.16 0.0256
1 4 ogt28t24 08:12 08:32 1.26 1.40 -0.14 0.0196
1 5 o&t28t24 08:44 09:O4 1.02 1.20 -0.18 0.0324
1 6 ogt28t24 09:1 7 09:37 0.99 '1.20 -o.21 0.w1
1 7 o&t28t24 09:49 10:09 0.94 't.10 -0.16 0.0256
0 8 o8128t24 1O:21 1O:41 0.98 1.20 -o.22 0.0484
1 I 48t28t24 11:03 11:23 0.90 1.10 -o.20 0.0400
1 10 o8128t24 11:35 11:55 0.91 1.10 -0.19 0.0361
1 1',|ogt28t24 12:07 12:27 0.92 1.10 -0.18 0.0324
n 9
t(0.975)2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 1.020 RM avq
Mean CEM Value 1.200 CEM avq
Sum of Differences -1.620 di
Mean Difference {.180 d
Sum of Differences Souared 0.296 fi2
Standard Deviation 0.023 d
Confidence Coeffi cient 2.5o/o Error (1 -taill 0.018
Relative Accuracv - APS 2.20 RA
A Relati,,e accuracy based upon +l- 'lO% of applicable standard based on Performance Specilication 6
I
I
T
I
T
t
I
T
I
I
I
I
T
I
I
I
I
T
T
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
30 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
I
I
t
I
T
T
I
T
T
I
I
t
I
I
T
I
I
I
t
A Relatire accuracy based upon altemate performance standard of +/- 5 ppm CO plus the confidence
coeficient.
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Client PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Location: Unit 5
DaE:8128124
Test Method: 10, 3A
CO ppmvd @15% 02 RATA
CEM Analyzer lnformation
CO Monitor/Model:Thermo 48iO-ABC CO Serial #:12305',t24125
O, Monitor/Model:Thermo 48iQ-ABC Oz Serial #:12305124125
1=accept
0=reject
Test
Run Test Date Start Time End Time
RM CO
ppmvd @ 15
"/42
CEM CO
ppmvd @ 15
o/42
(RMCEM)
Difference
(di)
(RM-cEM)
Difference2
(di2)
1 1 ogt28t24 06:35 06:55 1.8 2.1 -0.3 0.09
1 2 08t28t24 07:O7 07:27 1.9 2.2 -0.3 0.09
1 3 08t28t24 07:39 07:59 1.9 2.3 -0.4 0.16
1 4 08t28124 08:1 2 08:32 2.1 2.3 -o.2 0.M
1 5 ogt28t24 08:44 09:04 1.7 2.1 -0.4 0.16
1 6 o8128124 09:1 7 09:37 1.7 2.0 -0.3 0.09
1 7 08t28124 09:49 10:09 1.6 1.9 -0.3 0.09
1 8 08t28t24 10:21 1O:41 1.6 1.9 -0.3 0.09
0 9 08t28t24 11:03 11:23 1.5 1.9 -o.4 0.'t6
0 10 08t28t24 11:35 11:55 1.5 1.9 -0.4 0.16
1 11 08t28124 12:O7 12:27 1.6 1.9 -0.3 0.09
n 9
(0.975)2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 1.767 RM avq
Mean CEM Value 2.078 CEM avo
Sum of Differences -2.800 di
Mean Difference {.311 d
Sum of Differences Squared 0.900 di2
Standard Deviation 0.060 sd
Confi dence Coefficient 2.5o/o Enor (1 -tail)0.046 cc
Relative Accuracy - APS 0.36 DDm + cc differenceA
31 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
3.6 Unit 6
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
t
I
I
I
I
t
I
t
I
I
t
I
T
I
I
I
T
I
I
Client; PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Fuel Type: Natural Gas
Location: Unit 6
Date:8129124
Tes* Method: 7E, 3A
Fuel Factor: 8710
02 based NOx lb/mmBtu RATA
CEM Ana lvzer !nformation
NO, Monitor/Model:Thermo 42iQLS-ACBNN NO, Serial # :12309525999
02 Monitor/Model:Thermo 4tliO-ABC 02 Seria! #:12305124126
1=accept
0=reject
Test
Run Iest Date Start Time End Time RM NOX
lb/MMBtu
cEM NOx
lb/MMBtu
(RMCEM)
Difference
(di)
(RMcEM)
Difference2
(di2)
1 1 08t29t24 06:40 07:00 0.009 0.010 {.001 0.000001
1 2 08t29t24 07:08 07:28 0.008 0.008 0.000 0.000000
,|3 08t29t24 07:37 07:57 0.008 0.008 0.000 0.000000
1 4 ogt29t24 08:07 08:27 0.009 0.009 0.000 0.000000
1 5 08t29t24 08:36 08:56 0.009 0.009 0.000 0.000000
1 6 08t29t24 09:05 09:25 0.009 0.009 0.000 0.000000
1 7 08t29t24 09:35 09:55 0.009 0.009 0.000 0.000000
1 8 08129t24 10:04 10:24 0.009 0.009 0.000 0.000000
0 9 08t29t24 10:34 10:54 0.008 0.009 -0.001 0.000001
1 10 08129t24 1'l:03 11:23 0.009 0.009 0.000 0.000000
n 9
t(0.025)2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 0.009 RM avq
Mean CEM Value 0.009 CEM avq
Sum of Differences {.001 di
Mean Difference 0.000 d
Sum of Differences Squared 0.000 di2
Standard Deviation 0.000 sd
Confidence Coefficient 2.5% Error (1-tai!)0.000 cc
Relative Accuracy 4.18 RA
Bias Adiustment Factor 1.000 BAF
32 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
I
I
t
T
I
t
I
T
T
T
I
I
I
T
I
I
I
I
I Poect No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Client PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Location: Unit 6
DaE:8129124
Test Method: 7E, 3A
NOx ppmvd @15% OZ RATA
CEM Analvzer lnformation
NO, Monitor/Model:Thermo 42iOLS-ACBNN NO. Serial #:12309525999
02 Monitor/Model:Thermo 48iO-ABC Oz Seria! # :12305124126
1=accept
0=reject
Test
Run Iest Date Start Time End Time
RM NOx
ppmvd @ 15o/42
CEM NOx
ppmvd @ 15
"/42
(RM€EM)
Difference
(di)
(RMcEM)
Difference2
(di2)
1 1 o8t29t24 06:40 07:00 2.6 2.8 -0.2 0.04
1 2 08t29t24 07:08 07:28 2.2 2.2 0.0 0.00
1 3 08t29t24 07:37 07:57 2.2 2.2 0.0 0.00
1 4 o&t29t24 08:07 08:27 2.3 2.4 -0.1 0.01
1 5 08t29t24 08:36 08:56 2.4 2.4 0.0 0.00
1 6 o8t29t24 09:05 09:25 2.5 2.6 -0.1 0.01
I 7 o8129124 09:35 09:55 2.4 2.4 0.0 0.00
1 I 08t29t24 10:(X 1O:24 2.3 2.5 -o.2 0.04
0 I 08t29t24 10:34 10:54 2.2 2.5 -0.3 0.09
1 10 08t29t24 11:03 11:23 2.4 2.6 -0.2 0.04
n 9
(0.e75)2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 2.367 RM avo
Mean CEM Value 2.456 CEM avq
sum of urttenences {.800 di
Mean Difference {.089 d
Sum of Differences Squared 0.1/t0 di2
Standard Deviation 0.093 rd
Confidence Coefficient 2.5% Error (1-tail 0.071 cc
Relative Accuracv 6.77 RA
33 of '199 @Mostardi Plaft
Client PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Location: Unit 6
Da!€:8129124
Test Method: 7E,2
NO,lb/hr RATA
CEM Ana lvzer lnformation
NO, Monitor/Model:Thermo 42iQLS-ACBNN NO, Serial # :12309525999
1=accepl
0=reject
Test
Run Test Date Start Time End Time RM NO,
lb/hr
CEM NO,
lb/hr
(RMCEM)
Difference
(di)
(RM4EM)
Difference2
(di2)
0 1 08t29t24 06:40 07:00 2.40 2.60 -0.20 0.0400
I 2 o$t29124 07:08 07:28 2.09 2.10 -0.01 0.0001
,|3 08t29t24 07:37 07:57 2.01 2.00 0.01 0.0001
1 4 08t29t24 08:07 08:27 2.22 2.30 -0.08 0.00&
1 5 o\t29t24 08:36 08:56 2.23 2.30 -0.07 0.0049
1 6 08t29t24 09:05 09:25 2.35 2.40 -0.05 0.002s
1 7 o8t29t24 09:35 09:55 2.23 2.30 -0.07 0.0049
1 8 o\t29t24 10:04 '10:24 2.22 2.40 -0.18 0.0324
1 I 08129t24 10:34 10:54 2.14 2.30 -0.16 0.0256
10 08t29t24 11:03 1'l:23 2.26 2.40 -o.14 0.0196
n 9
(0.975)2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 2.194 RM avo
Mean CEM Value 2.278 CEM avo
Sum of Differences {.750 di
Mean Difference {.083 d
Sum of Differences Squared 0.096 di2
Standard Deviation 0.055 sd
Confi dence Coefficient 2.5o/o Error 11 -!ail 0.050 cc
Relative Accuracv 6.08 RA
Project No. M243506
Unit '1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
I
T
T
t
I
T
I
T
T
T
t
I
I
I
I
t
I
I
I
34 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
I
T
T
I
I
I
t
t
T
I
I
T
I
I
I
T
I
I
I Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Client PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Location: Unit 6
Da@:8129124
Test Method: 3A
O2olo ldryl RATA
CEM Analyzer lnformation
Oz Monitor/Model:Thermo 48iQ-ABC Oz Serial #:12305124126
1=accept
0=reject
Test
Run
Test
Date Start Time End Time RM02%
(dry)
cEM 02 %
(drv)
(RMCEM)
Difference
(di)
(RM€EM)
Difference2
(di2)
1 1 08t29t24 06;40 07:00 16.5 16.3 0.2 0.04
1 2 08t29124 07:08 07:28 16.6 16.3 0.3 0.09
1 3 08t29t24 07:37 07:57 16.6 16.3 0.3 0.09
1 4 08t29124 08:07 08:27 16.4 16.3 0.1 0.01
1 5 08t29t24 08:36 08:56 16.4 16.3 0.1 0.01
1 6 08t29t24 09:05 09:25 16.5 16.3 0.2 0.04
0 7 ogt29t24 09:35 09:55 16.6 16.3 0.3 0.09
1 8 08t29124 10:O4 10:24 16.3 16.3 0.0 0.00
1 9 08t29124 10:34 10:54 16.2 16.2 0.0 0.00
1 10 08129t24 11:03 11:23 16.2 16.2 0.0 0.00
n 9
(0.0251 2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 16.411 RM avq
Mean CEM Value 16.278 CEM avo
Sum of Difference:1.200 di
Mean Difference 0.133 d
Sum of Differences Squared 0.280 da2
Standard Deviatior 0.122 sd
Confidence Coefficient 2.5% Error (1-tail 0.094 cc
Relative Accuract 1.39 RA
35 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
Client PacifiCorp Location: Unit 6
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant Da!c:8129124
Project #: M243506 Test Method: 10, 2
Applicable Standard: 9
CO !b/hr RATA
CEM Analvzer lnformation
CO Monitor/Model:Thermo 48iQ-ABC CO Serial #:12305124126
1=accept
0=reject
Test
Run Test Date Start Time End Time RM CO lb/hr CEM CO lb/hr
(RMCEM)
Difference
(di)
(RM€EM)
Difference2
(di2)
0 1 o8t29t24 06:40 07:00 0.74 1.00 -0.26 0.0676
1 2 o8t29t24 07:08 07:28 o.77 0.90 -0.13 0.0169
3 o8t29t24 07:37 07:57 0.77 0.90 -0.13 0.0169
1 4 08t29t24 08:07 08:27 0.77 0.90 -0.13 0.0169
1 5 o8t29t24 08:36 08:56 0.76 0.90 -0.14 0.0196
1 6 o8t29t24 09:05 09:25 0.79 1.00 -0.21 0.0441
1 7 o8t29124 09:35 09:55 0.81 0.80 0.01 0.0001
1 8 08t29t24 10:04 10:24 0.76 0.80 -0.M 0.0016
1 9 o8t29t24 10:34 10:54 0.74 0.80 -0.06 0.0036
1 10 08t29t24 11:03 11:23 0.76 0.80 -0.04 0.0016
n 9
t(0.975)2.306
Mean Reference Method Value o.770 RM avq
Mean CEM Vatue 0.867 CEM avo
Sum of Differences {.870 di
Mean Difference 4.097 I
Sum of Differences Squared 0.121 ,i2
Standard Deviation 0.068 s
Confi dence Coefficient 2.5o/o Enor (1 -tail)0.052 :c
Relative Accuracy - APS 1.66 RAA
o Relati,,e accuracy based upon +l- 1Oo/o of applicable standard based on Perfurmance Specification 6
I
I
I
t
I
t
T
T
I
I
I
I
I
I
T
T
I
I
I
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
36 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
T
T
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
t
I
T
t
T
I
T
I
I
I
A Relatire accuracy based upon altemate perbrmance standard of +/- 5 ppm CO plus the confidence
coefficient.
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Client PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Location: Unit 6
DaE:.8129124
Test Method: 10, 3A
CO ppmvd @15Yo 02 RATA
CEM Analyzer Information
CO Monitor/Model:Thermo 48iQ-ABC CO Serial #:12305'.t24126
Or Monitor/Model:Thermo 48|Q-ABC O, Serial #:12305124126
1=accept
0=reject
Test
Run Iest Date Start Time End Time
RM CO
ppmvd @ 15
o/42
CEM GO
ppmvd @ 15
o/42
(RMCEM)
Difference
(di)
(RM-cEM)
Difference2
(di2)
0 1 08t29t24 06:40 07:00 1.3 1.8 -0.5 0.25
1 2 08t29t24 07:08 07:28 1.3 1.6 -0.3 0.09
1 3 08t29t24 07:37 07:57 1.4 1.6 -0.2 0_04
1 4 ogt29t24 08:07 08:27 1.3 1.5 -o.2 0.04
1 5 08t29124 08:36 08:56 1.3 1.7 -0.4 0.16
1 6 08t29124 09:05 09:25 1.4 1.7 -0.3 0.09
1 7 08t29t24 09:35 09:55 1.4 1.4 0.0 0.00
1 8 o8t29124 10:04 1O:24 1.3 1.4 -0.1 0.01
1 I ogt29t24 10:34 10:54 1.3 1.4 -0.1 0.01
1 10 08t29t24 11:03 11:23 1.3 1.4 -0.1 0.01
n 9
t(0.97s)2.306
Mean Reference Method Value 1.333 RM avo
Mean CEM Value '|..522 CEM avg
Sum of Differences -1.700 di
Mean Difference {.189 d
Sum of Differences Squared 0./150 di2
Standard Deviation 0.127 sd
Confi de nce Coeffi cie nt 2.5o/o Error fi -tail 0.098 cc
Relative Accuracy - APS 0.29 oom + cc differenceA
37 of 199 OMostardi Platt
4.0 CERTIFICATION
Mostardi Platt is pleased to have been of service to PacifiCorp. lf you have any questions
regarding this test report, please do not hesitate to contact us at 630-993-2100.
As the program manager, I hereby certify that this test report represents a true and accurate
summary of emissions test results and the methodologies employed to obtain those results. The
test program was performed in accordance with the test protocol, test methods, the Mostardi Platt
Quality Manual, and the ASTM D7036-12, as applicable.
MOSTARDI PLATT
-/
/2fu/4 prosramManaser
Christopher S. Eldridge
Quality Assurance
I
I
I
I
t
t
I
I
t
t
I
I
I
I
t
t
I
I
t
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
38 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
APPENDICES
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Appendix A - Company AETB Certification
40 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
mostardiaiplatt
March 23,2012
Efiective immediately, Mostardi Platt self-certifies that all Part 75 test proJects conform to the
ASTM D 7036-04 Standard Practice. The following contac{ information is provided as required
by the Standard:
MostardiPlatt
888 lndustrial Drive
Elmhurst, lllinois 601 26
63G993-2100
tplatt@mo-mail.com
Also, attached is a list of eacfr Qualified lndividual (Ol) with the type of exam (e.9., Group I' ll' lll
lV and/orV), the date the exam was taken and the name and email address of the exam
provider.
Should you have any questions or need additional information, please contact Thomas Platt,
P.E. at 630-993-2683.
Approved:
By:
Chief Executive Officer
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
41 of 199 OMostardi Platt
qSfl AETB lmport Data
I
t
Seckham
Benninghoff
Burton
carlisle
cohngolo
Col€man
Crlvlare
Dunn
Eldridge
Gro5s
Hendrlck5
Howe
len5en
lones
Kossack
Kukla
Lipinski
Peter5on
Petrovlch
Russ
sands
sather
Sollars
Sorce
Trez.k
I
L
c
F
P
s
E
L
J
R
MostardPl.tt 530,993-2100
MostardPlatt 630-993-2100
Most rd Pl.tt 630-993-21@
MostardPlatt 630-993-21@
MostardPhtt 630-993-2100
Most.rdPlatt 630-993-2100
MostardPlatt 63G9!r3-2100
MoltardPl.tt 630-993-2100
MoitardPlatt 630-993-2100
MostardPlatt 630-993-2100
Mostard Platt 63G8 3-2100
MostadPhtt 530-993-2100
Mosted PLti 630-993-2100
Mostard Platt 63G993-2100
Mo5tardPl.tt 630-993-2100
Moltard Pl.tt 630-993-2100
Mosterd Platt 630-993-2100
Most.rd Phtt 630-993'2100
MostardPLtt 630-993-2100
Mostard Pl.n 8G993-2100
Mostard Phtt 63G993-2100
MortardPhtt 530-993-2100
MostardPhtt 630-993-2100
MostardPl.tt 630-993-2100
MostardPlefr 630-993-2100
E
E
T
P
J
s
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Kenneth
Aaron
Stuart
Rob.rt
Nkholas
Paul
Jeffrey
Chrlstlah
Chrlrtopher
leffery
B.n amin
l.cob
Chrlstopher
Kyle
D.ni€l
.lo!hua
Mlch.l
Mark
wllllam
Tlmothy
Stu.n
Mlchael
Rlchard
Antelo
chrlrtopher
tolatt@mo'mail.com
tolatt@mp'mail.com
tola$@mp-mall,com
tplatt@mp-m.il.com
tplatt@mp-mail.com
tplatt@mrm.ll.com
tolatt@mp-mail.com
tpl.n@mo-mall.com
tplatt@mo-mall.com
tol.tt@mp-mail.com
tolatt@mp-m.il.com
tplatt@fro-m.il.com
tplat@mcmail.com
tolatt@mo-mail.com
tplatt@mp-mall.com
tolafi(amo-mall.com
tplatt@mo'mall.com
tplan@mo-m.ll.com
tplan@mlmail.com
tpl.tt@mrmail.com
tpl.tt@mo-mail.com
tolatt@mo-mail.coh
tolan@mo-mall.com
tplatt@mo-mail.com
tplatt@mo-mall.com
5/18/2023 source Ev.luatlon S*lety
9/8/2023 Source Ev.lu.tlon Sel.ty
1/4/2023 Source Ev.lu.tlon Selcty
1/8/2021 sourc€ Ev.lu.tlon 56lety
41412024 burce Ev.lu.tlon Selety
31242023 wce Ev.lu.tlon Sehty
1/4/2023 Source Evrlu.tlon Sclcty
10127 12023 Sourc. Evalu.tlon Scl.ty
21181202L Sutc. Ev.lu.tlon S@l.ty
l/ 19 / 2024 sEwce av.lu.tlon Schty
1/30/2020 Source Evrlu.tion Sciety
2117 12021 Sowce evafurtlon Sclety
1/4/2023 Source Ev.lualion Sci€ty
1/11/2021 sourcc Ev.lu.tlon sehty
llhfl2o2l Sourcc Ev.luatlon Sni€ty
4/4/2024 Source Evaluatlon S@lety
1/31/2020 Source Ev.luatlon Selety
L/!7 12023 Sourca Er.luatlon Sclety
21412022 burc. Ev.l!.tlon Schty
4/8/2020 Source Ev.luation Sdiew
1/5/2023 Source Ev.lu.tlon Schty
2frl2020 Sourc. Evelu.tion Sdiety
7 /2E12o23 source Ev.lu.tlon Selety
2/1812022 Source Ev.lu.tlon S6hW
411412020 Sowce Evalu.tlon Sclew
o5tlprcrram@rmall-com
q5tloroaram@qmall.com
ostiprorram@imail.com
ostiDrotram@rmall.com
qstiDrotram@tmail.com
ortiprorram@qmail.aom
ortioroqram@smail.com
qstiororram@qmall.com
ostlprorram(aamall.com
q5tlprcrram@gmall.com
qstiororram@amall.com
o5tlorotram@amril.com
qstigroaram@amail.com
qstiprotram@tmall.com
ostiDroaram@tmall.com
ortiorotram@rmail.com
ortiororram@amall.com
ortiproaram@!mall.com
artiproa6m@{mall.com
ostio@aram@amall.com
qitioroaram@!mall.com
o gtio,oaram@rmall.com
ostlprorram@qmall.com
ostioroaram@rmall.coft
ortioroaramtaamall.com
G.oup V (Pa.t 75)
Group V (Part 75)
G.oup V (P.rt 75)
Groug v (Pan 75)
Grcup V (Pan 75)
G.oup V (Part 75)
Group V (Part 75)
Group V (Pa.t 75)
Group V (Part 75)
G6up V (Part 75)
Group V (Part 75)
Group V (P.rt 75)
G@up v (P.rt 75)
GBup V (Part 75)
Group V (Part 75)
Group V (Part 75)
Group V (Part 75)
Goup V (Part 75)
GEup V (Part 75)
Goup V (Part 75)
Group V (Part 75)
Grcup V (P.rt 75)
Group V (P.n 75)
Group V (Part 75)
G@up v (Part 75)
I
I
T
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
T
I
I
I
I
slLs/2024
42 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
Appendix B - Ql Certification(s) for Field Personnel
Project No. M2435OO 43 of 199
I
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
@Mostardi Platt
I
ET
ETo
I
I
T
I
T
I
o)(,)5l
T
T
I
;l
5l'-
nE I
= c.i
a; I
o-l
t
T
!$
N
Nts\S\L
J
uo(,
.go
l!.9
E(,o
oaoN
o
ea!
=llolr
o
.Eo
\\
tl \\\
.J
EEF
E$Eo1-ocrrS aE9tGr- cL
ETHE c rrAo 2 e .H E:
EgiE;ii
ETEgTgEE?ES:?H
EtgEEHIE
E rE
E E ,E ; E: Fv 6 lQtAgEEE- 'E e E.6 5 F
s IgIifip'fr PF 6 5
E ;
=EE*a
tLJJ.-(d
r-l
P.
()
o{ol.{(d
tlr,ao
E
o
a!coo
I
T
t
I
I
T
I
Appendix C - Test Section Diagrams
t
I
I
I
t
I
I
I
T
T
I
Poect No. M243506 45 of 199 OMostardi Platt
I
unit 1, unit 2, Unit 3, unit 4, unit 5, and Unit 6
GASEOUS TRAVERSE
FOR RECTANGULAR DUCTS
14.75',
13.3'
Date:
PacificCorp
Gadsby Power Plant
Salt Lake City, Utah
August 26,2024
Distance from lnside Wall
To Traverse Point:
1. 2.0 Meters2. 1.2 Meters3. 0.4 MetersTest Location: Unit 1
Tests Points per Port: 3
TS-001 Rectangular Duct Drawing 3 Point Rev.0.1
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
46 of 199
GASEOUS TRAVERSE FOR ROUND DUCTS
Length
> 1l2Dia.T
Length
> zDia.I
Date:
Test Location:
Duct Diameter:
Duct Area:
No. Sample Points:
PacifiCorp
Gadsby Power Plant
Salt Lake City, Utah
August 26,2024
Unit 2 Stack
7.5 Feet
44.18 Square Feet
3
T3-006 Gaseous 3 Points
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Rev. 0.'l 1t1t2021
47 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
GASEOUS TRAVERSE FOR ROUND DUCTS
Length
> 1l2Dia.
-l-
I
Length
> 2 Dia.I
PacifiCorp
Gadsby Power Plant
Salt Lake Clty, Utah
August 27,2024
Unit 3 Stack
17.5 Feet
239.61 Square Feet
3
t
t
I
t
Job:
I
t
I
T
T
t
T
I
I
t
T
I
t
T
I
Date:
Test Location:
Duct Diameter:
Duct Area:
No. Sample Points:
T5-006 Gaseous 3 Points
Project No. M243506
Unit '1. Unit 2. Unit 3. Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Rev.0.1 1t1t2021
48 of 199 @Mostardi Plaft
GASEOUS TRAVERSE FOR ROUND DUCTS
**
> 1l2Dia.-T-
I
Lenglh
> 2Dia.I
Date:
Test Location:
Duct Diameter:
Duct Area:
No. Sample Points:
PacifiCorp
Gadsby Power Plant
Salt Lake Crty, Utah
August 28,2024
Unit 4 Stack
12.0 Feet
113.1 Square Feet
3
T5-006 Gaseous 3 Points
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Rev.0.1
GASEOUS TRAVERSE FOR ROUND DUCTS
Length
> 1l2Dia.--r-
I
Length
> zDia.I
Date:
Test Location:
Duct Diameter:
Duct Area:
No. Sample Points:
PacifiCorp
Gadsby Power Plant
Salt Lake City, Utah
August 28, 2024
Unit 5 Stack
12.0 Feet
113.1 Square Feet
3
T5-006 Gaseous 3 Points
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Rev.0.1
T
I
T
I
T
T
I
T
I
T
I
!
T
I
I
t
I
T
t
GASEOUS TRAVERSE FOR ROUND DUCTS
Length
> 1l2Oia.
T
I
Length
> zDia.
I
Y
Date:
Test Location:
Duct Diameter:
Duct Area:
No. Sample Points:
PacifiCorp
Gadsby Power Plant
Salt Lake City, Utah
August 29,2024
Unit 6 Stack
12.0 Feet
113.1 Square Feet
3
T5-006 Gaseous 3 Points
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Rev.0.1 1t1t2021
51 of '199 @Mostardi Plaft
Appendix D - Sample Train Diagram
Project No. M243506 52 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
USEPA Methods 3A, 7E, and 10 Extractive Gaseous Sampling Diagram
t ""r*--l
ATD-008 Extractive 3A 7E and '10
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Rev. 1.3
53 of '199
1t1t2021
@Mostardi Platt
Appendix E - Calculation Nomenclature and Formulas
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
T
I
I
T
t
T
t
I
T
t
T
T
T
T
t
t
I
T
I
Cllent: PacifiCorp
Facllity: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Test Locatlon: Unit 1
Date:8126124
( 73.2 ppm - 0.3 ppm) x
(9.34 o/o 0.27 o/o) x
( 6.66 o/o 0.20 o/o) x
73,5 ppm x (1.194 x 10^-7) =
0.00000878 lbs/dscf x 1,040 dscf/mmBtu
= 0.136 NOx lbs/mmBtu
Samole Calculations
NOx ppmud
90,3 Dom
89.9 ppm - 0.3 ppm
O2o/o (dry)
9.89 o/o
9.87 o/o - 0.27 o/o
CO2 o/o (dty)
9.91 o/o
9.74o/o - 0.20o/o
CO2 based NOx lb/mmBtu
0.00000878 lbs/dscf
x 100o/o
6.72 o/o
NOx ppmvd @ 3olo 02
= 73.5 ppm
= 9.34 o/o
= 6.72 o/o
Q",=(C-Q) x C..
C.-Ct
where:
Qu, = Effluent gas concentration, dry basis, ppm or o/o
C = Average gas concentration indicated by gas analyzer, dry basis, ppm or o/o
Co = Average of initial and final system calibration bias check responses for the zero gas, ppm or o/c
G = Average of initital and final system calibrauon bias check responses for the upscale calibration QdS, ppfi or o/c
Ga = Actual concentration of the upscale calibration gas, ppm or o/o
73.5 x ((20.e - 3.0)/(20.e - e.3))
0.1 NOx lb/MMBtu x
= 113.9
Mostardi Plaft
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
NOx ppmvd @ 3olo O2
NOx lblhr
473.8 = 04.42 NOx lb/hr
v5.0
55 of 199
RATA Extractive 4/16/20
OMostardi Platt
MOSTARDI PLATT
Derivation of Factors Used in Nitrogen Oxides Calculations
Factors for calculating concentration as pounds per dry standard cubic feet:
Factor for c^,.,- as No, - 28316 846 Tl"scf = 6.242801x 10-s lb ltf ur" 6.z42B x1o'5ttv2 ' 4.53592x 1oE 74 lb tqlml-
Where Mw
I
I
I
I
I
t
I
T
T
Factors for calculating from parts per million to lb/dscf:
Using 22.414liters of gas per gram-mole at 0"C and 1 atmosphere pressure,
One pound-mole of gas is contained in 359.04765 ft3 at 32"F and 29.92 in. Hg, or 385.31943 ft3
at 68"F and29.92 in. Hg
ppm x Mwlb/lb-mole = lb/dscf
385.31 943 dscf /lb-molexl 06
= pollutant molecular weight; NO2 = 46.0055 lb/lb-mole
Factor for ppm NO, == 8.3755 x 106 dscf/lb
46.0055 x 2.5952494 x 10-e
Use 8.3755 x 106
CN&F-008A Derivation of Factors NOx Rev. 1.2 111t2021
I
I
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
I
I
t
t
t
I
I
I
56 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
t
T
I
I
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
I
t
I
T
I
T
T
t
MOSTARDI PLATT
Pollutant Concentration Correction 3o/o for Percent Oxygen
20.9 - 3o/oCadi = Ca 2Ag - oys1z
where:
C"oi = Pollutant concentration corrected to percent Oz
20.9 - 3% = Percent Oz, the defined Oz correction value, percent
20.9 = Percent Oz in air
o/oO2= Measured Oz coflc€otration dry basis, percent
Co = Pollutant concentration measured, dry basis, ppm.
CN&F-007D Conection of Pollutant lo o/oO2 Rev.2.2 1t1t2021
Proiect No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
57 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
MOSTARDI PLATT
ppm Conversion Calculations and Factors
ppm to lbs/scf
(ppm X) x (conversion factor X) = X lbs/scf
lbs/scf to lbs/hr
Dry ppm's with dry flow, and wet ppm's with wet flow.
(X lbs/scf) x (airflow scf/min) x (60 min/hr) = X lbs/hr
lbs/scf to lbs/mmBtu
Dry ppm's with dry diluent, and wet ppm's with wet diluent.
COz - (X lbs/scf) x (F") x (100/COz) = X lbs/mmBtu
O, - (X lbs/scf) x (Fo) x (20.91(20.9-0z)) = X lbs/mmBtu
Conversion Factors
NO, - 1.19396 x 10'7
SOz-1.6625x10'7
CO-7.2664x10-8
CHo - 4.1637 x 10'8
C.Hu- 1.1419x10-7
CN&F-026 PPM Converstion Calcs & Factors Rev. 1.2
I
I
T
T
I
I
I
T
T
T
I
t
t
I
T
T
T
T
T
1t1t2021
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
58 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
t
t M'STARDI PLArrrI Emission Rate CalculationsI
A pollutant emission rate (E), expressed as pounds of pollutant per million Btu heat input from the fuel
I
combusted can be calculated by several methods as follows:
A. C = C,/7000 where, 6 = pollutant concentration, lb/dscf
I B ffi"- ," :il"5":: ,::;:l:::busted durins the rest is sampred and anaryzed ror sross
calorific value, then:
I e=ffi'nu
t where
"sY = sififfi?it"*yntandard conditions, dscr/hr
I C. lf an integrated gas sample is taken during the test and analyzed for o/oCOz or o/oO2, dry basis by
I volume, with an approved USEPA Method 3 or 3A gas analyzer, then
100 20.9
I
E=cFc%co2orE=cFa@;
Where o/oCOz and o/oOz are expressed as percent values:
F" = ? factor representing a ratio of the volume of carbon dioxide generated to the calorific value
of the specified fuel type combusted in Figure 1.
Fd = a factor representing a ratio of the volume of dry flue gases generated to the calorific value
of the specified fuel type combusted in Figure 1.
Fuel Tvoe F F.Fuel Tv6e F F"
Coal Anthrmiie 10100 1970 Fuel Oil 91 90 1420
Coal. Bituminous 9780 1800 9570 r820
Coal Lionite 9860 191 0 Naiural Gas 8710 't 040
Coal. Sub-Bituminous 9820 1840 Wood 9)to 't 830
Figure 1. Fuel Type
D.
t
T
t
T
T
!
T
lf fuel sample increments are taken and composited during the test and an ultimate analysis is
performed and the GCV is determined, then
^ 321 x 103 (o1o51
Fr = ----==::- where o/oC = Carbon content by weight expressed as percent. GCV
l3.e+101o111+ 7.53(o/oc) * 0.57(o/oS) * 0.14(0/oN) -0.46(0/o0))x 106Fd-GCV
H = Hydrogen, percent; C = Carbon, percent; S = Sulfur, percent; N = Nitrogen, percent; O =
Oxygen, percent
I
CN&F-009 Emission Rate Calcs
t
Project No. M243506
I
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Rev. 1.2
59 of 199
1t1t2021
@Mostardi Platt
MOSTARDI PLATT
Relative Accuracy Test Audit (RATA) Calculations and Bias Adjustment Factor
Calculation
Mean Difference
-1+d=-) dinLi=1
I
T
I
I
T
I
T
T
T
T
I
I
I
Standard Deviation
lzr=.,0? - [xilra']'
c.J-l-I n-l
t
Confidence Coefficient
.sd
LL - t0.0ZS-!n
Relative Accuracv
ldl + tcctRA=ffi: x 100
Bias Adiustment Factor
ldtBAF = 1+ csinlw
CN&F-030 Part 75 RA Bias Calcs
Project No. M243506
Unit I, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Rev. 1.2 1t1t202'l
t
T
T
I
I
T
60 of 199 OMostardi Platt
Appendix F - Reference Method Test Data (Computerized Sheets)
Project No. M243506
Unit '1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Test Location: Unit 1
Date:8126124
I
I
I
T
I
I
I
t
T
T
Run 1
NOx ppmvd 02o/o 1d,wI
Run 2
NOx oomvd 02 % (drv)Time
8:09
8:10
8:11
8:12
8:13
8:14
8:15
8:16
8:17
8:18
8:19
8:20
8:21
8:22
8:23
8:24
8:25
8:26
8:27
8:28
8:29
70.95
70.95
72.36
71.94
72.86
72.79
72.77
72.61
72.90
74.O1
73.63
73.06
73.58
73.88
74.O3
74.35
74.31
74.63
74.29
73.89
73.87
9.18
9.17
9.27
9.25
9.25
9.30
9.33
9.33
9.33
9.35
9.32
9.37
9.35
9.44
9.38
9.44
9.45
9.44
9.44
9.40
9.32
Time
8:39
8:40
8:41
8:42
8:43
8:44
8:45
8:46
8:47
8:48
8:49
8:50
8:51
8:52
8:53
8:54
8:55
8:56
8:57
8:58
8:59
71.57
71.46
9.10
9.14
CO2o/o (dryl
6.76
6.76
6.71
6.72
6.73
6.69
6.68
6.68
6.68
6.66
6.69
6.66
6.67
6.61
6.65
6.61
6.61
6.61
6.62
6.65
6.49
72.12 9.2171.58 9.1272.07 9.13
71.75 9.1072.69 9.08
CO2% (drvl
6.74
6.71
6.66
6.72
6.72
6.73
6.75
6.71
6.74
6.75
6.76
6.78
6.76
6.75
6.73
6.72
6.73
6.71
6.65
6.64
6.55
72.12
71.91
71.80
71.95
71.11
71 .51
72.45
72.O7
72.69
71.91
9.15
9.10
9.07
9.07
9.03
9.07
9.08
9.12
9.14
9.1372.74 9.1572.99 9.26
74.O1
73.81
9.28
9.07
Average
Time
9:07
9:08
9:09
9:10
9:11
9:12
9:13
9:14
9:15
9:16
9:17
9:18
9:19
9:20
9:21
9.22
9:23
9.24
9:25
9:26
9:27
6.66
CO2% HwI
6.65
6.64
6.61
6.61
6.62
6.61
6.&
6.69
6.71
6.69
6.69
6.70
6.73
6.68
6.74
6.72
6.70
6.68
6.73
6.67
6.68
73.22 9.34
Run 3
NOx opmvd 02% |dryl74.74 9.25
9.28
9.3373.60 9.32
74.25
73.76
74.24
73.31
73.48
73.36
73.25
71.87
72.67
71.56
72.86
Average 72.21 9.12
Run 4
6.71
74.01
74.05
72.44
73.10
72.U
9.31
9.32
9.28
9.19
9.15
9.20
9.21
9.18
9.14
9.22
9.11
71 .80 9.1 572.90 9.1971.97 9.21
9.13
9.22
9.21
Time NOx oomvd O2oh 4d,wl CO2 % (drv)
9:36 73.47 9.20 6.69
9:37 73.84 9.22 6.68
9:38 74.90 9.28 6.64
9:39 73.03 9.26 6.669:40 74.87 9.32 6.629:41 74.67 9.31 6.62
9:42 75.37 9.27 6.64
9:43 73.39 9.30 6.63
9:44 73.88 9.37 6.59
9:45 73.57 9.25 6.669:46 74.51 9.32 6.62
9:47 73.75 9.28 6.65
9;48 74.20 9.32 6.62
9:49 74.86 9.26 6.66
9:50 72.88 9.25 6.669:51 73.46 9.24 6.67
9:52 73.08 9.20 6.70
9:53 73.68 9.23 6.68
9:54 7310 9.20 6.69
9:55 73.42 9.15 6.73
I
T
t
I
T
T
9:56 72.31
Average 73.'.|.2
MostardiPlatt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
9.26
RATA Extractiv e 41 1 6120
@Mostardi Platt
I
I
I
v5.0
62 of 199
5.68 Average
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Test Location: Unit 1
Date:8126124
Time
10:04
10:05
10:06
10:07
10:08
10:09
10:'10
10:11
1O:12
10:13
1O:14
10:15
'10:16
10:17
10:18
10:19
10:20
10:21
10:22
10:23
1O:24
Run 5
NOx pomvd OZoh (drvl CO2 % (drv)
72.33 9.12 6.7472.40 9.19 6.7071.25 9.23 6.6872.55 9.16 6.7272.19 9.18 6.7172.68 9.24 6.6772.36 9.18 6.7172.22 9.21 6.6973.77 9.23 6.6873.43 9.28 6.6573.',t0 9.25 6.6773.05 9.35 6.6174.15 9.30 6.6374.32 9.36 6.6075.24 9.38 6.5974.64 9.31 6.6374.98 9.35 6.6074.45 9.41 6.5775.30 9.37 6.5974.92 9.31 6.6374.77 9.35 6.61
Run 6Time NOx oomvd O2o/o (dwl CO2 % (drvl
10:33 74.91 9.22 6.6710:34 73.'11 9.31 6.6310:35 73.67 9.20 6.7010:36 73.17 9.31 6.6410:37 73.56 9.27 6.6610:38 72.97 9.21 6.6910:39 73.72 9.21 6.6910:40 72.62 9.24 6.6810:41 73.27 9.26 6.6710:42 72.41 9.15 6.7310:43 72.49 9.14 6.7410:44 71.91 9.20 6.7010:45 73.06 9.18 6.7110:46 73.78 9.17 6.7210:47 73.10 9.24 6.6710:48 73.88 9.33 6.6210:49 74.11 9.20 6.7010:50 74.40 9.29 6.6410;51 74.54 9.34 6.6110:52 74.39 9.3'l 6.6410:53 74.16 9.21 6.63
Average
Time
11:04
11:05
11:06
11:O7
11:08
11:09
11:'10
11:11
11:12
11:13
11:14
11:15
1 1:16
11:17
11:18
1 1:19
11:20
11:21
11:22
11:23
11:24
73.53 Average 73.49 9.24
Run 8Run 7
NOx ppmvd O2o/o (drvl CO2% (drvl
75.00 9.30 6.64
75.63 9.36 6.61
74.82 9.43 6.57
74.94 9.33 6.63
75.29 9.35 6.6275.55 9.36 6.6175.09 9.42 6.57
75.55 9.36 6.61
75.19 9.38 6.60
75.34 9.35 6.61
74.79 9.36 6.6176.00 9.36 6.6176j0 9.36 6.6175.80 9.38 6.60
75.70 9.46 6.55
76.40 9.38 6.60
76.17 9.37 6.6076.60 9.19 6.5376.90 9.20 6.63
76.80 9.24 6.59
77.00 9.18 6.61
Time NOx pomvd O2olo ldryl CO2% (d,wl
1 1:33 75.55 9.32 6.631'l:34 75.70 9.36 6.6011:35 76.11 9.37 6.6011:36 76.18 9.33 6.621'l:37 74.75 9.30 6.6511:38 75.43 9.34 6.6211:39 74.74 9.34 6.6211:40 75.58 9.29 6.6511.41 75.84 9.30 6.6511:42 75.45 9.32 6.641'1:43 75.47 9.33 6.6311:44 76.18 9.34 6.6211:45 75.84 9.31 6.6411:46 76.07 9.34 6.6311:47 76.51 9.29 6.6511:48 75.86 9.36 6.6111:49 77.00 9.37 6.6111:50 76.47 9.30 6.6411:51 77.55 9.31 6.6411:52 77.14 9.35 6.61
'l 1:53 77.OO 9.07 6.45
Average 75.75 9.34
MostardiPlatt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
9.32
RATA Extractiv e 41 1 6120
OMostardi Platt
v5.0
63 of 199
Average
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Test Location: Unit 1
Date;8126124
T
I
T
T
T
I
I
T
Time
12:O5
12:06
12:07
12:08
12:O9
12:10
12:11
12:12
12:13
12:14
12:15
12:16
12:17
12:18
12:19
12:20
12:21
12:22
12:23
12:24
12:25
76.54
76.61
76.52
76.08
74.98
75.74
76.01
77.04
76.24
76.84
76.49
76.22
75.42
76.24
77.U
75.89
76.52
76.66
77.18
9.43
9.42
9.39
9.36
9.40
9.36
9.37
9.28
9.35
9.28
9.31
9.32
9.37
9.33
9.27
9.26
9.34
9.33
9.34
Time
12:34
12:35
12:36
12:37
12:38
12:39
12:40
12:41
12'.42
12:43
12:44
12:45
12:46
12:47
12:48
12:49
12:50
12:51
12:52
1253
12:54
76.84
76.58
76.57
76.62
76.11
76.67
76.73
77.27
76.40
76.74
75.77
76.64
9.35
9.37
9.40
9.35
9.31
9.30
9.34
9.36
9.34
9.30
9.31
9.40
Run 9
NOx ppmvd 02% 1drvl76.40 9.3977.57 9.41
CO2% (d,wl
6.59
6.58
6.56
6.57
6.59
6.61
6.58
6.62
6.60
6.66
6.61
6.66
6.64
6.63
6.61
6.63
6.67
6.67
6.63
6.63
6.62
CO2 % (drv)
6.55
6.s8
6.60
6.58
6.57
6.58
6.57
6.57
6.60
6.62
6.61
6.59
6.62
6.64
6.65
6.62
6.62
6.63
6.64
6.64
6.58
Run 10
NOx ppmvd 02o/o (drvl
78.32 9.4578.15 9.4278.35 9.38
78.34 9.4077.84 9.4278.16 9.4177.73 9.42
76.97 9.41
77.20 9.38
76.41 9.35
MostardiPlatt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
77.',|.4 9.37
RATA Extractiu e 4 I 1 6120
@Mostardi Platt
I
v5.0
64 of 199
T
I
I
I
T
I
T
I
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Test Location: Unit 2
Date:8126124
Time
8:09
8:10
8:11
8:12
8:13
8:14
8:15
8:16
8:'17
8:18
8:19
8:20
8:21
8:22
8:23
8:24
8:25
8:26
8:27
8:28
8:29
Run 1
NOx pomvd 02o/o (dwl
62.48 9.9363.66 8.9668.45 9.46u.84 7.6269.75 7.3268.05 7.2766.61 7.1366.18 7.13u.46 7.2067.22 7.3268.28 7.4068.47 7.3168.43 7.'.1865.22 7.1866.14 7.2269.30 7.3268.91 7.4369.50 7.v69.28 7.2467.17 7.2268.84 7.23
Run 2Time NOx opmvd O2o/o ldwl CO2% 1drvl8:39 63.69 10.61 6.688:40 62.83 10.64 6.698:41 65.60 10.28 6.868:42 69.93 11.29 6.368:43 67.19 10.22 6.898:44 61.66 11.23 6.428:45 67.00 13.24 5.348:46 61.46 12.59 5.638:47 66.72 10.01 6.998:48 67.25 9.93 6.038:49 69.14 9.88 6.068:50 67.84 9.83 6.098:51 67.57 9.76 6.128:52 66.86 9.79 6.118:53 66.97 9.90 6.068:54 69.94 9.99 6.018:55 68.41 9.97 6.038:56 67.01 9.77 6.128:57 67.86 9.76 6.'128:58 67.90 9.81 6.108:59 66.58 9.91 6.05
CO2% (dwl
6.21
6.65
6.28
6.68
5.93
5.97
6.07
6.08
6.03
5.95
5.90
5.96
6.06
6.05
6.03
5.96
5.89
5.95
6.02
6.04
6.03
Average 67.20 7.59
Run 3
Time NOx pomvd 02% (drul GO2 % (drv)
Average
Time
9:36
9:37
9:38
9:39
9:40
9:41
9:42
9:43
9:44
9:45
9:46
9:47
9:48
9:49
9:50
9:51
9:52
9:53
9:54
9:55
9:56
6.23
CO2% (dwI
6.06
6.03
6.03
6.01
6.06
6.06
6.07
6.03
6.05
6.05
6.09
6.'t6
6.15
6.10
6.06
6.06
6.10
6.14
6.17
6.13
6.00
66.64 10.40
Run 4
NOx oomvd 02% |dwl
59.49 9.88
69.33 9.98
69.02 9.97
70.22 10.03
68.85 9.93
9:07
9:08
9:09
9:10
9:11
9:12
9:13
9:14
9:15
9:16
9:17
9:18
9:19
9:20
9:21
9:22
9:23
9:24
9:25
9:26
68.19 10.3567.69 11.1704.00 10.3868.54 10.8862.62 10.1667.00 10.2965.53 10.3168.54 10.2070.40 10.0968.81 9.9569.58 9.8569.73 9.7869.18 9.7668.84 9.9569.97 10.0770.33 9.9970.55 9.8168.95 9.8067.65 9.8070.07 9.93
5.84
6.43
5.83
6.60
5.94
5.88
5.87
5.93
5.98
6.04
6.10
6.13
6.15
6.06
6.00
6.03
6.12
6.'13
6.13
6.07
9.30
9.40
69.33 9.9368.14 9.9268.86 9.5972.60 9.52
71.32 9.4570.54 9.31
73.39
71.30
71.61
71.60
70.90
9.55
9.34
9.4672.26 9.5372.83 9.5372.56 9.4571.83 9.36
9:27 71 .46 10. 1 3 5.98Average 68.46 10.13 6.06 9.62
71.19 9.67
MostardiPlatt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
v5.0
65 of 199
RATA Extractive 41 16120
OMostardi Platt
Average 70.34
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Test Location: Unit 2
Date:8126124
I
t
T
T
T
t
!
I
t
I
Time
10:04
10:05
10:06
10:07
10:08
'10:09
10;10
10:11
10:12
10:13
1O:14
10:15
10:16
1O:17
10:18
10:19
10:20
10:21
10:22
10:23
1O:24
9.96
9.82
9.60
9.69
9.95
9.48
9.48
9.28
9.08
9.21
9.36
9.35
9.37
9.19
9.07
9.07
9.17
9.30
9.27
9.12
9.05
Time
10:33
10:34
10:35
10:36
10:37
10:38
10:39
10:40
10:41
1O:42
10:43
10:44
10:45
10:46
10:47
10:48
10:49
10:50
10:51
10:52
10:53
69.31
71.72
72.69
9.78
9.26
9.37
Run 5
NOx pomvd 02% @wl
67.79
67.59
68.66
67.83
67.53
69.93
70.80
72.53
69.80
69.27
69.06
68.96
71.73
71.86
72.53
71.23
71.43
72.26
72.25
73.87
70.73
COZ% (drvl
6.09
6.06
6.08
6.05
6.02
6.03
6.04
6.05
6.13
6.08
6.01
6.02
6.01
6.09
6.15
6.15
6.10
6.04
6.06
6.13
6.17
73.56 9.24
73.51 9j273.59 9.01
CO2 % (drv)
6.03
6.06
6.08
6.01
6.08
6.07
6.02
6.06
6.00
6.02
6.14
6.19
6.20
6.17
6.10
6.11
6.11
6.18
6.22
6.21
6.17
Run 6
NOx oomvd 02% Gwl76.83 9.8069.69 9.8970.41 9.79
69.53 9.59
69.56 9.6569.55 9.88
72.89
72.27
74.47
74.33
74.64
73.34
71.51
72.90
72.98
9.00
9.05
9.20
9.17
9.19
9.03
8.95
8.99
9.06
Average
Time
11:04
11:05
11:06
11:07
11:08
11:09
11:10
11:11
11:12
11:13
11.14
11:15
11:16
11:17
11:18
1 1:19
11:20
11:21
11:22
11:23
11:24
5.07
CO2 % (drv)
6.01
6.06
6.03
6.10
6.19
6.12
6.07
6.12
6.21
6.23
6.22
6.14
6.07
6.08
6.13
6.18
6.20
6.12
6.07
6.05
6.05
Average70.36 9.37
Run 7
NOx opmvd 02 % (drv)
72.35 9.33
Run 8
6.11
71.24
70.24
9.M
9.52
Time NOx pomvd 02o/o (dlvl CO2o/o (drvl
11:33 73.07 9.71 6.09
11:34 72.08 9.60 6.0011:35 72.52 9.70 6.0711:36 72.69 9.74 6.0411:37 74.89 9.38 6.0811:38 76.32 9.36 6.06
11:39 76.03 9.32 6.0211:40 77.49 9.19 6.0911:41 77.41 9.11 6.1111:42 77.33 9.06 6.06
11:43 76.45 9.14 6.'14
11:44 76.65 9.27 6.0711:45 77.48 9.40 6.0011:46 79.07 9.40 6.0011:47 79.05 9.15 6.0511:48 77.17 9.01 6.01
11.49 76.85 9.07 6.07
11:50 78.07 9.32 6.02
11:51 80.35 9.42 6.0211:52 79.90 9.36 6.06'11:53 80.00 9.16 6.09
I
I
T
T
I
T
70.84 9.39
74.19 9.0174.55 8.97
72.46
74.66
74.31
73.15
74.64
9.23
9.04
9.21
9.31
9.21
9.00
9.18
9.31
9.29
9.18
9.07
9.04
8.80
9.02
74.24
74.76
74.75
74.61
76.17
75.96
75.82
73.82
73.8273.00 9.00
74.86 9.10
73.91 9.17
MostardiPlatt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
t
T
t
v5.0
66 of 199
RATA Extractive 41 16120
OMostardi Platt
6.'.12 76.71
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Test Location: Unit 2
Da!'e:8126124
Run 9
NOx ppmvd 02% {d,wl
Run l0Time NOx oomvd 02% (d,wl CO2 % (drv)
12:34 77.21 9.61 6.0612:35 76.37 9.55 6.0012:36 75.56 9.69 6.04'12:37 75.87 9.87 6.0512:38 76.51 9.97 6.0812:39 78.28 9.90 6.0412:4O 76.22 9.75 6.0112.41 76.69 9.22 6.0712:42 78.00 9.15 6.0212:43 79.38 9.34 6.1112:44 80.73 9.36 6.1012:45 79.99 9.24 6.1612:46 80.26 9.22 6.1712:47 79.44 9.31 6.1312:48 79.89 9.15 6.0212:49 79.89 9.11 6.0212:50 80.81 9.12 6.0212:51 79.38 9.31 6.1412:52 80.24 9.51 6.0412:53 80.27 9.41 6.0812:54 80.18 9.23 6.18
Time
12:05
12:06
12:07
12:08
12:09
12:10
12:11
12:12
12:13
12:14
12:15
12:16
12:17
12:18
12:19
12.'2O
12:21
12:22
12.'23
12:24
12:25
75.97
77.68
76.93
76.71
75.65
75.21
74.14
75.87
77.99
78.46
77.96
79.62
80.22
79.46
78.81
78.44
79.70
79.71
80.01
78.20
78.U
9.809.82 6.069.87 6.049.73 6.009.66 6.049.70 6.029.70 6.029.66 6.049.45 6.M9.37 6.089.15 6.189.19 6.179.18 6.179.16 6.179.'t5 6.199.13 6.199.17 6.'t89.34 6.109.39 6.079.34 6.109.33 6.11
CO2 % (drvl
6.07
77.85
MostardiPlatt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
6.10
v5.0
67 of 199
RATA Extractive 4116120
OMostardi Platt
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Test Location: Unit 3
Date:8127124
I
t
T
T
T
T
I
t
T
I
Time
6:35
6:36
6:37
6:38
6:39
6:40
6:41
6:42
6:43
6:44
6:45
6:46
6:47
6:48
6:49
6:50
6:51
6:52
6:53
6:54
6:55
Run 1
NOx ppmvd 02o/o Grvl
Run 2
Time NOx opmvd 02% Hryl7:02 53.61 9.61
7:03 54.42 9.63
7:04 53.80 9.627:05 52.33 9.717:06 50.88 9.747:07 51.83 9.65
7:08 53.17 9.67
7:09 51.91 9.61
7:10 54.43 9.697:11 54.39 9.607:12 51.30 9.687:13 51.65 9.657:14 52.97 9.607:15 55.46
7:16 55.70
7:17 52.57
7:18 53.907:19 55.417:20 55.357:21 56.567:22 53.03
9.71
9.77
9.71
9.70
9.72
9.74
9.79
9.78
45.29
50.90
48.72
40.39
36.06
44.44
49.77
50.27
47.O1
47.90
49.19
9.62
9.55
9.64
9.81
9.85
9.65
9.60
9.69
9.67
9.68
9.67
47.59 9.67
CO2 % (drv)
6.38
6.78
6.53
6.55
6.25
6.32
6.34
6.31
6.31
6.32
6.31
6.36
6.39
6.30
6.29
6.30
6.31
6.31
6.30
6.30
6.30
CO2 % (drv)
6.31
6.30
6.31
6.28
6.27
6.31
6.3't
6.33
6.30
6.34
6.31
6.32
6.34
6.30
6.27
6.30
6.30
6.30
6.29
6.27
6.28
51.31 9.7149.36 9.65
48.85
48.58
49.49
51.74
54.23
53.52
54.32
9.65
9.62
9.61
9.63
9.66
9.67
9.68
Average
Time
7:28
7:29
7:30
7:31
7:32
7:33
7:34
7:35
7:36
7:37
7:38
7:39
7:40
7:41
7:42
7:43
7:44
7:45
7:46
7:47
7:48
5.36
CO2% Grvl
6.31
6.30
6.29
6.27
6.29
6.32
6.30
6.32
6.23
6.27
6.31
6.32
6.34
6.31
6.33
6.34
6.32
6.33
6.34
6.33
6.33
Average48.52 9.67
Run 3
NOx pomvd 02% @ryl55.96 9.6055.66 9.6752.96 9.71
53.56 9.68
Run 4
6.30
52.86
52.49
55.36
56.29
54.66
53.23
47.46
9.76
9.74
9.69
9.72
9.67
9.90
9.81
Time NOx ppmvd 02% Hryl CO2 % (drv)
7:55 55.56 9.62 6.357:56 56.23 9.67 6.347:57 55.31 9.73 6.327:58 55.78 9.83 6.28
7:59 57.22 9.65 6.36
8:00 56.52 9.75 6.31
8:01 56.38 9.74 6.328:02 55.32 9.75 6.328:03 55.59 9.73 6.33
8:04 56.49 9.77 6.31
8:05 55.77 9.69 6.35
8:06 57.41 9.67 6.368:07 57.14 9.64 6.378:08 56.70 9.69 6.35
8:09 57.05 9.69 6.35
8:10 56.56 9.71 6.34
8:'11 55.93 9.69 6.35
8:12 57.16 9.69 6.358:13 58.01 9.69 6.35
8: 14 57 .21 9.67 6.36
8:15 55.95 9.67 6.36
I
T
I
I
t
I
52.89 9.73
56.49
54.22
9.70
9.6654.16 9.7352.69 9.68
52.49 9.67
52.96 9.71
53.79 9.7055.83 9.68u.40 9.72
53.95 9.71
Average
MostardiPlatt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
v5.0
68 of 199
T
t
T
6.349.70
RATA Extractiv e 41 1 6120
OMostardi Platt
6.31 Average
I
t
I
T
I
I
T
T
I
T
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Test Location: Unit 3
Date:8127124
Run 5
NOx ppmvd O2o/o |drvl
Run 6
NOx pomvd 02o/o (drvl
55.62 9.6355.53 9.6157.12 9.6856.52 9.6357.33 9.6055.69 9.6454.76 9.6455.9't 9.6455.85 9.6357.68 9.6455.17 9.6454.68 9.6756.56 9.6555.23 9.63
57.07
56.18
55.27
56.83
56.81
57.27
55.72
9.65
9.66
9.64
9.65
9.65
9.65
9.68
Time
8:22
8:23
8:24
8:25
8:26
8:27
8:28
8:29
8:30
8:31
8:32
8:33
8:34
8:35
8:36
8:37
8:38
8;39
8:40
8:41
8:42
56.24
56.03
57.26
56.65
56.11
55.66
56.99
57.92
57.15
57.18
55.21
55.95
56.58
57.06
57.M
55.1 I
55.45
56.54
56.08
56.20
55.59
9.61
9.65
9.68
9.73
9.80
9.62
9.59
9.68
9.62
9.61
9.&
9.66
9.66
9.67
9.67
9.67
9.68
9.66
9.65
9.67
9.66
Time
8:49
8:50
8:51
8:52
8:53
8:54
8:55
8:56
8:57
8:58
8:59
9:00
9:01
9:02
9:03
9:04
9:05
9:06
9:07
9:08
9:09
COZ% ldrvl
6.36
6.36
6.35
6.34
6.30
6.38
6.40
6.37
6.39
6.40
6.38
6.38
6.38
6.38
6.37
6.38
6.37
6.38
6.39
6.38
6.39
CO2% @ryl
6.38
6.40
6.37
6.39
6.41
6.40
6.40
6.40
6.41
6.40
6.40
6.39
6.40
6.41
6.40
6.40
6.41
6.40
6.40
6.41
6.39
Average
Time
9:15
9:16
9:17
9:18
9:19
9:20
9:21
9:22
9:23
9:24
9:25
9:26
9:27
9:28
9:29
9:30
9:31
9:32
9:33
9:34
9:35
6.37
CO2 % (drv)
6.41
6.41
6.41
6.41
6.42
6.42
6.42
6.43
6.42
6.41
6.40
6.42
6.41
6.43
6.41
6.43
6.42
6.42
6.41
6.42
6.42
s6.38 9.56
Run 7
NOx opmvd 02o/o (dwl
57.74 9.5358.29 9.58s7.87 9.60
57.16 9.62
55.69 9.61
55.07 9.61
56.88 9.62
55.36 9.60
55.04 9.Al
55.55 9.65
55.17 9.68
57.04 9.63
56.81 9.65
56.04 9.60
55.67 9.6654.76 9.6356.45 9.65
il.90 9.65
u.79 9.67
56.13 9.6555.81 9.66
Average 56.13
I
t
I
I
T
I
Run 8Time NOx ppmvd O2o/o (drvl CO2 % (drv)
9:41 55.16 9.48 6.45
9:42 56.69 9.53 6.45
9:43 56.72 9.59 6.44
9:44 56.26 9.58 6.459:45 55.20 9.61 6.449:46 55.47 9.65 6.429:47 55.16 9.67 6.42
9:48 57.48 9.59 6.45
9:49 57.79 9.59 6.45
9:50 57.34 9.58 6.45
9:51 56.77 9.58 6.469:52 58.12 9.56 6.469:53 56.99 9.57 6.469:54 56.46 9.55 6.47
9:55 55.64 9.59 6.46
9:56 54.98 9.62 6.44
9:57 55.71 9.60 6.469:58 55.06 9.60 6.459:59 55.03 9.59 6.46
10:00 54.89 9.72 6.41
10:01 55.53 9.62 6.45
T
T
T
Average 56.11
MostardiPlatt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
v5.0
69 of 199
RATA Extractiv e 4l I 6120
@Mostardi Platt
56.12
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Test Location: Unit 3
Date:8127124
I
T
I
T
T
T
T
T
T
t
Time
10:07
10:08
10:09
10:10
10:11
10:12
10:13
10:14
10:15
10:16
1O:17
10:18
10:19
10:20
10:21
10:22
10:23
10:24
10:25
10:26
10:27
Run 9
NOx ppmvd 02% GwI CO2 % (drv)
58.53 9.47 6.4757.45 9.52 6.4757.73 9.56 6.4756.51 9.55 6.4854.96 9.60 6.46
58.32 9.64 6.4459.28 9.69 6.4346.35 9.88 6.34
38.82 9.76 6.40
49.39 9.53 6.5055.98 9.39 6.56
57.29 9.36 6.57
54.46 9.61 6.4742.45 9.70 6.4337.96 9.66 6.4549.27 9.43 6.5554.63 9.38 6.5755.66 9.38 6.56
53.24 9.45 6.54
50.92 9.51 6.52s0.00 9.53 6.51
Run 10
Time NOx pomvd O2o/o Gwl CO2 % (drv)
10:33 52.82 9.45 6.4910:34 52.74 9.39 6.5410:35 55.91 9.55 6.4810:36 53.42 9.62 6.47
10:37 51.31 9.54 6.49
10:38 53.08 9.67 6.4410:39 51.07 9.53 6.5110:40 53.60 9.53 6.51
10:41 55.84 9.53 6.5110:42 56.10 9.49 6.5310:43 55.78 9.51 6.5210:44 54.56 9.54 6.5110:45 54.85 9.56 6.5010:46 54.04 9.57 6.5010:47 53.03 9.53 6.5110:48 54.88 9.57 6.50
10:49 55.82 9.56 6.50
10:50 59.16 9.59 6.50
10:51 57.02 9.60 6.49
10:52 55.28 9.57 6.5110:53 54.82 9.60 6.49
MostardiPlatt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Average 6.50
v5.0
70 of 199
RATA Extractiv e 4 I 1 61 20
@Mostardi Platt
I
T
T
I
I
I
T
I
I
I
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Test Location: Unit 4
Datei 8128124
Time
6:35
6:36
6:37
6:38
6:39
6:40
6:41
6:42
6:43
6:44
6:45
6:46
6:47
6:48
6:49
6:50
6:51
6:52
6:53
6:54
6:55
16.10
16.11
16.11
16.10
16.09
15.98
16.02
16.02
16.04
16.04
16.04
16.03
16.02
15.97
15.97
15.97
15.97
15.97
15.97
15.98
15.96
Run 1
NOx oomvd 02% (drvl
1.19
1.19
1.19
1.19
1.33
0.94
0.92
0.89
0.99
0.99
1.12
1.19
1.25
1.39
1.39
1.39
1.49
1.59
1.59
1.59
1.59
Run 2Time NOx ppmvd 02o/o |drvl CO pomvd7:O7 1.59 16.35 1.027:08 1.59 16.34 1.057:09 1.20 16.33 1.067:10 1.05 16.35 1.047:11 1.'19 16.35 1.077:12 1.22 16.35 1.097:13 1.30 16.34 1.057:14 0.99 16.33 1.067:15 1.19 16.29 1.057:16 1.23 16.29 1.127:17 1.39 '16.30 1.097:18 1.56 16.30 1.137:19 1 .59 16.30 1.077:20 1.59 16.31 1.097:21 1.59 16.31 1.117:22 1.59 16.32 1.107:23 1.56 16.31 1.207:24 1.59 16.30 1.267:25 1.53 16.28 1.157:26 0.86 16.28 1.087:27 0.79 16.28 1.13
CO opmvd
1.07
1.07
1.08
1.04
1.M
1.08
0.99
1.01
1.00
1.02
1.02
1.04
1.01
1.00
1.05
1.04
1.01
0.98
'1.05
1.04
1.01Average 1.26 16.02
Run 3Time NOx oomvd 02% /dlvl CO opmvd
't.03 Average 1.34 16.31
1.06
1.09
1.10
1.18
1.21
1.19
1.13
1.15
1.18
1.12
1.11
1.15
1.17
1.10
1.U
1.0s
0.99
0.97
0.97
0.99
v5.0
7l of 199
Run 4
Time NOx pomvd 02o/o (drvl CO ppmvd
8:12 0.79 16.31 0.92
8:13 0.79 16^30 0.93
8:14 0.79 16.30 0.96
8:15 0.79 16.29 0.99
8:16 0.79 16.26 1.008:17 0.79 16.26 1.038:18 0.83 16.27 1 .018:19 0.83 16.27 1 .03
8:20 0.80 16.27 1.06
8:21 0.79 16.28 1.07
8:22 0.80 16.22 1.16
8:23 0.80 16.20 1.168:24 0.79 '16.20 1.218:25 0.80 16.19 1.13
8:26 0.80 16.18 1.21
8:27 0.83 16.18 1.18
8:28 0.80 16.17 1.16
8:29 0.87 1 6.18 1 .1 I8:30 0.99 1 6.1 8 1 .1 I
8:31 0.99 16.18 1.27
8:32 0.99 16.18 1.22
1.10
7:39
7:4O
7:41
7:42
7:43
7:44
7:45
7:46
7:47
7:48
7:49
7:50
7:51
7:52
7:53
7:54
7:55
7:56
7:57
7:58
0.79
0.83
0.90
0.99
1.16
1.26
1.43
1.59
1.66
1.83
1.99
2.13
2.19
2.19
2.40
2.56
2.11
1.59
1.85
2.22
16.34
16.33
16.35
16.35
16.36
16.36
16.36
16.36
16.36
16.36
16.36
16.36
16.37
16.36
16.35
16.34
16.34
16.33
16.34
16.337:59 1.40 16.24 0.98
MostardiPlatt
Project No. M243506
Unit '1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
1.10
RATA Extractiv e 4l I 6120
OMostardi Platt
Average
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Test Location: Unit 4
Date:8128124
I
I
I
e:37 1.8e 16.13 o.6i IAvaraoe 1.89 16.17 0 5?- I
aAverage 1.84 16.13 0.92 I
rime Hor.pr#" uorn ro^ co ppmvd rime ,rr"*f'Ll n ,or, co ppmvd I8:44 1.08 16.29 1.01 9'.17 1.89 16.24 0.918:45 1.58 16.29 1 .00 9:18 1 .89 16.25 0.88
8:46 1.g4 16.28 O.g7 9:19 1 .89 16.25 0.92 I8:47 2.07 16.28 0.98 9:20 1.89 16.23 0.93 I
8:48 2.28 16.26 0.98 9:21 1.89 16.22 0.888:49 1.7O 16.26 0.97 9:22 1.89 16.18 0.92 I8:50 '1.59 16.27 0.89 9:23 1.91 16.15 0.92 t8:51 1.94 16.27 0.91 9:24 1.89 16.15 0.958:52 2.47 16.27 0.93 9:25 1.89 16.15 0.918:53 2.85 16.27 O.g2 9:26 1.89 16.14 0.91 I8:54 3.11 16.27 0.95 9:27 1.89 16.14 0.90 I8:55 3.24 16.26 0.93 9:28 1.89 16.14 0.908:56 2.72 16.21 O.92 9:29 1.89 16.14 0.93 I8:57 2.01 16.18 0.93 9:30 1.89 16.14 0.87 I8:58 2.35 16.18 0.92 9:31 1.89 16.14 0.93 r
8:59 2.64 16.18 0.99 9:32 1.89 16.14 0.939:00 2.79 16.18 0.96 9:33 1.89 16.15 0.87 I9:01 2.81 16.18 0.94 9:34 1.89 16.15 0.91 I9:02 2.94 16.18 0.95 9:35 1.89 16.13 0.929:03 2.79 16.18 0.97 9:36 1.89 '16.12 0.969:04 2.64 16.18 0.97 9:37 1.89 16.13 0.92Average 2.36 16.23 0.95 Average 1.89 16.17 0.91
Run 7 Run Irtr ryww ffiwry''"w t9:50 1.85 16.22 0.90 10:22 1.86 16.22 0.929:51 1.87 16.22 0.90 10:23 1.86 16.22 0.919:52 1.89 16.21 0.95 10:24 1.89 16.22 O.9O I9:53 1.89 16.21 0.95 10:25 1.89 16.22 0.899:54 1.89 16.20 0.95 10:26 1.89 16.20 0.919:55 '1.89 16.19 0.95 10:27 1.89 16.21 0.89 I9:56 1.89 16.20 0.93 10:28 1.89 16.19 0.91 I9:57 1 .89 16.1 8 0.88 1 0:29 1 .89 16.20 0.919:58 1.89 16.13 0.94 10:30 1.89 16.12 0.919:59 1.89 16.13 O.g2 10:31 1.89 16.10 0.93 I
1 0:00 1 .89 16.1 3 0.92 10:32 1 .82 1 6.08 0.94 a
1 0:01 1 .89 16.1 3 0.90 1 0:33 1 .80 1 6.08 0.9510:02 1 .89 1 6.1 3 0.89 1 0:34 1 .73 16.09 0.92 t
1 0:03 1 .89 1 6.1 3 0.89 1 0:35 1 .80 16.07 0.9'l I1 0:04 1 .89 1 6.1 3 0.94 10:36 1 .86 't 6.05 0.94
1 0:05 1 .80 16.14 0.94 10:37 1 .80 16.05 0.9610:06 1.82 16.14 0.93 10:38 1.80 16.00 0.95 I10:07 2.OO 16.12 0.99 10:39 1.80 16.06 0.97 I10:08 2.03 16.12 0.97 10:40 1.80 16.06 0.92
1 0:09 1 .93 1 6.1 0 0.93 10:41 1 .80 16.06 0.94Average 1.89 16.16 0.93 Average 1.84 16.13 0.92
MostardiPlatt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
v5.0
72 of 199
RATA Extract ive 4t16t2O I
@Mostardi Plaft
T
I
I
t
T
T
T
I
t
I
I
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Test Location: Unit 4
Dal.c:8128124
Time
11:03
11:04
11:05
11:06
11:07
'11:08
11:09
'11:10
11:11
11:12
'11:13
11:14
11:15
11:16
11:17
11:18
11:19
11:2O
11:21
11:22
11:23
2.30
2.36
2.33
2.36
2.30
2.30
2.27
2.20
2.33
2.29
2.26
2.36
2.20
2.36
2.23
2.40
2.36
2.40
2.32
2.27
2.O0
2.20
2.19
2.19
2.12
2.12
2.19
2.24
2.27
2.01
2.20
2.20
2.20
2.14
2.10
2.10
2.09
2.06
2.09
2.10
16.16
16.15
16.14
16.14
16.14
16.14
16.13
16.13
16.13
16.10
16.05
16.05
16.04
16.01
16.01
16.01
16.01
16.01
16.00
15.63
Run 9
NOx oomvd 02o/o ldwl2.30 16.18
16.10
16.10
16.08
16.08
16.09
16.09
16.07
16.07
16.08
16.07
16.07
16.07
16.07
16.06
16.06
16.06
16.06
16.05
16.05
16.05
CO ppmvd
0.90
0.93
0.92
0.92
0.93
0.94
0.94
0.95
0.90
0.91
0.9'l
0.93
0.96
0.91
0.91
0.94
0.94
0.95
0.93
0.97
0.90
Time
11:35
11:36
11:37
11:38
11:39
11:40
11:41
11:42
11:43
11:44
11:45
11:46
11:47
11:48
11:49
11:50
11:51
11:52
11:53
11:54
11:55
CO pomvd
0.90
0.90
0.89
0.91
0.91
0.90
0.88
0.95
0.88
0.95
0.91
0.94
0.94
0.96
0.96
0.98
0.98
0.94
0.93
0.93
0.98
Run 10
NOx oomvd O2o/o 1dwI2.16 16.17
I
I
I
I
I
T
I
I
I
Average
Time
12:O7
12:08
12:O9
12:10
12:11
12:12
12:13
12:14
12:15
12:16
12:17
12:18
12:19
12:20
12:21
12:22
12:23
12:24
12:25
12:26
12:27
16.13
16.13
16.13
16.14
16.13
16.12
16.11
16.10
16.10
16.10
16.04
't6.04
16.04
16.04
16.04
16.03
16.04
16.03
16.02
16.00
16.00
0.93
CO oomvd
0.94
0.93
0.86
0.87
0.92
0.93
0.92
0.93
0.90
0.91
0.93
0.94
0.92
0.93
0.96
0.93
0.96
0.93
0.91
0.93
0.92
2.31 16.08
Run l'l
NOx oomvd 02% {dlvl
2.20
2.30
2.31
2.30
2.30
2.30
2.31
2.38
2.3s
2.33
2.34
2.30
2.30
2.34
2.30
2.30
2.30
2.30
2.30
2.29
2.31
Average 2.14
2.31 16.07
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
v5.0
73 of 199
RATA Extractiv e 41 1 6120
@Mostardi Platt
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Test Location: Unit 5
Date:8128124
I
T
T
T
I
T
I
t
T
T
Time
6:35
6;36
6:37
6:38
6:39
6:40
6:41
6:42
6:43
6:44
6:45
6:46
6:47
6:48
6:49
6:50
6;51
6:52
6:53
6:54
6:55
Run 1
NOx oomvd 02% Hwl CO pomvd4.39 16.08 I .644.28 16.11 1.614.03 16.11 1.583.74 16.11 1.563.41 16.09 1 .553.39 16.06 1.603.31 16.07 1.573.20 16.08 1.593.11 16.09 1.553.00 16.09 1.533.00 16.10 1.533.00 16.07 1.532.81 16.06 1.552.91 16.06 1.562.98 16.06 1 .572.93 16.06 1 .542.83 16.06 1.522.95 16.06 1.512.81 16.07 1.532.79 16.07 1.512.79 16.07 1.51
Run 2
Time NOx oomvd 02% @wl CO oomvd7:07 2.59 15.81 1.53
7:08 2.59 15.96 1.577:09 2.59 16.08 1.587:10 2.59 16.10 1.597:11 2.49 16.13 1.58
7:12 2.59 16.14 1.56
7:13 2.59 16.15 1.577:14 2.59 16.15 1.607:15 2.59 16.13 1.597:16 2.59 16.14 1.587:17 2.59 16.14 1.557:18 2.59 16.16 1.54
7:19 2.59 16.17 1.55
7:20 2.59 16.17 1.557:21 2.59 16.'16 1.547:22 2.59 16.16 1.577:23 2.47 16.16 1.617:24 2.39 16.16 1.687:25 2.35 16.13 1.65
7:26 2.59 16.10 1.63
7:27 2.50 16.1 1 1.72
Average
Time
7:39
7:40
7:41
7:42
7:43
7:44
7:45
7:46
7:47
7:48
7:49
7:50
7:51
7:52
7:53
7:54
7:55
7:56
7:57
7:58
7:59
3.22 16.08
Run 3
2.79 '16.11
1.55 Average
8:32 1.99
16.11 1.59
16.09 '1.93
NOx opmvd 02% Gryl CO pomvd
2.19 16.06 ',t.76
2j9 16.09 1.76
2.33 16.13 1.83
2j9 16.15 1.782.19 16.15 1.802.19 16.17 1.782.29 16.18 1.672.39 16.19 1.67
2.39 16.18 1.67
2.39 16.18 1.632.39 16.17 1.U2.39 16.17 1.662.39 16.15 1.77
2.39 16.14 1.66
2.52 16.13 1.552.69 16.13 1.522.63 '16.13 1.512.79 16.13 1.51
2.73 16.13 1.51
2.72 16.13 1.50
Run 4Time NOx opmvd 02% Hwl CO opmvd8:12 2.16 16.03 1.52
8:13 2.19 16.05 1.48
8:14 2.19 16.06 1.50
8:1 5 2.12 16.07 1 .518:16 2.59 16.07 1.568:17 2.36 16.07 1.628:18 2.23 16.08 '1.63
8:19 2.23 16.09 1.68
8:20 2.19 16.11 1.69
8:21 1.99 16.13 1.788:22 1.96 16.15 1.84
8:23 1.79 16.14 1.95
8:24 1.79 16.14 1.99
8:25 1.79 16.13 1.95
8:26 1 .89 16.10 1.928:27 1.99 16.09 1.92
8:28 1.96 16.09 2.01
8:29 1.86 16.09 2.02
8:30 1.86 16.09 2.02
8:31 1.99 16.09 2.00
t
T
t
T
t
I
1.48
15.14
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
t
T
I
1.79
v5.0
74 of 199
16.09
RATA Extractiv e 4 I 1 6120
@Mostardi Platt
1.65 Average 2.O5
I
I
T
I
T
T
t
t
I
I
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Test Location: Unit 5
Date:8128124
Time
8:44
8:45
8:46
8:47
8:48
8:49
8:50
8:51
8:52
8:53
8:54
8:55
8:56
8:57
8:58
8:59
9:00
9:01
9:02
9:03
9:M
Run 5
NOx opmvd 02% 4d,wl2.39 16.012.53 16.052.59 16.062.59 16.072.59 16.072.66 16.062.70 16.072.73 16.082.92 16.092.83 16.092.89 16.092.93 16.102.89 16.092.69 16.092.79 16.102.83 16.102.79 16.112.83 16.112.82 16.122.86 16.112.83 ',16.12
Run 6Time NOx oomvd 02o/o /d,wl
9:17 2.97 16.009:18 2.89 16.039:19 2.98 16.049:20 2.87 16.039:21 2.99 16.049:22 2.96 16.059:23 2.99 16.069:24 2.99 16.079:25 2.93 16.079:26 2.99 16.089:27 2.99 16.099:28 2.88 16.119:29 2.89 16.119:30 2.94 16.119:31 2.99 16.129:32 2.96 16.099:33 2.99 16.109:34 2.99 16.119:35 2.99 16.099:36 2.99 16.099:37 2.99 16.10
CO ppmvd
1.58
1.56
1.34
1.56
1.56
1.57
1.51
1.48
1.47
1.46
1.45
1.46
1.49
1.49
1.49
1.47
1.48
1.46
1.47
1.46
1.45
CO oomvd
1.48
1.49
1.49
1.49
1.48
1.48
1.47
1.46
1.44
'1.45
1.45
1.47
1.47
1.43
1.43
1.44
1.44
1.4',1
1.43
1.43
1.44
I
I
T
I
T
T
Average
Time
9:49
9:50
9:51
9:52
9:53
9:54
9:55
9:56
9:57
9:58
9:59
10:00
10:01
10:02
10:03
10:04
10:05
10:06
10:07
10:08
10:09
1.50
CO ppmvd
1.41
1.41
1.41
1.42
1.42
1.44
1.41
1.40
1.42
1.41
1.41
1.43
1.42
1.40
1.39
1.39
1.39
1.38
1.39
1.39
1.42
2.75 16.09
Run 7
NOx pomvd 02% 1d,wl
Average 2.96
10:41 1.59
16.08 1.46
16.12 2.20
3.01
3.01
2.99
2.99
3.03
2.99
2.99
2.99
16.08
16.10
16.11
16.11
16.13
16.13
16.16
16.17
Run 8Time NOx pomvd 02 % (drvl CO pomvd
10:21 2.59 16.07 1.4110:22 2.59 16.10 1.4210:23 2.63 16.10 1.4210:24 2.65 16.12 1.4210:25 2.69 16.13 1.4110:26 2.67 16.14 1.4210:27 2.59 16.15 1.401O:28 2.78 16.16 1.3910:29 2.79 16.17 1.4'l10:30 2.79 16.18 1.4010:31 2.79 16.16 1.4010:32 2.79 16.14 1.38
1 0:33 2.80 16.1 3 1 .4010:34 2.79 16.14 1.3810:35 2.80 16.13 1.4110:36 2.79 16.14 1.4O10:37 2.79 16.14 1.3910:38 2.79 16.14 1.3910:39 2.86 16.14 1.3710:40 2.70 16.14 1.49
2.99 16.163.03 16.172.99 16.17
3.14 16.17
3.04 16.15
2.88 16.16
2.79 16.172.76 16.182.90 16.17
3.13 16.17
3.19
3.09
2.86
16.17
16.16
16.15I
I
T
Average 2.99
MostardiPlatt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
16.15 1.41
v5.0
75 of 199
16.14 1.44
RATA Extractiv e 41 1 6120
@Mostardi Platt
Average
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Test Location: Unit 5
Date:8128124
I
t
I
I
T
t
T
T
I
T
Run 9
NOx opmvd 02%(dlvl
Run 10
NOx ppmvd 02% GwlTime
11:03
11:04
11:05
11:06
11:07
11:08
11:09
11:10
11 11
11:12
I'l:'13
11:14
1 1:15
1 1:16
11:17
11:18
1 1:19
11:20
11:21
11:22
11:23
3.39
3.27
3.19
2.91
2.85
2.77
2.59
2.60
2.65
2.79
2.82
2.86
2.79
2.76
2.66
2.66
2.59
2.59
2.69
2.62
2.96
16.16
16.16
16.17
16.17
16.17
16.18
16.19
16.17
16.15
16.13
16.14
16.14
16.14
16.14
16.16
16.16
16.17
16.17
16.16
16.15
16.16
Time
11:35
11:36
11:37
11:38
1 1:39
11:40
11:41
11:42
11:43
11:44
11:45
11:46
11:47
11:48
11:49
11:50
11:51
11:52
11:53
11:54
11:55
2.69
2.59
2.59
2.63
3.09
3.'19
3.19
3.03
3.03
2.86
2.63
2.59
2.59
2.49
2.46
2.79
2.99
2.99
2.99
2.93
2.96
16.01
16.08
16.08
16.10
16.09
16.10
16.11
16.11
16.12
16.14
16.16
16.17
16.17
16.17
16.15
16.14
't6.15
16.16
16.12
16.12
16.12
CO oomvd
1.38
1.40
1.37
1.37
1.36
1.36
1.35
1.37
1.36
1.35
1.37
1.37
1.37
1.37
1.38
1.36
1.U
1.35
1.35
1.36
1.38
CO pomvd
1.27
1.37
1.38
1.35
1.37
1.37
1.39
1.38
1.40
1.39
1.36
1.36
1.38
1.37
1.36
1.40
1.42
1.41
1.41
1.39
1.40
Average
Time
12:O7
12:08
12:09
12:10
12:11
12:12
12:13
12:14
12:15
12:16
12:17
12:18
12:19
12:20
12:21
12:22
12:23
12:24
12:25
12:26
12:27
1.37
CO oomvd
1.49
1.45
1.43
1.41
1.40
1.39
1.38
1.38
1.38
1.36
1.U
1.33
1.31
1.34
1.3s
1.35
1.35
1.36
1.U
1.35
1.38
16.122.81 16.16
Run 11
NOx ppmvd 02o/o (drvl
2.33 16.042.40 16.06
2.29 16.07
2.36 16.11
2.33 16.122.40 16.122.40 16.122.39 16.142.54 16.14
2.90 16.14
2.99 16.152.62 16.162.53 16.172.45 16.17
2.39 16.15
2.49 16.142.39 16.142.39 16.152.39 16.14
2.54 16.13
2.97 16.12
1.38
T
T
T
T
T
I
Average 16.13 1.37 I
t
I
MostardiPlatt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
v5.0
76 of 199
RATA Extractiv e 41 1 6120
OMostardi Platt
I
I
I
t
t
t
T
T
T
I
Client PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Test Location: Unit 6
Date:8129124
Time
6:40
6:41
6:42
6:43
6:44
6:45
6:46
6:47
6:48
6:49
6:50
6:51
6:52
6:53
6:54
6:55
6:56
6:57
6:58
6:59
7:00
Run I
NOx ppmvd 02 % (drv)
3.13 16.362.81 16.352.71 16.352.60 16.362.48 16.352.28 16.352.18 16.361.99 16.361.94 16.361.80 16.361.64 16.351.60 16.361.60 16.361.59 16.361.59 16.371.59 16.371.59 16.381.59 16.381.59 16.371.59 16.371.59 14.35
Run 2Time NOx ppmvd 02% Grul CO ppmvd7:08 1.59 16.32 1.027:09 1 .59 '16.35 1.047:10 1 .59 16.35 1.067:11 1 .79 16.34 1.037:12 1.79 16.33 1.057:13 1.76 16.32 1.077.14 1.76 16.32 1.067:15 1 .76 16.33 1.087:16 1.U 16.33 1.097:17 1 .59 16.34 1.067:18 1 .59 16.34 1.077:19 1 .59 16.33 1.O77:20 1 .59 16.35 1.047:21 1 .59 16.35 1.047:22 1 .59 16.36 1.O47:23 1.59 16.36 1.047:24 1.59 16.36 1.047:25 1.59 16.36 1.067:26 1.59 16.37 1.057:27 1.59 16.36 1.067:28 1.59 16.34 1.05
CO oomvd
1.21
1.19
1.09
1.10
1.04
1.O4
1.05
't.03
1.01
1.03
1.00
1.03
1.03
1.03
1.03
1.03
1.07
1.03
1.01
1.02
1.09
Average 1.98 16.27
Run 3Time NOx pomvd 02% {drvl CO ppmvd
Average 1.64 16.34
Run 4
1.0s1.06
1.05
I
I
I
I
T
T
I
I
I
7:44
7:45
7:46
7:47
7:49
7:39
7:40
7:41
7:42
1.59
1.59
1.59
1.59
1.59
1.59
1.59
1.59
1.59
1.59
1.59
1.59
1.59
1.59
1.59
1.59
1.59
1.59
1.59
1.59
16.32
16.32
16.33
16.33
16.34
16.34
16.33
16.35
16.35
16.35
16.35
16.34
16.34
16.35
16.35
16.35
16.35
16.36
16.35
16.35
1.09
1.09
1.06
1.08
1.01
1.06
't.09
1.06
1.07
1.08
1.04
'1.01
1.07
1.07
'1.05
1.02
1.05
1.02
1.U
1.01
Time NOx oomvd 02olo (dwl CO opmvd8:07 1.59 16.31 1.098:08 1.66 16.30 1.O28:09 1.79 16.28 1.048:10 1.79 16.28 1.038:11 1.79 16.28 1.028:12 1.79 16.29 1.018:13 1.79 16.29 1.088:14 1.80 16.28 1.098:15 1.80 16.29 1.068:16 1.79 16.29 1.028:17 1.79 16.28 1.098;18 1.79 16.30 1.088:19 1.79 16.31 1.098:20 1.79 16.31 1.028:21 1.79 16.31 1.058:22 1.79 16.30 1.088:23 1.79 16.31 1.018:24 1.80 16.32 1.058:25 1.79 16.31 1.018:26 1.79 16.31 1 .088:27 1.79 16.29 1.08
7:51
7:52
7:55
7:57 1.59 16.35 1.06
MostardiPlatt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
v5.0
77 of 199
16.30
RATA Extractiv e 41 1 6120
@Mostardi Platt
Average 1.78
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Test Location: Unit 6
Date:8129124
I
T
I
T
I
T
T
t
I
T
Time
8:36
8:37
8:38
8:39
8:40
8:41
8:42
8:43
8:44
8:45
8:46
8:47
8:48
8:49
8:50
8:51
8:52
8:53
8:54
8:55
8:56
Run 5
NOx ppmvd 02% Grvl CO opmvd
1.79 16.29 1 .06
1.76 16.30 1 .011.79 16.32 1 .081.76 16.31 1.021.76 16.31 1.O2
1.77 16.31 1.O4
1.76 16.31 1 .06
1.79 16.32 1.031.80 16.31 1.05
1 .79 16.30 1 .05'1.80 16.30 1 .061.80 16.31 1.O4
1.79 16.30 1 .09
1.79 16.31 1.01
1.79 16.30 1.00
1 .74 16.29 1 .0'l1.79 16.29 1 .031.80 16.30 1.001.80 16.30 1.01
1.80 16.30 1.06
1.80 16.30 1.02
Run 5
Time NOx ppmvd 02o/o {dlvl9:05 1.80 16.269:06 1.79 16.269:07 1.80 16.269:08 1 .80 16.26
9:09 1.80 16.25
9:10 1.80 16.24
9:11 1.80 16.249.12 '1.80 16.25
9:13 1.80 16.25
9:14 1.80 16.26
9:15 1.80 16.27
9:16 1.81 16.27
9:17 2.00 16.27
9:18 2.01 16.279:19 2.OS 16.279:20 2.00 16.279:21 2.00 16.27
9:22 2.00 16.26
9:23 1.98 16.26
9:24 1.83 16.25
9:25 1.86 16.24
CO ppmvd
1.07
1.04
1.04
1.05
1.09
1.08
1.03
1.09
1.05
1.09
1.02
1.O4
1.O7
1.01
1.04
1.04
1.07
1.O7
1.05
1.05
1.06
Average
Time
9:35
9:36
9:37
9:38
9:39
9:40
9:41
9:42
9:43
9:44
9:45
9:46
9:47
9:48
9:49
9:50
9:51
9:52
9:53
9:54
9:55
1.04
CO opmvd
1.02
1.07
1.08
1.03
1.04
1.O2
1.04
1.08
1.01
1.03
1.01
1.07
1.03
1.01
1.03
1.04
1.02
1.08
1.01
1.M
1.07
1.78 16.30
Run 7
NOx pomvd 02% @rvl
Average 1.87 16.26 1.05
Run 8Time NOx pomvd 02% @ryl CO oomvd
1 0:04 1 .85 16.1 0 1 .O7
1 0:05 1 .91 16.1 0 1 .O7
1 0:06 1 .95 16.08 1 .07
10:07 2.00 16.08 1.01
1 0:08 1 .96 16.07 1 .O710:09 2.00 16.06 1 .09
10:10 2.OO 16.09 1.01
10:11 2.00 16.10 1.05
10.12 1 .81 16.09 1 .0310:13 1.80 16.10 1.01
10:14 1 .80 16.09 1 .08
10:15 1.80 16.08 1.01'10:16 1.80 16.08 1.02
10:17 1 .80 16.07 1 .07
1 0:1 8 1 .80 16.06 1 .08
1 0:1 9 1 .80 16.05 1 .01
1 0:20 1 .80 16.03 1 .09
10:21 1.80 16.01 1.O4
10:22 1.77 16.01 1.0410:23 1.79 15.99 1 .0410'.24 1.80 15.99 1.09
1.62
1.60
1.64
1.80
1.72
1.74
1.80
1.80
1.61
1.71
1.76
16.28
16.28
16.29
16.29
16.29
16.29
16.29
16.29
16.30
16.29
16.29
I
T
t
I
I
I
1 .80 16.30
1.80 16.29
1 .80 16.28
1.80
1.80
16.27
16.27
1.80 16.27
1.80 16.26
1.80 16.261.80 16.241.80 16.22
Average 1.75
MostardiPlatt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
16.06 1.05
RATA Extractiv e 4 I 1 6120
@Mostardi Plaft
I
I
I
v5.0
78 of 199
1.04 Average 1.86
I
I
t
t
I
Client PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project #: M243506
Test Location: Unit 6
Date:8129124
Run 9Time NOx pomvd 02o/o (dtvl CO opmvd
Run 10Time NOx oomvd 02olo (dwl CO pomvd
1 1:03 1 .90 16.01 1 .0311:04 1.87 16.05 1.0211:05 1.80 16.06 1.04
1 1:06 1 .80 16.07 1.0411:07 1 .80 16.08 1 .09
1 1:08 1 .80 16.05 1 .03
1 1:09 1 .89 16.04 1 .0111:10 1.93 16.04 1.01'11:11 1.83 16.04 1.0411:12 2.00 16.03 1.0911:13 1.93 16.04 1.0711:14 1.80 16.04 1.09
1 1:15 1.99 16.03 1.03
1 1 :'16 1 .93 16.03 1 .O711:17 2.00 16.02 1.O711:18 2.O0 16.02 1.02
1 1:19 2.00 16.03 1.0911:2O 2.00 16.04 1.0811:21 1.86 16.04 1.O211:22 1.80 16.04 1.0211:23 1.89 16.02 1.O4
10:34
10:35
10:36
10:37
10:38
10:39
10:40
10:41
'10:42
10:43
10:44
10:45
10:46
10:47
'10:48
10:49
10:50
10:51
1.79
1.66
1.80
1.80
1.80
1.80
1.80
1.80
1.80
1.80
1.80
1.80
1.80
1.80
1.80
1.80
1.80
1.80
1.80
1.80
16.06
16.06
16.03
16.04
16.04
'16.05
16.03
16.08
'r6.04
16.04
16.03
16.03
16.04
16.05
16.04
16.03
16.03
16.03
16.03
16.02
1.08
1.02
1.08
1.04
1.02
1.04
1.05
1.04
1.04
1.03
1.01
1.09
1.02
1.04
1.03
1.01
1.02
1.06
1.07
1.01
10:52
10:53
I
I
I
I
10:54 1.96 16.02 1.07Average 1.80 16.04 1.04
MostardiPlatt
Proiect No. M243506
Unit '1 , Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Average r.90 16.04 1.05
RATA Extractive 41 16120
@Mostardi Platt
v5.0
79 of 199
T
I
Appendix G - Continuous Emissions Monitoring System Data and Plant Operating Data
I
I
I
t
I
I
I
t
I
T
I
T
I
I
I
t
I
I
T
Project No. M243506 80 of 199
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
@Mostardi Platt
s(LE(Eoo=o
oi.
d
d
i
o
i
N
N
t,oo)
l
olE
:8qo
AE
E
E
z
A
ii
i
E
:e
_d
Ai
il1E
(ocllCc(E'r
tclicf
S.
r
.
t
lo
.
I
!
=s=i
.
i
s1
-
od
=
4E,Y
_
.t
s
F
[6
8
f,
t
?
5
a??$
t
cE
SH
;
E
E
ii
f
E
i
Jd
d
.
i
iI
dld"l
'
ll
f!e
i"trl6l'
It"id
lil=It"l<
i
lrIiiiul-il"to
l*iit
IilIl-l=l'
iIl*i5lr
IIIIlrldIIIIil-t*1t
!
t>
!,i
d
toil.IE
l,t"
IIlolo
i
t"
IIi
l1lIII=
6t
l!t\Iil'
IIl=l3lJlll.ldIt-
l.
d
IIIkt,
i
dt"l(
!
l(
I:i"ldlJIIIl1"€IIIl"ql'te
I-
Iit"t'
iit,l'
iIIl.lql:ia]N
qq{
1,
1
,
tli-
t
-
lo
t
lo
i
i'
1
"
il
l=l]-
aIt"ldt-
IIl*
lllIIIil:l.tt
!a
l"16
.
t'
IIInIIIi=dioll(
!
It"l.,
i
l*Llo
.
i-
IIll"
IIrl'
IIi,q
l-lni1IIIl.ldIIIIIl;
iL(!
q;a!
t"
ld
;
l"IlI
I
..
{
lq
II
l'
IIl"lc
i
l=iIr
oN6otNoNb{!
6
L6
Ya
*
o.
g
wz
E'c
*
{g
XE
r
^
?
-
EF
oI
€
I
F
a
6
ar
;
e
5
o
p5
$1
6
o
o6
F
N
E
O)
!
E
NE
(5
k
-
oo
L
ii
qo
O
-
P
E
oo-EIou
tI
q
lq
Tt
l-IElolcIN
l-l'trIt
!
IN
8
i
-
i
=
F5
,E
E
:e!
ITTTIIITIIITtTIITII
(!
(LEoooo
cid
d
c
i
or
i
.
i
J
.
i
6
i
d
.
;
d
d
o
o
i
q
q
q
q
q
q
q
q
q
q
c
q
q
e
q
q
e
q
q
.
!
q
cq
q
q
q
q
q
q
q
q
q
q
q
e
9
q
q
q
q
q
q
oo
6
@
6
@
o
o
o
@
o
N
I'o
o)
:
or
=
*pOEqo
IE
E
E
a
a
cl
l
E
!
6
iT
E
E
!E
o
63*e
-.
l
i
c;
c
i
c
i
c
i
c
i
d
c
i
<
i
c
i
c
i
c
;
c
;
c
i
d
c
i
.
i
c
i
<
i
d
c
i
ci
nn
q
:
q
n
t
9
9
q
!
t
q
q
q
q
q
\
\
q
\
oo
6
0
@
6
@
@
@
@
@
@
r
q
Q
q
q
q
q
q
q
q
.
-
q
\
I
,.
C
Q
I
i
e
;;
;
J
;
;
;
;
J
J
.
.
J
J
J
:
J
J
:
J
;
d
a
r
o
c
i
d
a
r
c
;
c
i
d
(i
a
d
d
a
c
;
r
;
o
i
d
o
(o=trlo(E(,f$--f
8i
-
6q
=
cE
c&;
)
=E
r
-
e{
E
z\
*8
t
.
-
6E
G9
J
ftrS
P
gE
=o
-
t
r
:
EH
E
E
s
fi
i
I
E
i
cio
d
c
i
-.
d
?
!
!
!
!
!
i
l
!
!
!
9
9
9
Q
9
C<
6
;
6
6
i
o
i
o
i
i
a
o
i
o
i
;
;
;
J
;
d
i
E
E
6
6
o
o
o
s
65
o!
i
r
eN
e
q
t
a
N
(
N
e
q
e
t
l
l
e
Q
Q
Q
e
l
e
@6
0
0
@
o
o
o
6
6
0
0
@
o6ido+No
NS
sa
L
PE
JF
,v
2
€
i
*
{g
XE
'L
l
r
!
-
(E
>E
l
i
t
-
;
E
EI
6e
5
O
9r
S3
5
o
oE
i
x
e
O)
:
E
FE
(E
h
-
oo
L
A-
Q
o
O
-
P
E
oo-t8ot
.UEE66o=@
did
d
N
N
Nd
d
S
t6
(n
:
t
OEE36Io
EE
E
I
I
i
IIIE
il
.
;
-
d
id
.
i
F
N
N
.i.
i
.
i
d
f
l
d
i,
j
r
R
l
-
di
i
f
.i
d
.
i
d
N
i
l
-.
^
3
.
o'd
r
r
c
i
N
d
+.,
i
c
i
d
i
l
N
(o5ELr!d5!l
:
.F
8;
!O
{
l
E
Qn
t
r
FEl
i
t
cr
-d
E
Eg
E
E
S
J
E
iX
i
E
i
f
f
qI6iBs
tstsqo-fr(!
nli:
qq*s
ts
-.
ett!s
cl
E,5
l1e:t
fis3Eza-
t-
,
itz3TEqti!E.
!EIT)e_i
IPrE,t
t
rE5AD=
(F,plri!"F3E
BE
=
;
NNgtN
(r
)
g
E,
gE
:5
E
;E
*
;5
gE
I
?
3E
si
t
EF
=
HH
o-
8.
E
eE
'
E
IT
IEl
0-ErItIITTtII
dc
i
c
i
d
N
N
Nd
N
S
It6
('
)
lGEsIan
+a
+
6
di
l
;
.
Y
'
N
N
d;
.
i
d
N
d
FN
o
S
j
q4
\
q
tIItIIt
E
gE
SE
g
E
E
ii
f
E
E
EE
!
!
i
i
IIrI
ilNs
f6i
qJ*8N
q:q(s
:itc!E
,iiNs
fltBs
1
1:
,leI!3t
Zirzi
.E[,
iEt-ht
tdl'_i
fFEE,::
rE5(o=
(F9EirIs"t
r
3E
,f
;
1
=
i
Itr
io!tN
-'
E5*
E8
T
3c
-E
E
t
eE
He
i
o
?t
t
g8
5
g!
E
FH
*
ot
-
eo
bE
ECoo-t8o
(Eo-E(Eoo=@
a;F
:
J
.
i
t,o
65oI
|
:
*ao=#Io
rir
i
t
s
d
(o=clEc(E1ocl+cf
&F
t
(r
.
.
l
=
c?
9
c
NF>.
i
dS
E
r.
F
-
.t
s
8
-
Eg
E
tE
5
!Fo5rS
E"
-
g
E
EH
.
E
E
S
fi
i
I
E
i
tE
E
5
g!
iE
i
E
E!
,
a$
*liE
lc
;
r
lc
;
-t
-
II
,1
.
Icit-!t:
IINlolri!Iidt;l{
iI!I.:
t_lst:
lele
lII
.i
,=l
'
I
.;
t'
IIt-lsIit-l-
I!
q(!N
t-l{t-ININ
(,!ec
l.l-Ihl=It
t"ldIl"l8lIl.Idt:
le
!
IN
t"ldl5IIt"ldl1"<i
l3iIIi*l'
IIIt:ls
q.ia
Illd
i
IIilEi-Io
t"t'
IIIit
iIIl=t"l_lll.
IIIt
s
IIit"l<
i
It
sI'
t"ldi'
IIIl=t-
Il_
Ii"
Il.
i
IIidIIIi^r-l-
I,NiS
LIIIIit€1iiIIi?:a
t-l.
;
io
-t-
IIi=1'
IIIdIIl-Ir(!N3
il
oi
!o
;
I1iIIIl
r;
c
t
IiI
q
lq
ntF
iIIIIII
-
l-
o
loIIII
ci
l
.
;
jlJ
IILiII
c
tqIIII
I
l
e
NI
!
AQt3
ileIIIi=l
II.l.
;
l8t-
It-ldt-l'
iIlet-l*ieiN
Ii.trlE
-
l.l"
IIl"i9t-Nl-
l"l'
ji"I'
iIt"l9t-t*!!
eE
II
!tNP*No
ro
S
aa
5
-
8E
tv
z
E-
e
r
<o
5.
E
.J
=
;
3E
rf
;
6
BI
dx
5
o
ga
gs
5
o
oG
F
N
t
9t
=
c
N
c
(E
H
-
Oo
L
A-
qo
(l
)
-
PEo(LtIoE
IITITtITTTtIIIITttT
i
rj
lc
i
'
i"
III
s
E-
;
E5
I
ET
EErITIIIEl
Hr
t,
IIIIIIITt
E
gE
sE
E
E
E
,i
x
f
E
E
.i.
i
r
i
d
N
d
(d
N
8
d*
;
J
N
N
^'
.
b
-
dr
i
r
i
"
i
N
d
qq
q
q
.,
i
q.
?
q
q
rr
r
ttr
i
;
i
i
IIIE
(o3E(!rtc){cf
8,
r
'
,
lI
}
{
!
=sEi
\
i
I9ss
5-N
qii(!N
q
I3rtN
.o
B=*
EE
El
s
EE
*
f;
E
*f
;
E
o
ga
g=
5
gE
E
FN
€
$E
'
EE
eE
=
B
3I
=
;
-go-€a!6o=o
oi
6
o
i
.
d
N
N
t\
l
q
=
.
to
o)
5
o{
=
*ao:
E,
,Io(oEfEtr(Eroc3{cl
8"
.
'
,
lo
i
!
=
(E
c
N^
;
D
=h
.
i
sl
-
od
=
:-.
Y
_
.5
FEE
ef
,
,
?
5
=t66r$
aG
E"
-
g
E
EH
E
E
S
ii
f
r
E
E
oo
o
o
ci
.
J
d
r
i
tE
E
E
€
!
iE
I
E
*{
-d
AI
te1aE6
I
"1
"
d
l
.
;
'l
'
III
-t
_
-t
-
II
d
l
.
i
,1
,
:
lJ
l
-t
-
et
e
NI
N
l"INiiI
II
It-ldt'
I
l
ooi
IIt-
l6
r
l-
g
l'
:
Ic
rl
I:Il_
i
-
l.
l
i
t"
t
"
!1l
I
1-
l
-
1J
I
J
ll"t
"
d
l
d
l'
t
'
il
l.
i
lc
;
lo
Io
-
l-
l
-
ilrll1l"
i
"
lJ
lc
;
ir
Ili1t-
l
-
l.
'
1
.
I
ri
I
-t
-
i
l
i
-i
-
ix
i
t
I.
.
iII'
lIIloI:t-I(
!ta
l"Il*ldlFll-IIl'
IIIIt;l-1N
lrl"
r
"
l*
l
'
II1Il.l-
iIIt-l.
.
i
IIIIi.
liFi;IIIr-It
s
lc
i
l;III1-
lc
;li
iIIl*i'
illilt?t-(!i
t,i"l1Il"IIiii;l=l-lc
it;l'
IIIi:t-ig
IIlql-l!t-i1I1"I:qFIIIlcl'
IIt"ldi:
Iiit-lrIll.
lhi:Ne
IldIl.a
t"t\t-
Ii.l!
IIi.l.
ihl'
lIt.]'
It.l-l=IIN,3
I{ciui=Ii"I
t'l'i:l.tqi!
l@l5iIIl'
IldIIIIIIll9l-l-IQte
t_Il=l-i-t-
I
t-l'
IIt"lil=l+1NIN
t-t.IN
I
tN:$No
F*
S
a6
=P
E
Jt
s81
,
E:
'o
-
=
r
F
-
(E
>E
l
l
t
r
i'i
6
ts
i
6
s
5
o
9a
g:
6
oo
6
F
N
t
CD
:
E
F=
(U
E
-
Oo
L
-
qo
(l
)
-
*Eo(LtIou.
:3
I
t
-
:
;
E5
(,
.!i4(
!
I
IItttIII
oo-EooooEI
oo)
fqtI
jii
6
i
@=fEE(Ed=fd--
l
8,
f
'
,
rr
}
4
=
c
N^
.
D
>A
\
i
-e
<
.
z--/
.A
r
bg
=
SP
rB
E"
-
g
E
SH
s
E
g
ii
i
E
i
aq
q
q
o-
6
@
F
r
-
q
q
q
q
I
q
-
-
.q
q
q
d
r
i
d
F
6
c
i
i
6
d
d
J
d
d
d
<i
@
.
d
dlc
i
o
s
NN
d
N
;:
a
i
c
c
i
J
ci
.
i
,
.
i
ci
ri.
a
i
+
l
r
r.i
d
o
i
.i
d
d
c
i
c
i
d
o
d
o
d
o
c
;
o
o
c
i
c
i
c
i
c
i
c
i
d
o
q
q
.
!
q
q
q
q
c
q
q
q
q
q
q
c
q
q
I
c
q
q
\q
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
\
t
\
\
\
\
\
a
\
@o
o
6
@
6
0
@
@
qq
q
e
q
s
q
q
e
e
q
e
e
q
q
e
s
e
q
q
e
IITIITTt
aE
E
E
2
3
I
E
Ei
Fs
<t
e
E
s
E
-6
6i
!E*E
t=
oo
o
o
\q
q
q
q
\
q
q
q
q
c
q
q
q
c
q
q
q
q
q
q
6@
F
6
ei
9
e
n
9
n
:
t
f
i
t
t
l
:
:
i
9
e
9
9
s
g-
:
FS
od
L
zl
l5s)az-
l)2a
l:3t
zE-
I:3t
zE:EE
!:tr
dz<!oqI
id)ca
aa(:UFEd,:
,$iao=(F,gi;iv;1"F)C)0
oT(No
@s
sa
=
PE
JFwz
E-
Z
*
<g
XE
'o
-
l
x
!
-
(E
>E
l
i
t
-
I'i
E
B:
r=
f
r
E
o
?r
g:
5
oo
6
F
X
e
O)
:
E
NE
(5
h
-
do
L
^-
Qo
(D
-
P
E
o(LEIot
s0-Eooo=o
qq
.
{
q
dN
d
S
qq
.
1
.
'
l
ri
.
i
.
;
.i;
j
'
(
d
N
oo
d
-
!g
(t
=ot
=bg#Io
--
a
(
'
{
i.i
@
d
(ocft,c(udcltc:)
8.
"
'
r
-
|r
,
:
t
E
q!
cNF>.
i
od
=
<t
r
-
.t
s
8
-
Eo
-
:
,
=
at
e
5
=f65r&
P
sE
=o
-
c
2
,
SH
E
E
s
}i
i
E
E
E
<id
d
c
i
*E
E
t
!
r
rE
E
i
E
:
DE*:
!E
t"ld
;
l^t-l.
i
t-(!
,(
!
IN
IFt?i:IIIIt"t:
l1.iII:t"lolrIil'
I
It"t"I
It.lc
;
l"
i:I
lct'
II1;t'
i*jIl*l"iIl"lo
i
iB
l"lc
;t'
IIt"ldI.il:l!IQ
ir
iIIlc
i
l'
It.lqIIIiIild
IIt"l.l.
IlclrIiIIi-t,
;t;l.
iIIII'
I
i
-
l*ic
II
d
l
d
"i
'
IIIIiI
qIi"l'
IIIl.li1-(!N
i*l'
IIIITt-l*taIN
l=It"l.
i
IIIIit-l.
it'
iIIlolc
it'
Ill"l;i'
ll€Iil-lsi!.:
l;t.ti
ilIi"
il-lc
i
Ill-Ei-
.
IIt.
loIII,ilr-e
It:ldt:ie
l_l"
t
ldINt-
"i
"
l
"
l
,
--
l
-
l
-
.l
"
l
_
i
"
=i
-
l
=
l
'
_i
"
t
"
l
"
']
'
l
-
l
'
iI
'l
"
l
"
l
"
it
i
-i
-
i
-
l
-
=i
=
i
=
l
-
il
l
"i
"
1
"
"
<i
l
c
i
l
c
;
l
c
i
o.
ro
.
lq
o-
ii
l
"l
"
l
.
l
"
'l
'
l
'
i
'
ii
"
.i
'
i
.
1
.
-l
-
i
=
i
=
il
^i
ln
l^
i
:i
:
:
:
:
AL
t
,
!
e
hNStNo
os
s6
L
@=
I
p
og
*2
E-
i
c
r
<q
,
5.
E
,
J
v
-
o
L
;
3E
ri
;
6
E=
6p
E
o
9r
gs
5
O
OE
Fd
E
\)
t
=
c
(t
E
(E
H
-
@O
L
-
qo
O
-
PE
t,(LE8oE.
IIITTIIITIITIIttIIt
t:idI.Ililel'IJt-IQle
s
*-
;
F5
oe
c
ITIITTIT
G(LE(E6o=o
aq
a
q
N
d
oo
N
o
oi
oi
o
i
oi
+e
;
{
i
Y
t
\
jtHT
::a
q
IIIIIItTI
od
d
-
@cl!tC(gdcf*cl
8,
.
'
,
ff
i
NP
=h
{
-
d=4E-E
-
.6
t
s
6g
E
It
E
5
tr?B
t
cE
=o
-
c
2
5H
E
E
5
ii
f
i
E
F
J,
j
j
.
ieE
E
5
4
s
ii
i
;
l
:
iEIE
Ir"
lI1ieIt.l"ll,I'1i
IIlrloi3l
l-l.ININ
l"
lleL.1*
l,l*IlIit
it.
Ii"l=ll=
II
I
t9l
NA
l-ir(!-
It-lo
i
I1IiIIt-t-t-It.tdt'
It-to
;t"
iIIl:l"l'
il=l'
it"lc
il-
it"l.
i
l6
-
IillIi\
IIl.lc
tl'
IIEl-t.In Ilcl*
lt"l-
I1-
Ilc
le
l"
l
'
il
i,
l
*
t:
l'
l
'
l-
l
-
l=
l"
i
"
ll
t^
i
_
lr
i
l+
l'
l
=
il
t"
l
"
lB
lB
io
-
Io
-
t-
l
-
tl
l"
l
.
l'
l
'
t.
l
.
il
i!
l
!
l-
l
-
(iN
!;
N
It.
ld
i
t"t"l.
iI'
Il.i'
Ilt.l-
Il.
Illl*l=IIIl"
lt"Iit"1..
.
ILl6
-
It"I.
it:ta
ialdi-INIt
leli
ll:t(
!
l.ql'lrINIca
It,
;
iIilIt-ldisi'qit
s
IiIl.tii.iiL
It"i3
!
i
"t
"
*l
*
x
;
l
e
i
e
3
Eg
g
,s
lI
d,
l
t
-
.
1
-
ce
e
N
IIII
,1
,
't
'
III
;i
;
q
16
-
-l
'
II
-t
-
.t
lo
il
+
iI
_l
_
dl
d
3StN
9S
's
a5r
Eg
El
e
?E
I
(I
=
Y
>
-
to
>
5
1
=
s
E
g;
'
*
i
t
o
95
rE
E
EF
=
Hf
6-
3,
E
.LEI&
qq-i
-
IIIII
ct
l.
d
1I
d
l
d
t-
l
-
ill
i
l-l
-
(uIE(!oo=o
;
d
;
d
6
i
.
i
<
;
6
<
i
-
.i
;
a;
i
c
i
J
.i
6
;
d
oi
od
*
.
i
r.
i
d
i
6
6
6
6
@
1
o
@
@
q\q
q
e
q
q
q
q
q
n
q
q
q
e
q
q
q
q
q
e
r
e
q
.
!
r\
c
q
i
q
.
q
a
q
q
!
q
.q
q
c
\
lCgo)
=
or
=EgB,
)Io
,l
q
q
q
q.
i
,
q
I'q
q
\
q
q
\
q.
q
\
q
q
I
c
t
ci
c
i
c
;
d
o
c
j
d
d
d
d
c
i
d
c
j
c
i
<
;
c
j
o
o
cj
c
;
cj
;;
;
J
J
;
J
-
;
;
J
-
;
:
;
;
J
;
;
;
-
J
d
d
d
;
il
c
i
<
i
<
i
:
c;
;
G
i
c
;
ai
o
F
d
c
i
c
i
J
t
a
1
:
r-
a
.-
.-
!
i-
!
!
!
!
r-
i
-
i
-
r
-
r
-
r
-
t
@o
o
6
6i
@
t
s
o
o
;
d
;
6
d
,
;
d
d
i
A
;
d
qi
.b
ci
d
d
d
l;,
i
d
;
;
-9\
E
E
6
ql
OE
L
@=lEC(ud--cf+=cl
6.
{
'
)
r.
r
:
1
=
(r
E
C
&b
=a
.
i
od
=
*8
-
s
-
YE
E
+F
r&
t
eE
'=
o
-
c
z
EH
E
E
s
ii
f
i
E
i
ci
c
i
d
c
;
cE
E
!
9
a
g
E
E
?
EA
iE
i
E
t
;
_
d
Ai
EESE
l"
c
e
r
!
(!
t
N
t
t
!!
q
q
t
q
t
q
e
e
q
e
e
oo
o
6
@
@
@
o
@
@
@
@
6
0
€
o
Ne
$
!
e
!
q
g
e
a
t
N
s
q
Q
e
l
e
e
{
e
oN@osNoNb$6
L
PE
JE
tv
2
E-
i
*
{g
XE
I
^
?
.
-
E
-
-
-.
E
7i
:
.
.
tu
>
<
A
F
6
6
ts
I
ds
5
o
9r
g3
5
oo
B
i
x
e
\)
t
,
-
c
i
{
c
(U
h
-
.D
o
L
^-
Sl
o
O*
P
E
o(LioooE.
tIITTTITTIIIIT!TTII
IItIIITtTIItItIITII
(uEEs6o@
lo
o
?
.i
6
i
.
i
ri
li6
6
Itoo:or
=B$6fo
-:
-
l
dd
d
d
N
d
q(
.
{
q
q
.i;
d
c
i
N
N
(oclE(!dcltl
S.
r
,
t
to
-
q
E
r1
A
e
NP=i
.
i#ii
-
.E
F
ES
T
E
fr
-
3
5
'I
br&
tE
t
sE
gE
S
E
E
ri
x
f
i
i
E
ci
.
i
c
i
c
i
d
d
tE
i
;
E
i
II
!!
Yls
.t3
{E
qo_!(!s
t-s
cttt!E
Bgtdo
NS
{!
a
E6
Y
f
r
-
o{
tv
z
E-
e
:
se
;E
s
l€
Ii
I
(U
Ui
-
of
i
E
o
P;
[8
5
g!
E
FN
*
(u
d
-
do
bd
Ee
AE
=
IsoE
,i
t
r
=
;
(EEE(Eoo=o!,6
o)
l
OE*srIo
q!\
:
@f!,codcf*cl
8'
r
'
t
(r
:
.
!
=
sr
g
cF=A
.
l
'
sl
-
od
=
4E-E
-
.5
F
bE
el
,
?
5
a??B
t
eE
sH
s
E
E
;i
i
f
E
E
.!
i
q
qCE
E
E
9
g
ii
i
;
E
:
Ets
t:IE
l"lo
;
t\i=1l"
ll'
IIi;IlqIt
st'
iIIIt-lc
;l'
i.IIlqI6
Il.l;
Il.ININ
Il"t:I\1'
l"IIl=t'
iIi_ldI'
iIt'
IIIt-
l@IIll*l'
IliIllll*ldIt(
It-ldItst'
iIIt-l.
;I'l"
iIlql].lf
l]'
]Q]N
i'
l
'
dt!N
I
:l
*
'l
'
Ii-t:
iIt.
lc
i
lcl'
Ii"ldl"iiul.LCt-
t"lolrIil"lat"iDt;
-q.{qJ
It"lc
,l'
It:
IIl"]'
IIl-lil:l!!
c;
It.Ir
I].ldI:
IIt-
Il*
iIit:t'
IIIt-l.
it-
I1iisl"
lIt-l"
i=ll1iloiIt
s-IIIlr
;l.
IIti
Il"lc
it'
i-
l!(!
i!
:siD
l.t
JIlIIl*ln:IIIIl.ci
1il.
,
l
l*IlIt-i=IIIJ'
li1El-1.il'Jl.c
I
II't,l=iiIt-i"
iiuit"lri'
Il"tc
,IJ
1ll*lo
qq
oi:iII
lnl"l't.telurE
-6
9
9
H
Es
3
I
oF
r!
(
!
B'
S
Noo*No
co
S
sa
L
6Y
JF
,v
2
E-
Z
r
<o
i
E
,
J
1
-
O
L
'
.L
d
y-
E
-
(E
>=
,
i
F
id
6
nr
;
s
5
O
9a
g8
5
oo
B
F
N
E
O)
:
E
FE
(U
k
-
oo
L
F
t:
o
O*
PE
AE
=
(LtIou.
IIIITtITIIIIITtTTTI
-g(LEooo=o
i
n
\
I
q
q
q
q
e
n
\
q
c
q
\.
'
l
q
!
q
q
\
-a
q
a
a
q
i
:
a
i
i
q
q
a
:
-
-
-
q
q
:
*r
o
6
e
I
q
.
,
l
.
i
q
q
\
\
q
q
q
qq
aq
t
.
t
.
1
q
q
4
NN
f
f
t,oOr
l
or
:
*ao:pIo
6d
.
6
d
\
I
t
q
a.
1
q
i
q
\
:
q
-.
q
q
q
q
\
q
q
q
o6
@
0
6
0
0
i
i
60
@
@
@
@
@
@
(o--f1'(od=cfi=cf&-
(}
{
!
=
cE
cNP
=E
r
-
o.i
l
=
z5
*8
&
-
-
E,
E
+F
oQIE
i
t
eE
=o
-
t
r
:
EH
E
E
s
ii
f
i
E
i
AE
E
F
O
A
6!
E
E
=
d
9.
E
8
E
a:
<=
:
!
!
:
,
di
{?i=
oiN
o
i
o
€
..
6
ae
e
9
f
:
f
i
:
:
l
:
!
f
Q
9
9
6
9
Q
9
R*H
E,
E
6
6l
OE
r
qq
q
q
Q
e
Q
Q
q
e
t
a
e
Q
e
t
e
r
e
!
a
66
0
@
O
O
@
@
O
@
@
@
@
ee
e
q
e
s
Q
e
q
q
e
{
a
e
e
e
e
{
q
t
s
@ootovNo
SS
a6
E
OY
JTwz
E-
i
4
<o
;
,
.
-
.
)
=
o
L
;
l€
{i
;
6E
I
n
s
E
o
?t
s8
5
sr
o
6
F$
E
r.
r
r
=
c
e{
c
6E
-
(D
0
L
F
Q
o
(l
.
)
-
9E
AE
=
ot8ot
(!EE(Eooo
rr
r
S
-
ci
i
J
J
d
d
!,o
CD
=
ot
:Eqo
d@
@
d
N
d
(oEloc(Edcf+cl
I'
f
'
t
(r
:
!
=
@-&s
=i
.
r
-
.s
-
O.
d
=
4E*F
-
.6
F
EA
E
,t
9
5
;EnS
tE
!9
oE
Sg
c
E
s
ii
f
i
E
E
o@
@
J
tE
E
E
!
!
i€
i
E
!i
o
6EII!E
IIl-Io
i
t-i
t-
Il-lot-
t-
l.
.
i
lEIIt"ldt,
It5l'
iIIIt-
iil"t'
IIIl"l!
IIIldiIIi.t'i
IN
IlIl=IIt-lc
i
ii:t"
iliIlcIIill"lo1-
-
It"lil"
IIIl-l:lcIN
-i
"
;
"
i'
l
'
i
-
il
l*
l
*
i
*
le
19
l!
il
l
i"
1
"
"
i'
i
'
-
iil.
l
.
l
"
ll
l,
l*
i*
I'
i
"
i
'
;l
i=
i
=
l
-
I'
l
'
'
'
i"
i
"
i
"
lc
i
l
<
i
l<
;
r-
l
-
l
-
ti
l
d
l
J
rr
i
l"
l
'
1
"
i,
"
I'
l
'
i
'
ii
i
i.
"
"
l-
l
.
,
.
..
.
.
(,
!
e
ai
e
e
lt-ldiIlt"
l6
rl"I'i'
iIIl=I'
Iit.lc
il'
IIiIir
IIIIIIit-tc
;
I=IIll.
il1ll.l-1Ilqt'
Iql'qqiqlo
'
Ir.
t
i
si
r
-i
-
!t
e
!]
e
l6Iir
!
ls
It"IJ
Ilo
ii^IIIl"l'
IlqiI
Ilo
i
IIl=It-l"
IIt-
IIl-
IIi-l@iIt"l.
i
IEiIIIt-t'
i,
ilniIt-
IIIIl.
.
i
Ilql-IIi:
IiIid
IIl.
it-lcte
IIINt-l.q
qo
s
$-
;
F5
(,
E
L
IIt
?N3*No
ro
$
te
5
-
3E
(v
z
E-
=
E
<o
j.
E
.
J
=
O
L
;
3E
rE
;
EB
:
6
E
E
o
9E
s3
5
oo
6
F
X
E
9'
P
-
C
N
E
GH
-
OO
LF
{O
c)
-
PEo(LEIot
tITtTTITTIITIt
ITttTTTTIItTTIIIITT
oEE(oooo
do
i
d
J
.?
\.
1
q
q
q
c
q
q
q
q
q
q
q
e
q
q
I
q
q
e
.t
e
q
q
qq
!
\
q
q
q
-
q
9
9
9
-
e
e
a
q
o
q
e
a
-
-
-
6
d
o
o
-
N
-
-
d
:
:
.
i
.
i
^i
-
o;
o
o
F;
d
J
rd
d
6
i
\q
\
!
:
q
q
!
t
q
q
q
n
q
q
9
P
!
q
9
(
!
!o
o)
1
ol
E
*aO:
J#Io
aa
-
q
aE
E
E
z
.
ii
!
E
gi
o
6I
{E
li
q
q
I
i
q
9
q
q
e
q
\.
!
-
!
q
q
q
\
e
ol
c
60
0
0
qq
q
q
q
c
c
q
q
q
9
q
q
q
q
c
q
q
q
q
q
ji
J
j
j
j
j
j
i
J
J
i
J
j
j
j
j
j
j
j
j
o6
0
0
(o=lEc6.r
)=f$=f
8"
.
.
,
rf
x
=
cE
c
NP=E
;
O.d
=
at
-
d96E
'l
3
5
Jt69lr
I
eE
SH
E
E
S
ii
f
i
E
i
-
q
q
.
q
q
-.
:
:
q
q
.
!
q
q
q
-
-
q
q
i
60
N
6
n
i
?
e
e
n
r
9:
r
:
:
:
a
r
I
l:
i
I
Yl
1
9
I
:
;
r;
e
s
fi
-
:
F5
ad
I oo:E:
zl=-BE=:
=Eq:odz<
!!o!Ii43Ez
d
-€<f!FEO
't
2
=
>E5a
h)<t
see
Iti*2i
li-NFooog
qa
a
a
a
Q
t
a
a
q
a
E
E
a
(
!
q
t
t
q
q
@@
o
@
@
o
o
o
o
o6I{No
(o
s
sa
L
P;
Jt
swz
E-
e
*
{.
9
XE
'I
l
Y
:
-
(5
>
E
l
{
t
-
;
6B
i
6
s
r
o
?r
ge
E
oo
6
F
n
t
It
P
-
c
N
c
(U
h
-
do
L
^-
to
O
*
PE
aE
'
o(LEIot
E(Eo-Eoo@tto
o)
=
ot
=
*ao!5r
lIo@lEort=l.r--l
8,
r
.
,
G-
=s5
>a
.
.
i
Oo
d
=
zqoL
_
.4
)
g
bE
E
fi
e
5
Jtrr
S
E"
-
E
E
EH
E
E
S
;i
i
f
i
E
i
:c
i
c
i
.
i
+o
6
6
@@
o
c
i
gE
E
E
9
A
GE
E
!
,
=
'
5
F:
E
3
O
<=
E
E
s
I
'
.i
!{l:Ec6
--
-
s
q
e
q
q
c
q
e\
11
q
q
q
q
q
\
q
q
\
c
c
q
lo
6
o
oi
'
d
;
F
l
;
a
;
J
d
r
d
d
J
d
-
ci
d
F
'
o
i
J
ci
ON
€
@
O
iii
i
+
-
r
r
d
F
d
d
d
d
@
d
t
i
d
d
di
d
d
<
;
@
d
d
d
;
d
;
;
;
<
i
;
a
6
d
d
d
d
a
F
;
d
c
i
d
d
d
d
ci
c
i
d
d
c
;
o
o
d
d
d
d
<i
d
d
d
.
i
c
,
d
c
;
o
c;
qq
q
c
e
q
q.!
c1
q
q
I
q
!
q
I
c
q
q
q
q
-.
6
9
9
6
9
q
9
-
-
:
--
:
-
:
:
a
*
N
*
q
!
C
!
9
9
:
:
H5
(,
F-
oo
o
@
@
6
0
@
o
!!
e
Q
t
t
s
e
s
e
s
e
!
!
s
g
e
a
t
Q
{
{IsNo
f-
S
s6
L
6
Y
Jt
s
.v
2
E-
l
4
(q
r
j.
E
;
}E
I
f
;
6
EI
6s
E
o
9t
r
s:
5
oo
6
F
X
E
l)
r
=
.
N
tr
(5
b
-
@o
LF
!
]
O
O*
P
E
oltodotr
TTItTTITIITIITIIITI
l5e
:ta"
jE6
!=;ca!=:dtl!E0=
iE)d
G{6Q
-€<l
!FEO,=
3
,ciaD)
(F,gIE\F)o)g
on:iN
@E
5-
EE
tv
z
E-
i
:S
E
'E
;
gE
TE
;
E
B:
il
f
r
E
o
ga
i
ii
=
6
gT
E
FH
*
$T
-
EE
eE
=
Eo-Eo
,B
!
=
;
!s
tBs
qE\e.G
IE
t=B!
q;-s
q;B:
d.i
c
i
d
d
(
r.
o
t
IITITIIIITITIsl
E5r
ff
i
l
#l
fi
9
5
IE
TI
s0-E.Eoo=o
iJ
d
i
N
d
6l6
6
d
d
rld
d
r
j
N
d
toor
lG*"
8#IU'
-.d
.
i
c
i
N
N
i.
i
t
s
r
i
f
l
N
i;
i
d
d
d
ra
.
6.
!,
t
oo
o
t
t
aI
sH
E
E
E
ix
f
i
F
tr
r
l
E
i
II!I
-F
l
(ELEooo=o
ll@
o
i.
i
d
.
i
o-
-'a
a
d
N
N
.i
t,o
d)
lor
:
*^
8s;Io
eE
E
t
g!
iE
!
E
Ei
o
dt
!E{lls-t
s
(ol!,c(Edl+Ef
8.
.
'
t
8T
E&s
Ei
.
I
'
!l
-
od
=
4L*t
-
.E
E
-
E6
'
t
f
E
et
3
5
atoEnE
'
ta
!l
oE
=*
;
C
S
ii
f
i
E
dd
d
c
i
--
-
N
o6
N
O
;J
d
.
i
dd
d
r
i
11-
I'
lt-t-1'
lIl".il-
II;I'
I<i
irlg
lit-
It-
lc
,
lqt-
IIiIIi'
q.
l-;l-IIIt"l.
;
l=irlo
It-I-IiIl-t-
Iil_IlqI:iIIl"!t-l6IIiil!!
Ii-
riL-
1
.
-
6
lo
6
IIli
^i
l.
n
N
_,
'
-
!r
e
L
!
t"
Ii-
l"
i
.
l
"
i-
l
=
l
'
i-
l
-
i
=
l,
i
,
l
'
lr
l*
ln
l-
l
-
l
-
li
l
l-
l
i
l
r
ii
t
t-
i
-
t
-
ii
l
l.
i
l
-
ld
;
ii
l
l.
i
"
l
.
i'
i
'
l
'
i.
i
.
i
.
l"
l
"
l
'
li
i
l'
i
"
1
"
ti
"
l
il
i
d
l
i
l
,:
,:
l:
N
i
t
!
lc
!
rN
i!
lN
o'q
IIIl*l!IIIN
1l
t-I'il-IIil.laI1D
It"tol"l.
i1"1.
it'
Ilt-ldllll=i'l_i'
IlIlt.i-t.t;
l"l.
It"ldt-
l^
i
lDi"iIlst@
'
I'
iilrt!
t-io
"
]tIIIII
t"lc
it'
llt-
1"
lo
i
I
,t
icIlIIII
.i
*
-t
-
IIII_l
-
^t
^
II!I
,l
*
"i
'
I
l.IJl
q
qolq
ll-ili"to
'
Ill"i.
.
IIll.l9:l,!l;
t-
It"toil.
it-t.iN
I
E
€=
E
IE
;
Hs
I
'E
ll
r
et
N
o
to
ITITTI
oNStNo
o)
S
s6
=
PE
)twz
E-
Z
E
<c
,
5.
E
,
J
-
-
O
L
'o
-
l
Y
F
-
tE
>€
l
l
t
r
i;
6
nr
;
s
5
o
$5
[s
E
or
i
6
i
i
l
E
O)
=
E
NE
(5
E
-
OO
L
x-
S
o
O*
PE
lO.L€I,Ud.
TIIIITIITI
IIIIItIIIIITI
(EEE(E6o@dEIgo
!E
r
l
i
i
IIIT
.i
.
i
d
i
-
'
d
d
r.
.
8
.
-o
d
G
4id
d
'
{
N
N
qq
r
l
q
**
.
8
.
qq
.
i
q
qq
q
q
,J
J
J
N
'
i-
o
-
l
-
l
:
oo
o
,
:I
(E=l
::c
ff
i
l
=h
.
r
-
E;
r
E
s
f
f
i
l
r
sI
E
i
E
+
P
'
,l
l
l
*
I
I
E
II
qiY!BB
gnBe
qF*E3
.q:t!(
..
iB!!
.iBt!
tsitB!
fraN
.i-
i6StN
oF
.6
;
$$
==
EE
Ei
e
iE
r
d
?
x
E
-
*
hi
fi
i
E
?
EE
Ei
E
PF
=
HE
o
5,
E
aE
-
t8oE.
$l
=
l
(Ed6(Eoo@toGryEgdDFt
lo
dd
c
;
-
id
d
d
N
N
(oclE'c(Urtc=+cf,
8d
,
,
1r
}
,
1
=
c)
9
c
XF>.
i
ar
-
_e
<
E
z--{
.A
E
-
E.
P
E
ft
,
?
5
a?g6rs
E
eE
SH
S
E
E
ii
f
i
E
F
dJ
d
d
6i6
b
cid
i
d
dii
r
i
E
i
EE
!E
il:@IIl"laiIlcI'
iIl-l-It-
Iql'
il-IJlF
-
IIIit,
t"l.
il'
Ii:le
Il.oIt"
l-t"
Ii"l*II
It-l-t;INIit-l.
;t'
IIlslo
l-l.
it'
IiFIiIt.lo
II
I't(ic
li'ITlc
III-l8t*leIF
l"
i
"
i'
t
'
Il.l'
IIlr
It.luldt-
IIiiat:
IiI
It\l=It-ldi=IIit.l.
;l"
Il1"
l"
i
l
i!Ir
IINiN
1*
lsItsIt!
5rL
alN
IIl=Ilr
;
l=1i.ldi
iloldi'
iIt_lqi;IIi=t'
IIl=l'
it.i"l*IIiaI'
iil"iF
'
iIt.
Il.ji"lt
Il-i"t"l*II,
ltEl
ljl"o
I'l"It.
Il"lc
;
1I
ts
d
o@
lIIl
c
lqiIIII
d
l
c
i
IIIIi
-i
-
.l
'
IIIIIIIIIIiIiI
-t
.
dli
l
IiiI
e
iq
'i
'
Il
-t
-
il
lc
;
-.
l
.
j
III
dJ
'
oo@o*NoNFa6
5*
qE
E?
.
,
E=
I
=f
E
.s
iE
Ef
'E
(E
H-
co
i
i
g
O
p3
98
5
oo
6
F
i
e
l)
r
Y
-
c
C{
E
(5
E
-
FO
L;'
QO
()
-
PEoo-tsoE
TIITTTTtttIIIIIITII
tiBt.ieit
!
l!
'
l1t
It.
-6
r
3
6
-
e
;
F5
o!
r!
IItIIIIIItTTTtItTIT
GEEGao=oto
or
c
gl
gE88a
Fl
l
o(o5Ed5t'
.E:)
Sr
t
9!
i
=
ff
i
=i
'
\
i
t
sE
-#
SE
S
E
S
J
F
ii
f
i
i
E
f
f
-.
i
;
d
N
N
6r
6
E
64
6
-
dil
d
a
i
N
N
3.
dd
d
{
N
f
l
tr
i
;
i
i
IIrE
r{
q
-
--
-
N
qq
q
r
!
qt!!s
.
NI
6t
tsFcs
;t!E
ts
-r
E
F
I
-
E
I
i
5
o!
+
Et
!
5t
NN5tN
(\
s
=E
g
f3
e
EE
*
fr
5
HE
i
o
P;
[5
6
g!
E
FH
E
ES
-
N?
o
-
qE
aE
=
tIot
(EEE(Eooo
qq
q
q
6i
o
8
J
dd
d
d
N
(
t,oO'EOEb3o=cl
D
Ft
l
o
SE
E
E
4
t
E.
E
E
E
ET
"=
*
i
EiEI
17E6
-F
(oclE'codcf+=trf,
8.
r
.
,
l(
}
4
=
ccxp>\
is-
Oo
d
F
.+zF
-
.E
F
EE
fE
5
a?
6Ert
E"
-
g
E
EH
E
E
E
Ii
i
E
E
E
cq
q
q
--
-
s
F;
r
j
.
,
i
:iEN
qt"tll5t.rqIt
s
iN
l"It
s
iiiIIlxl<
i
l"llllcl"l'
IIl"ldIl.lFt"
lilcliIlc
i
l"
i4;
IIt"lal5]NIts
1"
Itsl'
iIi=t'
IIlil.
i
llIt"ldi=llIlFlitloLiiIl*Its
i:(
!
Ilqib,Iil*l"I1"iql-<i
t;
IiqlllI!aa
l-I'
Itsl5IIIi,l6l=l.l'
IIIIi.lr
i
IFiliciSldlt-iFL!
It.ldlr
IIl"l.
il"
Il.l'
IIIIl5t*i!IFIN
l.It
st.
lc
i
IIl.l=i'
Il:
Il"i"It
iII:i-I]N
l"l"lc
i
l"
il-lit"
IIt-lc
it'
It-li
i6
{1.
i.dIiisl:iqIN
lelN
-
i-lel5ls
ll
il'j
I'J
t'
l
'
tl
t"I'
ii
t-l.
it"
II
t"
ll.
.jII!IIIIi*IIt"i-:NlFIt
!
t"l.
;t-
IilFiN
-
iIIt.
j@IlIl,
it
sNlFl-
Il;
IIIIIt.
i@IIiIli-l!1A
IIIt-lEIIt"lc
i
lr
iIIl:
llrItslu
l
"1
"
i
l
E
'i
'
lI1III
-t
"
o
l
J
IIIi
-t
-
"1
"
III
"1
.
c
lc
ila q
lc
^t
"
IiIIi
.-
t
-
h
N
]to
E
E=
5
i5
t
i
5
1
o
i
.
l
.
IN
N
ts
l
F
)a==
i6!.:it
ZIE
lF6:E6cEdE/
l5!Fr@,2
=
;a?P
,e
,
l=IarF)o)9
,
@sNotNo
Cf
)
s
sa
L
O
Y
Jt
s
.v
z
E-
e
*
<g
i'
E
'
^
?
-
E-
ol
E
I
F
i
;
E
BI
dn
g
O
91
95
5
O
96
FB
E
l)
r
Y
-
c
(!
t
r
(E
E
-
FO
L
F
qo
c,
-
PE
o(Loood
TTITITITITTIIII!tTI
IEt
EErTTIIT
tt
dtr
t
o
TIITITITI
(c
,
:)E(Ed){trf
8.
r
'
t
HE
Ew*\
i#TE
.
.f
i
F
E6
I
E
SF
6h
If
tC
t
aE
sE
s
E
E
ii
i
i
E
io
'
r
i
.
i
d
N
li-
+
"
i
N
N
ci.
i
.
i
r
i
d
f
l
de
i
d
l
d
d
ir
!
;
E
i
ITr!
qr
t
q
r
q
qq
q
q
ts
F
N
€
.
TqjNB
iiN3
teN5
tse3NN
ENE
Fr?NN
frNN
$
Es
B
or
E
PiioB
$sES
Q
f,
r
-
og
T
3c
-E
:
*
nE
$H
i
o
P;
ii
5
5
gi
E
FH
E
EF
-
N?
O
-
PEoiE
z,
k5IE!r
IEql
'EIECtf
;
)<
a
-+iEEI
52:
,:
E54D=
(F,ElrII{F]E
oEE'(U6o=ot,o
C"
E
ot
EEI
IFt
lo
ljd
i
c
i
N
N
..
.
$
-
\q
r
?
i
{
q9
r
q
d
oo
6
a
d
d
ts
d
d
d
N
d
o.
EE
!
;
E
i
I!I!
(oc:)E(Edc,
f{cf
8r
t
ff
iwSr
.
i
"5
E
4L-t
r
-
*E
fi
.
8
5
-A
te
E
aE
EH
S
E
S
ri
i
f
i
E
,j
i
r
N
c!\
q
\
ijN-
q?Ns
BnrtsaB
tFtsqIJiiNs
tlqs
qsc{fles
o-F$N{!
nns
$oottNo
ro
S
qe
5-
rE
rv
z
E-
'
c
:5
8
;E
f;
;5
sf
i
i
O
9r
;
gt
E
od
f
;
F
E
t
ED
TE
FE
(E
E
-
FO
s
f,
qo
O-
P
E
oItIoE,
tTTIIItIITTIITtI
E
TU
g
t
l
5
,&
E
tTI
ItITIITTdI
ET
-J
l
TTI5r=l
E
-!
I
ff
i
"
,
=f
;
$
$
E
#
:
T
o0-EG6o=o
;.
i
i
.
i
d
f
l
ai{
i
d
d
N
d
ii
i
l
E
i
II!t
qq
.
'
{
q
0,
ts
t
s
F
O
-
qq
q
q
3E
E
8
.j
i
i
t
f
6{
.
.
{
6
-
q
EF
t
s
3
q8F.et!{
EaN
Fa!!i
ilqN
g
I=
:
,!
EFf,
gooE
to
S=-
$8
Ti
e
3E
*
fr
5
HE
i
O
gr
i
[8
5
S!
E
FH
€
od
-
No
b
d
EE
aE
=
tIoG.
o(LE(Eoo=o
od
o
r
i
N
N
(otrl!,Co,f
icf!'cl
8"
.
'
t
lo
.
.
t
=
(.
l
g
c
xp
>r
\
r
-
sl
-
Oo
i
r
=
4E?F
-
.t
s
F
Eo
-
t
l
E
t[
E
5
:fq6r$
E
EE
SH
;
E
E
ii
f
E
i
--
-
N
r{q
q
-
6{
N
-
o-
o-
SE
E
5
!
:
ii
!
E
E€
ox
q
!E{eIE
It-Ir
i
"t
"
l-Iil
Il.teIt
st(l-loJ-
.
ll1"
!o
i
tft
-
t"Il"lt
1l*IItd
'
l
l"IIIIi-t.
iI"l-lolqIIIioiIit-lnI]N
It'
IIi=t'
Il"Ili1.
1o
'
IIIIIl"IIIl"t-
lc
;
lo
-t-
IiIi,
IFl"lIt-
lo
'
il.t'
IIl*t;
IIIIl"l;Its1_l{
i
t_lo
;
tfl
IIit"ld
ii.l*IIIIIIt'
lI1l,
ll"l'
IIIl"ti
iFt-l.
il'
l"ts
.
tii:!ia
l,t:It!t
iIjlll"L-i'
{t-l;iIiIIt-ldt-lo
i
t-inIFllIl.LF.
IiIIIi
l"t;
iIt"lc
i
it-ldIJII\].
IIi.d1
iFi'
IIIi.l.
i
iit<
i
Ill-ld
;
t"I],L.
l<
i
i=l.
i
l"IIl,
i
II
l-lr
;t-hl.
il=l=IIli
iIIIir
IIii;lcl-
ll"lc
i
ItsFl;
Il.iIlIi.
{
IIlt.t"llt-IIi-IFIIIIIldt-IIIIt"l+lijiIIIi6II i,
i
,
'i
'
)Et,
;
Iib
t;qIN
l
III't-
II
l"IiIlot.
Jl*;
ldt't:l'
il*l=ll=IIt.toIlc
'
l-
it"l*
iIIrt"lclrIi"iIIil!l'
IIli=lnNl;
tTT
oooiotfNo
F*
S
s6
r
o
Y
-.
o.
9
tv
2
E-
J
c
r
<o
j.
E
,
)
=
o
L
'(
L
z
r
-
E
-
(5
>=
X
F
ii
6
nr
;
e
5
o
$3
;
$8
5
oo
C
F
X
E
L,
,
E
-
e
N
t
r
(5
k
-
FO
La
-
So
O*
F
E
o(LrIot
TtttIITTII
s
*-
i
3
F5
'&
nE
zf
l5:
:I3ia!I3t
Za-
!t3Ez
3FE,I(c{dcIFEIEiID=
(F,giEi!;E
TTITIITT
(!o-Eooo=o
q,
q
.
a
q
-
!
61
1
q:
q
a
q
q
q
t
-
q
a
q
q
t,
I
oaEor
gtr
I
d
c
i
c
i
d
c
i
c
i
c
i
,
c
i
c
i
c
i
d
d
c
i
.
i
d
d
d
d
;
d
d
d
$E
EE
€i
g]
E
,
E
E
G
:
<:
:
E
E
:
o
6I83€=
;o
;
o
a
i
a;
c
j
o
i
d
dd
d
d
c
u?
q
e.!
t
q
q
q
n
q
a
q
q
q
t
q
q
q
q
.
?
@o
6
0
0
0
@
@
;
J
.i
d
d
;
a;
c
;
d;
;
ri
ai
.i
J
;
6i
c
i
<
i
J
J
ci
!
q
q
q
q
q
q
q
1
q
q
q
!
'
l
q
q
u
?
q
q
I
e
q
ITI5T
C(su5l
-E
ff
i
t
>\
i
E.
-
g
E
s-
55
€
E
g
E
E
T
t
5g
*
E
!
f
F
dl
l
s
v
l
e
6
g
=
'l
-
.
:
i
i
-
.
i
I
q
q
q
.
?
n
q
ol.
.
c
1
q
al
c
c
q
q
.
!
\
ql:
-
-
i
rf
!
q
9
r
\
q
q
q
q
q
r
6
lo
@
@
-.
6
:
i
i
t
:
:
i
f
r
P
9
e
9
9
I
*
;
;
;
d
;
;
;
d
;
;
;
;
;
L;
;
;
E
E,
E
d
d5
o!
i
r
qq
q
e
q
q
q
!
e
q
q
{
e
q
e
e
e
e
N
q
q
qq
q
l
e
q
c
e
q
q
e
q
e
e
e
a
s
Q
e
q
!
qq
q
q
I
q
q
c
q
q
q
q
c
c
q
q
q
c
q
q
q
o
o
l
o
o
o
\q
c
q
9
q
9
c
q
q
c
e
q
q
q
\
9
q
c
q
q
I
=a)
f5:
:iz-
lirI:3t
zz-
I:3t
z=3
:Eq:f,dz<!-!cqI
icf,<z
ol(:UFEd
,6ito=
(F,g:I
;u;ItF3E
IPsNo
@S
sa
L
PE
JFwz
E-
i
*
{g
:E
't
l
v
F
-
(U
>€
l
{
r
i'
i
6
Ei
E
;
E
o
?r
g3
5
o:
o
B
F
X
t
O)
:
E
N=
(5
h-
FO
L
^-
So
(I
)
*
PE
o(LE8ou
o(LEGoo=@tod2ot
gE8s7
Ft
l
o
'a
i
i
.
i
N
N
6.
--
-
N
.1
o
.
n
,
q
@cf,E'c(Ericl+Ef
8#
t
q.
1
=
(E
c
:;
D=\
i
t
uE
.#
EH
.
g
E
s
-
:
"
r
F
I
EE
#
E
E
F
E
'il
l
u
v
r
e
o
l
*,
i
l
,.
i
i
l.
l
'
e-
tE
E
E
I
g
ii
!
E
E€
o
6l
!E{iTE
iIII
.
l.
I
.t
^
<i
tc
i
l
eaee
IIiI,
J
t"t^It"i*1-
l$1=((
IIlc
!t-
IIN
1"F@
iI!r
;l*
iIIt.
Iit"t!
!t:t!t!
It-
ld
i
l11-l.
il'1JlFlIlclI.l.
i
l-l.LA
l,t"tqi*iIIiIl*liIt-t:
IlIIIIi-ldllI1_lit^lc
;i'
ti:l"
iIl*
Il-
i,(Its
IIl=tdl:(-
1.FIi=II
i
-i
"
lJ
L
i
.
l.
II;I"i
.
I
NN
li
Ii-l'
IIIt-t.l8IItit_rq(!
qt-lrt"
IIIIlu
1I'
lIlci6
l
IloIIlIILlc
iL.,aIE
t"t;
IIil-IIIt"
l<
it'
IIIit-tqi-iIIiqIllt:!
Il'l"IrleIt"l.l-IF
ae(
r
lqlnI1_1<
i
ldli
IIild
lrIl"
JEl-ieiN
t:IQitsrb
z)
ft]::
Z)io!I3t
zT.
I:3t
Zr5!Ee:
i:ldE!ita-{
(!!FEE9I
E
rE7AD)
(F,elc)diE"F3E
a!
s
*-
,
E5
!
TTITtIT
tsf{PtNo
o)
S
sa
=
PE
JF
,v
z
E-
e
r
<o
i
E
;
:E
{E
;
6
Ei
6s
g
o
?r
ge
6
od
6
F
X
e
ED
:
E
NE
(U
b
-
Fo
L
F
Q
o
o)
-
PE
o(LrIod
TIIIITt
TTII
oEEo0o=o
IIItRl
E*r
tTITIIttI
q.
t
!
r
l
.F
.
3
;*
r
;
r
i
d
N
o-
q9
1
q
FF
F
q
od
s
i
do
o
€
dc
i
.
i
r
i
N
N
d.
'
d
€
'
d
d
@clE(Eto3dcf
Sr
,
t
rr
}
l
E
gL
c
dE
r
=i!
.
1
-#*u
-
FF
E
cE
sH
S
E
E
ii
i
E
E
ri
-
-
t
i
rq
c
q
dt
J
F
:
3
ir
E
;
i
i
IIIE
5Ns
!i
qI$I
o63tN
OE
N
'
{!
e
tr
.
tE
J
i
E
1
ti
'
c
XE
r
d?
x
E
-
fi
A?
fi
E
p
?
EE
EE
E
EF
=
f;
€
d
-
8,
E
aE
-
EI&
E
T=
E
d
I'
rg
d;
d
i
(EEE(I,oo@o)
(Do
(ocfE(E,,r
,cl+cf
8"
;
RE
!-s=
9
gE
9E
EH
E
E
E
E
-
^
E
:
.
Et
r
I
E
E
E
AE
F
s
j
.:
t
Y
?
.
:
l
Y
?
;
-
;
EE
(
J
o
l
r
r
l>
c
;d
d
d
ii
d
i
NN
N
R
-P
;
l
j
dd
d
B
i;
;
R
'
il
E
i
sE
<:
i
E
!
3
6X
a
EI
!!
l,lcIIdit.IEl"Iit"l"IilidIl:
IIIll.lrt.t:tn
IiI,NIIt-iIIIit.idII
iIt;
iIIidl
III
r
l
-
iIIIII
el
e
d
ldIiIII
"i
"
IIiIi
.t
-
8t
8
I
l
.1
.
"1
"
I
al
a
i
;
l;
IIIiIII
^l
'
i
ll
l'
l
^
lltllrl,
i
,
l^
i
"
liir
It,ili,
lo
Ili
l-
r
-
IJ
J
ltll
l-
l
-
le
is
{}
t
;
t;
t
i
IIilrIii;18lu)
Il=
o6(botNoNaN^
L
6Y
r
L
o
g
&?
"
'
s
'
E
'
dE
-
BI
o>
€
8
t
r
r
6
3:
8
3
5
o
9i
E
98
6
o
o5
F
N
.
E
ED
!
E
HE
(!
h
-
bo
L
=
NOEE
'coo-Eeot
tITTtITTTTItIIITTII
lsl:te
a
E=
E
5
F
l
oE
a;
II}te
l=l'
lIli
I]=l
iiIIIldIiIlt;
lI1llr]ElI1_t'
iIIl"ld;l.
I
I'
IIi]=t'
I1l.l'l:I!i8isa
ElIIIll:
Ill,
lII1-i'
IiI1;i"ldl't.lil-
iIiIt.t"
iIt,l"
Iii-
IliI1.
l
Is1e5
i.
i
.
i^
l
^
llii
l-
l
-
i"
l
'
1i
lr.t
.
ilI
I
'l
'
II
;l
u
is
Is
l-le
lIisIi"l-iIIiIIIEldII{IIIIt.
IiIt"liiIii"ld
Ii!qe
IlillI
,i
,
,
l,
lII
.1
-
r
]'IlIIi!l8I
Iec
l$
BIss
$s
N-N
i
ITITIT TTII
o(LEooo=o
aa
:
9
q
\
P
\
a
q
f
q9
a
:
a
9
9
a
9
r
y
Nd
d
-
-
-
N
d
d
d
N
N
d
N
d
N
-
dd
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
o
o
o
o
6
o
d
d
o
d
d
d
r@
r
d
NN
N
.
J
d
d
N
J
;
N
N
d
N
d
N
N
N
N
d
F
d
N
d
d
N
d
.
d
d
d
d
N
N
d
N
N
d
N
d
d
N
d
Y
E
E
o
o
o
o
o
5
pl
aa
I
\
:
I
q
q
I
q
\
q
q
q
q
I
a
.q
l
.
.
9
q
9
I
FT
T
do
d
oIE
E
E
EI
TS
!
E
T;
-d
.
!
6
6t
IC
F
:8
3
9
o
o
o
l
o
dd
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
oq
q
q
o
;J
:
;
;
J
;
;
;
;
-
-
.,
.
-
-
-
d
il
d
6
d
N
d
i
N
o
d
d
d
d
N
o
d
.N
d
o
o
Nd
d
N
N
N
N
d
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
N
d
N
d
N
N
q9
q
q
q
c
q
c
q
9
9
q
9
9
0
c
9
9
q
9
\
I=I5l
Es;
t
E^
i
tt
,
;
E
E
*
u
*
;
I
;
rl
t
i
l
!
r
3
i
i_
I
iid
6
r9!No$No
NS
N^
a
L
o.
9
E
L,
=s
,
=
.
J=
O
L
'(
!
=
v
:
-
o>
E
8
t
r
a
6
E:
6
5
E
O
gr
g5
5
or
<i
f
i
F
&
P
o)
r
E
RE
(!
h-
Ao
g
i
NodE
.Ed)(LEooox
dd
d
o
(U0-E(Eoo=o
d;
d
t
o,o!oC)
toclEc(Edcft5
8"
;
8E
v-s;
.
s
s
E
25
EE
E
E
E
s
-
^
E
:
:
ii
f
i
f
i
E
E
F
f
l
T
:
dr
d
j
d;
d
d
dd
d
d
dd
i
l
q
i
Nd
d
H
NN
N
E
ii
E
E
i
E
_
dEEI
1E
Ii;Il=
IIIi:l-iIII
Il-lill"1"
1l:
IIl.l-Irt.rSts
l-l.
IR3Ii:
IIIIl=II,.!t-
ii1EI:isle
l-l-l:IIl=IIl-I'iel-tals
lIt-
lIlIl*ldIIdIIl"
IIIIIlqiRIiIIl"l.cl;
ll-
l
;IIII:Iiistbla
I
EllldlIIt.El"IdIl"IIl"lBl'
t-ldl-l,1dIIl"l"I
;il.?ssi6
L}
l$
I:l-It"l*IihIl-I
e
lcIIIIt'
t;!e
I!-t-
IIIii*ldildII1l.l'
IIt.dII1i"l-
Ii'
Ii=LSls
l1i:l:iql"IIl.l"l-IIit.
llll-IIIl=IIIII$tS
ll-t?llitNiIIIl8l'
It"l_lqt"
Il"JIIiIl=IIIi*is
ll
-i
-
IIIIlIllll
sl
s
IIIIIIi
'i
'Ei
E
-t
-
IIIII
d
ldIiIIl
-t
"
i*lIll.i=lt.la
qnsB
.cE
EE
6
t
l
oe
G
It-t-
IIIIIE
II'
l1-Idl=IIIl.l:lsrS
te
I
-l
-
,1
,
-l
-
8qqn
o,{
tNotNo
oo
S
N-
i
r
8E
\3
e
=3
E
'O
-
=
r
E
-
o
>*
8t
r
i,
i
E
fr
;
Tf
l
E
rJ
=E
Eb
o
od
G
F
&
E
O)
T
E
HE
(s
h
-
bo
L
=
NO
9*
EEo(LEooot
ITIIttITI
(o(LE(goo=oE:l
dd
d
d
;;
;
t
i
-*
-
x
gE
E
S
FF
;i
;
d
id
d
d
i{
d
d
;;;
N
d
N
tTI
dd
N
f
i
5T=l
E
nE
I
Ec
.
i
Et
t
;
g
E
*
u
f
f
I
;
rl
S
l
l
!
I
!
!
=
I
rE
E
E
iE
-6
r
:
EI
iE
I
-l
-
IIIl
:l
r
I
:i
3
IIIIIiI
Ei
E
IIII
;;
IiIIiII
33,
1,
IIIIIII
qq'
l"
IIII
d
l
d
IiIIIIIIII
;
lJiIiIII
:
i
;
sl
s
i
-t
-
III_t
-
el
e
II
i.l-IIiIEl"iI1et'
lIl-l,
IdIIt;
IIIisLl*tb
IIit"
IIIlelIIIl.
iIIIie!iIIleicIIIl"IIIt.1'
lul-
Il=IIIIIt-lcIIil-NIIIl'
IIIt-
lI6
!
l"i:
IIIlst"istb
Il.
!
lul:l*l'
IIt_t9l"IL^
r
l"t-t-l*tsls
ii"ldt*
IiI1-l'
IiiIii-i;
LIiIIle1_l"
IILINiIt.t1tsl"
Il-
It,
IIILJ'
IIiIi-i-IIIIloIl'
Il.l"Il"I].il
l*iIIt"
IIl"I
il.
IIl,
il=IBl"II,
Il"I],l'l9I
illIIl1l;IIlI18lolIiIlIIili
li-iIllIE1I1-
lr
_
lIIlIlf
r
IIIlll.
i
1III
ss
it-l"iiIn
qna
Ilrtsls
.i
lIr\qnb
i"ldt-Ii'
IIIi-i-
IIIit-l8l.
IIl-let'
III].l'
IIlrql"
IIlqIIiIIiIIIt"t;
IIIIIIi=isits
III'
i=It-l8l_IIl=l-l$l-
Il'
IIl=IIIIt:t_iB
8Il:t$t;
;t
;-i
-
III
-l
-
II
'
]'
l
Neoo{No
st
S
N^
L
6v
f
F
OE
t
1
-
.
'-
.
i
,
]E
8E
'(
L
=
v
:
-
G
>i
8t
r
r
6
E:
6
$
E
O
9E
98
5
o
d6
F
N
.
E
ED
!
E
HE
(E
h
-
;;
o
L
=
NO
9*
EE
't
roo-Eoqot
IIt;
IIiSl(
!
q
e
t=
E
6
F
f
oi
x
bB
(!EE$oo=@o,O)oro
(otrlEc(!rttrl{cl8;
o:SEs;
e
s
E
9E
EH
E
E
E
S
-
^
E
T
5I
#
E
E
E
rr
F
s
i
.l
?
Y
?
.
n
i
?
;
E
Eq
u
o
l
l
r
f
>c
d;
r
N
ii+
d
d;
d
d
;J
;
if
EE
E
$E
<=
:
E
g
o
-d
3io!
ir
--
.
8
Nd
N
B
-
1.el-
I
:
l
:
IIIIIII
q
iqIIIIi)IIiijl
!ae
IIlsl'
Il=l"
Ihl-
ll1',
IIll:
Ii.lEtile
Il;
'l-
IIt.l'
IiiIl*
'
ldiiit-lr
IIt_l3lilt;
Ill=I'sl:
ilIl=IiIt.l5l"
ii"l"
iIIi.ldtNII]"l3l-ql"IIIIIl=t^6es
Ii.
IIlet'
-t
"
-
l"III
=l
=
III
*l
*
'l
'
II
"i
"
'l
'
II1
.i
-
-t
-
nl
*
:e
rPiIIt.t"
IIIi=IIiIl-tql"t8lJ
rs
iElIiiiBl"IIIiirIIlt"IEt:
iIl,
Iiii.l'
iil=
I
o
lo
i
!;
;
r;
l
a
iiIlliIi=l.IiIlst"iit"i'
IIl.l*li"l-l^l*Ii\iIlri-IIIixi;ib
I'1-
Il-
Il"l-Iilui_lii
Ii1l,;
i-r9
IIIii;
IIIl"
IIlt"t5ldIIIllIt
IlsIllIlct;
IIIt:idIiIl-l*IIIiIt-ldIIiIIt:l=l
.r
"
be
iIIi"i.rire
l*t:lsts
.!
fl
t*
$
5
$'
,
*E
?cootNo
ro
S
N^
L
6Y
-
L
O
g
&?
,
'r
=
r
JE
O
L
'tL
=
v
:
F
o
>€
8t
r
r
E
E:
.
-
i
E
o
er
gr
5
o
o6
i
N
E
O)
!
E
HE
(!
h
-
bo
L
=
NO
9*
EF
.EoL5qon
ITtIItTIITtIITIIIII
ItIIITITt
E0-E(Eoo=o
q:q
q
d@
d
d
EEI
88
8
P
dd
i
l
d
ir
6
N
qq
q
Q
r
.
;;
-
t
i
tTI:r5l
Egg
l
>c
.
i
,
EE
E
i
E
E
*
,
=
i
I
;
,l
l
I
s
I
*
I
I
j
l
.
I
f
EE
E
$E
<r
i
E
g
3
,
a3
!cla
T
IIl-
iIl1IllIldIIIt.IEIiut"
IIlet"
II
Il.1'
iII1"i"isl"iI
di*IIIt'
iIl.ldt.tsts
ilal'
Iiel*IIl.i"IIl"l'
IIIl=1l"lriE
l"ii*l'
IIi;t_lxllIl.l'
Il:ts]E
lqltoilll'
lt"ldl'lrl-Il_l=IIIt-t'
ilIl=t9l.ai
b
Il=ldlllllr
IIIIIi.rEIiiii-inI
l-1-
Ili:
IIIleIl-
1-
lidIIIIIl*l*l.tst"
IIIl'
IiIIl.l*lIt"l-l'
IIIl"l'
iiii:
I1li8t.LS;
ldi-l^Il'=lIt8t:
It"
iloIJIlt.t'
llIi8iQ'i
8
Ii.t-il.l!l"ildIIIl8l'
II
r-
l
-
!i
ilI,
ti.
r
-
l"
l"
iiilrl
i=
i=
llil"1
"
t8
l8
ld
ld
ri
I
],
1
,
lltit"
l
"
il
i
i
l
II
"1
"
l'
l
'
iill
.
l"
l
"
li
i.
i
"
i-
l
-
I
,I:lit
ic
l{
t-
t
-
rl
,lili,
l
.
l-
!
-,l
lr1
i-
1
.
t-
l
-
I
i^
l
-
ls
lBI
;
l
;
ri
l
n
t"lrI
i.
Ilr
iIl"dIIIIiIi3IIIt-i'
IliIIlBl'
l1^t;t.
t
IIl'
It"t'
iIl=IlIIi{
]
TsE
INn
Ilil*IN
Ilql-iii"lrIIt_IEl"ld
It"lut"l'
III
"1
"=l
'
II
ui
u
ii
'
l'
II
81
8
.l
'
IIII
lat'
Ildt"
iiIIt.l'
ll1l-lBiisi
Il"lsl*IIi"l-IIiIllIl-l'
ll:
ILIIiel;s
IIl'
Ii,i:aIN
E
E=
I
5
F
l
o;
od
N
Nq!ootlNo
(o
S
N^
L
6v
f
F
OE
t
1.
.
=9
E
I
J=
O
L
'a
L
=
v
>
-
o
>E
8t
r
a
6
ts
:
Ei
E
o
gE
g8
E
o
oG
F
i
.
E
ED
!
E
HE
(E
h
-
il
o
L
-
NO
9
*
EE
'too-Eoot
(EoE(I,oo=o
dd
d
d
dd
d
;
dd
d
d
O)o)ot-
(o=cl!,c(Eiocf,icf8"
;
6!SEs;
9
gE
9_
E
EH
E
E
E
s
-
.
8
:
ii
E
f
E
i
f
l
F
t
r
i;
d
d--
r
s
i
+i
d
{
rE
E
E
$E
<r
i
E
!
o
-d
t5iEiE
IId
l.l=Il.l-iIl-IIl"dss
iL-
IIIiiIldiiiI!IiII.l"IIl*IIIIl-IIIiIrl9l=1S1b
Il:lstb
lt-i-
II1rdlxIlIt-l-iIt.Iri"iit.l-ll1=Il=IIrsis
E
IIN
d
id
Il-
lqldIIil.
iiIII^
lll;
l
;
I
d
l
d
IilI
r
l*lIt-
Lrs,S
l^lBl-
It"lNI
iie
IIl.t-t.ri
te
-i
-
IIIllI
c
lcIIiIIlI
-l
--l
-
llII
!
lN
st
s
l=l'
Ilal-iIl"ldiIIiiIIt_l8i"Ii*IilnIll"let'
lI
IiIIieiIIIlulole
qIIIni"IIIl'
ir8i'
iIIlIl*t"
Ill"iat'
i-
IIIt"lol"tela
IIIIl:
lIlee
i-IiIIIt:
1iltlgis;
I1"
t8t"tetn
EIl.Il=IIIi"l8t.
i::
IIl-t-
III'
l.
r
It-ldI
II
;l
;
Ii
"t
_
"t
-
II
oI3*No
l-
S
{6
L
OY
f
F
og
iz
E-
i
:5
e
;E
'(
!
=
r
:
-
o>
€
8
t
r
r
6
B:
E
3
E
o
e'
t
se
s
od
G
F
N
.
E
O)
!
E
HE
(U
h
-
Eo
L
=
NO
9-
BE
'E(LEoot
ITIIIIIIIIIIItIIII!
E
i=
;
6
!
f
oi
x
is
!l
NIIluIIiIIIt:
IIi!Il:IIlI11-
IIEls
t.lqt-
Il=IIIIIl:
ilIiIII6t'rE
4a
IIIIITITI
.EEE(Eoo=o
dd
N
g
'
dr
i
.
i
E
'
;;
;
d
dd
d
d
dd
d
d
EET
TII
dd
d
;
=I5l
Egs
t
=A
i
Et
s
s
E
E
*u
F
=
I
;
rl
t
l
l
!
r
r
E
"T
t
i+
d
ds,
5
5E
r*
II
I
E
IE
-d
.
!
-
EE
EE!E
II!IIlII
d
l
i
l
IldIIIIIt.l"
I:IIi-lalNt.lBlIIlBl*IIl8l"IIil.l'
Iill'
It'tsts
dai
1lIIIl
d
l
d
I
Il"
t.jdIIIl=ldIt"l"iIIt,
ia
o
ldldLILIi-
dNB
lql:
It-l6l"lsla
Il-:srA
IlIt;ls
d it:l-IIIl,ldIIl-t:isIE
qb
r
i.
r-
i
-
ll
t_
1
"
t9
tq
l-
1
"
il
l-
l
-
iill8i
5
l"
]
'
ll
i"
l
"
ll
r"
i
i=
i
=
l'
i
'
il
i-
l
^
il
l-
1
"
l.
l
.
]'
l
'
l,
l
,
il!i'
i
'
il
t_
l:
lQ
i
!
;
l
;
llIIIIIIsl
t
d
ldI
I1iiIiII
dIt,I'tsIE
ilnIIIlet.ld11Et-
IIIl=IiIt-ldiis$
.r
iIIt"1d
IIl*IIIil.t3IIIi3i*IIiiIIisi;
ilIliIIIi=I:t.sI
l,II8lf
r
Il"iIl*i"Ii1t'
L:IIl:ilItes
8d
.!dtt.i;
i
t
IIIlliII
sl
8
IIII
-l
'
Ii
EI
E
,
l.
IIII
-l
-
II
"1
.
*l
*
III
^1
"
r
l'
IIIII
;
lJIIIiI
-t
-"
i'
III]Nl-l"L}i!
E
E=
!
.i
Ef
aa
:2f
uI
3e
l:3t
zz-
I:3t
zzi
EE
{tf,Ezr
tf!CI
id
.
f,E2
E
-I<:
!Ft49:
:
,45(D=<t
s
5E
iu3l
lI:
))-:i
iEZa;rZ.
EOAI
J
sP*No
@S
N^
L
d9
a
L
og
Ei
,
.
EE
'
aL
=
v
:
F
E
>5
!l
.
r
at
r
ii
-
co
ar
!
o
PE
[e
5
o
o5
F
i
.
E
O)
!
E
HE
(5
h
-
do
L
=
NO
9-
BE5o.Eod)G
g0-E(Eoo=o
dd
d
i
dd
d
*
NO
r
O
o)O)oo)
(oEfac(!dEfrCl
I
"';
lf
,
y
9E$-EN
9
gE
9-
E
EH
s
E
E
E
-
^
E
:
EI
#
E
E
E
+r
F
s
'tt
r
9
9
6
-
-
g
5
r
r
'
=
'
'r
r
.
l
.
r
i
r
,
i
i
r
!
-
Jid
d
iii
i
;;J
df
lE
E
rE
<:
i
E
g
3
o6
r
tl!!
l.l=il*IIIt"
It,i=I
It-l-IiIIIil-iI1li-l"I1Ii_i"I
t:t-
IiII
l'
ii"
I1l=llol:tsls
lr
IIIIlsl"Il"l-it"ili=IIl_t;
IIt-l:is
l'
IlIi,l:l;is
l-id1ll=t"
lIIIlnIl"Ii*ii"i-IIt-iIt.l'
l1=1e:e;
:
d
oI*No
o)
S
N^
i
r
tg
t
7.
"
=9
E
r
JE
O
L
't
L
=
r
:
F
o
>E
8t
r
io
'
E3
:
a
8
6
o
gr
g:
5
o
oG
F
E
E
ED
TE
RE
(5
h
-
ts
o
L
=
NO
9*
EE6.LEoot
TIITItITtIItIIIIttI
e
.96
F
l
6e
ildiIiI
Il*III
Ii,
IIiIl-
ii1d
IlIlqt-
IIt"l"
Il"lel=IIl-l"
IIt.
Iit,
IIIll.]'
lIl=llI1"liL:Ti
l'
It-lel-
IiiIl1.l'
lll:
IIIIIl"IQl3
Ii_l=It-litrL"
l:
l"t8t-
it.l=Ill,
iIl=l-l;s
d:i;i
I
"i
"
t
=i
=
l
=
ll
ll
sl
e
l
e
.l
"
l
'
I
c
l
r
't
-
IIiI
-t
-
IIIIIII
d
i
d
il"
IIlqlxl'
Ill"1'
I]=llt":ii
Il*i'
It"
llet:tcE
IIIt"
Iil*l=l.t)l$
€a
..:dl.
I
ii
l=
l
=
lli'
]
'
il
i,
l
-
1:
l:
ls
s
e
lB
TItIttITt
(E(LE(Eoo@
dd
d
i
dd
d
d
qq
t
o
!
dd
d
d
dd
d
d
N
N
EiI
dd
d
d
i;
;
N
ITI
dd
d
B
iid
;
ET:l
ECE
I
>c
i
ET
E
E
E
E
*
,
r
i
I
;
,i
i
.
I
.
:
I
*
I
I
l
l
i'
I
;:J
d$E
5
E
i;
I'
L
d:
<.
i
I
E
3
6X
a
35EC
!!:o
T
Be
llsIIIl-l*Ilnlll1i.l'
l1t"
It-lNIIIIl-t:lJIIlct'
Il=Ill,l:ISls
ll*IlLldiIIIt"
Iit_t"
iiIl=lcit.l*IIl_l=II1"l;
illi=lll.l::i
lt:l"l-l'
Iit"IEIIi"l.
iiIt.
?
iIIi;l'ii(:
lei,l"iIlldt"l,lIl"Il'
Il.lr
-t.t'
d-t
-
II1
,
i.
-t
-
IIII
=l
=
Iinhss
i:
t:1-
IIIlnl.
iIlrd
i
1',
i-
i
-
lt|l
l-
l
-
1-
l
=ll"
l
"
tl,l
i"
l
"
t'
t
'
it
It.
l,t-
IIIi.
IIlrix
Ito
l
t-
IIIIl.
IIF1!ic
l=Il*t:t;rB lqIIIi.
III
I
i
It.
iil"l*it"tdIllt;l"
Ii.l"
IIIt"ldt'
Il'
It.i:il_lJIqt-IIIit-l'
IIIIIt:1"rtls
t'
Il"ldli-
liIEiil*
iiIl.
IiIt-
IIii1t1o
IIi.l;
IIi:IIiIlrt-ela
.1
.
i=
1
=
I
ii_
i
"
l*
l*
il
i
Ll
.
r"
i
"
II
=l
=
.l
'
lt.
l
.
l"
l
"
t1t.
i
"
l*
lx
l"
l
"
11
t-
l
-
l-
i
-
ll
l"
l
.
l"
l
"
ltrl:l
:
i"
l
"
itrl
rx
ls
l.
l
'
ri
i=
l=
iIt1l=
i
=
rltl:l
!
"l
:
i
l
;
a
re
t"ldi-IIIl-l'i-iIt.ldIIit'
It"ldlct.
ldIt
il-l'
IlIIJOIIIl"ldt8l3Il"l"
l.t'
IIll=Ili-I!1.
II
_t
_
-i
-
IlIIlI
*l
t
:
lr
-1
-
sl
s
si
s
_t
-
-l
-
III
,1
,
.
I'
III
dd
6:itI
ON
o
t
ru
_
E
t
qg
E3
e
E:
r
l
L
=
x
:
-
r
n=
{E
s
O
HE
T:
3
o
YS
rS
E
PE
S
S5
u
d
sE
tu
oE
(LEd()t
G0-E(!6o=@o)d)o6t
@trfEtr(Elr
tclj.Ef8-
()
=
c.
,
c
3-ii
9
E
E
9E
EH
E
E
E
s
-
^
E
:
,
ii
E
f
Ei
f
I
T
J
dd
d
E
dd
d
d
.id
d
d
;B
i
i
ii
J
i
J;
;
d9E
E
E
IE
<=
i
E
a
o
_6
EIEI
i!
;;
:
N
E
I
dIIltt:
i$ti
dN
idi'
IIIld
*l
=
"
lolII
c
lc
-j
-
II
.1
.
iII
"t
"
EI
E
'
l'
iLII
-t
_al
s
.i
.
'i
"
IIIII
.t
-
-t
-
IiIIl
q9-l
-
IIil
n
l
!
-l
-
sl
s
st
g
.!ol
i,qIis,t.l.
i
IIt,loIIl-l-{l-lNIl.
l-
q
IIIldlo
-
ii
IL.
ldt-
IIIl.l:
IIIIi-l.t-lBI!l"t'
IllqIIlql.
i-i@1I1-
l3II
dIIIl.iIIi
Ii't-
IlBliiBl.lgt.isE
t:l-iIl3Ii"l't"t'
IIt"l*Rli
IiIIt.l'
IIIl=ll*t-JQIt
lqIEia1-
lt;
Il:l!t.r$is
l.I'
IIIi=IIIt"l'
iIIIl^IElr
t.leiIIt:
iI,t.ldIllIIlslII1BIIllsl-
q
IIIl"lildiiIl'
IliI1-
IIllIrt.ITIl-inii
sIiBl
eI
:
t
:
b;
"t
"
=i
-I
"l
-
.
l.
I
aS
N!tNoa6
c
-
8E
&=
'
-
'3
=
f
Ai
il
s
o
YE
FS
E
9E
:
S6
i:
E
sg
o
6E
.LEoot
III!tITTII!IITTTIIt
f
Eu
,i
g'
d
IIt!ITIII
(!EEooo
@d
d
d
N-d
?
N
d{
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
o
qq
.
q
q
\
9
\
\
q
9
6
NN
d
N
N
d
N
d
d
d
d
N
N
dN
d
d
oo
d
d
d
d
d
d
i
d
d
d
d
dJ
d
d
dd
d
d
o
d
d
d
o
d
d
d
d
o
o
d
d
o
d
d
d
:a
:
a
a
a
a
i
l
:
:
:
q
q
9
q
:
r
a
a
r
dd
@
d
6
6
d
@
d
d
d
d
d
@
@
@
@
o
@
d
@
E!I
ii
d
i
I
I
9
q
-
le
.l
t
q
a
.
q
q
n
9
:
9
q
I
q
q
99
9
q
C
9
q
q
q
q
c
q
q
q
q
q
9
q
9
9
q
III
No
o
d
*
o
6
d
d
i
6
d
d
;
i
;
-
F
o
o
t
o
6
r
a
!
9
.o
q
q
q
I
6
q
q
q
1
1
6
6
-
1
a
r
5l
E'c;El
s5SE
3
>6
1
o
o
;
c
i
E
s;
;
g
E
E
=
"
i
=
I
=E
E
s
E
E
B
E
E
.
S
rf
!i
l
!
I
I
!
=
I
--
-
E
tl
t
t
t
s
E
E
E
;
E
i:
Q
I
I
F
d
eO
{i
{
E
s
E
o!
!ciE
88
8
t
t
t
E
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
.96
pl
6A
c
t
;b
b
a
;
i
a
i
a
a
i
;
;
;
;
b
i
i
;
;
b
ilb
b
a
;
a
b
;
;
e
b
l
b
;
;
b
a
l
a
b
ort?@oINoN
rA
N^
5
*
3g
E
?.
,
'9
=
r
JE
O
L
'(
L
=
r
:
-
o>
€
8
t
r
i
t
6
ts
:
6
F
E
O
g6
98
5
o
oG
i
n
t
9t=
c
N
tr
(E
h-
Ao
L
=
NOAEoIEoeot
--
-
3
NN
d
d
dd
d
d
;;
;
E
J
d6
J
i
ji;
d
(E(LE(Uoo=oO)o)o(oN
(oEl!,c(Ud=cfncl8-
l.
(
)
v
(')
.
E
v-i;
,
Et
E
E
E
E
s
E
r
i
,n
8
9
6
.
.
9
6
Y
t
=
d,
'
j
l
r
r
l
r
r
l
l
E
EE
r
J
6
l
r
r
l>
-
dd
d
e
dd
d
d
dd
d
d
PN
P
A
$E
!
f
t
E
iE
II
It-t-
iIl-I'1:
lsl!
diI
dl.l:lq IiI
r?
lr
l
-l
-
III
ts!!tsotNo
NS
N-
5*
tE
T1
,
EE
r
JE
O
L
'I
l
v
E
-
*
h=
sE
E
o
91
95
5
or
d
6
Fi
.
E
ED
!
E
HE
(t
r
h-
;
o
L
=
NO
9*
BE5(LEa(,u
ITTIIIttIttIIITIIIT
t_ldt-iIIlsl"Il'
ll'
IIil.l*It"t8I.l=ii"Ii'
it'
ini=Iit-;IIlr
iIlIIl5l'
llt.*IIlel=iIle
.
i"iIIli
IIIld
ilnl=IIIl_l3IIIIIi*
IIil;idiiildIll8iIIil-Ill*lr
l-
:;iEt-
IlxllIl-
li"IIII:IIIIt-IIIIit:
le
.
IIIll-t"IIIt-l]=lIieIililais
.1ea
l^In
l=
l
=
rlrl
il1_
l
_
i'
]
'
!.t
-
li
:l-
-
ls
s
lc
lt
Itlit"iu
lu
rliilit-
l
-
l"
l
.
ilIIl.
l
"
i"
i
"
IIiiII'l"IIil-iIIt"lB
l.
l
.
I
il
i.
l
.
l-
r
-
It"tn
N
i*
-
ta
e
t;
la
5iB
IIIIi*
It"ld IIIlcl-IIl=l"IIlIIl-IIIBil=IiII]-ts1S
Il=iIl=iIiii-l-ilsis
ll*l-IIlIl*It"ld
.i
"
i
"
ii
Ii
_l
^
t
-
=i
=
l
*
llri
-t
-
l
-
'1
"
1
"
iIIi-lrii
iiIitlr-
l
-
l'
i
'
irtirirlrl
l-
l
-
-l
-
;
rl
i
i!littal
e
.1
.
r;
l
;
el
;
R i
-i
_
iiI!I
-t
-
d
ld
8t
8
J;
I
.t
"
r
l'
IIII
.i
.
IIIIi
r
l'
BsB
NdIIIl-l'
IiIt-i;ie
o9I
E
C
a
E=
c
IIIttIIIT
(E(LEooo=o
dd
d
d
dN
d
d
N
N
d
d
d
N
N
N
N
d
d
d
d
d
o
d
d
66
0
0
do
d
d
d
d
d
o
o
o
o
d
d
d
d
o
d
o
o
o
o
dd
d
d
6
d
@
d
o
d
d
@
d
d
@
d
d
d
o
d
@
dd
d
d
:
i
I
:
q
q
:
n
.
t
n
q
q
n
n
!
q
9
I
I
q
I
dd
d
d
N
N
d
d
d
d
d
o
d
d
o
d
d
Nd
d
d
\!
q
q
q
a
o
q
9
q
\
N
q
q
n
n
n
I
P
I
I
EiT
TIIET5l
E
nE
I
Ec
.
i
=t
t
;
E
=
,
,
E
:
I
*
59
*
€
E
E
A
E
F
5
;
'l
i
l
r
I
i
I
I
r
l
i'
I
dd
d
d
do
d
d
o
o
o
d
o
d
o
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
o
o
-;-
-
;
j
;
-
;
J
J
-
J
J
-
-
dd
d
i
r
d
d
d
-
d
N
d
q
d
d
r
@
i
N
-
q
d
d
d
d
N
N
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
'd
d
N
d
d
d
N
N
;;J
d
ris
+
d
q
!
q
i
r
q
q
d
e
!
i
i
i
r
?
{
!
q
I
a
Y
{
1
a
.1
.1
rt
N
.
.
!
.
1
N
f
:
c
I
-
:
q
o
gE
E
=
9
d
E'
E
E
;
5!
IE
9
F
{>
S
E
e
i
o!EC!E
iF
F
F
F
I
o95
!
r
6e
c
6oFo$No
co
S
N^
L
@v
:f
F
og
81
.
,
q=
.
J=
O
L
'(
!
=
r
:
-
o
>€
8
t
r
r
E
B-
-
,
3
E
o
?E
95
5
o
o5
i
{
.
t
9r
u
c
N
c
(t
r
k
-
;o
L
=
NO
O
*
EE
'Eoo-ooot
"i-
d
;
d;d
d
88
6
9
d-
d
d
dd
d
d
&8
8
8
;;d
d
soE(E6o=@O)o,oro6l
(oc:)Ecodcft5
8"
;
la
)
=
c.
,
c
v-
(\
,
t
-
>n
i
s
s
E
25
EH
E
E
E
S
-
^
E
:
EE
E
E
f
!
BE
E
.
S
i
;
8
8
;
?
6
;
n
.
i
d.
l
u
n
r
r
l
n
r
l
l
S
Es
(
J
6
2
r
r
f
>c
dd
d
d
;;
;
N
ild
d
drE
E
E
s
E
".
;
E
E;
6!
!E!E
8
Llnl=Ii-ldiiil=1i1l8ll*ldIIl.lEt.l*t"iIi-IIIIq
l^irIri
IIirl-
IIIIIldIiil=l'
Itqi-
IirI"
lt"l-]"Ii"l"t,t-l"ldt"isis
rl
^t
-
o
ld
-t
-
IIII
*l
o
.
i"ilIIIllIlII
81
8
II
-t
^
*
l*IiIII
-t
"
t.
IIr
Iit.l*il-1=
Ilt_l!l"lsl:
drie!t
n
ln
lIit*
l
*
"
l"
i
Ilil.
i
"
;
l;
i.
l-
r
-
l8
ir
t'
l
'
l1rl
l:
lr
IIil,
l
,
t"
'
li
it"l-
iil-l'
ii-
l
l'
Il8l"
il=
Ilal"it"lNIIit.ld.II1"ldlIIt-;IilqIlxt;
I11Nl"ls;
l.
IIIl-It_liIIt.t'
IIIIl:
iIirl-te
!
d
i.l-iiIi:IIIlslfrl"IIl=t"!I1IIlIl:
iIIt:
I1.l-
IIl^dIli=t.
?
iIIii;l"!bs
IIt"diIt.l"
iIIIt.
iII
dd.?q
lq1-
IlI1"
l"diL.
IEiII.llt_l*
iIldl-
liIll8l"
It"t"
Il5l.IIl=IIIIlql-IIlIl"ls;
Ng!
it-iIIl-Ilildl.l:l=lnitss
I
q
i.
t
IIIIIIIiIIit.t"
IIl_li
IIIiIIl_t'
iIl*Ig
lcl'l=t"
IIl"lrIiIl=Ii-lEIIt
dci
ItT
Ne@onNoN
!t
b
N^
i-
8E
\4
e
3=
'O
-
=
!
!
r
*
H=
#i
E
o
ei
98
3
ar
d
6
FE
.
E
O)
!
E
HE
(E
h-
bo
L
=
NO
9-
EE
'5o-Eaot
ITITTII
ss
T
"!g
EE
s
$'
ITTIITIII
(EEEa!oo=@
dd
d
d
--
-
J
dd
N
i
d.
i
d
D
i;
i
l
i&&
R
t
dd
d
d
;J
;
d
IET
TITET5l
En;
l
Ec
.
i
,
Et
E
t
e
E
*
r
F
i
l
;
,L
I
,
l
I
i
I
I
l
s
"I
dd
d
i
l
-
aJ
+
d
NN
N
S
$E
5E
i
€
I
I
I
E
d!
<.
+
E
!
o
-d
!
5
6!
!'!E
F
T
l.
t"
iP
Ii=IFIil"lel*IIIi-i-ii*ll.]'
Il.
I3l:ts;S
l-1-
lIIi5l-IIIiIl
l"l-
IIt-l=III
Id
Il"l-
IIl*l"
IIi"l'
ilIl"IlsIE
lsl-
It.lxl"
llI'l*;bs
lxl"
IIldIII,
iIt-lEt.tsts
ddqQ
iIl"lIl-l1iiIIl"
lIiIIi-ld
llleiiiI
I
is
is
it
l.
i
"
l.
l
'
il
l-
1
,
l.
i
.
l3
lB
i'
l
'
il
l.
l
.
t:
l"
l
.
l-
l
-
l"
l
'
1l
l"
i
"
l'
i
l.
l
.
,
ii
i-
i
-
fl
:
is
ls
is
s
i
l^Iit.
lIIEt"t"ldt.dIlcII1tdIl3iiI'
tdIIIr1-
lllI:Ilal8ae
dI
lql-II]-dIrlI:iIEdIIi.
'
IIiIinIIIIIl*iId:s!
inl-lrl-
IdIIl"l-l.
Iii^l.
Ilil"lEllI'iul"Il-IIil=IiIIi3r8r$
lIiIIIlaItl=Ilet.isl$
l
-t
-
-i
-
i*Ill-ilBt^l-IIIrt.is$
ib
IIlst:lss
l-l1It-l*
iIIIi.ldIIIIIEl"!1l-E3
dd
{oo,oiNo
ro
S
N^
5*
tE
Il
e
FE
'o
-
J
!
E
-
G
>E
-E
E
.
c
iu
H-
6
t.
U
O
Pr
98
5
ar
oS
F
N
E
ED
!
E
HE
(s
k-
ts
o
L
_
N
O
9-
BE6oEoot
-
r
l
o
.
?
l{
E
E:
t
l3
5
F
f
I
o
F
-t
*
;
t
;
(E(LE(u6o=@
dd
d
d
dd
d
d
dd
d
d
fi
;
[
f
,
&&
i+
d
d
;J
;
d
q)O)ot-N
@trf,EIc(E'r
tcl*5
8.
.
;
EE
s-S"
r
9
gE
9_
E
EH
E
E
E
S
.
^
E
:
!I
#
E
E
E
+
E
F
s
i
.T
?
Y
?
.
:
l
i
?
;
E
Es
(
J
6
2
r
r
l>
c
d;
d
d
q
.
'
!
.
1
.t
iE
E
E
te
_6
Bi
!c4t
F
ilql=IIl-i-I1lt"l"iIt.IEl"Ii'l"t-l'
iI1:
lsti
ql-
i{iIl-l-
IiIil"lNiIIl-IEl"l,IIIIi.iFIIiIIiIIltIIiIi.l'
IIIIlIl-l"ixtbta
dId::t;E
qt-t-ldII
q
I
l=ItIIlqiIIir(
!a
Iit"t;
lIt;it-iEt.I(
!
ldiIiiIIl=IIislsls
t"1-
I1-I'
it-idIIldILit-l-I!8t"Iicl*iIt-l*iIIIi'
IIt"IJI
8dc.lis
lei.lsls
Ll;Ii"lit.ts
qIIIldIIldiIl.l*
iIt-leldllt"Il*II'3lIl:ls:
lile
i,
i
-
litl
l"
l
.
lll'
i
'Il=
l
=
l-
l
-
ll
l'
l
*Ils
le
l'
l
'
lr
lil
I
t
lt
l-
l
-
li
l=
l
=
li
l.
i,
l-
i
-
i1i=
[
llr"
l
.
l"
i
"
Ir
tN
-l
-
III
"1
.
'l
-
Nooo$NoN
(o
b
N^
L
OY
I
L
O
g
&?
"
EE
.
J=
O
L
'
O-
=
r
!
-
o>
€
8
t
r
i
t
E
3=
a:
E
O
gE
98
5
o
o6
t
r
&
.
8
ED
TE
HE
(E
h
-
bo
L
=
NOE.
E
.Eoo-E6qot
ITTtTTITTITTtTItttI
-l
-
Eq
Il.l8IBts
$
i"
t
5
qf
oe
sE
ITIITIITI
g(L5(Eooo
dd
d
s
dd
d
d
--
-
r
dd
d
N
ER
E
$
NN
JJ
J
:
Bfi
I
tIT=l
il
En;
l
=6
i
,
ET
E
E
E
E
*
r
+
i
I
;
,l
i
.
l
I
I
i
I
I
r
E
"
t
dd
d
d
;;
;
N
di;
d
dd
d
d
iid
JiE
;
i
;E
<I
:
E
!
O
_
d
EiTE
!'!E
F
I
l.
!
IIIl-l-I
5!a
"1
"
=l
=
-l
-
't
-
l:t;
Eb
Id
It"l:ldIIIl=
it-
IIIIl-Il"l"i'
iIIIIlsi"
i16
.
t*
liIt;
1It;
Il_t6
iisls
l!
IIl.lnIi"l*l"t9l-isl$
1q
Iisiii,
IIi=ldIIIil:
IIIt.
it"l*l.t8Il,
IIIli=
qiltdIi*IiiIIl-ldIt-IElel-t;t$l"l8t;
i
q
lrl-iiiIi*IIIIIi"let.l-I'
iqt*IIIilqi-:Il*IIIi-l5l"Il.l"IIldlNiIIIlBl"l,lN
l8
i8
li:
ln
It"ils
IIIl8l'
l!b
r.
l
i-iIiiIqlIIi-]"Il,lpll"IIl_IiIIi"iIIll,l"Il;IIIt;
iII1Itltai
IIlal't"INI
let"rils
It-lsIlsls
iiI
sr
s
sl
s
l,l-l-
li-l'
IIIIIl'
IIIlIt"In
IItl-l.l-IIl-I'
II1l"Il-l"ts]E
l-i-l=IInIIIt.l'
II;l"
Il*
"!g
EE
,i
g'
d
oIP{NoN
l'
-
AN^
L
6V
-
L
o
g
E?
"
's
=
'
dE
-
9i
o
>E
8
t
r
i
;
6
B=
6
3
E
o
gE
98
5
o
oG
F
i
E
O)
r
E
HE
(E
h
-
bo
L
=
NO
-Eo(LEoqoE.
E.E(LE(Uoo2oO)o)oo)(\
t
(ocfEc.Edcf{cl8;
b!rr
'
E
v-
(\
t
-=c
.
i
9
gE
9E
.=
o
-
!
E
=
EH
E
g
H
S
-
.
8
;
ii
E
i
t
E
fi
T
J
dd
d
d
d;N
d
d;
d
E
iid
dE8
8
E
dd
d
B
--
-
x
ii6
dFE
IE
f
i
9:
l
I
E
o:
<>
i
I
E
:
6X
a
at
Ic,E
t"t-
IiIIIIl*IiIIt:l.rSti
d
Ii-ldl-iIiIt-
IIlIl"t"1I1_lcllI1.l'
ii-
IIiII'5rb
lat;
Ilil"l-IiIt-l=t.t;
It-lsls
EN
t.
It^l=IIIl=l8l;te
qlal;
-t
"
-t
-
III
:ItNo
@S
N_
L
6Y
f
F
oE
wz
E^
e
:5
E
;E
'(
L
E
x
E
-
(E
><
EF
i
d
H9
=
6
E
E
o
#r
sP
E
o
dG
F
i
i
O)
!
E
HE
(o
k
-
bo
L
=
NO
9*
BE
.Eoo-Eoqot
ItTITTITItITTTtTItI
IqI
--
l
d
s
t=
!l
g
t
$=
*
].
;a:
I
;
oo
Il"
!
t-ii1l*rr
l
II
lIIIIt"
?t-
I
l'
It-leIl:I'
Il-t'tsls
ldIIIt"l.
Iil"lRI8lJIIIrtst"l-
iit"l=iIil:
IIl1";iirsls
l"IIIli
IIIIt.ial'
IIlt-1""
IIiIIt-
IIl*t;
iIIi-i'
I:I,:
iIi,.1qx;i
t-lslsl"l"1-Nls II
"!
lnIII
Il-leI'
Iil.
lIt"]-
Itl"It-
IIIi'
iItsI1:
l$
Ii-iIlIiI,lla
i
Illt"dIIt.
IIIt.lil"
II
ilqIl*t;
IIIIt-l'
iIl
It^I1^
i=It5ldIl"
Iillrlql"
l-lsl"l"
IIl,i'
IIIIl-
iIl"l-i${s
Il_l"l-lr
IIIt-lsl$
l-
t":ti
{
ItIItTtIT
EET
TTIET
!,c5l
EH=
T
EG
i
ss
s
e
E
E
"
.
;
=
l
,
ir
t
f
E
t
f
f
l
F
j
II
(UEE(sU'o=o
qq
q
P
=
=
88
8
8
E
i
iE
!
E
Ei
dx
o
€Id!
dd
d
dR&
&
3
--
-
N
dd
d
d
Nd
N
*
liIE
IiI'
iIi,t81qt'
Ii_l"l;
i
IIIIi-I'i
li*t-
iIIrI'
IIIl"
IIl-ldIIl8iel"
It"l'
iIi-l'
iIt"l'
Ii.l=sIQI
l"
'
iieiIil-Itl"It5ls
ilnIIIIiildIIIi,l"l"IIIt.l"IIlil8ls
'
lr
-l't'
la]'
ll-l"
IIl=ilIl:IsE
qqd8d
il-ldIl=l*
iIt-laldl6l"I;
IIt.l=ITiE
IIIIl"5IIl"
Il-Il-l-lqt'
It.t-t-li
I
-l
^
-t
-
II
.l
*
-
l'
II
"t
"
n
l"IIII
"t
"
Et
5
II
"t
"
.l
'
i
n
In
Ei
*Ii
"t
"
'1
"
lI
d
ld
E.
IE
"t
'
III
"t
"
IIIiI
'
l'
II
a
:ib
IIirIIl.l.ldl"
Il*
IiIIIqlF
q
it"d
IIt.l"
iIl"
t-
IIiIl-lsl6l-l"IIl=iIllit.ss
Iiol-l-lr
IIIi=l"
It"l8iIt"l6d
IIIlxl'
II:IIi:a$
Pl
e
Il-l'
Il'
IIIEt-Bta
iqiIIl"l=Ii"
It-l'i"l'
IIl=iIl=srE
rl
*
III
ol
*
"
i-II
,t
"
.1
.
Ii
.i
.
EI
E
IIl=IIl:lss
d
s
E=
:
;
E,
sE
oTtNo
o)
S
N^
5
*
tE
t
?.
,
=s
=
r
J=
O
L
'(
L
i
x
!
-
o
>€
8t
r
i
;
6
E:
6
8
E
o
9t
g:
5
o
dG
F
E
.
E
O)
!
E
HE
(5
k
-
bo
L
=
NO
9-
BE
E(LEootr
dd
d
d
so-E(Eoo=oO)o)o(')
(ocfE'c(E1r
,=cl.f.Ef8-
l(
)
-
rr
.
E
Y-=
c'
i
9
gE
9E
'=
o
-
E
c
:
EH
E
E
5
5
-
^
E
;
5I
#
E
E
E
B
E
F
s
i
.l
t
Y
?
.
n
Y
?
;
E
Es
(
J
6
l
F
r
l>
c
q\
q
a
dd
d
*
.?
F
idd
d
g
i;
i
d
;;
;
N
.
EE
E.
!
f
f;
TT
!
E
!
;
-,
i
3iEE
lc!!
i:it-t"l=Ii=IIt.l=tsti
l*l.l'
ldldIl,t"i'
IIl=IIIITl:l.tgl$
t;
ldl"IIl,l=IIi.tsrs
I
l"r9
iIl=l"
Ill"l'
it.
IiIIIIiIIIi!llIl'
l].
Ii:ix,bi
-
l"
i
"
i=
l
=
l-
l
=
idisIIIIrqlIdIlll:ldll_d:iel"iBiqiIiIl-iH
.
i;IiI::llqI$s
iiIIl"t;
iIIiIldIIiiIl3iiIlql=iIIli
IIt"
IIiIitI'
lIll=lIIl.
lIt.=tsts
t-i-IiiniiLit"IEl"IIt'
IFIi"l=IIi=IIIt-
ii1.t:IS1a
It-t-IIIIt-lqIiIIIlNIIIi-l5l"It:
IiIt.l'
Illll:isB
txi
IiIIil9i'
IItql=IiIII,l;tc
Il.l-IIt.ldIIIIt-l't"l.l*lBt:l{t'
IIIl9l-
IIIl=iIII1"1"
tea
il"
rt-
ii1Ilst.i-c
IIl=IiI1:1.
lsIE
1.1
iIIlgldiIIIIiirIlEl"lllt"].
Iiqlfr
ii18
.
t8lNl.
I
d
3d&I
ogC
EE
5
F
l
od
o
Iz,
,f
;
)Eia!tjt
Zt_!=jtr3!Eqt
iEl-!d2$
)<Z
a
-IIiEO
,t
:
,Gro54D=
(F,g!r
iEl{tJ:
)isItrtIt
t-5t
i:J
g3No
oe
Eo
E
-
IE
E?
s
-3
E
t
O
-
l
Y
!
-
*
E=
#E
E
O
HE
T:
?
o
YE
FS
E
EE
=
H?
b*
EE
AE
(LEooG
tTTtTItTTtIITITtTIT
IIIIITIIT
oo-E(Eoo=o
dd
d
d
N
N
--
-
t
dd
d
d
dd
d
d
dd
d
d
ET
T II
;J
d
i
--
-
N
iii
d
EI
Ecir
EHs
I
>c
.
i
se
;
i
E
E
"
^
6
=
l
ii
E
i
E
E
i
E
F
i
r
il
E
t
$
E
<=
i
E
!
o
-,
t
!
5
!c!3
I
i-lll"iiit-idiIIIldiiIIt.INIIiIIt-ldlRIIIIl.l8l'1"..i
l;IIIlql-
IIIiiIIIIlpIi*ts
LIi!
iIlii-ldIIIIIl"iIIlxIIl-IIIt-l'I'
It"
i-
a
IIIIIii=llIIl.istb
it-
IIli
IIIIIIIIIt-t.l.
IlFIIIt"l']"
ihl-lIl.l\lIlIlIl-l'I-lIl.lft
Ill'
IIl'
It-lcl-i1l.l'l=lct-t.tsls
eQI
l"1-
lIieI
IIl-dIl*IIl
1^
IIIt-t-l-IIl"
dIl=IIIl=IIlulsls
t-
IiII1Nl:1SIQ
l*IIIIt
Ill.l'
IIIl:
IIIIiIt-
l
E
t8t;
IIi"li
llrIIIsl:
Ii=IjIl=i;IisIE
L.
ldIi
l=
dil.t:tats
lt^ldII,l'
il-IEldIii;l-
Il"l'
iIt"iNIt-l-L,
IIIIil=1Il-ists
l.
lIiIt,ldiniI5l"
lt"dIl"ldIiIl8t'
IIIl!t"
It.
lIl"l=IIl'
l
:L:dlsi
t^ldl"1"t;
lIlJ18
.
l^Il=IiIIiel'
Ii!IIt.ri
Itsl$
idIIIIldIldI'
IlliqIlIlslIic:Iiiixl'
11l-l'
illIil:IIIIINl-iars
l=ldIileIIIlel;ts
"!e
eE
,i
g'
d
l.
l
.
i=
l
=
l-
l
-
l"
i
.
ll
i'
=
l
'
i"
l
"
IE
IE
li
t"
i
"
l.
l
.
ilt"
i
.
ld
l
d
l-
l
*
ii
lc
iq
lE
lf
l'
l
-
liLr
,
Ir
t8
l*
1
"
ll
l=
l=
ll
l-
1
,
t-
t
-
lrlr
l=
i
-
ill.
l
.
l-
1
-
ll
i.
i
"
1l
li
t
;
ls
ls
F9!PttNo
rE
o
'
Qa
E
'-
tE
&i
*
'
3
E
t
(L
I
s
F-
-
>€
8t
r
a
fr
fr
:
TH
.
?
6E
Ei
E
E,
E
E
SE
!v
=
No
;E
g
oF
o-EEt
EdPoI=@o)o)b(')(,
(ocl!tc(gdcl+'=f
8"
;
EE
t-s;
9
gE
9E
EH
E
E
E
5
-
^
E
:
5E
#
E
E
E
iE
F
s
,r
E
9
O
.
.
9
O
v
'
;
d.
'
j
u
r
r
l
r
r
r
r
b
Eq
9
6
>
F
r
D>
E
;d
d
i
dd
d
B
;;
i
t
i
;J
d
g
Jd
;
N
i;d
diE
i
E
E:
-a
Et
rE
!E!!
t-t_t;
IIIt-ldIIIIi:t.
INB
i_
1
.
t-
-
Ib l-l'
IIt.ld
IIt"t:
IIIIi.
d
t"l-lrIt"lut.l!ts
oIFoiNoN
r;
s6
L
Ov
-
L
o
g
&
i,
o
EE
'(
L
=
v
>
F
e:
5
-
E
i
F
iu
i
i
-
E
o
Y
E
o
Ht
r
g8
5
o
dC
F
E
E
ED
!
E
HE
(U
h
-
do
L
-
NO
9*
BE
'coo-EoaoE.
TTIIIITITIttTTTTTTt
IieliIlln1"
ll.l"
IIIIit"Il.
!t"
lluIil=I;Iiitl*IE
Il.
lIIIIl=Il"l-
ll"l-l=iiri:r$
lqIIIt.lr
iIIirt-
iIIil.i-
iIIi$lsIE;i
iuIi.1'
It.t-
ldl-
qIQ
ddIdi!IIIIl!tet;te
i-i'
l-
'
IiIl;INItr
ILIlr
;
l_
q
d
ilPIIIIii.tnjlIII: q'l
lIll^l"IIIll-l"ilrl'
IIIt'
Il.
iNIIiqlullt-j';lIl=
II
It_IlsIIil*It,
IIII=lEsta
ll
Iltl_
t
-
lr
t
!
l8
l8
t-
t
"
It
le
ls
!s
Il-ldt-
iNts
II
rl
r
II
nl
,
t
J'
llII
.1
-
*1
"
IIIII
-1
.
.
i'
IiiI
-t
-
xl
x
"t
"
II
Ei
E
-i
-
1=]"1"I'
Iil:Ii5l8t.
iC
E5s;
I
i*
,i
g'
r
Tt
d6
d
6
d6
6
d
L
dd
6
d
d
d
6
d
d
d
IIIIITTTI
=6L6(ooo=o
dd
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
o
o
d
o
o
o
??
J
N
dd
d
N
d
d
d
N
d
N
dd
d
i
99
9
9
9
9
9
0
9
iid
6
@
d
t
s
t
s
6
6
d
d
d
d
i
d
d
d
q
d
!
Nd
N
N
N
d
N
d
N
N
d
d
6d
6
d
O)ot(')
oo
d
d
o
d
o
d
d
o
o
d
o
d
o
o
d
d
o
d
o
TI
I
9
C
q
q
9
q
<?
9
9
q
q
I
9
I
9
q
C
9
9
C
C9
9
6
:
=
9
P
r.
I
q
I
9
I
q
q
9
I
!
,q
n
A
I
i
q
I
\
rr
!
a
r
1
*
n
1
!
r
r
NN
d
d
d
N
N
N
Y
EE
6
F
l
qF
rlc
l
c
c
l
N
e
{
l
e
Q
l
l
e
c
c
N
e
t
!
;T
EC5I
E==
I
Y-s"
l
ss
;
e
E
s
"
"
6
=
l
ii
f
fi
!
E
F
[
f
f
r
od
d
d
d
d
o
o
o
d
d
d
d
o
d
d
d
d
o
d
d
gE
E
:
Ei
I
e
!
E
a:
<>
:
E
!
o
o!
!.i!
I
@$Fo$No
NS
N^
5
*
tg
t1
,
,
gE
I
J=
6
L
'
O-
I
x
!-
o
>€
8t
r
i
r
E
ts
:
c
o
-
t
E
o
Hr
s5
5
oo
G
F
i
E
O,
!
E
HE
(5
h-
;
i
o
L
=
NOAE
't
rodEoqot
s(LEGoo=@o)ct
)olo(r
,
88
8
P
dd
d
d
id
d
d
did
J
dd
N
d
;;
;
N
(ocfEaodcltcf('
)cl(\
iclJcl
H!tN
o
oE
ci
€*
s
e
E
s
-
^
;
ii
E
f
i
E
E
f
l
[
f
J;;
d
dd
d
d
$
E
E
E
T
E!
i
I
I
E
d
3d
<I
:
E
!
O
-d
!5a!
!ciE
F
II
q!s
EN
.i
.
i
.l
=
l
Il.l"
IIIt.lFt-tc
J
t
qIaa
Il_ls
lln1-
lII:
IlaIl,lr
lIll";LIlIIIit;
Il-l-
lIIldlli.I1:
tas
lsl"
iIl*
iit-lsI1a13
.
iil"
Il"ldt"il,l-Iii"l'
IiIl'
IIliI:1!
1S
l.Init:iIIIl^l=lsIt.t!q
t"i'
iIIt-li
!IIji=
dcI!i
Ii-lEt.t!ie
E
t"
3
F5
6a
o
n
It,
iIIIt:
IIIIl-IIIi:iiii_t8i"l"t-is
IlaicIiIIl"
i
lIIlItJ
IdIII5l
e
i
l-IIl=iIIil.
IlINRr;
lIl-l,l'
IIil.
'
r
iIlIiIIIiBI!
\!s
l-l-ii=lNIIl=
-t
-
Il
:
t
:
iII
81
8
"t
'
iI
d
l
d
IIiI
TTTITTT
NoFo*No
(o
S
N-
5
*
tE
t
1.
,
=g
=
.
J=
O
L
'(
!
i
r
!
-
o
>€
8t
r
i'r
63
:
r
-
h
E
o
tr
95
5
o
dG
F
X
.
E
O)
!
E
HE
(E
h
-
Ho
L
=
NO
9*
EEE(LEa{,t
TtIITITIII
ITtIITtII
go-E(Eoo=@
dd
d
d
Nd
d
B
;;
d
g
88
8
P
.i
d
d
i
dd
d
;
dd
d
N
;i;
ddd
d
d
(t)<t)ET
ITIEI
EIc5r
EHs
I
i-
ss
s
i
E
E
-
;=
l
ii
f
f
EE
F
f
f
f
r
;;
-
t
i
dd
o
FS5
5
E
i
e
I!
!
E
te
-d
,
!
6
EE
!ciE-;
I
E
"l
_
-l
-
Il.t8l"
i
8didd
l"IIIEt;
i8!i
q
Illel"l-t"lB
dN
IIt"l*tNlgIlIl]-
ll*ji:l*]Rl8IINE
Il*3dE
IIi"lJlligl1l"
lIr-
i-
l
"1
"
IIEl'
I
EdE
l'
IIl3ldiIIIiFIIil<
:
l-lI1IqlllIlei'laB
l-t"IIIIt-t:
1Ii]'
ii.t"iIt:l3t.,eis
IIleI-iIIl"lEIt!is
IIiat'
IIIIi.I-itt-
iIlt'
lilBl.1s
INQNc
l_l-Iiiet'
IIilsi.iIt.i"iIl.
.l-iIIjt.
lo
,t'
lt"ldlnIi:
Iiil'
It.
lEl*ia
l:t!t;
i-
,
-
i
-
l=
1
.
1
.
I'
l*
l*
li
l
l'
r
'
i
'
l-
l
-
i
-
l'
l
'
l
'
l.
l
.
l
.
l,
l
,
l
,
ll
l
I8
E1
3
l'
l
'
l
'
l"
i
"
l
"
i"
l
"
t
"
l.
i
"
t
"
l-
l
-
l
-
l-
i
-
i
-
lr
lr
lr
ii
l
il
l
l'
i
'
l
'
l.
l
.
l
.
l'
1
"
i
.
li
l
lli"
l
-
i
"
l5
l8
l3
IN
!
N
E
lE
$r
g
IdI.!
fl
t=
E
.r
$'
si
c
N1
,
oE3e
!:3t
2a-
!:3t
zEE3)zttc!Ef<2
a
-IIEEE9:
r
rE5AD=
(F,El=?d
i1l1EJ)-ri5t
)
=t
iJlaiE
Ns!6otNo
$S
N_
5
-
tE
t
?,
,
=g
=
'
aL
=
v
:
F
*
H=
..
!
E
g
o
-r
98
5
o
oG
F
&
.
t
O)
r
E
RE
(E
h-
ti
o
L
=
NO
9*
EE6(LEad,t
(EEE(!ooo
dd
d
i
J;
;
N
dd
d
d
NN
N
f
r
88
8
P
dd
d
$
o)o)ot-(r
,
@c:)
!,c(sdcft58;
6€rr
'
E
v-s;
E
E
E
9E
Eg
5
E
E
5
-
^
;
:
5E
+
E
E
E
$E
F
5
i
.l
t
Y
?
.
:
l
?
?
i
i
E
EE
r
'
l
6
l
r
r
f
>a
do
;
o
iEE
E
E
TE
rr
!
E
!i
,
6'EI
iz
Il*t-
IIl-l'l=It.t8l"lct.-t"
IIIiI
IIt.lel'
Il"IBld
t-t
isl.le,a
l"!stb
II.a
lr
l
l=i"
iIi=
*l
*
-t
-
IIII
n
le
"t
"
III
'l
'
!II
il=
II
,
l.
IIII
r
lq
-t
-
II
i,
3
@6ddo!tNo
ro
S
N4
5
r
tE
t
?,
=g
i
'
d=
-
9:
rU
>€
8t
r
it
E
ts
:
6
E
E
o
er
st
8
o
d6
F
X
.
e
O)
!
E
HE
(E
h-
;
i
o
L
=
NO
9*
EEE(LEa{)t
tTITITItTtIIIITtItI
EdiIl,ldl"lt"iu
l
IIIIIi^l"lt"dIii-l8,$ie
t.
IIlIl"I:luti
it_l'
iII
IdqE
sl
e
dd
I
"l
_
Nd
IIII
I
ea
r
i=
3
6
r
l
o-
EE
Ilot-
iB
l-IIIi.l-IlIt;
IIi.leIi.if
,lrt"Il-l=iii.
,i-Ill.
it-l-IIIii-ldIiIlIlII'
llIIl-l8;IEIIiIt-ict-
iii:
lll"loIIIl-it,e
llli.
l;l-8Iil-
lI1"
IldiIl-
IIIi-
lini-
lll*ia
rgls
irSl.cis
t"l=IIt^l*
III,t-
II
IiI
"inl
s
"t
"
II
Il-l"
iIIt
ii*l'e
8
l.loliIrl'
IIiiI1"
lliJNt;
t-l'
IIIIt"l'
IiiIii'
lll-li8INls
d!rIiIIIt:
IIilII1l
ioI(!
IN
t.
!I=I
des
IIIITIItI
(ELE(Eoo=o
dd
d
d
d;d
;
88
E
g
dd
d
d
dd
d
d
;d
;
H
q)ct)ET
ItI
.;
;
N
dd
d
;
;;
;
s
;l
!,c5r
EH=
T
i"
i
It
g
i
E
E
*
u
f
f
t
i
rl
!
!
l
!
r
I
!
"
tI
iE
E
t
fi
E
"r
;
I
E;EI
ir
i*
l
*
il
l*
i
,
l"
l
"
l.
l
.
ii
t.ldIIl.lBl!
lBl.tas
i
"
i"
II
ol
*
*l
*
a
tN
It'
Iii,l.IIi*It.tct-t:
t\t'
iiIl"i3t;
IIi-lxl-Iirl*IIl*l'
I ldt'
lldIIlIiriiIl.l5II
3l-t-i=iIIii,
lrldIldieIIl-dIl"18l;lil-
ilqiIIi:
llIi:IIIt-t;
ioeie
t-IiIIl"i;rNt;
IIIt"t"I
Il.IIIIiIluiI
I1Ii3IIIlst-l"l-I
lil=it"It.l'
II
It.i-i:Ilit'
IIt-t;l*iN
N"1
"
"l
*
Il=IIIIl"l8l.tets
IIt-l.l"lale
dIQs
Il"
r1-
IIIllsl"
IlIi-e
II
t-t8ldiIIIi*dIl=
"r
"
1
"
9
l
o
l
r
li
;
r
a
a
Il_it-
ilslsl.ists
IiIt"lnIIIIII
Ei
E
IIII
si
s
"
l"I1Il
"i
"
IIII
r
l'
IIiiIIIIIII
"t
.
r
l'
l
-;
88
I
E
r
I
I
5
E=ON
N
EA
6NoiotNo
(o
S
N^
5
r
8E
E
?,
,
'g
E
'O
-
=
!
:
F
o>
*
8
t
r
i
t
E
ts
=
6E
E
o
9a
S8
5
o
o
6
F'N
.
t
O)
!
E
Hc
-
(E
lB
-
;r
o
L
=
NO
9-
BE5o-Eqot
(E0-E(Eoo=oO)cnoO)
(')
@clEc(EdEf$cl
8"
;
lo
=
c.
)
t
r
v-i;
.
9
gE
9E
Eg
E
E
E
s
-
^
E
:
5g
#
E
E
E
l
E
F
s
i
.l
t
Y
?
.
:
l
Y
?
;
,
r
s
EE
(
J
o
l
p
r
3>
a
88
8
P
did
d
jid
d
dd
d
i
CE
E
E
B
E
i!
!
I
E
i
EI
IE
d
Il-IIIl"t:
II
ai
IllllIIlIiLI
"l
'
III
d
l
d
II
-1
.
ei
e
"1
"
III
el
s
-l
-
III
q
lc
JI
E
i
"t
"
"1
"
I
-]
*
']
'
II
:L
:
IiII
=l
=
IiI1
al
o
oY?oo{No
F-
S
N^
5r
tP
E
?,
"
'9
E
.
J
=
O
L
'(
L
=
Y
:
-
o
>E
8t
r
i
i
6
ts
:
6
3
E
o
et
ge
5
o
o6
F
N
H
o)
!
E
3E
(E
h
-
;o
L
=
NO
9*
EE
.Eo(LEoood
tTtIIIIItIITIIITIII
IIIIt^
lllIlcIIl-ld
It-
IlqiLi3IIIIIl-t8Il*t"IIl=Ilel-Il-t-
iIIIl8!rg
It_tFit"
iIIiel.tIi"lBl'
Il=t*i-t;
iIt"lEl-la
1.i"li
Il=llxIIt"l"Il.
IIIIlqt-
IIIIl"
se
I.l
I1IIl.t:l;t"tdIIl.
i
iiILt-i-
;IIl.
lli-i8,eIB
IidiIIIIIln
?
lIllt:
lt,ial'{It.tdiIIt*t;
ll-:
IIIi"dIiII*;a
ilnIIIIt-ldIIIIit.
iIIIdl'
IIl.
*l"IIt-tNIIit-l,
t
IlIIIl=Iis
Pl
e
iIIlI
!
tc
iIIIII
3
!;e
l
ENnl
s
"l
'
iII
Ei
3
-t
-
IIIl
"1
"
jII
'l
-
IIIIiIIii
.r
l:!I1IlIII
"1
"
I
l
i
3,
4
i
N
t
!
i
tB
IIIgd
igi'
IIt-
IlsI
l
_t
_
-l
-
IiI
-l
-"l
'
III
-l
-
I
Bt
8
.1
.
II
_t
_
d
ldIII
-l
-
IIIIri"LNt$
1*Nts
I
Er
E
5
F
l
oe
de
q
IIItIIIII
.go-EG6o@EiT
dd
d
d
d;
d
;
oo
?
o
.i
.
i
d
d
did
d
JJ
J
N
Sd
d
d
tIT:l5r
E
tg
I
L.
,
Et
s
;
E
E
*
u
f
f
I
i
rl
t
l
l
!
r
!
!
=
t
;;
;
N
f
EE
E
sE
<r
+
E
!
6
-a
_!
e
EI
!I
F
I
-t
-
iiIiI
58
dd
li:IIIIIi"
IiIl.
lI
8aatRd
i
^l
'
IIIIIIIIIIIIII
.!
n
!Nsi
s
lt,
II!I
I
:
iI]"
ljIIIIidIiiRist;
liitd
IIt.l-
I18i"IIt.l.
lIl.t"t"IIIl-I'
II]=iIt.l"
ll,1-
lea(!
ilnl"ldIIIIl"l"i"IIIIIl=Il-l-
lIIl"i*iII't"IIIIt.
It.l-EIE
r'l
l1ldIIldIiIi8l"Ii^
.
ieIIIilst;
IIlsIIl"l"
II1"I
li-
I1d
i*
]*
i*
l-
i
-
l
-
il
tii
i
l:
l:
l:
i:
iii
t
ii
l
]"
'
'
ll
i
ll
l
iu
'a
iu
l'
i
"
1
"
lr
i
l.
t
_
1
"
l"
l
"
l
"
li
l
l.
l'
l.
lB
lg
i
r
i"
t
"
l
"
il
i
l"
i
"
i
"
l'
l
'
l
'
!l
l"
i
"
]
"
ll
l
l-
l
-
l
-
li
r
l-
l
-
1
,
l-
-
.
-
ll
ril
i
l'
l
'
l
'
ll
r
1.
1
,
1
.
l'
t
'
t
"
l,
l
ii
.
l
l-
l
.
-
l-
i
-
-
iq
]a
!
is
i
s
ts
dI
l
Nln
lllIIIt"IIIId
IiIt'
IIiicIIIl_l!iIt-l'
IIIIl.qIIll"J:Il
ilqIIILI]"ii;Il.
i
I1Ill-
IFioIl-
III1I1;t'
IIt"1-
IidIIIt"Inl-
I
ll:
IIIll"]"
IllcidI1-
i=t;tdI
i;IIIIEt"
IIt-i.
IldiIIl-
IIIIl"i1Ii"IEl't"l"l"Il'
dId
Io
i
-
t-
-
Il!
c
I!a
l.el$
d
i"
Il,
ii
EI
InPttNo
@S
N^
5
*
tE
t
3,
"
=9
E
I
J=
O
L
'
(!
=
r
E
-
o
>E
8
t
r
i
r
6
E:
6
E
E
o
9i
i
gP
E
o
d6
F
i
.
f
CD
!
E
HE
(s
h
-
;o
L
=
NO
9*
EEo(LEootr
l=t!
tt
-9
-
c
g
EE
=
6
r
l
oe
x;E
dd
d
;
(!EEooo=@
dd
N
;
o,o)ot
(of!,co,r
icf+cl
8"
;
6P(f
,
ES-=
..
i
60
6
9
-
Ee
s
e
e
s
-
;=
=E
E
E
E
E
*E
F
E
JX
_
Q
5
>
2
J
-
!
i
5
ig
9
6
.
.
9
O
v
r
'
;
.lr
r
r
l
r
r
l
l
b
EE
u
6
>
F
r
>>
d
--d
d88
8
P
dN
d
d
;6
d
i
dd
d
6
dd
d
d
;;
;
N
dd
d
6
r
I
E
E
i
Ei
<-
i
E
t
o
-d
t
E
Ei
!E
I
3cs
i_l-ta
l"IIl"I
n
II
-t
-
o
lo
cs
!
IIl-ldl-i
diEi"I ld
ieII
qIIl=IIIIi=i"ItIt
t.
lIt'
Lt.t"IIIi!l"ts1S
lqIEt"
II1l:l=IIeIIIi:i.t!e
i"
i
"
i
"
t-
L
*
t
-
il
l
ri
i
i"
l
"
l
"
IIII
lt-li1q;i
IIIlc
l;IIIlc
t,l'
IIt_IN
t,l'
IIl.]'
it-l.t!rNl8
l'
Iil"l-IQt!
t"
iIll"laIlIIt9t-
Ila,s
i_l=il-ldII
iiI
81
8
IIIII
N
l
d
IIII
.t
.
sl
E
l_t"INIE
iirt-
IlIl=
i_ldIIIl*i=ts
Tt
el
s
'
l"II
,i
.
'i
"
Ii
TITTII
t-t:
ld
s
{6P*No
Or
S
N6
L6
Y=
F
og
t4
"
'c
E
r
JE
O
L
't
L
jv
E
-
o
>€
8t
r
i
r
Et
s
=
6
3
6
o
gr
gP
5
od
G
F
N
t
O)
!
E
HE
(5
h
-
do
L
=
NO
9*
BEELEa(,t
q
TIT
t.i
E
Er
e
5
F
l
OE
B
tTIIIIITI
(5(LEooo(c
)
dd
6
d
dd
N
N
N
N
d
N
d
d
d
d
N
d
N
d
d
NN
N
H
did
i
dd
d
d
qq
l
a
^N
d
-
J
d
d
d
N
d
d
N
N
d
N
d
N
N
N
d
N
88
5
9
dd
d
d
o
d
d
o
o
d
o
o
o
d
d
d
d
o
o
d
o
od
d
d
6
d
d
o
d
d
d
d
o
d
d
d
6
d
d
@
d
dd
N
d
N
N
d
N
N
N
d
d
d
d
d
N
d
N
d
N
d
I
I
q
^1
I
C
q
C
q
:
r
rq
q
q
\
c
i
q
q
',
q
r
q
qq
q
q
9
9
q
q
q
q
c
q
9
q
q
9
q
9
q
q
q
1
i
E!I
tII5l5l
E
sE
I
Ec
i
rt
l
;
E
E
*
u
$
;
l
:
rl
S
i
l
!
r
u
!
"
t
N
d
d
N
N
,N
d
N
n
c
d
d
N
d
d
N
N
od
d
d
o
o
d
o
o
o
d
d
d
o
o
d
o
o
d
d
d
CE
E
E
*
g
!E
F
;
:
!
IE
E
E
O
:
<>
i
E
!
6
TC
I
oTxo
oq
o
r
N^
c
RE
Tt
:
-
i
E
-
>E
8t
r
it;
fr
fr
-
_e
I
E
?
EE
EE
i
PE
:
S6
\v
-
No
b
*
BE
o.Eoqot
Appendix H - Galibration and Response Time Data
Project No. M243506
Unit t, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
cllent: Pacificorp
Feclllty: Gadsby Powor Plant
Proroct #: M243506
Tolt Locltlon: Unit 1
o.toi 8t26t2024
Opsr.tor: C.Eldndg€
Box Truck:
Probe Longth:
Prcbe Typa:
Srmplo Plrno:
Port Longth:
Port Slzo (dlametor):
Port Type:
Ouct Shlpo:
Lcngth (tr.Ysrua lldo ot duct):
wdth:
Loc.tlon of Tost Porta:
Duct Araa:
Equlv!lont Dl.motor Rectangular Duct:
Uprtraam OlemetorE:
Downrtroam Dlrmolorr:
Number ot Ports Samplod:
Numbor of Polnts por Port:
Totrl Numbea of TravoBo Polntr:
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
BT13
'14 0
Extracliv6
Horizontal
7
4.5
Nippl€
Redangular
14.75
13.33333333
Side of ducl
196.67
14.006
1.5
1.5
t
I
I
I
T
T
I
I
I
t
I
I
I
I
I
T
t
I
T
1 22.75ln. 2 54.24ln. 3 85.74
1
3
It Polnt Msr|(lng3 (lncludlng port longth):
Polnt I lnchoa
ft
ft
Sq. Ft.
Minimum Upstroam Distanm
Minimum Domstroam Oistan€
ld€al Upstream Distane
ld€al Downstream Distance
7.0 Feet
28.0 Feet
28.0 Feet
1 12.0 F€6t
v5.0
144 of 1 99
RATA Extractive 4/1 6/20
OMostardi Platt
Typ.Sottlng Cyllnd., lD Cyllnder Vrlua Analyzsr
ReaDonSe Dlltorcnc., % of Sprn Date
lild cyllndsr % of hlgh
cvllnder
NOx ppmvd
t6 I I 59610 o o 1c -0 100i 1D9t)na)
d co 32 O ()lOA uraDoa)49.27o/.
143 3 ta3 60 {t 160l'N)aDOr9
o2./" (dryl
zorc TBU I{2T'4J o o05 -{)41
illd 1t59610 9.891 9.90 -{}.0406 1t29t2032 43 A2o/o
Hldh 22.57 22.56 o.o40h 412212032
CO2 % (dry)
trc o -0 33%Llr3t oS)
l,o 1t
il tflruBa90u 1a 45 1a 51 -o 3306 4t22J2032
I
T
T
T
T
T
I
T
I
t
T
I
T
I
t
I
T
I
t
clLnt: PsdfiCorp
Frclltty: G.dsby Prycr Planl
Fual Typa: Natural Gas
Futl F.ctor: 1040
Dllu.nt: CO2 %
Trtl Locrtion: Unil 1D.t , u8n1
Oprntor: C.Eldridgc
Pror.ct *: M243506
02 % Codcllon: 3
02% Comctlon Drir
Cma = Conccnb-ation = Avm! value ot tcst
Cm=Arcra€c Pre and Post Span C{as = ConEtad gas valuc of test
Mostardl Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
RATA Enr.ctive 4/16/20
OMostardi Platt
PleI
9.34 9.3 o.22
o.21 12
3 9.891 -0.53 .0.04
q
9.71 9 a ,ol
1.95 -t tl
0.1s
6 9.891 {l(t.20
9.97 c ol .o
na
t o21 U 971 5.7 -n tt
n o {
u 666 U,$-o.43 -0.76
0.20 0
9.912 n
U 0.33 -o
t
E 9.912 1 o 9a/-u
562 5.5 -0.92
9.89 n o
Run I Run
Data Sun Tlm.End
Tlm.
NOx
ppmvd
NOx ppmvd
@3%02 CO2 % (dry)02%ldryl NOr {ral lnpui
MMBtdhr
Nox lb,hr
u.l$
6]JY q
3 6
9.3 0.1 39 175 66.0{
10:24
U.I J6
1)O
lr6./9.3 1/174 n1
IU al26,121 1a
v5.0
145 of 199
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Test Location: Unit 1
Date:8126124
Project #: M243506
I
T
t
T
T
t
I
T
T
t
I
T
T
T
I
t
I
T
T
Linearity Cal/Pre 1 Cal
Time
7:42
7:43
7:44
7:45
7:46
7:47
7:48
7:49
7:50
7:51
7:52
7:56
7:57
7:58
7:59
NOx ppmvd
-0.01
21.47
179.31
183.58
183.60
151.94
0.58
0.19
7.94
85.03
90.25
0.41
14.14
86.07
89.86
02% (drvl
22.56
9.25
0.02
0.02
0.07
6.95
9.90
9.90
4.17
0.05
0.05
9.89
3.99
0.34
0.33
CO2o/o (dryl
18.51
7,91
0.11
0.09
0.08
6.59
9.74
9.77
4.28
0.07
0.06
9.76
4.05
0.21
0.19
Mostardi Platt
Pro.iect No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
v5.0
146 of 199
RATA Extractive 4116120
@Mostardi Platt
m
z
m
2
m
z
m
z
m
z
m
z
I
T
T
I
I
T
I
T
t
T
I
I
t
I
I
T
T
T
T
Client: PacifiCorp
Facillty: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Test Location: Unit 1
Dale: El26l24
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Time NOx oomvd
8:33 O.2'l
E:34 47.62
8:35 89.88
Timo NOx ppmvd
9:30 0.409:31 50.28
9'.32 88.76
9:33 89.86
Post 1/Pre 2
O2oh Gwlz 9.85
0.37m O.21
Poet 3/Pre 4
O2olo 6.\lz 9.85
o.21
0. 16m O.17
CO2 % (drv)
9.72
0.32
0.21
CO2 % (drv)
9.70
0.31
0.22
0.20
Time NOx oomvd9:02 0.409:03 49.399:04 E9.36
Time NOx oomvd9:59 0.5010:00 46.0410:01 88.00
Poot ZPre 3
O2o/o Gwl2 9.78
0.24m 0.18
Poet {Pre 5
02 % (drv)z 9.74
0.56m 0.17
CO2oh Hwl
9.78
0.35
o.21
CO2 % (drv)
9.84
0.80
0.21
RATA Extractive 4/1 5/20
@Mostardi Platt
v5.0
147 oI'199
Client PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Test Location: Unit 1
Oatei 8126124
T
I
I
I
t
I
I
T
T
I
t
I
I
I
I
T
I
I
T
Time
10:28
10:29
1 0:30
Time
11.27
11:28
11.29
'1't:30
NOx oomvd
040
52.36
89.37
NOx oomvd
0.41
'l 1.30
85.58
90.51
Post s/Pre 6
02o/o (drvlz 9.71
030m 0.18
Post 7/Pre 8
02%(dI1,lz 9.82
4.00
0.1 1m -0.07
CO2 % (drv)
9.85
0.48
0.22
COZo/o (dotl
9.77
4.58
0.46
0.41
Time NOx pomvd
10:56 0 35
10 57 53.9610:58 89.36
Time NOx oomvd
1 1:59 0.34
12:00 4.86
12:01 83.021202 89.17
Post 6/Pre 7
02%Gwl
z 9.46
0.23m 0.19
Post 8/Pre 9
O2o/o (drvl
z 10.05
5.92
0.20m 0.20
CO2o/o (drul
9.71
0.31
o.22
CO2o/o (dntl
9.96
5.31
o.24
0.21
RATA Extractive 4/16/20
@Mostardi Platt
m
z
m
z
m
z
m
z
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unil 6
v5.0
148 of 199
T
I
t
T
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Projoct#: M243506
Test Location: Unit I
Oalet 8126124
Post 9/Pre '10Time NOx oomvd 02 % (drv)
12:28 0.39 z 9.8612:29 0.23 9.1012:30 60.26 0.23'12:31 89.80 m 0.22
CO2 % (drv)m 9.94
9.02
0.26z 0.22
Post l0Time NOx oomvd 02% /d,rvl12:57 0.39 z 9.9712:58 43.58 0.3112:59 89.40 m 0.13
CO2 % (drv)
m 9.89 m
0.35z 0.22 z
t
T
I
t
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
v5.0
149 of 199
RATA Extraclive 4/1 6/20
@Mostardi Platt
I
ICllent: PacifiCorp
F.clllty: Gadsby Power PIant
Pro.lsct #: M243506
Tost Locrtlon: Unit 2
O.$i 8n612O24
Oporator: C.EIdridge
Box Truck:
Probe Longth:probo Typo:
Srmple Pl.no:
Port Longth:
Port Slzo (dlam.tor):
Port Typ.:
Duct Sh.pe:
Diamotcr:
Duct Arer:
Upstrerm DllmetaB:
Domstroam Dlematan:
Numbsr of Portt Sampl6d:
Number of Polnt! por Port:
Total Number of TruvaBo Polntr:
T
BT13
10.0
Extractive
Horizontal
4
Nipple
Circular
7.5
44.18
o7
'1 1
,1
J
Calibration
It
ln.
ln.
Polnt M.rtlngs (lncludlng port longth):
Polnt ,
1
2
3
lnchsg
19.03
49.00
78.97
I
It
sq. Ft.
Minimum Upstream Distane
Minimum Oomstream Oistan€
ldeal Upstream Oistanco
ld€al Downstroam Distance
t3 8 Feet
15.0 Feet
15 0 Feot
60.0 Feet t
I
I
I
I
I
t
I
T
I
I
t
TMostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 'l , Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
v50
150 of 199
RATA Extractivs 4/16/20
OMostardi Platt I
Tvpo SettlnO Cyllndor lD Cyllndor V.luc Anrlyzer
Rotoongo Ollrorcnco, % of Sprn EXprra(on
D.to
Mld cyllndor r of hlgh
cvllndor
Zero 11596'10 0 0.29 -{J.16%1t2912tJ32
NOx ppmYd Mtd FBT} I 4 90.32 90 30 0.010/6 4n!2032 49 2704
Hloh cc25734t la3 3 143 0a o 1)oa 4t23t2029
02 % (dry)
26rc EtsUlqzt}lJ 0 u03 { 13%4t2312032
Mtd il 9.891 9.88 0.050/6 1t29t2032 43.820h
Hldh ?57 22.55 0.090/6 4t22t2032
CO2 % (dry)
z.erc o02 4 1104 u?3D03?
Mtd LL59btO I 912 990 o.otoh 1t29t2032 53 T20h
Hloh E80088900 14.45 16 41 o 22%4t22t2r-]32
Tvoe RM Anrlvzer rrh Anrlwer Sorn RM Grr SDrn
NOr oomvd Ihermo 42C 42CHL5 l 1 69330 143
oz !a 11140 Gas Analvzsr 01440D114326 5 22 5t
co2%1440 Gas Analvzer 01440D 1/4326 20 '1u.45
Siart 96% RosDon3e Tlm. lmlnl
llorcrla I
Domtc!lo I
Cll.nt: PacifiCorp
Frcllhy: Gadsby Pflcr Planl
Full Typ.: Nalural Ga3
Fu.l Frclor: 1040
Dllu.nt: co2 o/o
Lma = wnccnrdutr or ur s5
Cm=Awragc PG and Post Span Cqas = corKted gas valuc of test
Mostardi Pl.tt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
TGri Locrtlon: Unit 2
O.L: 816121op.nton c.Eldridg.
PrcJ.cr ,: M24350602 % Comcllon: 3
v5.0
151 of 199
RATA E{rac1iv.,U16/20
OMostardi Platt
(Cnas qGn Biasta o3t .o 11 o3
lu 40 {E
o22 9.8 ln
9.83 1n
u.uu 1.O2 -0.18 -0.1 3
83 I 0.07 -o.17 -n05 I oxq
I
3J o.27 o.71 .o.27
o.'t2 -0.01 I tt
-o 03 1A 0 -oM
Client:
Facility:
Test Location:
Date:
Project #:
Time
7..42
7:43
7:44
7:45
7:46
7:47
7:48
7:49
7:50
7:51
7.,52
7:56
7:57
7:58
7:59
NOx ppmvd
0.00
9.51
174.61
180.59183.08 ih
150.69
7.84
0.29 iz
3.07
76.1590.30 im
0.29 z
4.65
79.3790.60 m
02% (drvl
22.55
10.31
0.13
0.'11
0.10
7.32
9.88
9.88
4.37
0.04
0.03
9.81
5.40
0.15
0.12
CO2 % (drv)
18.41
8.79
0.24
0.18
0.02
6.23
9.08
9.90
4.65
0.03
0.02
9.83
5.73
0.18
0.09
PacifiCorp
Gadsby Power Plant
Unit 2
8t26t24
M243506
Linearity Cal/Pre 1 Cal
I
I
T
I
t
T
T
I
T
I
I
I
t
t
T
I
I
t
t
MostardiPlatt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
v5.0
152 of 199
RATA Extractive 4 I 1 6 120
@Mostardi Platt
m
z
Time
8:33
8:34
8:35
t
I
T
T
t
I
I
T
T
T
I
t
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Test Location: Unit 2
Datei 8126124
Time
9:30
9:31
9:32
9:33
NOx oomvd
o.47
34.1 3
90.32
NOx oomvd
0.47
28.99
88.94
89.96
Post l/Pre 2
O?oh ldrul
z 9.88
1.55
m 0.19
Po3t 3/Pre 4
O2'/o Gtvlz 9.83
1.93
0.33
m 0.26
CO2 % (drvl
9.94
1.90
0. 19
CO2 % (drvt
9.80
1.88
0.27
0.24
Time NOx oomvd9:O2 0.559:03 36.02
Time NOx oomvd
9:59 0.E5
10:00 28.38'10:01 89.01
Post ?Pre 3
02%ldlvlz 9.87
1.64
m 0.17
Poot 4/Pre 5
O2o/o (drul
z 9.65
1.38m 0.10
CO2 % (drv)
9.97
2.O5
0.23
CO2 % (drv)
9.89
1.E3
0.31
RATA Enractive 4/16/20
@Mostardi Platt
m
z
m
2
m
z
m
2
m
z
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
v5.0
'I 53 of 199
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Test Location: Unit 2
Oetei 8126124
I
I
I
I
T
t
T
I
T
t
I
t
I
t
T
I
T
I
T
Time NOx opmvd10:28 0.4310:29 30.9510:30 89 78
Post 5/Pre 6
O2oh /dwl
z 9.88
0.60
m 0.07
Post 7/Pre 8
O2o/o {drvlz 9.82
4.00
011m -007
CO2 % (drv)
9.72
0.86
0.35
CO2 % (drv)
9.77
458
0.46
041
m
z
m
z
m
z
Time
1 0:56
10:57
10:58
Post 6/Pre 7
NOx pomvd O2o/o ldryl CO2 oi (drv)
0.4229.89m10.0434.74 0.04 0.9190.38 m -0 17 2 0.39
Time
11:27
11:28
11:29'l'l:30
NOx oomvd
0.41
'l '1.30
85.58
90.5'l
Time NOx oomvd11:59 0.4112:00 1.2912.01 70.0012.02 89.74
Post 8/Pre 9
02 % (drv)
z 9.88
6.89
-0.09m -0.13
CO2 % (drv)
9.8'l
6.83
0.55
0.46
RATA Extraclive 4/16/20
@Mostardi Platt
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit '1. Unit 2. Unit 3. Unit 4. Unit 5. and Unit 6
v50
1 54 of '199
I
I Client PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Test Location: Unit 2
Datet 8126124
Post 9/Pre 10
NOx oomvd O2oh 1dwl0.48 z 9.78
0.39 9.72
90.04
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
COz% ldryl9.28 m
9.1 0
0.750.35 z
Post 10Time NOx pomvd O2oh (drul CO2 % (drv)
12:57 0.54 z 9.92 m 9.2112.58 24.15 'l .05 1.77
12:59 90.22 m -0.03 z O.34
m
2
v5.0,l55 of 199
RATA Extractive 4/16/20
@Mostardi Platt
Cllont: PacifiCorp
Faclllty: Gadsby Pow€r Plant
Proloct #: M243506
T6rt Locrtlon: Unit 3
Dtlo2 812712024
Oporator; C.Eldridgs
Box Truck:
Probe L.ngth:
Prob6 Typc:
Sampls Plano:
Port L€ngth:
Port Slza (dlrmotor):
Port Typo:
Ducl Shrpe:
Dlamet6r:
Duct Arot:
Uprtroam DlrmeterE:
DownEtrorm Olrmotsr!:
Numbar ot Ports Samplod:
Numbar ot Polnts par Port:
Totrl Numb€r of Trave6o Polnts:
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 'l , Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
BT1 3
15.0
EXractive
Horizontal
4
4
Nipple
Cirelar
17.4666667
239.61
2.7
9.1
1
I
J
lnchos
'19.75
51.24
82.74
I
I
I
I
I
I
T
I
T
I
I
I
I
I
I
t
T
I
T
ln.
ln.
Polnt M!rtlngr (lncludlng port longth):
ft
Sq. Ft.
Polnt;
1
J
l\,linimum Upstream 0istance
Minimum Domstream Oistane
ld6al Upstream Distanc€
ldaal Oownstream Distance
8.7 Foet
34.9 Feet
34.9 Feet
139 7 Feet
v5.0
156 of 199
RATA ExtractivB 4/16/20
@Mostardi Platt
t
I
I
T
t
T
I
I
T
I
I
T
T
t
t
t
I
I
I
Clllnt Pacilicorp
F.clltty Gadsby Powor Plant
Fual Typa: Nalural Gag
Fucl Frctor: 1040
Ollu.nt: CO2 %
T.!t Loc.llon: Unil 3DtLi El27l24
Opontor: C.Eldridgo
PE .cl li M243506
02 % Comctlon: 3
Cma = Ctr@batioo of cal Gas
Cm=Arcrage Prc and Post Span
= Avq4c valuc of t6t
Cgas -- CoGted gas valuc of test
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
RATA Extractive 4/1 6/20
@Mostardi Platt
I o l:t u3J u 16 ,0.70
ul/om o2)
5 E.87 o ll .1 UU ut6
-1
6 8.904 6au -t 6J
US 896 6.12 ti
U 897 8.96 n 11
a 041 -o.27
lo 8.99 o
Run a Run
D.la $rn Tlm.Endl'lm.NOx
p9mvd
NOr ppmvd
@r*02 :o2 ./t (dry 02 % (dry)NOx Lat lnpulM[&ffit
NOr lbrhr
75.,138
53.2
9.8 0.1 10 763.( 83.683
8:12 55.0
6
76.64
v5.0
'l 57 of 199
I
TClient: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Test Location: Unit 3
Date:8127124
Project #: M243506
I
t
I
I
I
I
T
T
Linearity Cal/Pre 1 Cal
Time
5:44
5:45
5:46
5:47
5:48
5:49
5:50
5:51
5:52
5:53
5:54
5:58
5:59
6:00
6:01
NOx oomvd
0.00
22.96
175.34
183.46
179.62
33.35
0.45
3.97
63.72
86.77
91.70
0.22
'15.43
85.95
87.90
02% (dwl
22.52
9.72
-0.20
0.01
6.80
10.68
10.57
6.81
0.00
0.05
0.07
10.70
3.24
0.00
0.01
CO2 % (drv)
18.54
8.75
0.21
0.05
4.89
8.92
8.93
5.36
0.06
0.04
0.04
8.84
2.95
-0.03
0.09
t
I
I
T
I
T
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit '1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unil 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
v5.0
158 of 199
RATA Extracliv e 4 I 1 6 120
@Mostardi Platt
I
T
I
I Glient: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Test Location: Unit 3
Oatei El27l24
Time
6:57
6:58
6:59
Time
7:50
7:51
7:52
Post 1/Pre 2
NOx oomvd 02% Grrtl0.95 z 10.3813.65 2.6587.89 m -0.05
Post 3/Pro 4
NOx oomvd 02 % (drv)
1 .10 z 10.4120.46 2.3690.73 m -0.05
CO2 % (drv)
8.87
2.54
0.17
CO2 % (drv)
8.89
2.36
0.24
Post ZPre 3Time NOx oomvd O2o/" (dtvl CO2 % (drv)
7:24 0.93 z 10.42 m 8.877:25 18.28 2.47 2.417:26 92.75 m -0.03 z 0.21IPost 4/Pre 5Timo NOx pomvd O2ch ldrul8:17 0.93 z 10.428:18 21.49 2.138:'19 92.34 m -0.03
CO2 % (drv)
m 8.92
2.20z 0.28
T
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit '1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
v5.0
159 of 199
RATA Extractive 4/16/20
@Mostardi Platt
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Test Location: Unit 3
Oetet 8127124
t
T
I
I
T
I
I
I
T
I
I
I
I
I
I
T
T
I
t
m
z
m
z
m
z
m
z
m
z
m
a
m
z
m
z
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Time NOx pomvd
8:44 0.988:45 22.578:46 91.61
Time NOx oomvd
9:37 1.01
9:38 25.889:39 90.51
Post 5/Pre 6
O2o/o ldrulz 10.43
2.40m -0.05
Post 7/Pre E
OZoh ldrulz 10.38
2.15m -0.05
GO2 % (drv)
8.91
2.44
0.3'l
CO2o/o (dtvl
8.97
2.32
0.37
Time NOx ppmvd
9:1 1 0.959:12 25.939:13 92.34
Time NOx oomvd
'10;04 27.86
10:05 90.86
Post 6/Pre 7
02 % (drv)z 10.40
1.70m -0.06
Post 8/Pre I
O?oh Hwlz 10.42
1.81m -0.05
CO2 % (drv)
8.95
1.96
0.34
CO2 % (drvl
8.96
2.04
0.39
RATA Extractive 4/16/20
@Mostardi Platt
v5.0
160 of 199
Client: PacifiCorp
Faclllty: Gadsby Power Plant
Proiect#: M243506
Test Locatlon: Unit 3
Datoi 8127124
Post g/Pre l0
NOx oomvd O2olc (dwl
1.08 z 10.3729.76 1.7692.48 m -0.07
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
CO2 % (drv)m 8.91 m
2.09z 0.42 z
Time
10:55
10:56
10:57
Poct l0
NOx pomvd 02 % (drv) CO2 % (drv)
1.23 z 10.42 m 8.99 m30.54 1.67 2.0192.41 m -0.06 z 0.44 z
v5.0
161 of 199
RATA Extractive 4/16/20
@Mostardi Platt
Cllont: PacifiCorp
Faclllty: Gsdsby Power Plant
Projcd f: M243506
To3t Locatlon: Unit 4
Dtlot U2812024
Oporrtor: C.Eldndge
Box Truck:
Probe Longth:
Probe Typo:
Ssmplo Plano:
Port Longth:
Port Slzs (diamoter):
Port Typo:
Duct Shape:
Diemeter:
Ouct Araa:
Upatream Dlam€to6:
Oomltream Dlamoterc:
Numbor ol Ports Sempled:
Numbsr of Polnts par Port:
Total Numbor of Traverce Polnts:
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit I, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
BT,I3
12.0
Enractive
Horizontal
8
4
FIange
Circular
12
1 13.10
04
63
1
3
3
lncho3
23.75
86.74
t
I
I
I
I
T
I
I
I
I
T
I
I
I
I
I
T
T
I
in.
ln.
n
Sq. Ft.
Polnt Mrrklngr (lncludlng port length):
Polnt #
1
2
3
Minimum Upstream Distance
Minimum Downstream Oislan@
ldeal Upstream Distanc€
ldeal Downstream Distance
6.0 Feet
24.0 Feet
24.0 Feel
96.0 Feet
v5.0
162 of 199
RATA Extraclive 4/1 6/20
@Mostardi Platt
Calibration Gases
Typo Sonlng Cyllndor lD Cyllndor Value Analyzar
Rssoonso Oltrsronce, % ot Span Drto
qyilnqer a or rugrl
cYllndsr
NOr ppmvd
tlo FBOO91 1 a8 o {.01 o 1104 21512029
d cc262396 5 00d 495 o Aoor StaDi)6 55 500*
Hlqn LLt t5ZE I 9.01/9.02 4 030li'5t1512026
02 % (dry)
2etd 0 010 444%215t2029
10 51 to 53 r ogo*419t2032 6.570/a
rh TBUUAA9OU 22 57 2? 55 O 090/6 419) DOa)
CO ppmvd
zafo IBUI4U992 0 ooa { aoo6 419t2032
Mtd E80091 188 4 aga 5.U0 2t5t2029 4a aa%
Hldh FBOOO7f35 10 0)10.04 4.20%10t2t2031
T.rt Loquon: Unil ,a
O,nai 8ngn1
Op.nton C.EldridgoPFI.ct ,: M2,t3506
02 % Comctlon: l5
ClLrt: PacifCorp
Faclllty: Gad3by Powcr Plant
Furl TtD.: Nalural Gas
Full Frcton 8710
Dllu.nt: 02 %
c.llbntlon comd.d D.l.
Run I Run
D.to 31.il Tlfr.End
Tlm.
NOr
Ppmvd
NOr ppmvd
e 15% 02 O2'h ldryl CO ppmvd CO ppmvd
@1s%02
oz btxd
NOx Hart lnput,NOx lblhr co tbrhr
at2al21 o9 11
Its 16 J lu t.539
7:59 1.7
1 Ug tl 16 3 IJ Ulu t.B6
3.1 it
I I
7 U,6 t.u 2.305 0.59
lu:zl 10r,11
I t'03 123 oa l.u U,U 1
]U
U,O t.l 0.011
= avrdge value of test
Cm=Avcrage Prc and Post Span C{as = CotrKted gas value of test
Moslardi Plstt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
RATA Extractivo 4/16/20
@Mostardi Platt
v50
163 of 199
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Test Location: Unit 4
Date: 8128124
Project #: M243506
Linearity Cal/Pre I Cal
02% ldrvl
0.04
14.04
22.40
22.51
22.55
8.34
0.01
0.01ah 0.00
0.04
0.10iz 0.10
8.24
10.54
10.53
3.18
o.14
0.14
0.13im 0.13
z 0.15
8.34
10.40
'10.43
5.64
0.18
0.18m 0.16
5:49
5:50
5:51
5:52
5:53
5:54
5:55
5:56
5:57
5:58
5:59
6:00
6:01
6:02
6:03
6:04
6:05
6:06
6:16
6:17
6:18
6:19
6:20
6:21
6:22
6:23
I
T
t
T
t
t
I
I
T
I
I
I
I
T
I
I
I
I
t
0.37m 0.11 z
0.08
0.18
0.17
0.19
Time
5:47
5:48
NOx ppmvd
-0.01
-0.01
-0.01
-0.01
-0.01
2.84
'11.65
9.58
9.02
7.36
-0.01
-0.01
-0.01
-0.01
-0.01
2.80
1 0.55
7.84
6.27
4.95
-0.01
-0.01
-0.01
-0.01
0.69
4.03
4.53
4.99
CO ppmvd
10.04
8.66
1.14
0.02
0.00
0.02
0.11
0.17
0.17
0.48
3.27
5.00
3.90
0.45
0.08
0.09
0.18
0.19
0.20
0.20
4.93
3.72
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
v5.0
1&4 of 199
RATA Extractiv e 4 I 1 6 120
@Mostardi Platt
I
T
I
t
I
I
I
T
I
t
I
I
I
T
t
T
T
I
T
Client: PacifCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Test Location: Unit 4
Oale2 8128124
Time
6:58
6:59
7:00
7:O1
7:02
7:O3
7:04
Time
8:02
8:03
8:04
8:05
8:06
8:07
8:08
Post l/Pro 2
NOx oomvd O2o/o (dwl
-0.01 z 0.09-0.01 9.13-0.01 '10.55
-0.01 10.55
2.44 1.49
4.96 0.09
4.98 m 0.22
Post 3/Pre 4
NOx opmvd O2o/o (dwl
-0.01 z 0.08-0.01 8.82-0.01 10.52-0.01 10.53
1.35 1.93
4.79 0.21
4.79 m 0 22
Time NOx oomvd7:30 -0.017:31 -0.01
7.32 -0.01
7:33 -0.01
7:34 1.337:35 4.807:36 4 80
Time NOr pomvd
8:35 -0 01
8:36 -0.0'l
8:37 -0.018:38 -0.018:39 1.518:40 4.758:41 4.89
Post ZPre 3
O2o/o (drul
z 0.09
8.5'l
10.54
10.55
2.O2
0.tIm O.22
Post 4/Pre 5
02 % (drv)
z 0.08
9.1 5
10.50
10.51
1.89
0.19m 0.21
CO oomvd
5.09
3.59
0.30
0.1 1
0.'l 1
0.20
0.24
CO oomvd
5.08
3.63
034
0.1 1
0.1 3
0.21
0.26
CO oomvd
5.07
3.84
0.40
0.12
0.1 1
0.21
0.29
CO oomvd
5.02
3.58
0.33
0.09
0.11
o.20
0.25
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
v5.0
165 of 199
RATA Extractive 4/16/20
@Mostardi Platt
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Test Location: Unit 4
Dale: 8128124
I
T
I
I
I
I
I
T
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
t
Time
9:07
9:08
9:09
9: l0
9:1 'l
9:12
9:13
Time
1O:12
10: 13
1 0:14
10: 15
1 0:16
1O:17
10: 18
CO pomvd
5.12
3.57
0.32
0.t0
0.13
0.20
0.25
CO oomvd
5.04
3.56
0.35
0.1 'l
0.1 5
0.21
025
CO oomvd
5.06
3.70
0.39
0.1 1
0.12
0.22
0.28
CO oomvd
5.11
3.76
0.35
0.'10
0.'13
0.20
0.26
Post s/Pre 6
NOx oomvd O2o/o (drvl
-0.01 z 0.06-0.01 9.17
-0 01 10 47
-0 01 10 481.54 1.334.59 0.054.90 m 0.05
Post 7/Pre 8
NOx oomvd O2o/o (dw\
-0.01 z O.O4
-0 01 9.08-0.01 10 44-0.01 10.451.74 0.984.60 0. 10
4.91 m 0.18
Time NOx oomvd9:40 -0.01
9:41 -0.01
9.42 -0.01
9:43 -0.01
9:44 2.069:45 4.609:46 4.93
Time NOx oomvd10:44 -0,01
10:45 -0.01
10:46 -0.01
10:47 -0 0110:48 I .89
10:49 4.60
10:50 4.90
Post 6/Pre 7
02% 1drulz 0.05
8.72
10.46
10.46
0.61
0.04m 0.04
Post 8/Pre 9
O2o/o Gwlz 0.04
8.63
10.43
'10.43
0.86
016m 0.18
v5.0
166 of '199
RATA Extractive 4/16/20
@Mostardi Plaft
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
T
T
t
I
T
T
T
T
I
I
I
I
I
I
T
T
T
I
I
Cll.nl: P.ciicoe
Fellky: G.drby Pw.r Pl.nt
Pnold t: M243ffi
Tdl.dlo: Unn4
Ofri 8n8n4
Pod e/PE 10lgl-crE:d 92.!UCu){01 t 002 !
Pd lmm 1l
IiEr MlrrrEIC 02 T ldnr lglloxt1158 -001 . 002 z 495 m1159 401 8S 35S12:00 0 00 10 39 0 341201 { 01 10 40 m 0.00
{01{010m
205
4.60
905
10 40
CO omvd5.02 m
347o32000 t
014
023
026
Pd il
02 r ldNr glrr@tl
r 007 : 488 m10.21 2.46
10 39 0211039 m 010 r266 014015 022m 015 026
12:02 2.og12:03 4.60
1.15
o171204 4m m 017
0.1 3
0.23o2a
v5.0
167 of 199
RATA E*r.tu.4/16120
@Mostardi PlaftProject No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Cllent: PacifiCorp
Faclllty: Gadsby Power Plant
Proloct #: M243506
Test Loc.tlon: Unit 5
Dtlot 812812024
Oporator: C Eldridge
Box Truck:
Probe Longth:
Prob€ Typo:
S.mple Plano:
Port Lsngth:
Port Slze (dlrmetor):
Port Typo:
Duct Sh.p€:
Dlrmster:
Duct Are!:
Upstroam Dlamoto6:
Domstrorm DlamotoB:
Numbor ot Port3 Sampled:
Numbor ot Polnts psr Port:
Total Numbsr of TravoEo Polnt3:
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 'l , Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
BTl 3
14.0
Extractivo
Horizontal
4
Flang6
Circular
12
113 10
04
6.3
lnchoa
23.75
55 24
86.74
I
T
I
I
I
I
I
T
t
T
I
T
I
t
I
T
T
I
T
in.
ln.
1
3
3
Polnt Mlrklngs (lncludlng port longth):
ft
Sq. Ft.
Polnt I
,|
2
3
Minimum Upstream Distance
Minamum Domstr€am Distane
ldoal Upstr€am Distane
ldoal Downstream Distanc€
6.0 Feet
24.0 Feel
24.0 Foet
96.0 Feet
v5.0
168 of 199
RATA Extractive 4/1 6/20
@Mostardi Platt
I
T
t
I
I
I
I
T
t
T
I
I
I
T
T
T
T
I
I
Cll.nl: PacifiCorp
Frclllty: Gadlby Powcr Plant
Fu.l Typ.: Natural Gas
Fu.l Frcton E710
Ollucil: 02 %
Tlrt Locrllon: Unil 5ott , 8128124
Op.nton C.Eldridg6
Prel.c-t ,: M2,13506
02 % Comctlor: 15
cma = ffismMorGr@s
Cm=Avcrage Prc and Post Span
C = Avgaqe valuc of test
Cgas = ConEtrd gas value of tcst
Moslardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
v5.0
169 of 199
RATA Extractivc 4/1 6/20
@Mostardi Platt
PE Po* zem
I 5 0(x ,4.99 -l I I 0.00
ia 89
0.00 a I U o
0.o0 0.00
a9 000 4.89
U 00
JI 078 0.00 n
om
4.89 o rl uw u.w
90 4.90 2.42 11
0.c m o UU
Plel
1 t6 0.37 t6.08 15.,(
]U 0.l6
1 3 U4U 0.o0
t0 5t l0.l tn /-ug
5 l3 IU 048 t6 08 16.2 0.09
0.13 11
ts t0 5l 10 ln tt UU UJ5
054 t6 16.
10 55 0 t .U ll
11 10.51 t l3 l6 004 -0.os -0.58 0.00
Run #n U'S Sdn as Soan Drift
a Eca 016 i -tm o
2 4.898 o2u -0 80 0.10
a u 14 499 -o ln
500 0.14 17 oao o20 0
a ,0.70
0.15 o60
l@ -u.ru
016 1,8
i|.93 4.S 020 U
l0 120 0.t0 -0.50
a a u 16 016 0
crllbntlon coftctad Data
Run I Run
D.la Sun llm.End
Tlm.
NOr
ppmvd
NOx ppmvd
e 15% 02 02%(d.yl CO ppmvd cO ppmvd
e 1516 02
02 baaad
NOx
lbrmmBtu
H.rt lnput,NOx lbrhr co tb,hr
I 6:J5 6155
2 l5 a la I u1l J lll t.l u
I lc t.9 0.012 1L
6:J2 I
l6 u ulJ 02
3.0 't6 I
I ta
l0 al 1,J
013 t3
t:J5
16 lb U UI2
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Test Location: Unit 5
Date: 8128124
Project#: M243506
Linearity Cal/Pre 1 Cal
I
T
T
T
T
I
t
t
I
T
t
I
I
I
T
T
I
T
I
ih
Time
5:47
5:48
5:49
5:50
5:51
5:52
5:53
5:54
5:55
5:56
5:57
5:58
5:59
6:00
6:01
6:02
6:03
6:04
6:05
6:06
6:16
6:17
6:18
6:19
6:20
6:21
6:22
6:23
02% (dll
0.06
13.53
22.57
22.60
22.61
9.04
0.08
0.07
0.06
0.10
0.05
0.06
9.76
10.55
10.54
3.47
0.06
0.05
0.05
0.04
0.08
3.75
10.38
10.42
10.39
0.53
0.34
0.32
NOx ppmvd
0.01
0.01
0.00
0.00
0.01
1.20
12.73
9.288.88 ih
6.88
0.210.00 iz
0.00
0.00
0.00
22.94
17.86
8.09
5.204.96 im
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
1.80
4.56
4.99
CO pomvd
10.07
8.63
1.12
-0.14
-0.06
0.03
0.31
0.39
0.39
1.43
5.05
5.08
3.8s
0.31
0.'11
0.17
0.35
0.38
0.37
0.37
5.07
4.91
1.18
0.16
0.28
0.25
0.40
0.41
MostardiPlatt
Projecl No. M243506
Unit 1. Unit 2. Unit 3. Unit 4, Unit 5. and Unit 6
v5.0
170 of 199
RATA Extraclive 4 I 1 6120
OMostardi Platt
Time
6:58
6:59
7:00
7:01
7:O2
7:03
7:04
Time
8:02
8:03
8:04
8:05
8:06
8:07
8:08
I
T
I
t
T
I
t
T
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
T
T
T
T
Client PacifCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Test Location: Unit 5
Datet 8128124
Post 1/Pre 2
NOx opmvd O2o/o (drvl
0.00 z 0.160.00 5.260.00 10.300.00 10.320.35 5.784.42 0.104.89 m 0.06
Post 3/Pre 4
NOx oomvd 02 % (drvl
0.00 z 0.090.00 5.94-0.01 10 41-0.01 10.450.46 4.6'l4.35 0.084.89 m 0.05
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
CO oomvd
4.97
4.60
0.78
0. 18
0.17
0.34
0.42
CO oomvd
4.98
4.42
0.63
0.14
0.17
0.35
0.40
Time NOx opmvd7:30 0.00
7 31 -0.01
7.32 0.007:33 -0.0'l
7:34 0.317:35 4.02
7:36 4,89
Time NOx pomvd
8:35 0.008:36 0.008:37 0.00
8:38 0.00
8:39 0.45
8:40 4.12
8:41 4.89
Post 2/Pre 3
02olo ldrtlz O.17
3.85
10.43
10.45
5.78
0.1 1
m 0.07
Post 4/Pre 5
O2oh (dwl
z 0.09
5.99
10.42
10.45
4.84
0.07
m 0.05
CO oomvd
4.99
4.86
1.20
0. 19
0.16
0.33
0.41
CO oomvd
5.00
4.41
0.62
0. 16
0. 17
0.36
0.40
v5.0
171 of 199
RATA Extractive 4/1 6/20
OMostardi Plaft
t
TClient: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Planl
Project#: M243506
ITest Location: Unit 5
Datoi 8128124
Time
9:07
9:08
9:09
9:10
9:1 |
9:12
9:1 3
Time
10:12
10:13
10:14
10:15
10:16
10:17
10:18
Post s/Pro 6
NOx oomvd 02%/druI0.00 z O.O70.00 4.570.00 10.390.00 10.43o.12 5.743.76 0.094.89 m 0.05
Post 7/Pre 8
NOx ppmvd O2 % (drvl0.00 z O.110.00 6.370.00 10.550.00 10.57
0.1 3 5.293.75 0.194.89 m 0.13
Time NOx oomvd9:40 0.009:41 0.009:42 0.009:43 0.00
9:44 0.36
9:45 4.03
9:46 4.89
Time NOx oomvd10.44 0.00
10.45 0.00
10:46 0.00
10 47 0.0010:48 0.0910:49 3.9010:50 4.89
Post G/Pre 7
02% ldw\z 0.13
6.0'l
10.49
10.52
4.89
0.13
m 0.12
Post 8/Pre 9
O2o/o (dw\
z 0.19
5.46
10.55
10.57
5.17
0.16
m 0.11
CO oomvd
4.93
4.71
0.93
0.17
0. 16
0.34
0.40
CO opmvd
4.98
4.39
0.63
0.14
0.16
0.34
0.41
CO oomvd
4.99
4.47
0.67
0. 15
0. 't6
0.33
0.41
CO oomvd
4.93
4.62
0.85
0. 16
0, 16
0.33
0.40
I
I
T
t
I
T
t
T
T
I
T
I
T
T
I
I
v5.0
172 ol 199
RATA Extractive 4/1 6/20
OMostardi Platt
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 'l, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
T
I Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
I Project#: M243506I t""t t'"11",1,
u',1'1,10
I rime !.9.rrrrc'*tt&"Ji* co oomvd rime Nox pomvd '""tlf.rii;'J, co oomvd
I 11.26 o.oo z 0.12 z 4.9s m 't I:58 0.00 z 0.19 z 4.96 m11:27 0.00 5.17 4.65 11:59 0.00 4.91 4.73
11:28 0.00 10.56 0.9'l 12:00 0.00 10.52 0.97
- 1i:29 0.00 10.59 m 0.16 z 1201 0.00 10.55 m 0.16 zI lir? ilB r ?? B I 13',zz ilt, i?l z:lt,
11 .32 4.90 m 0. 1 1 O.41 12:04 4.89 m 0.15 0.40
I p- ry'o'!ir,-"*' , ry m12:31 0.00 6.35 4.37
- 12.32 0.00 '10.53 0.65I ',i;21 BB? ::,T m Bl3 z
12:35 3.32 0.19 0.31
I
12:36 48e m 001 040
I
t
T
I
T
T
I
T
t
I Mostardi Platt
Proiect No. M243506
I
unii t, unit 2, unit 3, unit 4, unit 5, and Unit 6
v5.0
173 of 199
RATA Extractive 4/1 6/20
@Mostardi Platt
Cllent: PaotlCorp
Faclllty: Gadsby Pow€r Plant
Proloct #: M243506
T6rt Locrtlon: Unit 6
Delc 812912024
Oparator: C.Eldridge
Bor Truck:
Probo Longth:
Probe Typo:
Sample Plrne:
Pori Length:
Port Slze (dlamcter):
Port Typs:
Duct Sh.ps:
Dlamotor:
Duct Aror:
Upstroam Dlametero:
Dom3troam DlametoE:
Number of Ports Sampl6d:
Numbor of PolnE per Port:
Total Number ol Trlver3o Polnts:
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 'l , Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
BT1 3
80
Extractive
Horizontal
12
4
Flange
Ciralar
12
'1 13 10
04
63
lncho3
27.75
59.24
90.74
tt
ln.
ln.
Polnt Merklngs (lncludlng port longth):
I
I
I
T
T
T
T
t
I
T
T
T
I
I
t
T
I
T
T
Polnt il
'1
2
3
1
3
3
ft
Sq. Ft.
Minimum UpstrBam Distance
Minimum Domslream Distan@
ldeal Upstream Distane
ldeal Downstream Distanco
6.0 Feel
24 0 Feel
24 0 Feel
96.0 Feel
v5.0
174 of 199
RATA Extractive 4/16/20
@Mostardi Platt
Calibration Gases
Tvp6 Settlng Cyllndor lD Cyllndsr Valu6 Andyzar
Rcsoonse Dlflercnco, % of Sptn ErPtaa(0n
Date
Mld cyllnder % or hrgh
cvllnder
NOx ppmvd
Zoro ccl 16370 0 000 0 00%at2at2031
Mtd 2396 5.004 5.15 1 620A 31312026 55.50%
Hldh D5)47 I Ot7 495 o Tloa 5t15t20?6
02 % (dry)
zorc LLI I6J/U o o.o3 -o 13%at2at2031
Mtd 140992 '10.51 '10.58 -0.3'l %4t9t2lJ32 46.570h
Hloh 8900 22.57 22.59 4.09%412A2032
CO ppmvd
Ze?o o o09 {) 9004 nED03)
Mtd t 16370 4 974 495 o 2404 at2at2031 4S
Hlon EbUUU/JJ6 10.02 9.9 /o.50sa 1rJt2t2031
I
I crhnt: Pacincorp
Flclllty: GEdsby Powsr Plant
T.rt Locdlon: Unit 6Drr: 8/29/2/tOp.ntor: C.EldridgrPol.ci t: M243506
02 % Coreciloni t5
Fual TEr: Natural GasI Fu.l F.don 8710I Dilu.il: oz%t NOr oomvd Comdlon Datr
I
I 02 % lddl Comdlon D.h
t
T CO oofrvd Cotffilon O&
!
T
T
I
I
T
= CorcntratM of Cal Gas C = Avraoe valuc ot tcst
Cm=Avcraqe Pr€ and Post Span Cgas = ConKted gas value of test
I
I
T
T
T
Mosl.rdi Plat
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
MTA ExtEciive,l/1€i/20
@Mostardi Platt
T
PE zErc
t ,o o1 -0 01 1a a 01t
5UU -0 0t -0.01 I ooo
J 5 fi)a t -o ot tt U
1 t ,0 0l t8 -0.33 It
-0 0'l .0.01 -0.01 I
6 5 0(x t -u ll lt
t 0 .U 17 0.1 m n ll
5U6 0.00 -0.01 o7a o33 { 11
9 -oo -o ol .o I u tl
to .U UI .U UI "0.01 o11 noo
PE zm rrc I <En Eir( I h^
I o
t u 16 10 4t 't5.34 15.6 0.66 o
I u43 10.12 o a
4 i l6 U.I J
10 I tu.{t u.rJ 0
6 at uw U IJ
t ll 10.37 14.24 't6.6 111
lo I 0.33 t0.o
I t6 u4 0
to 1 0 t5 0.18 i )t
tMt Potul c
I 12U -0 to -0.80 0.90
o17 o.12 0.'t 5 i
1.971 I o !1 I I .U ]U
ll u11 ol 179 1.05 1.0 2.69 om
4.71 11 n tt !i I ?o om
6 4 a o 10 I ,U IU .u
7 a IU U ]U 162 1.04 1.0 3.69 oa -o
458 4.€o
a la ll IU 'u.s4580.11 n il n ll om
crllbntloh comdad orta
Run a R!n
orta $.d nm End
nna
NOx
ppmvd
NOr ppmvd
e rs% 02 02 ?{ (dryl CO ppnvd CO ppmvd
(,15%02 t{Ox
lbrmmBtu
tL.t lnput,
MMBturhr
NOr lbrhr co tbrhr
6:40 7 2 103
7.OA IJ U UU5
l.o 16.6
13
l6 I,U I,J 2
lq o 1
7 lb IU uw9 U-ET
a 1U:g t.E 16.3tnta
10 !1 1 1',23 l.u I,J 2.255 0.76
v5.0
175 of 199
T
IClient: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Test Location: Unit6?
I vwer I rqrr(
IDate:8129124
Project #: M243506
Linearity Cal/Pre 1 Cal
Time
5:45
5:46
5:47
5:48
5:49
5:50
5:51
5:52
5:53
5:54
5:55
5:56
5:57
5:58
5:59
6:00
6:01
6:04
6:05
6:06
6:07
6:08
6:09
NOx oomvd
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
3.15
9.22
8.95
6.38
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.98
3.73
5.15
-0.01
-0.01
0.00
-0.01
1.54
5.20
02% Grvl
0.07
17.74
22.64
22.59
6.21
-0.01
-0.02
0.04
0.01
-0.05
0.03
8.90
10.58
10.58
2.89
0.17
0.16
-0.03
9.79
10.41
10.42
1.90
-0.05
CO ppmvd
9.97
7.75
0.71
0.02
0.03
0.10
0.17
0.44
3.19
4.05
4.95
3.79
0.34
0.09
0.09
0.18
0.24
4.92
3.10
0.21
0.08
0.10
0.21
lm
I
T
T
T
I
T
T
I
I
I
T
I
I
T
T
T
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
v5.0
176 of 199
RATA Extraclive 4116120
@Mostardi Platt
m
2
T
T
T
t
T
T
T
I
t
!
I
I
T
I
T
I
I
T
T
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Test Location: Unit 6
Date: 8129124
Time NOx ppmvd
7:02 -0.017:03 -0.017.04 -0.017:05 2.977:06 5.08
Post l/Pre 2
O2olo (drvl
z 0.12
10.39
10.38
0. 17m O.12
Post 3/Pre 4
02% |dwlz 0.10
9.86
10.42
10.42
0.80m 0.11
Time NOx oomvd7:30 -0.017:31 -0.017:32 -0.017:33 -0.0'l7:34 1.867:35 5.08
Time NOx oomvd8:29 -0.018:30 -0.018:31 -0.018:32 -0.018:33 1.988:34 5.03
Post ZPre 3
02olo (drvlz 0.24
9.73
10.42
'10.43
0.76m 0.10
Post 4/Pre 5
O2o/o {drulz 0.13
10.08
1 0.52
10.52
0.79m 0.12
Time
8:00
8:01
6:02
6:03
8:04
8:05
NOx oomvd
-0.01
-0.01
-0.01
-0.01
1.93
5.05
CO pomvd
4.83
2.58
o.17
0.1 5
0.24
CO oomvd
4.89
3.29
0.27
0.1 1
0.14
0.22
CO oomvd
4.71
3.29
0.26
0.12
0.12
o.24
CO ppmvd
4.68
3. 15
o.22
0.1 1
0. 15
o.22
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
v5.0
177 ot 199
RATA Extractive 4/1 6/20
@Mostardi Platt
I
TClient: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
ITost Location: Unit 6
Date: 8129124
Post S/Pre 6
NOx opmvd O2olo (drvl-0.01 z 0.10-0.0'l 8.33-0.01 10.41-0.01 10.412.20 0.715.05 m 0.08
Post 7/Pre I
NOx oomvd O2o/o (dryl0.00 z O.O7-0.01 9.71-0.01 10.33-0.01 10.332.38 0.715.05 m -0.02
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
I
T
T
I
T
T
T
T
I
T
T
I
T
T
T
t
Time
8:58
8:59
9:00
9:01
9:02
9:03
Time
9:57
9:58
9:59
1 0:00
10:01
10:02
CO oomvd
4.71
3.83
0.35
0.1 1
0.1 0
0.22
CO ppmvd
4.58
321
026
0.09
0. 13
0.22
Time NOx pomvd9:27 -0.019.28 0.009:29 -0.019:30 -0.019:31 2.299.32 5.04
Time NOx pomvd10:27 -0.0110:28 -0.0110:29 0.0010:30 -0.0110:31 2.5810:32 5.08
Post 6/Pre 7
O2o/o (dsylz 0.13
9.87
10.42
10.41
0.8'lm 0.09
Post 8/Pre 9
02 % (drv)z 0.09
3.99
10.45
10.47
0.55m 0.28
CO oomvd
4.65
3.14
0.23
0. 10
0.1 1
o.22
CO oomvd
4.68
4.80
1.22
0.14
0. 13
0. 19
v5.0
178 of 199
RATA Extractive 4/16/20
@Mostardi Platt
T
I
T
I
I
I
t
T
I
T
I
T
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Project#: M243506
Tost Location: Unit 6
Da|c:8129124
Post g/Pre 10Time NOr oomvd O2o/o (dryl
10:56 -0.01 z 0.1910:57 0.00 9.5210:58 0.00 10.4610:59 -0.01 10.45I'l:00 2.78 0.63
1 'l:01 5.02 m -0.32
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
CO opmvd
4.55
3.12
0.24
0.1 1
o.12
0.18
Time NOx pomvd
11:25 -0.0111:26 -0.0111:27 -0.0111:28 0.0311:29 2.86
1 1:30 5.09
Po3t 10
02 % (drvlz 0.16
9.77
10.48
10.47
0.76m -0.29
CO oomvd
4.58
3.t1
o.23
0.1 I
0.13
0.20
RATA Extractive 4/1 6/20
@Mostardi Platt
T
I
t
T
T
t
v5.0
179 of '199
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Appendix I - Calibration Gas Cylinder Data
180 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
t
T
I
I
I
I
t
T
T
I
I
T
Airgas
an Air Liquide company
Airgas Specialty Gases
Airgas USA LLC
12722 S. Wentworth Ave.
Chicago, IL 6o628
Airgas.com
Part Number:
Cylinder Number:
Laboratory:
PGVP Number:
Gas Code:
54402672299-1
144.0 CF
2015 PS|G
660
Mar 03, 2023
I
Certification performed in accordance with 'EPA Traceability Prolocol for Assay and Certitication of Gaseous Calibration Standards (May 20121" document EPA
600/R-12/531, using the assay procedures listed. Analytical Methodology does not require correction for analytical interference. This cylinder has a total analytical
uncertainty as stated below with a conlidence level of 95%. There are no significant impurities which affect the use of this calibration mixture. All concentrations are on a
mole/mole basis unless otherwise noled. The results relate only to the items tested. The report shall not be reproduced except in full without approval of the laboratory. Do
This Cylinder
Triad Data Available Upon Reguest
Sionalure on file
I
I
t
T
I
I Project No. tvtlPscved for Release
Unit 'l , Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
CERTIFICATE OF ANALYSIS
Grade of Product: EPA PROTOCOL STANDARI)
E02Nt99E15A0088
cc262396
124 - Chicago (SAP) - lL
812023
NO,NOX,BALN
Expiration Date:
Reference Number:
Cylinder Volume:
Cylinder Pressure:
Valve Outlet:
Certification Date:
Mar 03, 2026
Nol USe lnlS Uyllnoer Delow lUU pslg, l.e. U.// megapascalls.
ANALYTICAL RESULTS
Component Requested
Concentration
Actual
Concentration
Protoco! Total RelativeMethod Uncertainty
Assay
Dates
NOX
NITRIC OXIDE
NITROGEN
5.000 PPM
s.000 PPM
Balance
5.010 PPM
5.004 PPM
G1
G1
+l- 1.0o/o NIST Traceable
+l- 1.1o/o NIST Traceable
021 24 I 2023, 03 t 03t 2023
02t 24t 2023, 03 t 03t 2023
CALIBRATION STANDARDS
Type Lot lD Cylinder No Goncentration Uncertainty Expiration Date
GM|S 080121328 KA1004296
APEX 1324267
5.07 PPM NITRIC OXIDSNITROGEN
5.OO PPM NITRIC OXIDE/NITROGEN
+l- 0.9o/o
+l- 0.9o/o
+l- 0.9o/o
P\pt 27,2024
Dec23,2022
Apr 27,2024
PRM 12401
GM|S 08012138 KA1004296 NOX 5.07 PPM NOX/NITROGEN
The SRM. NTRM. PRM. or RGM noted above is only in reference to the GMIS used in the assay and not part of the analysis
lnstrumenUMake/Mode!
ANALYTICAL EQUIPMENT
Analytical Principle Last Multipoint Calibration
EC-1 Eco Physics nCLD 8445 844n0131 NO
EC-l Eco Phvsics nCLD 8445 844n0131 NOX
Chemilluminescence
Chemilluminescence
Feb 09, 2023
Feb 09. 2023
181 of '199 @Mostardi Phlge ,t of I
Airgas
an Air Liquide company
Airgas Specialty Gases
Airgas USA LLC
525 North Industrial Loop Road
Tooele, UT 84o74
Airgas.com
I
I
t
T
I
I
I
T
I
T
T
t
T
T
t
I
I
T
t
CERTIFICATE OF AI\IALYSIS
Grade of Product: EPA PROTOCOL STAIYDARI)
Part Number: E02N199E15A0131
Cylinder Number: CC725287Laboratory: 124 -Tooele (SAP) - UT
PGVP Number: 872023
Gas Code: NO,NOX,BALN
Reference Number: 153402735087-1
Cylinder Volume: 144.0 CF
Cylinder Pressure: 2015 PSIG
Valve Outlet: 660
Certification Date: May 15,2023
Expiration Date: Mav 15.2026
Certification performed in accordance with 'EPA Traceability Proiocol for Assay and Certiflcation of Gaseous Calibration Standards (May 20121' document EPA
600/R-12/531, using the assay procedures listed. Analytical Methodology does not require correclion for analytical interference. This cylinder has a total analytical
uncerlainty as slated below with a conlidence level of 95%. There are no significant impurities which affecl lhe use of this calibration mixlure. All concenlrations are on a
mole/mole basis unlass othenvise noted. The results relate only to the items tested. The report shall not be reproduced except in full without approval of the laboratory. Do
Triad Data Available Upon Request
Sionature on file
Project No. tvt&pfooved for Release
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Not use Ihts below 100 osto. t.e
ANALYTICAL RESULTS
Component Requested
Concentration
Actual
Concentration
Protocol Tota! RelativeMethod Uncertainty
Assay
Dates
NOX
NITRIC OXIDE
NITROGEN
9.000 PPM
9.000 PPM
Balance
9.077 PPM
9.017 PPM
G1
G1
+l- 1.Oo/o NIST Traceable
+l- 1.1o/o NIST Traceable
0 5 t 08 I 2023. 0 5 I 1 5 t 2023
0 5 I 08 t 2023. 0 5 t I 5 t 2023
CALIBRATION STANDARDS
Type Lot lD Cylinder No Concentration Uncertainty Expiration Date
NTRM
NTRM
160't0122
16010122
ND48023
ND48023-NOX
9.95 PPM NITRIC OXIDE/NITROGEN
9.95 PPM NOx/NITROGEN
1.0o/o
1.0o/o
Jun 07, 2026
Jun 07, 2026
lnstrumenUMake/Model
ANALYTICAL EQUIPMENT
Analytical Principle Last Multipoint Calibration
Thermo 42i-LS 1123749327 NO
Thermo 42i-LS 1123749327 NOx
Chemiluminescence (Mason)
Chemiluminescence (Mason)
May 03, 2023
May 03, 2023
182 of 199 @Mostardi Phlge 1 of I
I
T
I
Airgas
Airgas Specialty Gases
Airgas USA LLC
525 North Industrial toop Road
Tooele, UT 84o74
Airgas.com
an Air Liquido company
CERTIFICATE OF ANALYSIS
Grade of Product: EPA PROTOCOL STANDARI)I Part Number:
Cylinder Number:
Laboratory:
PGVP Number:
Gas Code:
E02Nt99E15A3576
EB0142043
124 -Tooele (SAP) - UT
872024
NO,NOX,BALN
Reference Number:
Cylinder Volume:
Cylinder Pressure:
Valve Outlet:
Certification Date:
1 53-40301 5445-1
144.0 CF
2015 PS|G
660
Apr 23,2024t
I
I
T
I
Expiration Date: Apr 23,2032
Certification performed in accordance with 'EPA Traceability Protocol for Assay and Certification of Gaseous Calibration Standards (May 2012)' documenl EPA
600/R-1 2/531 , using the assay procedures listed. Analytical Methodology does not require correction for analytical interference. This cylinder has a total analytical
uncertainty as stated below with a conlidence level of 95%. There are no significant impurities which affect the use of this calibration mixture. All concentrations are on a
mole/mole basis unless otheMise noted. The results relate only to the items tested. The report shall not be reproduced except in full without approval of the laboratory. Do
Not Use This Cylinder below 100 psig, i.e. 0.7
T
t
T
Triad Data Available Upon RequestI
T
I
T
I
T
I
Sianafrrre on file
Project No. MABFOved for Release
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
ANALYTICAL RESULTS
Actual Protoco! Total Relative
NOX
NITRIC OXIDE
NITROGEN
90.00 PPM
90.00 PPM
Balance
90.32 PPM
90.32 PPM
G1
G1
+l- 0.5o/o NIST Traceable
+l- 0,5o/o NIST Traceable
04t 1 6t2024, 04t23t2024
04t 1 6t2024, 04t23t2024
CALIBRATI ON STAIYDARDS
No Concentration
0.4o/o
0.3%
1.60/0
1.5%
Apr 25, 2031
Feb 28,2025
Feb 17,2026
Feb '17,2023
GM|S 2023c/'25I
PRM 12414
GM|S 1s31022022103PRM 12409
98.40 PPM NITRIC OXIDE/NITROGEN
100.19 PPM NITRIC OXIDE/NITROGEN
4.914 PPM NITROGEN DIOXIDE/NITROGEN
15.01 PPM NITROGEN DIOXIDE/AIR
cc754372
APE1514048
cc51 7868
D91 3660
The SRM, NTRM, PRM, or RGM noted above is only in reference to the GMIS used in the assay and not parl of lhe
ANALYTICAL EQUIPMENT
lnstrumenUMake/Model Analytical Principle Last Multipoint Calibration
Nicolet iS50 AUP2010228 NO LNO Apr 10,2024
Apr 10,2024Nicolet iS50 AUP2010228 NO2 i
FTIR
FTIR NO2
183 of 199 @Mostardi PFlge 1 of f
CERTIFICATE OF ANIALYSIS
Grade of Product: EPA PROTOCOL STANDARI)
E02Nt99E15A0076
cc257347
124 - Tooele (SAP)- UT
872021
NO,NOX,BALN
Airgas
an Air Liquide company
Airgas Specialty Gases
Airgas USA LLC
525 North Industrial t oop Road
Tooele, UT 84o74
Airgas.com
I
T
I
T
I
I
T
T
T
I
T
I
t
I
I
T
T
T
I
Part Number:
Cylinder Number:
Laboratory:
PGVP Number:
Gas Code:
Reference Number:
Cylinder Volume:
Cylinder Pressure:
Valve Outlet:
Certification Date:
153402189195-1
144.4 CF
2015 PS|G
660
Aug 23,2021
Expiration Date: Auq 23.2029
Certification performed in accordance wiih "EPA Traceability Protocol for Assay and Certification of Gaseous Calibration Standards (May 20121" document EPA
600/R-1 2/531 , using the assay procedures listed. Analytical Methodology does nol require correction for analytical interference. This cylinder has a total analytical
uncertainty as stated below with a conlidence level of 95%. There are no significant impurities which affect the use of this calibration mixlure. All concentrations are on a
Triad Data Available Upon Request
Sionature on file
Project No. ruApFoved for Release
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
mole/mole basis unless otherwise noted
ANALYTICAL RESULTS
Actual Protocol Total Relative
Concentration Method Uncertainty
Assay
Dates
Component Requested
Concentration
NOX
NITRIC OXIDE
NITROGEN
180.0 PPM
180.0 PPM
Balance
183.3 PPM
183.2 PPM
G1
G1
+l- 0.9o/o NIST Traceable
+l- 0.9o/o NIST Traceable
08t 1 6t2021, 08t23t 2021
08t 1 6t2021. 08t23t2021
CALIBRATION STANDARDS
Type Lot lD Cylinder No Concentration Uncertainty Expiration Date
0.8olo
2.0o/o
2.1o/o
Oct 19,2026
Feb 20,2020
Feb 01, 2023
NTRM 20060332PRM 12386GMIS 401648675'102
EBO1 13126 250.3 PPM NITRIC OXIDE/NITROGEN
D685025 9.91 PPM NITROGEN DIOXIDE/AIR
CC5OO959 5.074 PPM NITROGEN DIOXIDE/NITROGEN
The SRM, PRM or RGM noted above is only in reference to the GMIS used in the assay and not part of the analysis.
ANALYTICAL EQUIPMENT
lnstrumenUMake/Model Analytical Principle Last Multipoint Calibration
Jul29,2021
Jul 29, 2021
Nicolet iS50 AUP2'l'10269 NO MNO
Nicolet iS50 AUP2110269 NO2 impuritv
FTIR
FTIR NO2 impuritv
184 of "199 OMostardi Phlge 1 of 1
I
t
I
I
t
!
t
T
I
t
T
I
I
T
I
I
t
Airgas
an Air Liquido company
Part Number:
Cylinder Number:
Laboratory:
PGVP Number:
Gas Code:
Airgas Specialty Gases
Airgas USA LLC
52S North Industrial Loop Road
Tooele, UT 84o74
Airgas.com
Reference Number:
Cylinder Volume:
Cylinder Pressure:
Valve Outlet:
Certification Date:
1s3402949569-1
87.0 CF
2214PSIG
590
Jan 29,2024
Expiration Date: Jan 29,2032
Certification performed in acc,ordance with 'EPA Traceability Protocol for Assay and Certification of Gaseous Calibration Standards (May 2012)'document EPA
600/R-12/531, using the assay procedures listed. Analytical Methodology does nol require correclion for analytical interferenc,e. This cylinder has a total analytical
uncerlainty as stated below with a confidence level of 95%. There are no significanl impurities which affect the use of this calibralion mixture. All concentrations are on a
mole/mole basis unless otheMise noted. The resulls relate only to the ilems tested. The report shall not be reproduced except in full without approval of the laboratory. Do
Not Use This Cylinder below 100 psig, i.e. 0.7
Triad Data Available Upon Request
Sionaiure on fileT
I Project No. naApfuoved for Release
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
CERTIFICATE OF ANALYSIS
Grade of Product: EPA PROTOCOL STANDARD
E03Nt80E8047767
115961 0
124 - Tooele (SAP) - UT
872024
c02,02,BALN
ANALYTICAL RESULTS
Component Requested Actual Protocol Total Relative
CARBON DIOXIDE
OXYGEN
NITROGEN
+l- 0.7o/o NIST Traceable
+l- 0.5o/o NIST Traceable
'10.00 %
10.00 %
Balance
9.912 o/o
9.891 o/o
G1
G1
01t29t2024
01t29t2024
CALIBRATION STANDARDS
Lot lD Cylinder No Concentration
1306041 1
I 1 060604
7.489 O/O CARBON DIOXIDE/NITROGEN
1 4.93 O/O OXYGEN/N ITROGEN
0.6olo
0.20/o
NTRM
NTRM
cc41 3s37
cc338173
May'14,2025
Nov 02, 2028
ANALYTICAL EQUIPMENT
Analytical Principle
Horiba VIA-S10 SV4MEUTJ CO2
Horiba MPA-5'10 W603MM58 02
Jan 10,2024
Jan '10,2024
185 of '199 @Mostardi PFlge 1 of t
Aitgas
an Air Liquide company
Airgas Specialty Gases
Airgas USA LLC
S2S North Industrial Loop Road
Tooele, UT 84o74
Airgas.com
I
I
I
T
I
I
I
T
T
T
I
T
T
I
t
T
T
T
T
CERTIFICATE OF AIVALYSIS
Grade of Product: EPA PROTOCOL STANDARD
Part Number: E03N159E15A3452
Cylinder Number: E80088900Laboratory: 124 -Tooele (SAP) - UT
PGVP Number: 872024
Gas Code: CO2,O2,BALN
Expiration Date:
Reference Number: 153-403021556-1
Cylinder Volume: 159.0 CF
Cylinder Pressure: 2015 PSIG
Valve Outlet: 590
Certification Date: Apr 22,2024
Aor 22.2032
Certirication performed in accordance with "EPA Traceability Protocol for Assay and Certification of Gaseous Calibration Standards (May 20 12)' document EPA
600/R-'l 2/531 , using the assay procedures listed. Analylical Methodology does not require correction for analytical interference. This cylinder has a total analytical
uncertainty as stated below with a confidence level of 95%. There are no significant impurities which affect the use of this calibration mixture. All concenlrations are on a
mole/mole basis unless otheMise noted. The resulls relate only to the items tested. The report shall not be reproduced except in full without approval of the laboratory. Do
Not Use This Cylinder
Triad Data Available Upon Request
Sianalrrra an file
Project No. MABF@ved for Release
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
ANALYTICAL RESULTS
Component Requested
Concentration
Actua!
Concentration
Protocol Total RelativeMethod Uncertainty
Assay
Dates
CARBON DIOXIDE
OXYGEN
NITROGEN
19.00 %
22.0Q o/o
Balance
18.45 o/o
22.57 o/o
G1
G1
+l- 1.0o/o NIST Traceable
+l- 0.5o/o NIST Traceable
04t22t2024
04t22t2024
CALIBRATION STANDARDS
Type Lot lD Cylinder No Concentration Uncertainty Expiration Date
NTRM
NTRM
1 3060802
09061434
cc41 5397
cc282492
24.04 O/O CARBON DIOXIDE/NITROGEN
22.53 o/o OXYGEN/NITROGEN
0.6olo
o.404
Dec 1 1, 2025
Mav 13,2025
lnstrumenUMake/Model
ANALYTICAL EQUIPMENT
Analytical Principle Last Multipoint Calibration
Horiba VIA-S10 SV4MEUTJ CO2
Horiba MPA-510 W603MM58 02
CO2 NDIR (Dixon)
02 Paramagnetic (OIXON)
Apr 03,2024
Apt 03,2024
186 of 199 OMostardi Phtge 1 of t
I
T
I
I
t
I
I
t
t
T
t
t
I
I
I
t
Airgas
an Air Liquide company
Airgas Specialty Gases
Airgas USA LLC
525 North Industrial loop Road
Tooele, UT 84o74
Airgas.com
Part Number:
Cylinder Number:
Laboratory:
PGVP Number:
Gas Code:
Reference Number:
Cylinder Volume:
Cylinder Pressure:
Valve Outlet:
Certification Date:
153403015455-1
150.0 cF
201s PS|G
590
Apr 09,2024
I
T
I
Expiration Date: Apr 09, 2032
Certification performed in accordance with "EPA Traceabilily Protocol for Assay and Certification of Gaseous Calibration Standards (May 2012)'docum6nt EPA
600/R-1 2/531 , using the assay procedures listed. Analytical Methodology does not require correclion for analytical interference. This cylinder has a total analytical
uncertainty as stated below with a confidence level of 957o. There are no significant impurities which affect the use of this calibration mixture. All concentrations are on a
mole/mole basis unless otherwise noted. The results relate only to the rtems tesled. The report shall not be reproduced excepl in full without approval of the laboratory. Do
Triad Data Available Upon Request
Sionature on file
Project No. u*Bpoved for Release
Unit 1. Unit 2. Unit 3. Unit 4. Unit 5. and Unit 6
CERTIFICATE OF ANALYSIS
Grade of Product: EPA PROTOCOL STANDARI)
E03Nt80E15A0015
EB0140992
124 - Tooele (SAP) - UT
872024
co2,02,BALN
Not Use This Cylrnder below 100 r.e. 0.
Component Requested
Concentration
ANALYTICAL RESULTS
Actual ProtocolConcentration Method
Total Relative
Uncertainty
Assay
Dates
CARBON DIOXIDE
OXYGEN
NITROGEN
9.000 o/o
10.50 %
Balance
8.904 o/o
10.51 o/o
G1
G1
+l- 0.7o/o NIST Traceable
+l- 0.4o/o NIST Traceable
04t0912024
04t09t2024
CALIBRATION STANDARDS
Type Lot lD Gylinder No Concentration Uncertainty Expiration Date
NTRM 130604'l 1
'I 1060604
cc41 3537
cc3381 73
7.489 O/O CARBON DIOXIDE/NITROGEN
1 4.93 O/O OXYGEN/N ITROGEN
0.6olo
0.2o/o
May 14,2025
Nov 02. 2028NTRM
lnstrumenUMake/Model
ANALYIICAL EQUIPMENT
Analytica! Principle Last Multipoint Calibration
Horiba VIA-S10 SV4MEUTJ CO2
Horiba MPA-510 W603MM58 02
CO2 NDIR (Dixon)
02 Paramaqnetic (DIXON)
Apr 03,2024
Aot 03.2024
187 of 199 OMostardi Ph8ge { of I
CERTIFICATE OF AI\IALYSIS
Grade of Product: EPA PROTOCOL STANDARI)
E02Nt99E15A3166
E80091 188
124 - Tooele (SAP) - UT
872021
CO,BALN
Aitgas
an Air Liquide company
Part Number:
Cylinder Number:
Laboratory:
PGVP Number:
Gas Code:
Airgas Specialty Gases
Airgas USA LLC
525 North Industrial toop Road
Tooele, UT 84074
Airgas.com
t
I
T
T
t
I
I
T
T
T
I
t
T
I
t
T
T
T
I
Reference Number:
Cylinder Volume:
Cylinder Pressure:
Valve Outlet:
Certification Date:
153402022557-1
144.3 CF
2015 PS|G
350
Feb 05,2021
Expiration Date: Feb 05. 2029
Certification performed in accordance with 'EPA Traceability Protocol for Assay and Cerlificalion of Gaseous Calibration Standards (May 2012)' document EPA
600/R-1 2/531 , using the assay procedures listed. Analytical Methodology does not require correclion for analytical interference. This cylinder has a total analytical
uncertainty as stated below with a confidence level of 950/o. There are no signiflcant impurities which affect the use of this calibration mixture. All concentralions are on a
mole/mole basis unless othenrvise noted. The resulis relate only to the items tested. The report shall not be reproduced except in full without approval of the laboratory. Do
Triad Data Available Upon Request
Sionature on file
Proiect No. lvtApsoved for Release
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Not Use I hrs Cylrnder below '100 t.e
Component
ANALYTICAL RESULTS
Actual
Concentration
Protocol Total RelativeMethod Uncertainty
Requested
Concentration
Assay
Dates
CARBON MONOXIDE 5.000 PPM 4.898 PPM G1 +l- 0.8o/o NIST Traceable 0210512021
NITROGEN Balance
CALIBRATION STANDARDS
Type Lot lD Cylinder No Concentration Uncertainty Expiration Date
NTRM 0801 1 130 KA1004049 9.855 PPM CARBON MONOXIDE/NITROGEN 0.5o/o Jun 05, 2024
lnstrumenUMake/Model Last Multipoint Calibration
ANALYTICAL EQUIPMENT
Analytical Principle
Thermo 48|-TLE 1'163640031 CO Feb 0'1. 2021CO NDIR (Mason)
188 of 199 OMostardi PFlge 1 of 1
t
I
T
I
t
t
I
T
I
T
I
I
I
I
t
I
T
T
I
Airgas
an Air Liquide company
Airgas Specialty Gases
Airgas USA LLC
525 North Industrial toop Road
Tooele, UT 84o74
Airgas.com
Part Number:
Cylinder Number:
Laboratory:
PGVP Number:
Gas Code:
153402826198-1
144.0 CF
2015 PS|G
350
Aug 28,2023
Certification performed in accordance with "EPA Traceability Protocol for Assay and Cerlilication of Gaseous Calibration Standards (May 2012)" document EPA
600/R-1 2/531 , using the assay procedures listed. Analytical Methodology does not require correclion for analytical interference. This cylinder has a total analytical
uncertainiy as staled below with a confidence level of 95%. There are no significant impurilies which affec't the use of lhis calibration mixture. All concentrations are on a
mole/mole basis unless otheMise noted. The results relate only to the ilems tested. The report shall not be reproduced except in full without approval of the laboratory. Do
Nol Use This below 100 osio. i.e. 0.7
Triad Data Available Upon Request
Sianahrra on fila
Project No. tuAppcved for Release
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
CERTIFICATE OF AIYALYSIS
Grade of Product: EPA PROTOCOL STANDARI)
E02Nt99E15A3166
cc116370
124 - Tooele (SAP) - UT
872023
CO,BALN
Expiration Date:
Reference Number:
Cylinder Volume:
Cylinder Pressure:
Valve Outlet:
Certification Date:
Auq 28.2031
Protocol Total RelativeMethod Uncertainty
CARBON MONOXIDE 5.000 PPM 4.974 PPM G1 +l- 1.2o/o NIST Traceable 0812812023
NITROGEN Balance
CALIBRATION STANDARDS
No Concentration
NTRM 12062802 CC365313 9.82 PPM CARBON MONOXIDE/NITROGEN 1.0o/o Feb 12,2024
ANALYTICAL EQUIPMENT
Thermo 48I-TLE 1'163640031 CO CO NDIR (Mason) Aus 23,2023
189 of 199 @Mostardi PFlge I of t
Airgas
an Air Liquide company
Airgas Specialty Gases
Airgas USA LLC
525 North Industrial Loop Road
Tooele, UT 84o74
Airgas.com
CERTIFICATE OF AI\IALYSIS
Grade of Product: EPA PROTOCOL STANDARI)
I
T
I
T
T
T
I
T
I
T
T
T
I
I
I
I
t
T
I
Part Number: E02N199E15A0310
Cylinder Number: E80007336Laboratory: 124 -Tooele (SAP) - UT
PGVP Number: 872023
Gas Code: CO,BALN
Expiration Date:
Reference Number: 153402856708-1
Cylinder Volume: 144.0 CF
Cylinder Pressure: 2015 PSIG
Valve Outlet: 350
CertificationDate: Oct02,2023
Oct 02, 2031
Certification performed in accordance with "EPA Traceability Protocol for Assay and Certification of Gaseous Calibration Standards (May 2012)" document EPA
600/R-12/531. using the assay procedures listed. Analytical Methodology does not require correction for analytical interference. This cylinder has a lotal analytical
uncerlainty as stated below with a conlidence level of 95%. There are no significant impurities which affect the use of this calibration mixture. All concentralions are on a
mole/mole basis unless otheMise noted. The resulis relate only to the items tested. The report shall not be reproduced except in full without approval of the laboratory. Do
Not Use This Cylinder below
Triad Data Available Upon Request
Sianafurra on fila
Project No. tvtApsoved for Release
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
ANALYTICAL RESULTS
Component Requested
Concentration
Actual
Concentration
Protocol Total RelativeMethod Uncertainty
Assay
Dates
CARBON MONOXIDE 10.00 PPM 10.02 PPM Gl +l- 1.1o/o NIST Traceable '1010212023
NITROGEN Balance
CALIBRATION STANDARDS
Type Lot lD Cylinder No Concentration Uncertainty Expiration Date
NTRM 12062802 CC365313 9.82 PPM CARBON MONOXIDE/NITROGEN 1.0o/o Feb'12,2024
lnstrumenUMake/Model
ANALYTICAL EQUIPMENT
Analytical Principle Last Multipoint Calibration
Thermo 48|-TLE 1 16364003'l CO CO NDIR (Mason)Sep 21, 2023
'190 of 199 @Mostardi PFlge 1 of 1
I
I
t
I
I
I
I
T
t
t
t
t
I
I
I
I
I
T
I
Airgas
an Air Liquide company
Airgas Specialty Gases
Airgas USA LLC
S2S North Industrial loop Road
Tooele, UT 84o74
Airgas.com
Part Number:
Cylinder Number:
Laboratory:
PGVP Number:
Gas Code:
Reference Number:
Cylinder Volume:
Cylinder Pressure:
Valve Outlet:
Certification Date:
153403086239-1
146.0 CF
2015 PSIG
660
Jul 16,2024
Expiration Date: Jul 16,2027
Certification performed in accordance with "EPA Traceability Protocol for Assay and Certification of Gaseous Calibration Standards (May 2012\" document EPA
600/R-1 2/531 , using the assay procedures listed. Analytical Methodology does not require correction for analytical interference. This cylinder has a total analylical
uncerlainty as stated below with a confidence level of 95%. There are no significant impurities which affect the use of this calibration mixture. All concentrations are on a
mole/mole basis unless olherwise noted. The results relate only to the items tested. The report shall nol be reproduced except in full withoul approval of the laboralory. Do
Triad Data Available Upon Request
Sionature on file
Project No. u&Foved for Release
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
CERTIFICATE OF ANALYSIS
Grade of Product: EPA PROTOCOL STAI\DARD
E02A199E15W0021
cc509499
124 - Tooele (SAP) - UT
872024
NO2,BALA
Not Use This Cylinder below 100 psig, i.e. 0.7 megapascals.
Component Requested
Concentration
ANALYTICAL RESIILTS
Actual Protocol Total RelativeConcentration Method Uncertainty
Assay
Dates
NITROGEN DIOXIDE 50.00 PPM 50.29 PPM G1 +l- 2.0o/o NIST Traceable 0710912024,0711612024
AIR Balance
CALIBRATION STANDARDS
Type Lot !D Cylinder No Concentration Uncertainty Expiration Date
GMIS 1534022022406 CC517972 30.86 PPM NITROGEN DIOXIDUNITROGEN
PRM 12409 D913660 15.01 PPM NITROGEN DIOXIDE/AIR
The SRM, NTRM, PRM, or RGM noted above is only in reference to the GMIS used in the assay and not part of the analysis.
1.60/o
1.50/o
Feb 17,2026
Feb 17,2023
ANALYTICAL EQUIPMENT
Analytical Principle Last Multipoint CalibrationlnstrumenUMake/Model
Jul 12,2024MKS FT|R NO2 018143349 FTIR
191 of '199 OMostardi Phlge 1 of I
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Appendix J - NOz to NO Converter Efficiency Test
192 of 199 @Mostardi Platt
t
t
NO2 to NO Converter Test
t Client: PacifCorp Conv. Temp: 323 oC
I Facility: Gadsby Power Plant Test Type NO2 Direct
I Test Location: Unit 1 Max: 50.4 ppm
Date:812612024 Conversion: 100.24 %Requiremsnt: 90.00 %
I ;-""- rest Post-caribration
i Time NO, Cal Flaq Time NO, Time !9, Cal FlaoI il? 13?31 ' 13,?3 !3i l:.l; 33 z
7:48 0.58 13:1 1 50.3 13:19 80.4
I iii\ *:,i . lll3 i31 Max 3:20 so1 m
PRE.CALRESULT POST-CALRESULT
t zero 0.10%mid -O.O4o/o
high 0.160/o
zero O.14"/omid -A.12o/o
I
I
T
I
T
T
T
t
I
I
t v5.0
193 of 199
RATA Extractive 4/16/20
@Mostardi Platt
T
Mostardi Platt
Poect No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
TYpe RM Analvzer s/n Analvzer SDan RM Gas Soan
NOx oomvd Thermo 42C 427404465 200 I E3.3
Type Setting Cylinder lD Cylinder Value Analyzer Response Difference, % of Spar EXPrrauon
Date
NOx ppmvd
Zeto LL596't O 0 0. 19 -0.10%1t29t2032
Mid EBO142043 90 32 90.25 O.O4o/o 4t23t2032
Hioh cc257347 1 83.3 '183.60 -O 16o/d 4t23t2029
NO2 ppmvd CEG cc509499 50 29 7t16t2027
Tvoe RM Analvzer Make/Model FIM Analvzer s/n Analvzer Soan RM Gas Soan
NOx DDmvd Thermo 42C 42CHL61 16S330 200 1 83.3
Type Setting Cylinder lD Cylinder Value Analyzer Responee Difference, % of Spar EXprrauon
Date
NOx ppmvd
Zero 115961 0 0 o.29 -0. 160/.1t29t2032
Mid E8O142043 90 32 90.30 O O1o/a 4t2312032
Hioh cc257347 1 83.3 183 08 O.12o/o 8t23t2029
NO2 ppmvd CEG cc509499 50.29 711612027
NO2 to NO Converter Test
T
I
I
I
I
t
I
T
I
t
I
I
I
T
t
T
t
T
T
Max
Max
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Test Location: Unit 2
Oalet 812612024
Project#: M243506
Pre-Calibration
Conv. Temp: 327 oC
Test Typ€ NO2 DirectMax: 50.4 ppm
Conversion: 100.12 o/o
Requirement: 90.00 %
Post-Galibration
Time
7:46
Time
13:09
13:10
13:1 1
13 12
'13:13
NO.
50.3
50.3
50.3
50.4
50.4
Time
13:17
13:18
'l 3: 19
13.20
No- Cal Flao
183.08 h
NO- Cal Flaq
0.1 z
13.5
87.590.1 m
7:47 150.697:48 7.847:49 0.29 z7:50 3.077:51 76.1 5
7:52 90.30 m
PRE-CAL RESULT
ze?o 0.16%mid -0.01%
high -0j2%
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unil 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
POST.CAL RESULT
zeto 0.05%mid -0.15o/o
v5.0
194 of 199
RATA Extractive 4/16/20
@Mostardi Platt
T
t
I
I
t
I
t
I
I
T
T
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Test Location: Unit 3
Oatei 812712024
Project #: M243506
Pre-Calibration
Time NO, Cal Flaq
5:47 183.46 h
5:48 179.62
5:49 33.35
5:50 0.45 z
5:51 3.975.52 63.725:53 86.775:54 91.70 m
PRE.CAL RESULT
NO2 to NO Converter Test
Tsst
Time IO.
1 1:10 50.311:11 50.311:12 50.3
'l 1:'13 50.4 Max11:14 50.4 Max
v5.0
195 of 199
Conv. Temp: 325 oC
TestType NO2 Direct
Max: 50.4 ppm
Conversion: 100.12 o/o
Requirement: 90.00 %
Post-Calibration
Time Nq Cal Flaq
11.20 0.1 z11:21 14.811:22 87.5
11:23 88.6 m
POST.CAL RESULT
zeto 0.05%
mid -0.94o/o
zero O.25o/omid O.75o/ohigh 0.09%
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit '1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
RATA Extractive 4/16/20
@Mostardi Platt
Tvoe RM Analyzer Make/Model RM Analvzer s/n Analvzer Soan RM Gas Soan
NOx oomvd Thermo 42C 42CHL61 169330 200 183 3
Type Setting Cylinder lD Cylinder Value Analyzer Response Difterence, % of Span EXprrauon
Date
NOx ppmvd
Zero EB0 140992 0 0.45 -o.250h 4t9t2032
Mid E80142043 90.32 91.70 -o.750/a 4t23t2032
Hioh cc257347 183.3 183.46 -o o90/"4123t2029
NO2 ppmvd CEG cc509499 50.29 7t16t2027
Typ€RM Analyzer Make/Model RM Analvzer s/n Analvzer Soan RM Gas Soan
NOx oomvd Thermo 42C 427408865 20 I 017
Type Setting Cylinder lD Cylinder Value Analyzer Response Difference, % of Spar EXptrauon
Date
NOx ppmvd
z.ero E8009't 188 0 -0.01 0.11o/o 21512029
Mid cc262396 5.004 4.95 0.60%3t3t2026
Hioh cc725287 9.017 9.02 -0 03%5t15t2026
NO2 ppmvd CEG cc509499 50.29 7116t2027
Cli€nt PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Test Location: Unit 4
Datei 812812024
Project#: M243506
NO2 to NO Converter Test
Test
Conv. Temp: 320 oC
Test Type NO2 DirectMax: 51.0 ppm
Convercion: 101.41 o/o
Requirement: 90.00 %
Post-Calibration
Time NO, Cal Flaq
13:06 0.0 z13:07 L713:08 3.913:09 4.8'13:10 5.1 m
POST.CAL RESULT
zeio -O.11Yo
mid 1.060/o
Pre-Calibration
Time NO.5:55 9.025:56 7.365:57 -0.01
5:58 -0.01
5:59 -0.01
6:00 -0.016:01 -0.01
6:02 2.806:03 10 556:04 7.86:05 6.3
No.
50.4
50.4
50.4
50.951.0 Max
Cal Flaq
h
z
Time
12 57
12:58
'12:59
'13:00
13:01
t
t
I
T
I
I
I
T
I
T
I
t
I
I
I
I
T
T
T
6:06 5.0 m
PRE-CAL RESULT
zerc -0.11Yomid -0.60%high 0.03%
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
v5.0
196 of '199
RATA Extractive 4/16/20
OMostardi Platt
I
I
NO2 to NO Converter Test
t Client: PacifiCorp Conv. Temp: 327 oC
I Facility: Gadsby Power Plant Test Type NO2 Direct
f Test Location: Unit 5 Max: 50.4 ppm
Oalei 812812024 Conversion: 100.14 a/o
Requirement: 90.00 %
I ,::,:::'- res, Po3,.ca,ibra,ion
a Time NO, Cal Flao Time NO, Time NO, Cal Flaq
I s:s5 B.gB h 12:s7 50.3 13:06 o.o zt 5:56 6.88 12:sa 50.3 13:07 2.15:57 O.21 12:59 50.3 13:08 4.85:58 0.00 13:00 50.4 13:09 5.0 mf 5:59 o.oo 13:01 50.4 Maxr :.B? BBB z
6:02 22.94I :,:: ':i'
6:06 5.0 m
I
I
I
T
I
I
t
t
I
I
I
I
PRE.CAL RESULT
-iE?6-6-.lo"z"-
mid -O.49o/ohigh -1.52o/o
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
POST-CAL RESULT
-;ro
o--o-6ilmid -0.160/o
v5.0
197 of 199
RATA Extractive 4/16/20
OMostardi Plaft
Tvoe RM Analvzer Make/Model RM Analvzer s/n Analvzer SDan RM Gas Soan
NOx oomvd Thermo 42C 42CHL61 169330 20 s 017
Type Setting Cylinder lD Cylinder Value Analyzer Response Difference, o/o of Span EXprratlon
Oate
NOx ppmvd
Zero E80091 't88 o 0.00 0.000/o 2t5t2029
Mid cc262396 5.004 4.96 O 49o/a 31312026
Hioh cc725287 9.017 8.88 1.52o/o 5t15t2026
NO2 ppmvd CEG cc509499 50 29 7116t2027
TvDe RM Analvzer Make/Model RM Analvzer s/n Analvzer SDan RM Gas Soan
NOx oomvd Thermo 42C 427404465 20 9.O t
Type Setting Cylinder lD Cylinder Value Analyzer Response Difference, % of Span Expiration
Date
NOx ppmvd
Zero cc1 16370 0 0.00 0.00%812812031
Mid cc262396 5.004 5.'15 1.620k 313t2026
Hioh cc725247 9.O l 8.95 o.74Vd 5t15t2026
NO2 ppmvd CEG cc509499 50.29 7t1612027
NO2 to NO Converter Test
t
T
I
I
t
t
I
T
I
t
t
I
I
I
I
t
I
t
I
Client: PacifiCorp
Facility: Gadsby Power Plant
Test Location: Unit 6
Datet 812912024
Project#: M243506
Pre-Calibration
Conv. Temp: 320 oC
Test Type NO2 DirectMax: 50.4 ppm
Convercion: 1OO.2O o/o
Requirement: 90.00 o/o
Post-Calibration
5:52 6.38
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.98
3.7
5.2
PRE-CAL RESULT
zeto 0.00o/omid 1.620/ohigh -0.74%
Mostardi Platt
Project No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
Time
5:51
Time
11:40
1 1:41
11:42
11:43
11:44
Time
11:49
11:50
11:51
11:52
No,
0.0
2.6
5.1
Cal Flao
z
m
N9. Cal Flao
8.95 h
No,
50.4
50.4
50.4
50.450.4 Max
5:53
5:54
5:55
5:56
5:57
5:58
5:59
6:00
6:01
POST.CAL RESULT
zero -0.11o/omid 1.29o/o
v5.0
198 of '199
RATA Eltractive 4/16/20
@Mostardi Platt
DTVISION OF AIR QUALITY
END OF THE REPORT
Poect No. M243506
Unit 1, Unit 2, Unit 3, Unit 4, Unit 5, and Unit 6
'199 of 199 OMostardi Platt
Gadsby Unit 1 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-26-2024)
Reference Methods 2, 3A, 6C, 7E, 10, & 19
Source Information
Company Name PacifiCorp Gadsby
Company Contact:Joseph Betenton
Contact Phone No.(801) 220-7708
Stack Designation:Unit 1
Test & Review Dates
Test Date:8/26/2024
Review Date: 3/31/2025
Observer:Not Observed
Reviewer:Rob Leishman
Emission Limits Emission Rates
SO2 NOX CO SO2 NOX CO
lbs./MMBtu
lbs./hr. 179.0 66.745
ppm 336.0 116.484
%O2 Correction as a whole #3.00
Test Information
Stack I.D. inches
As ft^2 Y Dl H @ Cp Pbar Pq (static)
Ps
Stack Pressure
174.00 165.130 0
Contractor Information
Contact:Andrew Bruning
Contracting Company: Montrose Air Quality Services
Address: 990 W 43rd Avenue, Denver, CO 80211
Phone No.: 303-810-2168
Project No.:
1040
Division of Air Quality
Instrumental Reference Methods - Gaseous Measurements
Round
Method 19 - F factors for Coal, Oil, and Gas
Fd Fw Fc
dscf/MMBtu wscf/MMBtu scf/MMBtu Diluent
F factor used
O2
CO2
Anthracite 2
Bituminous 2
Lignite
Natural
Propane
Butane
10100
COAL
OIL
GAS
9780
9860
9190
8710
8710
8710
10540
10640
11950
320
10610
10200
10390
1970
1800
1910
1420
1040
1190
1250
Wet CEM
Correct For O2
CO2 Interference w/CO
Yes
Yes
Yes
Gadsby Unit 1 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-26-2024)
Company PacifiCorp Gadsby
Point Source Unit 1
Test Date 8/26/24
Start
Time
End
Time Run
CO2
%
Gas Flow
HSCFH
Gas Flow
Btu/SCF
Gas Heat
MMBtu/hr
NOx
lb/hr
NOx
lb/MMBtu
NOx
PPM
NOx
PPM
@3% O2
Unit Load
MW
Headers
Here
Headers
Here
Headers
Here
8:09 8:30 1 6.9 4511.9 1050 473.8 66.7 0.141 77.6 115.85 29
8:39 9:00 2 6.9 4512.2 1050 473.8 65.7 0.139 76.9 114.23 29
9:07 9:28 3 6.8 4515.5 1050 474.1 67.5 0.142 78.3 117.1 29
9:36 9:57 4 6.8 4525.5 1050 475.2 69.1 0.146 79.5 120.07 29
10:04 10:25 5 6.8 1529.8 1050 475.6 69.2 0.145 79.6 119.72 29
10:33 10:54 6 6.8 4513 1050 473.9 68.7 0.145 79.7 119.35 29
11:04 11:25 7 6.8 4530.6 1050 475.7 71.9 0.151 82.4 124.59 29
11:33 11:54 8 6.7 4516.8 1050 474.3 73 0.154 83 126.41 29
12:05 12:26 9 6.8 4514.9 1050 474.1 72.7 0.153 86.5 126.5 29
12:34 12:55 10 6.7 4518.2 1050 474.4 74 0.156 84.5 128.44 29
11
12
13
14
15
16
Gadsby Unit 1 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-26-2024)
Division of Air Quality
NSPS Relative Accuracy Performance Specification Test - CEMS Certification
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 1
SO2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
CO2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Acquisition System: Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:
Test Date SO2 Dry SO2 Dry SO2 Test Date % CO2 Dry
8/26/2024 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff 8/26/2024 RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm @ % O2 lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr. Run#
Start
Time End Time %c %c
1 8:09 8:30 1 8:09 8:30 Y 6.7 6.9 -0.24
2 8:39 9:00 2 8:39 9:00 Y 6.8 6.9 -0.15
3 9:07 9:28 3 9:07 9:28 Y 6.7 6.8 -0.07
4 9:36 9:57 4 9:36 9:57 Y 6.7 6.8 -0.11
5 10:04 10:25 5 10:04 10:25 Y 6.6 6.8 -0.18
6 10:33 10:54 6 10:33 10:54 Y 6.7 6.8 -0.11
7 11:04 11:25 7 11:04 11:25 Y 6.6 6.8 -0.19
8 11:33 11:54 8 11:33 11:54 Y 6.5 6.7 -0.15
9 12:05 12:26 9 12:05 12:26 6.5 6.8
10 12:34 12:55 10 12:34 12:55 Y 6.5 6.7 -0.18
11 11
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
Average = Average = 6.640 6.800 0.153
Sd Standard Deviation = Sd Standard Deviation = Sd Standard Deviation = Sd Standard Deviation = 0.05
Confidence Coefficient = Confidence Coefficient = Confidence Coefficient = Confidence Coefficient = 0.039
RA - Relative Accuracy = RA RA RA - Relative Accuracy =2.89%
n = 0 0 0 n = 9 or RA of 1%0.16%
t0.975 = t0.975 = 2.306
E.L. Relative Accuracy =
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;9
c Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 2 For SO2 and NOx Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
13.2 Relative accuracy Performance Specification. The RA of the CEMSS must be not greater than 20 percent when RM is used in the denominator of Eq. 2-6
(average emissions during test are greater than 50 percent of the emission standard)or 10 percent when the applicable emission standard is used in the
denominator of Eq. 2-6 (average emissions during test are less than 50 percent of the emission standard).
Up dated January 17, 2006
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 3 For O2 and CO2 Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
13.2 CEMS Relative Accuracy Perfromance Specification.
The RA of the CEMS must be no grater than 20 percent of the mean value of the reference method (RM) data. 1 percent O2 or CO2.
The results are also acceptable if the absolute value of the difference between the mean RM value and the mean CEMS value is less than or equal to 1.0 percent O2 (or CO2).
Up dated September 14, 2016
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 6 For Continuous Emission Rate Monitoring Systems (CERMS)
13.2 CERMS Relative Accuracy. The RA of the CERMS shall be no greater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM's test data in terms of the nits of the emission
standard, or 10 percent of the applicable standard, which err is greater.
Up dated January 17, 2006
Passed
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
111Servomex 1440D
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Gadsby Unit 1 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-26-2024)
Division of Air Quality
Relative Accuracy Test Audit of
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 1
NOX Analyzer:Serial No.:
O2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Acquisition System: Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:336.00 179.00
Date NOx Dry NOx Dry NOx Test Date % O2 Dry
8/26/2024 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff 9/30/2014 RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm @ 3% O2 lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr. Run#
Start
Time End Time %c %c
1 8:09 8:30 Y 113.9 115.85 -1.9 Y 0.137 0.141 -0.004 Y 64.99 66.7 -1.72 1 8:09 8:30 9.3
2 8:39 9:00 Y 111.1 114.23 -3.2 Y 0.134 0.139 -0.005 Y 63.37 65.7 -2.33 2 8:39 9:00 9.2
3 9:07 9:28 Y 113.5 117.1 -3.7 Y 0.136 0.142 -0.006 Y 64.43 67.5 -3.07 3 9:07 9:28 9.3
4 9:36 9:57 Y 116.0 120.07 -4.1 Y 0.139 0.146 -0.007 Y 66.10 69.1 -3.01 4 9:36 9:57 9.3
5 10:04 10:25 Y 116.7 119.72 -3.1 Y 0.140 0.145 -0.005 Y 66.74 69.2 -2.46 5 10:04 10:25 9.4
6 10:33 10:54 Y 116.8 119.35 -2.5 Y 0.138 0.145 -0.007 Y 65.33 68.7 -3.37 6 10:33 10:54 9.5
7 11:04 11:25 Y 120.2 124.59 -4.4 Y 0.143 0.151 -0.008 Y 67.96 71.9 -3.94 7 11:04 11:25 9.6
8 11:33 11:54 117.6 126.41 0.145 0.154 68.73 73 8 11:33 11:54 9.3
9 12:05 12:26 Y 118.7 126.5 -7.8 Y 0.147 0.153 -0.006 Y 69.60 72.7 -3.10 9 12:05 12:26 9.3
10 12:34 12:55 Y 120.3 128.44 -8.1 Y 0.148 0.156 -0.008 Y 70.21 74 -3.79 10 12:34 12:55 9.3
11 11
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
Average = 116.4 120.7 4.292 0.14 0.146 0.006 66.52 69.50 2.98 Average =
Sd Standard Deviation = 2.20 Sd Standard Deviation = 0.001 Sd Standard Deviation = 0.712 Sd Standard Deviation =
Confidence Coefficient = 1.692 Confidence Coefficient = 0.001 Confidence Coefficient = 0.548 Confidence Coefficient =
RA - Relative Accuracy = Relative Accuracy =5.00%Relative Accuracy = RA - Relative Accuracy =
n = 9 9 9 n = 0 or RA of 1%
t0.975 = 2.306 t0.975 = 2.306 t0.975 = 2.306 t0.975 =
E.L. Relative Accuracy = 35% 1.78% EMRA EMRA 37% 1.97%
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;
c Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 2 For SO2 and NOx Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
4. Performance and Equipment Specifications
4.3 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS shall be no grater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM test data in terms of the
units of the emission standard or 10 percent of the applicable standard, whichever is greater
For SO2 emission standards between 0.30 and 0.20 lbs./MMBtu use 15 Percent of the applicable standard;
For SO2 emission standards below 0.20 lbs./MMBtu use 20 Percent of the emission standard;
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 3 For O2 and CO2 Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
12. Calculate the arithmetic difference between the RM and the CEMSS output for each run. The average of the nine (of more) data sets constitute the RA.
13.2 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS must be no grater than 1 percent O2 or CO2.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 6 For Continuous Emission Rate Monitoring Systems (CERMS)
13.2 CERMS Relative Accuracy. The RA of the CERMS shall be no greater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM's test data in terms of the nits of the emission
standard, or 10 percent of the applicable standard, which err is greater.
Up dated January 17, 2006
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
PassedPassedPassed
112Thermo 42C
Gadsby Unit 1 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-26-2024)
Division of Air Quality
Relative Accuracy Test Audit of
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 1
CO Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:
Acquisition System: Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:
Date CO Dry CO Dry CO
8/26/2024 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm @ % O2 lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr.
1 8:09 8:30
2 8:39 9:00
3 9:07 9:28
4 9:36 9:57
5 10:04 10:25
6 10:33 10:54
7 11:04 11:25
8 11:33 11:54
9 12:05 12:26
10 12:34 12:55
11
12
13
14
15
16
Average =
Sd Standard Deviation =
Confidence Coefficient =
RA - Relative Accuracy =
n = 0 0 0
t0.975 =
E.L. Relative Accuracy =
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;
c Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 4 For Carbon Monoxide (CO) Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
applicable emission standard is used to calculate RA.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 4A For Carbon Monoxide (CO) Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
13.2 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS must be no greater than 10 percent when the average RM value is used to calculate RA, 5 percent when the applicable
emission standard is used to calculate RA, or within 5 ppmv when the RA is calculated as the absolute average difference between the RM and CEMSS plus the 2.5
percent confidence coefficient.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 6 For Continuous Emission Rate Monitoring Systems (CERMS)
13.2 CERMS Relative Accuracy. The RA of the CERMS shall be no greater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM's test data in terms of the nits of the emission
standard, or 10 percent of the applicable standard, which err is greater.
Up dated January 17, 2006
13.2 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS must be no grater than 10 percent when the average of the RM value is used to calculate RA or 5 percent when the
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Gadsby Unit 1 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-26-2024)
Division of Air Quality
NSPS Relative Accuracy Performance Specification Test - CEMS Certification
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 1
SO2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
CO2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:
Test Date SO2 Dry SO2 Dry SO2 Test Date % CO2 Dry
8/26/2024 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff 8/26/2024 RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm @ % O2 lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr. Run#
Start
Time
End
Time %c %c
1 8:09 8:30 1 8:09 8:30 Y 6.7 6.9 -0.24
2 8:39 9:00 2 8:39 9:00 Y 6.8 6.9 -0.15
3 9:07 9:28 3 9:07 9:28 Y 6.7 6.8 -0.07
4 9:36 9:57 4 9:36 9:57 Y 6.7 6.8 -0.11
5 10:04 10:25 5 10:04 10:25 Y 6.6 6.8 -0.18
6 10:33 10:54 6 10:33 10:54 Y 6.7 6.8 -0.11
7 11:04 11:25 7 11:04 11:25 Y 6.6 6.8 -0.19
8 11:33 11:54 8 11:33 11:54 Y 6.5 6.7 -0.15
9 12:05 12:26 9 12:05 12:26 6.5 6.8
10 12:34 12:55 10 12:34 12:55 Y 6.5 6.7 -0.18
11 11
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
Average = Average = 6.647 6.800 0.15
Sd Standard Deviation =Sd Standard Deviation =0.05
Confidence Coefficient =Confidence Coefficient =0.039
RA - Relative Accuracy =RA - Relative Accuracy =2.89%
n =0 n =0 n =0 n =9 or RA of 1%0.15%
t0.975 =t0.975 =t0.975 =t0.975 =2.306
BAF =No Bias
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;Alterative RAc Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
RATA Semiannual Test Annual
SO2 RA < 10% RA < 7.5% OR < 12ppm
ppm
CO2 - The relative accuracy for CO2 monitors shall not exceed 10 percent. See Alternative Below
Pt. 75, App. A 3.3.3 The relative accuracy for CO2 monitors shall not exceed 10 percent. Alternative - If the mean difference of the CO2
monitor measurements and the corresponding reference method measurement, calculated using Equation A7
Up dated September 25, 2017
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 6 For Continuous Emission Rate Monitoring Systems (CERMS)
13.2 CERMS Relative Accuracy. The RA of the CERMS shall be no greater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM's test data in terms of the nits of the emission
standard, or 10 percent of the applicable standard, which ever is greater.
Up dated January 17, 2006
Passed
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Servomex 1440D 111
Gadsby Unit 1 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-26-2024)
Division of Air Quality
Relative Accuracy Test Audit of
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 1
NOX Analyzer:Serial No.:
O2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:336.00 179.00
Date NOx Dry NOx Dry NOx Test Date % O2 Dry
8/26/2024 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff 8/26/2024 RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm @ 3% O2 lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr. Run#
Start
Time
End
Time %c %c
1 8:09 8:30 113.9 Y 0.137 0.141 -0.00383 64.99 1 8:09 8:30 9.3
2 8:39 9:00 111.1 Y 0.134 0.139 -0.00524 63.37 2 8:39 9:00 9.2
3 9:07 9:28 113.5 Y 0.136 0.142 -0.00612 64.43 3 9:07 9:28 9.3
4 9:36 9:57 116.0 Y 0.139 0.146 -0.00690 66.10 4 9:36 9:57 9.3
5 10:04 10:25 116.7 Y 0.140 0.145 -0.00468 66.74 5 10:04 10:25 9.4
6 10:33 10:54 116.8 Y 0.138 0.145 -0.00714 65.33 6 10:33 10:54 9.5
7 11:04 11:25 120.2 Y 0.143 0.151 -0.00814 67.96 7 11:04 11:25 9.6
8 11:33 11:54 117.6 0.145 0.154 68.73 8 11:33 11:54 9.3
9 12:05 12:26 118.7 Y 0.147 0.153 -0.00618 69.60 9 12:05 12:26 9.3
10 12:34 12:55 120.3 Y 0.148 0.156 -0.00801 70.21 10 12:34 12:55 9.3
11 11
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
Average = 0.140 0.146 0.00625 Average =
Sd Standard Deviation =Sd Standard Deviation =0.001 Sd Standard Deviation =Sd Standard Deviation =
Confidence Coefficient =Confidence Coefficient =0.001 Confidence Coefficient =Confidence Coefficient =
RA - Relative Accuracy =RA =5.20%RA =RA - Relative Accuracy =
n =0 n =9 n =0 n =0 or RA of 1%
t0.975 =t0.975 =2.306 t0.975 =t0.975 =
No Bias
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;
c Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
RATA Semiannually Annual NOx Multipliers
NOX RA < 10% RA < 7.5% Old Multiplier New Multiplier
Alternative RA
For units where the average of the monitoring system measurements of NOX emission rate during the RATA
is less than or equal to 0.20 lb./MMBtu, the mean value of the NOX continuous emission monitoring system
For SO2 emission standards between 0.30 and 0.20 lbs./MMBtu use 15 Percent of the applicable standard;
specification of 10.0 percent is not achieved.
di (Rmi - CEMSi)-0.006
Alterative RA Passed
Thermo 42C 112
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Gadsby Unit 1 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-26-2024)
Division of Air Quality
NSPS Relative Accuracy Performance Specification Test - CEMS Certification
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 1
Average Emission
Dry SO2 NOX CO
lbs./MMBtu 0.141 Average % concentration
lbs./hr.66.74 CO2 O2
ppm corrected for %O2 116.48 6.63 9.36
Run 1 Enter O2 or CO2
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2 CO2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.37E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 8.783E-06
lbs./hr.64.99 6.66 9.35
ppm corrected for %O2 113.93 6.66 9.34
Run 2
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.34E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 8.686E-06
lbs./hr.63.37 6.75 9.18
ppm corrected for %O2 111.06 6.66 9.12 Raw Value
Run 3
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.36E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 8.794E-06
lbs./hr.64.43 6.73 9.28
ppm corrected for %O2 113.45 6.68 9.22 Raw Value
Run 4
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.39E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 8.946E-06
lbs./hr.66.10 6.69 9.34
ppm corrected for %O2 116.01 6.66 9.26 Raw Value
Run 5
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.40E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 8.936E-06
lbs./hr.66.7380 6.62 9.42
ppm corrected for %O2 116.66 6.65 9.27 Raw Value
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Raw Value
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
O2
CO2
Clear
lbs./MMBTU
Gadsby Unit 1 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-26-2024)
Division of Air Quality
NSPS Relative Accuracy Performance Specification Test - CEMS Certification
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 1
O2
CO2
Clear
lbs./MMBTU
Run 6
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.38E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 8.864E-06
lbs./hr.65.3268 6.69 9.53
ppm corrected for %O2 116.83 6.67 9.24 Raw Value
Run 7
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.43E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 9.080E-06
lbs./hr.67.96 6.61 9.58
ppm corrected for %O2 120.23 6.60 9.34 Raw Value
Run 8
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.45E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 9.122E-06
lbs./hr.68.73 6.55 9.28
ppm corrected for %O2 117.62 6.62 9.32 Raw Value
Run 9
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.47E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 9.206E-06
lbs./hr.69.60 6.52 9.28
ppm corrected for %O2 118.72 6.62 9.35 Raw Value
Run 10
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.48E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 9.282E-06
lbs./hr.70.21 6.52 9.34
ppm corrected for %O2 120.33 6.60 9.37 Raw Value
Run 11
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft
lbs./hr.
ppm corrected for %O2 Raw Value
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Gadsby Unit 1 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-26-2024)
Calibration Error Test
Test Date August 26, 2024 O2
CS - Cal. Span 22.57
Units %
Cylinder No. Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level 0.00 0.05 0.05 0.22% Passed Cal.
Mid-level 9.89 9.90 0.01 0.04% Passed Cal.
High-level 22.57 22.56 0.01 0.04% Passed Cal.
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of CS - Cal. Span Low-Level 0.00%
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level 43.82%
100% of Cal. Span High-level 100.00%
Test Date August 26, 2024 CO2
CS - Cal. Span 18.45
Units %
Cylinder
No.
Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level 0.00 0.06 0.06 0.325% Passed Cal.
Mid-level 9.91 9.77 0.14 0.770% Passed Cal.
High-level 18.45 18.51 0.06 0.325% Passed Cal.
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of Cal. Span Low-Level 0.00%
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level 53.72%
100% of Cal. Span High-level 100.00%
Test Date SO2
CS - Cal. Span
Units ppm
Cylinder
No.
Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level
Mid-level
High-level
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of Cal. Span Low-Level
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level
100% of Cal. Span High-level
Test Date August 26, 2024 NOx
CS - Cal. Span 183.30
Units ppm
Cylinder
No.
Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level 0.00 0.19 0.19 0.104% Passed Cal.
Mid-level 90.32 90.25 0.07 0.038% Passed Cal.
High-level 183.30 183.60 0.30 0.164% Passed Cal.
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of Cal. Span Low-Level 0.00%
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level 49.27%
100% of Cal. Span High-level 100.00%
Test Date CO
CS - Cal. Span
Units ppm
Cylinder
No.
Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level
Mid-level
High-level
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of Cal. Span Low-Level
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level
100% of Cal. Span High-level
Gadsby Unit 2 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-26-2024)
Reference Methods 2, 3A, 6C, 7E, 10, & 19
Source Information
Company Name PacifiCorp Gadsby
Company Contact:Joseph Betenton
Contact Phone No.(801) 220-7708
Stack Designation:Unit 2
Test & Review Dates
Test Date:8/26/2024
Review Date: 4/1/2024
Observer:Not Observed
Reviewer:Rob Leishman
Emission Limits Emission Rates
SO2 NOX CO SO2 NOX CO
lbs./MMBtu
lbs./hr. 204.0 100.074
ppm 336.0 72.371
%O2 Correction as a whole #3.00
Test Information
Stack I.D. inches
As ft^2 Y Dl H @ Cp Pbar Pq (static)
Ps
Stack Pressure
174.00 165.130 0
Contractor Information
Contact:Andrew Bruning
Contracting Company: Montrose Air Quality Services
Address: 990 W 43rd Avenue, Denver, CO 80211
Phone No.: 303-810-2168
Project No.:
1040
Division of Air Quality
Instrumental Reference Methods - Gaseous Measurements
Round
Method 19 - F factors for Coal, Oil, and Gas
Fd Fw Fc
dscf/MMBtu wscf/MMBtu scf/MMBtu Diluent
F factor used
O2
CO2
Anthracite 2
Bituminous 2
Lignite
Natural
Propane
Butane
10100
COAL
OIL
GAS
9780
9860
9190
8710
8710
8710
10540
10640
11950
320
10610
10200
10390
1970
1800
1910
1420
1040
1190
1250
Wet CEM
Correct For O2
CO2 Interference w/CO
Yes
Yes
Yes
Gadsby Unit 2 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-26-2024)
Company PacifiCorp Gadsby
Point Source Unit 2
Test Date 8/26/24
Start
Time
End
Time Run
CO2
%
Gas Flow
HSCFH
Gas Flow
Btu/SCF
Gas Heat
MMBtu/hr
NOx
lb/hr
NOx
lb/MMBtu
NOx
PPM
NOx
PPM
@3% O2
Unit Load
MW
Headers
Here
Headers
Here
Headers
Here
8:09 8:30 1 6.2 6419.2 1050 674 90.1 0.134 66.7 109.91 49.5
8:39 9:00 2 6.2 6441.7 1050 676.4 92.9 0.137 68.5 113.21 49.4
9:07 9:28 3 6.2 6436.1 1050 375.8 94.8 0.14 69.4 115.29 49.5
9:36 9:57 4 6.1 6434.7 1050 675.7 96.6 0.143 70.5 117.91 49.5
10:04 10:25 5 6.1 6424.4 1050 674.6 96 0.142 70.1 117.07 49.4
10:33 10:54 6 6.1 6427.1 1050 674.9 97.2 0.144 71.1 118.49 49.6
11:04 11:25 7 6.2 6431.8 1050 6754 97.6 0.144 71.6 118.92 49.4
11:33 11:54 8 6 6418.5 1050 674 101.5 0.151 73.3 123.91 49.5
12:05 12:26 9 6.1 6421 1050 674.2 101.9 0.151 74.4 124.36 49.6
12:34 12:55 10 6.1 6417.8 1050 673.9 102.4 0.152 74.5 124.9 49.5
11 .
12
13
14
15
16
Gadsby Unit 2 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-26-2024)
Division of Air Quality
NSPS Relative Accuracy Performance Specification Test - CEMS Certification
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 2
SO2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
CO2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Acquisition System: Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:
Test Date SO2 Dry SO2 Dry SO2 Test Date % CO2 Dry
8/26/2024 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff 8/26/2024 RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr. Run#
Start
Time End Time %c %c
1 8:09 8:30 1 8:09 8:30 Y 6.0 6.2 -0.16
2 8:39 9:00 2 8:39 9:00 Y 6.1 6.2 -0.08
3 9:07 9:28 3 9:07 9:28 Y 6.0 6.2 -0.22
4 9:36 9:57 4 9:36 9:57 Y 6.0 6.1 -0.09
5 10:04 10:25 5 10:04 10:25 Y 6.0 6.1 -0.10
6 10:33 10:54 6 10:33 10:54 Y 6.0 6.1 -0.12
7 11:04 11:25 7 11:04 11:25 Y 6.0 6.2 -0.24
8 11:33 11:54 8 11:33 11:54 Y 6.0 6 -0.05
9 12:05 12:26 9 12:05 12:26 Y 6.2 6.1 0.08
10 12:34 12:55 10 12:34 12:55 6.4 6.1
11 11
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
Average = Average = 6.020 6.130 0.106
Sd Standard Deviation = Sd Standard Deviation = Sd Standard Deviation = Sd Standard Deviation = 0.09
Confidence Coefficient = Confidence Coefficient = Confidence Coefficient = Confidence Coefficient = 0.072
RA - Relative Accuracy = RA RA RA - Relative Accuracy =2.95%
n = 0 0 0 n = 9 or RA of 1%0.11%
t0.975 = t0.975 = 2.306
E.L. Relative Accuracy =
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;9
c Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 2 For SO2 and NOx Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
13.2 Relative accuracy Performance Specification. The RA of the CEMSS must be not greater than 20 percent when RM is used in the denominator of Eq. 2-6
(average emissions during test are greater than 50 percent of the emission standard)or 10 percent when the applicable emission standard is used in the
denominator of Eq. 2-6 (average emissions during test are less than 50 percent of the emission standard).
Up dated January 17, 2006
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 3 For O2 and CO2 Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
13.2 CEMS Relative Accuracy Perfromance Specification.
The RA of the CEMS must be no grater than 20 percent of the mean value of the reference method (RM) data. 1 percent O2 or CO2.
The results are also acceptable if the absolute value of the difference between the mean RM value and the mean CEMS value is less than or equal to 1.0 percent O2 (or CO2).
Up dated September 14, 2016
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 6 For Continuous Emission Rate Monitoring Systems (CERMS)
13.2 CERMS Relative Accuracy. The RA of the CERMS shall be no greater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM's test data in terms of the nits of the emission
standard, or 10 percent of the applicable standard, which err is greater.
Up dated January 17, 2006
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
211Servomex 1440D
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Passed
Gadsby Unit 2 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-26-2024)
Division of Air Quality
Relative Accuracy Test Audit of
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 2
NOX Analyzer:Serial No.:
O2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Acquisition System: Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:336.00 204.00
Date NOx Dry NOx Dry NOx Test Date % O2 Dry
8/26/2024 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff 9/30/2014 RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr. Run#
Start
Time End Time %c %c
1 8:09 8:30 Y 67.0 66.7 0.3 Y 0.138 0.134 0.004 Y 92.85 90.1 2.75 1 8:09 8:30 7.6
2 8:39 9:00 Y 66.5 68.5 -2.0 Y 0.135 0.137 -0.002 Y 91.29 92.9 -1.61 2 8:39 9:00 10.4
3 9:07 9:28 Y 68.5 69.4 -0.9 Y 0.142 0.14 0.002 Y 96.11 94.8 1.31 3 9:07 9:28 10.2
4 9:36 9:57 Y 70.9 70.5 0.4 Y 0.146 0.143 0.003 Y 98.92 96.6 2.32 4 9:36 9:57 9.8
5 10:04 10:25 Y 71.0 70.1 0.9 Y 0.147 0.142 0.005 Y 99.01 96 3.01 5 10:04 10:25 9.5
6 10:33 10:54 Y 72.5 71.1 1.4 Y 0.150 0.144 0.006 Y 101.53 97.2 4.33 6 10:33 10:54 9.3
7 11:04 11:25 Y 73.7 71.6 2.1 0.154 0.144 Y 103.70 97.6 6.10 7 11:04 11:25 9.2
8 11:33 11:54 Y 76.8 73.3 3.5 Y 0.160 0.151 0.009 108.03 101.5 8 11:33 11:54 9.4
9 12:05 12:26 Y 78.2 74.4 3.8 Y 0.157 0.151 0.006 Y 105.95 101.9 4.05 9 12:05 12:26 9.5
10 12:34 12:55 78.7 74.5 Y 0.153 0.152 0.001 Y 103.37 102.4 0.97 10 12:34 12:55 9.5
11 11
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
Average = 71.7 70.6 1.042 0.15 0.144 0.004 99.19 96.61 2.58 Average =
Sd Standard Deviation = 1.90 Sd Standard Deviation = 0.003 Sd Standard Deviation = 2.227 Sd Standard Deviation =
Confidence Coefficient = 1.459 Confidence Coefficient = 0.002 Confidence Coefficient = 1.712 Confidence Coefficient =
RA - Relative Accuracy = Relative Accuracy =4.10%Relative Accuracy = RA - Relative Accuracy =
n = 9 9 9 n = 0 or RA of 1%
t0.975 = 2.306 t0.975 = 2.306 t0.975 = 2.306 t0.975 =
E.L. Relative Accuracy = 21% 0.74% EMRA EMRA 49% 2.10%
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;
c Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 2 For SO2 and NOx Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
4. Performance and Equipment Specifications
4.3 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS shall be no grater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM test data in terms of the
units of the emission standard or 10 percent of the applicable standard, whichever is greater
For SO2 emission standards between 0.30 and 0.20 lbs./MMBtu use 15 Percent of the applicable standard;
For SO2 emission standards below 0.20 lbs./MMBtu use 20 Percent of the emission standard;
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 3 For O2 and CO2 Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
12. Calculate the arithmetic difference between the RM and the CEMSS output for each run. The average of the nine (of more) data sets constitute the RA.
13.2 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS must be no grater than 1 percent O2 or CO2.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 6 For Continuous Emission Rate Monitoring Systems (CERMS)
13.2 CERMS Relative Accuracy. The RA of the CERMS shall be no greater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM's test data in terms of the nits of the emission
standard, or 10 percent of the applicable standard, which err is greater.
Up dated January 17, 2006
212Thermo 42C
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
PassedPassedPassed
Gadsby Unit 2 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-26-2024)
Division of Air Quality
Relative Accuracy Test Audit of
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 2
CO Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:
Acquisition System: Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:
Date CO Dry CO Dry CO
8/26/2024 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr.
1 8:09 8:30
2 8:39 9:00
3 9:07 9:28
4 9:36 9:57
5 10:04 10:25
6 10:33 10:54
7 11:04 11:25
8 11:33 11:54
9 12:05 12:26
10 12:34 12:55
11
12
13
14
15
16
Average =
Sd Standard Deviation =
Confidence Coefficient =
RA - Relative Accuracy =
n = 0 0 0
t0.975 =
E.L. Relative Accuracy =
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;
c Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 4 For Carbon Monoxide (CO) Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
applicable emission standard is used to calculate RA.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 4A For Carbon Monoxide (CO) Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
13.2 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS must be no greater than 10 percent when the average RM value is used to calculate RA, 5 percent when the applicable
emission standard is used to calculate RA, or within 5 ppmv when the RA is calculated as the absolute average difference between the RM and CEMSS plus the 2.5
percent confidence coefficient.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 6 For Continuous Emission Rate Monitoring Systems (CERMS)
13.2 CERMS Relative Accuracy. The RA of the CERMS shall be no greater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM's test data in terms of the nits of the emission
standard, or 10 percent of the applicable standard, which err is greater.
Up dated January 17, 2006
13.2 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS must be no grater than 10 percent when the average of the RM value is used to calculate RA or 5 percent when the
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Gadsby Unit 2 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-26-2024)
Division of Air Quality
NSPS Relative Accuracy Performance Specification Test - CEMS Certification
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 2
SO2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
CO2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:
Test Date SO2 Dry SO2 Dry SO2 Test Date % CO2 Dry
8/26/2024 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff 8/26/2024 RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr. Run#
Start
Time
End
Time %c %c
1 8:09 8:30 1 8:09 8:30 Y 6.0 6.2 -0.16
2 8:39 9:00 2 8:39 9:00 Y 6.1 6.2 -0.08
3 9:07 9:28 3 9:07 9:28 Y 6.0 6.2 -0.22
4 9:36 9:57 4 9:36 9:57 Y 6.0 6.1 -0.09
5 10:04 10:25 5 10:04 10:25 Y 6.0 6.1 -0.10
6 10:33 10:54 6 10:33 10:54 Y 6.0 6.1 -0.12
7 11:04 11:25 7 11:04 11:25 Y 6.0 6.2 -0.24
8 11:33 11:54 8 11:33 11:54 Y 6.0 6 -0.05
9 12:05 12:26 9 12:05 12:26 Y 6.2 6.1 0.08
10 12:34 12:55 10 12:34 12:55 Y 6.4 6.1 0.28
11 11
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
Average = Average = 6.062 6.130 0.07
Sd Standard Deviation =Sd Standard Deviation =0.15
Confidence Coefficient =Confidence Coefficient =0.107
RA - Relative Accuracy =RA - Relative Accuracy =2.89%
n =0 n =0 n =0 n =10 or RA of 1%0.07%
t0.975 =t0.975 =t0.975 =t0.975 =2.262
BAF =No Bias
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;Alterative RAc Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
RATA Semiannual Test Annual
SO2 RA < 10% RA < 7.5% OR < 12ppm
ppm
CO2 - The relative accuracy for CO2 monitors shall not exceed 10 percent. See Alternative Below
Pt. 75, App. A 3.3.3 The relative accuracy for CO2 monitors shall not exceed 10 percent. Alternative - If the mean difference of the CO2
monitor measurements and the corresponding reference method measurement, calculated using Equation A7
Up dated September 25, 2017
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 6 For Continuous Emission Rate Monitoring Systems (CERMS)
13.2 CERMS Relative Accuracy. The RA of the CERMS shall be no greater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM's test data in terms of the nits of the emission
standard, or 10 percent of the applicable standard, which ever is greater.
Up dated January 17, 2006
Servomex 1440D 211
Passed
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Gadsby Unit 2 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-26-2024)
Division of Air Quality
Relative Accuracy Test Audit of
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 2
NOX Analyzer:Serial No.:
O2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:336.00 204.00
Date NOx Dry NOx Dry NOx Test Date % O2 Dry
8/26/2024 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff 8/26/2024 RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr. Run#
Start
Time
End
Time %c %c
1 8:09 8:30 67.0 Y 0.138 0.134 0.00375 92.85 1 8:09 8:30 7.6
2 8:39 9:00 66.5 Y 0.135 0.137 -0.00203 91.29 2 8:39 9:00 10.4
3 9:07 9:28 68.5 Y 0.142 0.14 0.00221 96.11 3 9:07 9:28 10.2
4 9:36 9:57 70.9 Y 0.146 0.143 0.00341 98.92 4 9:36 9:57 9.8
5 10:04 10:25 71.0 Y 0.147 0.142 0.00477 99.01 5 10:04 10:25 9.5
6 10:33 10:54 72.5 Y 0.150 0.144 0.00645 101.53 6 10:33 10:54 9.3
7 11:04 11:25 73.7 Y 0.154 0.144 0.00955 103.70 7 11:04 11:25 9.2
8 11:33 11:54 76.8 Y 0.160 0.151 0.00930 108.03 8 11:33 11:54 9.4
9 12:05 12:26 78.2 Y 0.157 0.151 0.00614 105.95 9 12:05 12:26 9.5
10 12:34 12:55 78.7 Y 0.153 0.152 0.00139 103.37 10 12:34 12:55 9.5
11 11
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
Average = 0.148 0.144 0.00450 Average =
Sd Standard Deviation =Sd Standard Deviation =0.004 Sd Standard Deviation =Sd Standard Deviation =
Confidence Coefficient =Confidence Coefficient =0.003 Confidence Coefficient =Confidence Coefficient =
RA - Relative Accuracy =RA =5.10%RA =RA - Relative Accuracy =
n =0 n =10 n =0 n =0 or RA of 1%
t0.975 =t0.975 =2.262 t0.975 =t0.975 =
Use BAF 1.03
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;
c Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
RATA Semiannually Annual NOx Multipliers
NOX RA < 10% RA < 7.5% Old Multiplier New Multiplier
Alternative RA
For units where the average of the monitoring system measurements of NOX emission rate during the RATA
is less than or equal to 0.20 lb./MMBtu, the mean value of the NOX continuous emission monitoring system
For SO2 emission standards between 0.30 and 0.20 lbs./MMBtu use 15 Percent of the applicable standard;
specification of 10.0 percent is not achieved.
di (Rmi - CEMSi)0.004
Alterative RA Passed
Thermo 42C 212
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Gadsby Unit 2 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-26-2024)
Division of Air Quality
NSPS Relative Accuracy Performance Specification Test - CEMS Certification
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 2
Average Emission
Dry SO2 NOX CO
lbs./MMBtu 0.148 Average % concentration
lbs./hr.100.07 CO2 O2
ppm or % 72.37 6.06 9.44
Run 1 Enter O2 or CO2
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2 CO2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.38E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 8.003E-06
lbs./hr.92.85 6.04 7.60
ppm or %67.00 6.08 7.59
Run 2
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.35E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 7.946E-06
lbs./hr.91.29 6.12 10.42
ppm or %66.52 6.08 10.40 Raw Value
Run 3
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.42E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 8.181E-06
lbs./hr.96.11 5.98 10.18
ppm or %68.49 6.06 10.13 Raw Value
Run 4
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.46E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 8.463E-06
lbs./hr.98.92 6.01 9.77
ppm or %70.85 6.08 9.62 Raw Value
Run 5
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.47E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 8.475E-06
lbs./hr.99.0086 6.01 9.49
ppm or %70.95 6.07 9.37 Raw Value
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Raw Value
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
O2
CO2
Clear
lbs./MMBTU
Gadsby Unit 2 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-26-2024)
Division of Air Quality
NSPS Relative Accuracy Performance Specification Test - CEMS Certification
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 2
O2
CO2
Clear
lbs./MMBTU
Run 6
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.50E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 8.655E-06
lbs./hr.101.5288 5.98 9.34
ppm or %72.46 6.11 9.33 Raw Value
Run 7
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.54E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 8.807E-06
lbs./hr.103.70 5.97 9.21
ppm or %73.73 6.12 9.17 Raw Value
Run 8
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.60E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 9.176E-06
lbs./hr.108.03 5.95 9.38
ppm or %76.82 6.05 9.33 Raw Value
Run 9
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.57E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 9.336E-06
lbs./hr.105.95 6.18 9.50
ppm or %78.16 6.10 9.44 Raw Value
Run 10
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.53E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 9.404E-06
lbs./hr.103.37 6.38 9.47
ppm or %78.73 6.07 9.43 Raw Value
Run 11
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft
lbs./hr.
ppm or %Raw Value
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Gadsby Unit 2 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-26-2024)
Calibration Error Test
Test Date August 26, 2024 O2
CS - Cal. Span 22.57
Units %
Cylinder No. Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level 0.00 0.03 0.03 0.13% Passed Cal.
Mid-level 9.89 9.88 0.01 0.05% Passed Cal.
High-level 22.57 22.55 0.02 0.09% Passed Cal.
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of CS - Cal. Span Low-Level 0.00%
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level 43.82%
100% of Cal. Span High-level 100.00%
Test Date August 26, 2024 CO2
CS - Cal. Span 18.45
Units %
Cylinder
No.
Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level 0.00 0.02 0.02 0.108% Passed Cal.
Mid-level 9.91 9.90 0.01 0.065% Passed Cal.
High-level 18.45 18.41 0.04 0.217% Passed Cal.
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of Cal. Span Low-Level 0.00%
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level 53.72%
100% of Cal. Span High-level 100.00%
Test Date SO2
CS - Cal. Span
Units ppm
Cylinder
No.
Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level
Mid-level
High-level
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of Cal. Span Low-Level
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level
100% of Cal. Span High-level
Test Date August 26, 2024 NOx
CS - Cal. Span 183.30
Units ppm
Cylinder
No.
Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level 0.00 0.29 0.29 0.158% Passed Cal.
Mid-level 90.32 90.30 0.02 0.011% Passed Cal.
High-level 183.30 183.08 0.22 0.120% Passed Cal.
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of Cal. Span Low-Level 0.00%
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level 49.27%
100% of Cal. Span High-level 100.00%
Test Date CO
CS - Cal. Span
Units ppm
Cylinder
No.
Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level
Mid-level
High-level
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of Cal. Span Low-Level
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level
100% of Cal. Span High-level
Gadsby Unit 3 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-27-2024)
Reference Methods 2, 3A, 6C, 7E, 10, & 19
Source Information
Company Name PacifiCorp Gadsby
Company Contact:Joseph Betenton
Contact Phone No.(801) 220-7708
Stack Designation:Unit 3
Test & Review Dates
Test Date:8/27/2024
Review Date: 4/1/2025
Observer:Not Observed
Reviewer:Rob Leishman
Emission Limits Emission Rates
SO2 NOX CO SO2 NOX CO
lbs./MMBtu
lbs./hr. 142.0 26.9 81.010
ppm 168.0 10.00 85.773
%O2 Correction as a whole #3.00 15.00
Test Information
Stack I.D. inches
As ft^2 Y Dl H @ Cp Pbar Pq (static)
Ps
Stack Pressure
174.00 165.130 0
Contractor Information
Contact:Andrew Bruning
Contracting Company: Montrose Air Quality Services
Address: 990 W 43rd Avenue, Denver, CO 80211
Phone No.: 303-810-2168
Project No.:
1040
Division of Air Quality
Instrumental Reference Methods - Gaseous Measurements
Round
Method 19 - F factors for Coal, Oil, and Gas
Fd Fw Fc
dscf/MMBtu wscf/MMBtu scf/MMBtu Diluent
F factor used
O2
CO2
Anthracite 2
Bituminous 2
Lignite
Natural
Propane
Butane
10100
COAL
OIL
GAS
9780
9860
9190
8710
8710
8710
10540
10640
11950
320
10610
10200
10390
1970
1800
1910
1420
1040
1190
1250
Wet CEM
Correct For O2
CO2 Interference w/CO
Yes
Yes
Yes
Gadsby Unit 3 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-27-2024)
Company PacifiCorp Gadsby
Point Source Unit 3
Test Date 8/27/24
Start
Time
End
Time Run
CO2
%
Gas Flow
HSCFH
Gas Flow
Btu/SCF
Gas Heat
MMBtu/hr
NOx
lb/hr
NOx
lb/MMBtu
NOx
PPM
NOx
PPM
@3% O2
Unit Load
MW
Headers
Here
Headers
Here
Headers
Here
6:35 6:56 1 6.5 7415.1 1050 778.9 71.7 0.092 47.8 75.69 68.2
7:02 7:23 2 6.4 7295.2 1050 766 76.1 0.099 51.2 81.52 67.7
7:28 7:49 3 6.4 7259.4 1050 762.2 75.2 0.099 50.8 81.19 67
7:55 8:16 4 6.4 7266.1 1050 763 78.6 0.103 53.1 84.76 67.3
8:22 8:43 5 6.5 7285.3 1050 765 77.6 0.101 52.8 83.73 67.6
8:49 9:10 6 6.5 7298.9 1050 766.4 78.8 0.103 53.6 84.82 67.5
9:15 9:36 7 6.4 7289.2 1050 755.4 78.5 0.103 53.2 84.33 67.7
9:41 10:02 8 6.5 7294.6 1050 766 76 0.099 51.9 87.87 67.5
10:07 10:28 9 6.5 7299.5 1050 766.4 71.3 0.093 48.8 76.59 67.6
10:33 10:54 10 6.5 7350.1 1050 771.8 75.2 0.097 51.1 80.07 67.9
11
12
13
14
15
16
Gadsby Unit 3 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-27-2024)
Division of Air Quality
NSPS Relative Accuracy Performance Specification Test - CEMS Certification
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 3
SO2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
CO2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Acquisition System: Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:
Test Date SO2 Dry SO2 Dry SO2 Test Date % CO2 Dry
8/27/2024 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff 8/27/2024 RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm @ % O2 lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr. Run#
Start
Time End Time %c %c
1 6:35 6:56 1 6:35 6:56 Y 6.4 6.5 -0.15
2 7:02 7:23 2 7:02 7:23 Y 6.3 6.4 -0.14
3 7:28 7:49 3 7:28 7:49 Y 6.3 6.4 -0.14
4 7:55 8:16 4 7:55 8:16 Y 6.3 6.4 -0.14
5 8:22 8:43 5 8:22 8:43 6.3 6.5
6 8:49 9:10 6 8:49 9:10 Y 6.3 6.5 -0.21
7 9:15 9:36 7 9:15 9:36 Y 6.3 6.4 -0.12
8 9:41 10:02 8 9:41 10:02 Y 6.3 6.5 -0.20
9 10:07 10:28 9 10:07 10:28 Y 6.4 6.5 -0.15
10 10:33 10:54 10 10:33 10:54 Y 6.3 6.5 -0.16
11 11
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
Average = Average = 6.290 6.450 0.157
Sd Standard Deviation = Sd Standard Deviation = Sd Standard Deviation = Sd Standard Deviation = 0.03
Confidence Coefficient = Confidence Coefficient = Confidence Coefficient = Confidence Coefficient = 0.023
RA - Relative Accuracy = RA RA RA - Relative Accuracy =2.86%
n = 0 0 0 n = 9 or RA of 1%0.16%
t0.975 = t0.975 = 2.306
E.L. Relative Accuracy =
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;9
c Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 2 For SO2 and NOx Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
13.2 Relative accuracy Performance Specification. The RA of the CEMSS must be not greater than 20 percent when RM is used in the denominator of Eq. 2-6
(average emissions during test are greater than 50 percent of the emission standard)or 10 percent when the applicable emission standard is used in the
denominator of Eq. 2-6 (average emissions during test are less than 50 percent of the emission standard).
Up dated January 17, 2006
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 3 For O2 and CO2 Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
13.2 CEMS Relative Accuracy Perfromance Specification.
The RA of the CEMS must be no grater than 20 percent of the mean value of the reference method (RM) data. 1 percent O2 or CO2.
The results are also acceptable if the absolute value of the difference between the mean RM value and the mean CEMS value is less than or equal to 1.0 percent O2 (or CO2).
Up dated September 14, 2016
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 6 For Continuous Emission Rate Monitoring Systems (CERMS)
13.2 CERMS Relative Accuracy. The RA of the CERMS shall be no greater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM's test data in terms of the nits of the emission
standard, or 10 percent of the applicable standard, which err is greater.
Up dated January 17, 2006
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
311Servomex 1440D
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Passed
Gadsby Unit 3 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-27-2024)
Division of Air Quality
Relative Accuracy Test Audit of
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 3
NOX Analyzer:Serial No.:
O2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Acquisition System: Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:168.00 142.00
Date NOx Dry NOx Dry NOx Test Date % O2 Dry
8/27/2024 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff 9/30/2014 RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm @ 3% O2 lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr. Run#
Start
Time End Time %c %c
1 6:35 6:56 Y 79.1 75.69 3.4 Y 0.097 0.092 0.005 Y 75.87 71.7 4.17 1 6:35 6:56 9.6
2 7:02 7:23 Y 85.9 81.52 4.3 Y 0.106 0.099 0.007 Y 81.10 76.1 5.00 2 7:02 7:23 9.8
3 7:28 7:49 Y 84.9 81.19 3.7 Y 0.104 0.099 0.005 Y 79.56 75.2 4.36 3 7:28 7:49 9.8
4 7:55 8:16 Y 89.1 84.76 4.4 Y 0.110 0.103 0.007 Y 83.69 78.6 5.09 4 7:55 8:16 9.8
5 8:22 8:43 Y 88.3 83.73 4.5 Y 0.109 0.101 0.008 Y 83.28 77.6 5.68 5 8:22 8:43 9.7
6 8:49 9:10 Y 87.8 84.82 3.0 Y 0.108 0.103 0.005 Y 82.92 78.8 4.12 6 8:49 9:10 9.7
7 9:15 9:36 Y 88.4 84.33 4.1 Y 0.109 0.103 0.006 Y 83.41 78.5 4.91 7 9:15 9:36 9.8
8 9:41 10:02 Y 88.7 87.87 0.8 0.109 0.099 83.87 76 8 9:41 10:02 9.7
9 10:07 10:28 81.4 76.59 Y 0.100 0.093 0.007 Y 76.61 71.3 5.31 9 10:07 10:28 9.7
10 10:33 10:54 Y 84.2 80.07 4.1 Y 0.103 0.097 0.006 Y 79.81 75.2 4.61 10 10:33 10:54 9.7
11 11
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
Average = 86.3 82.7 3.590 0.11 0.099 0.006 80.69 75.89 4.80 Average =
Sd Standard Deviation = 1.15 Sd Standard Deviation = 0.001 Sd Standard Deviation = 0.531 Sd Standard Deviation =
Confidence Coefficient = 0.883 Confidence Coefficient = 0.001 Confidence Coefficient = 0.408 Confidence Coefficient =
RA - Relative Accuracy =5.20%Relative Accuracy =6.70%Relative Accuracy =6.50%RA - Relative Accuracy =
n = 9 9 9 n = 0 or RA of 1%
t0.975 = 2.306 t0.975 = 2.306 t0.975 = 2.306 t0.975 =
E.L. Relative Accuracy = 51% EMRA EMRA 57%
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;
c Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 2 For SO2 and NOx Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
4. Performance and Equipment Specifications
4.3 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS shall be no grater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM test data in terms of the
units of the emission standard or 10 percent of the applicable standard, whichever is greater
For SO2 emission standards between 0.30 and 0.20 lbs./MMBtu use 15 Percent of the applicable standard;
For SO2 emission standards below 0.20 lbs./MMBtu use 20 Percent of the emission standard;
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 3 For O2 and CO2 Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
12. Calculate the arithmetic difference between the RM and the CEMSS output for each run. The average of the nine (of more) data sets constitute the RA.
13.2 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS must be no grater than 1 percent O2 or CO2.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 6 For Continuous Emission Rate Monitoring Systems (CERMS)
13.2 CERMS Relative Accuracy. The RA of the CERMS shall be no greater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM's test data in terms of the nits of the emission
standard, or 10 percent of the applicable standard, which err is greater.
Up dated January 17, 2006
312Thermo 42C
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
PassedPassedPassed
Gadsby Unit 3 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-27-2024)
Division of Air Quality
Relative Accuracy Test Audit of
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 3
CO Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:
Acquisition System: Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:10.00 26.90
Date CO Dry CO Dry CO
8/27/2024 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm @ 15% O2 lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr.
1 6:35 6:56
2 7:02 7:23
3 7:28 7:49
4 7:55 8:16
5 8:22 8:43
6 8:49 9:10
7 9:15 9:36
8 9:41 10:02
9 10:07 10:28
10 10:33 10:54
11
12
13
14
15
16
Average =
Sd Standard Deviation =
Confidence Coefficient =
RA - Relative Accuracy =
n = 0 0 0
t0.975 =
E.L. Relative Accuracy =
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;
c Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 4 For Carbon Monoxide (CO) Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
applicable emission standard is used to calculate RA.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 4A For Carbon Monoxide (CO) Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
13.2 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS must be no greater than 10 percent when the average RM value is used to calculate RA, 5 percent when the applicable
emission standard is used to calculate RA, or within 5 ppmv when the RA is calculated as the absolute average difference between the RM and CEMSS plus the 2.5
percent confidence coefficient.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 6 For Continuous Emission Rate Monitoring Systems (CERMS)
13.2 CERMS Relative Accuracy. The RA of the CERMS shall be no greater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM's test data in terms of the nits of the emission
standard, or 10 percent of the applicable standard, which err is greater.
Up dated January 17, 2006
13.2 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS must be no grater than 10 percent when the average of the RM value is used to calculate RA or 5 percent when the
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Gadsby Unit 3 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-27-2024)
Division of Air Quality
NSPS Relative Accuracy Performance Specification Test - CEMS Certification
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 3
SO2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
CO2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:
Test Date SO2 Dry SO2 Dry SO2 Test Date % CO2 Dry
8/27/2024 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff 8/27/2024 RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm @ % O2 lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr. Run#
Start
Time
End
Time %c %c
1 6:35 6:56 1 6:35 6:56 Y 6.4 6.5 -0.15
2 7:02 7:23 2 7:02 7:23 Y 6.3 6.4 -0.14
3 7:28 7:49 3 7:28 7:49 Y 6.3 6.4 -0.14
4 7:55 8:16 4 7:55 8:16 Y 6.3 6.4 -0.14
5 8:22 8:43 5 8:22 8:43 6.3 6.5
6 8:49 9:10 6 8:49 9:10 Y 6.3 6.5 -0.21
7 9:15 9:36 7 9:15 9:36 Y 6.3 6.4 -0.12
8 9:41 10:02 8 9:41 10:02 Y 6.3 6.5 -0.20
9 10:07 10:28 9 10:07 10:28 Y 6.4 6.5 -0.15
10 10:33 10:54 10 10:33 10:54 Y 6.3 6.5 -0.16
11 11
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
Average = Average = 6.299 6.456 0.16
Sd Standard Deviation =Sd Standard Deviation =0.03
Confidence Coefficient =Confidence Coefficient =0.024
RA - Relative Accuracy =RA - Relative Accuracy =2.87%
n =0 n =0 n =0 n =9 or RA of 1%0.16%
t0.975 =t0.975 =t0.975 =t0.975 =2.306
BAF =No Bias
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;Alterative RAc Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
RATA Semiannual Test Annual
SO2 RA < 10% RA < 7.5% OR < 12ppm
ppm
CO2 - The relative accuracy for CO2 monitors shall not exceed 10 percent. See Alternative Below
Pt. 75, App. A 3.3.3 The relative accuracy for CO2 monitors shall not exceed 10 percent. Alternative - If the mean difference of the CO2
monitor measurements and the corresponding reference method measurement, calculated using Equation A7
Up dated September 25, 2017
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 6 For Continuous Emission Rate Monitoring Systems (CERMS)
13.2 CERMS Relative Accuracy. The RA of the CERMS shall be no greater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM's test data in terms of the nits of the emission
standard, or 10 percent of the applicable standard, which ever is greater.
Up dated January 17, 2006
Servomex 1440D 311
Passed
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Gadsby Unit 3 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-27-2024)
Division of Air Quality
Relative Accuracy Test Audit of
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 3
NOX Analyzer:Serial No.:
O2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:168.00 142.00
Date NOx Dry NOx Dry NOx Test Date % O2 Dry
8/27/2024 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff 8/27/2024 RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm @ 3% O2 lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr. Run#
Start
Time
End
Time %c %c
1 6:35 6:56 79.1 Y 0.097 0.092 0.00540 75.87 1 6:35 6:56 9.6
2 7:02 7:23 85.9 Y 0.106 0.099 0.00687 81.10 2 7:02 7:23 9.8
3 7:28 7:49 84.9 Y 0.104 0.099 0.00538 79.56 3 7:28 7:49 9.8
4 7:55 8:16 89.1 Y 0.110 0.103 0.00669 83.69 4 7:55 8:16 9.8
5 8:22 8:43 88.3 Y 0.109 0.101 0.00786 83.28 5 8:22 8:43 9.7
6 8:49 9:10 87.8 Y 0.108 0.103 0.00519 82.92 6 8:49 9:10 9.7
7 9:15 9:36 88.4 Y 0.109 0.103 0.00597 83.41 7 9:15 9:36 9.8
8 9:41 10:02 88.7 0.109 0.099 83.87 8 9:41 10:02 9.7
9 10:07 10:28 81.4 Y 0.100 0.093 0.00696 76.61 9 10:07 10:28 9.7
10 10:33 10:54 84.2 Y 0.103 0.097 0.00641 79.81 10 10:33 10:54 9.7
11 11
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
Average = 0.105 0.099 0.00630 Average =
Sd Standard Deviation =Sd Standard Deviation =0.001 Sd Standard Deviation =Sd Standard Deviation =
Confidence Coefficient =Confidence Coefficient =0.001 Confidence Coefficient =Confidence Coefficient =
RA - Relative Accuracy =RA =6.90%RA =RA - Relative Accuracy =
n =0 n =9 n =0 n =0 or RA of 1%
t0.975 =t0.975 =2.306 t0.975 =t0.975 =
Use BAF 1.06
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;
c Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
RATA Semiannually Annual NOx Multipliers
NOX RA < 10% RA < 7.5% Old Multiplier New Multiplier
Alternative RA
For units where the average of the monitoring system measurements of NOX emission rate during the RATA
is less than or equal to 0.20 lb./MMBtu, the mean value of the NOX continuous emission monitoring system
For SO2 emission standards between 0.30 and 0.20 lbs./MMBtu use 15 Percent of the applicable standard;
specification of 10.0 percent is not achieved.
di (Rmi - CEMSi)0.006
Alterative RA Passed
Thermo 42C 312
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Gadsby Unit 3 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-27-2024)
Division of Air Quality
NSPS Relative Accuracy Performance Specification Test - CEMS Certification
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 3
Average Emission
Dry SO2 NOX CO
lbs./MMBtu 0.106 Average % concentration
lbs./hr.81.01 CO2 O2
ppm corrected for %O2 85.77 6.30 9.73
Run 1 Enter O2 or CO2
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2 CO2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)9.74E-02 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 5.948E-06
lbs./hr.75.87 6.35 9.64
ppm corrected for %O2 79.13 6.36 9.67
Run 2
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.06E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 6.373E-06
lbs./hr.81.10 6.26 9.78
ppm corrected for %O2 85.86 6.36 9.68 Raw Value
Run 3
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.04E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 6.283E-06
lbs./hr.79.56 6.26 9.81
ppm corrected for %O2 84.88 6.31 9.71 Raw Value
Run 4
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.10E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 6.605E-06
lbs./hr.83.69 6.26 9.80
ppm corrected for %O2 89.13 6.34 9.70 Raw Value
Run 5
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.09E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 6.569E-06
lbs./hr.83.2769 6.28 9.75
ppm corrected for %O2 88.26 6.37 9.66 Raw Value
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Raw Value
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
O2
CO2
Clear
lbs./MMBTU
Gadsby Unit 3 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-27-2024)
Division of Air Quality
NSPS Relative Accuracy Performance Specification Test - CEMS Certification
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 3
O2
CO2
Clear
lbs./MMBTU
Run 6
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.08E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 6.540E-06
lbs./hr.82.9183 6.29 9.74
ppm corrected for %O2 87.79 6.40 9.64 Raw Value
Run 7
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.09E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 6.576E-06
lbs./hr.83.41 6.28 9.75
ppm corrected for %O2 88.39 6.42 9.63 Raw Value
Run 8
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.09E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 6.629E-06
lbs./hr.83.87 6.30 9.70
ppm corrected for %O2 88.70 6.45 9.59 Raw Value
Run 9
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.00E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 6.105E-06
lbs./hr.76.61 6.35 9.67
ppm corrected for %O2 81.44 6.49 9.55 Raw Value
Run 10
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)1.03E-01 E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 6.308E-06
lbs./hr.79.81 6.34 9.67
ppm corrected for %O2 84.15 6.50 9.55 Raw Value
Run 11
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft
lbs./hr.
ppm corrected for %O2 Raw Value
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Gadsby Unit 3 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-27-2024)
Calibration Error Test
Test Date August 27, 2024 O2
CS - Cal. Span 22.57
Units %
Cylinder No. Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level 0.00 0.07 0.07 0.31% Passed Cal.
Mid-level 10.51 10.57 0.06 0.27% Passed Cal.
High-level 22.57 22.52 0.05 0.22% Passed Cal.
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of CS - Cal. Span Low-Level 0.00%
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level 46.57%
100% of Cal. Span High-level 100.00%
Test Date August 27, 2024 CO2
CS - Cal. Span 18.45
Units %
Cylinder
No.
Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level 0.00 0.04 0.04 0.217% Passed Cal.
Mid-level 8.90 8.93 0.03 0.141% Passed Cal.
High-level 18.45 18.54 0.09 0.488% Passed Cal.
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of Cal. Span Low-Level 0.00%
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level 48.26%
100% of Cal. Span High-level 100.00%
Test Date SO2
CS - Cal. Span
Units ppm
Cylinder
No.
Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level
Mid-level
High-level
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of Cal. Span Low-Level
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level
100% of Cal. Span High-level
Test Date August 27, 2024 NOx
CS - Cal. Span 183.30
Units ppm
Cylinder
No.
Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level 0.00 0.45 0.45 0.245% Passed Cal.
Mid-level 90.32 91.70 1.38 0.753% Passed Cal.
High-level 183.30 183.46 0.16 0.087% Passed Cal.
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of Cal. Span Low-Level 0.00%
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level 49.27%
100% of Cal. Span High-level 100.00%
Test Date CO
26.9 CS - Cal. Span
10 Units ppm
Cylinder
No.
Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level
Mid-level
High-level
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of Cal. Span Low-Level
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level
100% of Cal. Span High-level
Gadsby Unit 4 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-28-2024)
Reference Methods 2, 3A, 6C, 7E, 10, & 19
Source Information
Company Name PacifiCorp Gadsby
Company Contact:Joseph Betenton
Contact Phone No.(801) 220-7708
Stack Designation:Unit 4
Test & Review Dates
Test Date:8/28/2025
Review Date: 4/3/2025
Observer:Not Observed
Reviewer:Rob Leishman
Emission Limits Emission Rates
SO2 NOX CO SO2 NOX CO
lbs./MMBtu
lbs./hr. 22.2 26.9 2.171 0.623
ppm 5.0 10.00 2.327 1.096
%O2 Correction as a whole #15.00 15.00
Test Information
Stack I.D. inches
As ft^2 Y Dl H @ Cp Pbar Pq (static)
Ps
Stack Pressure
132.50 95.754 0
Contractor Information
Contact:Andrew Bruning
Contracting Company: Montrose Air Quality Services
Address: 990 W 43rd Avenue, Denver, CO 80211
Phone No.: 303-810-2168
Project No.:
8710
Division of Air Quality
Instrumental Reference Methods - Gaseous Measurements
Round
Method 19 - F factors for Coal, Oil, and Gas
Fd Fw Fc
dscf/MMBtu wscf/MMBtu scf/MMBtu Diluent
F factor used
O2
CO2
Anthracite 2
Bituminous 2
Lignite
Natural
Propane
Butane
10100
COAL
OIL
GAS
9780
9860
9190
8710
8710
8710
10540
10640
11950
320
10610
10200
10390
1970
1800
1910
1420
1040
1190
1250
Wet CEM
Correct For O2
CO2 Interference w/CO
Yes
Yes
Yes
Gadsby Unit 4 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-28-2024)
Company PacifiCorp Gadsby
Point Source Unit 4
Test Date 8/28/25
Start
Time
End
Time Run
CO
lb/hr
CO
ppm
CO
ppm@15
% O2
Unit Load
MW
Gas Flow
HSCFH
Heat
Btu/SCF Heat Input
MMBtu/hr
NOx
lb/hr
NOx
lb/MMBtu
NOx
PPM
NOx
PPM
@15% O2
O2
%
6:35 6:56 1 1.1 1.6 1.97 24 2392.9 1050 251.3 2 0.008 1.7 2.14 16.1
7:07 7:28 2 1.2 1.7 2.15 24.1 2391.8 1050 251.1 2.1 0.008 1.8 2.27 16.1
7:39 8:00 3 1.3 1.8 2.23 24 2385.7 1050 250.5 2.4 0.01 2.1 2.62 16.1
8:12 8:33 4 1.2 1.8 2.14 24.9 2456.2 1050 257.9 1.3 0.005 1.2 1.4 16.1
8:44 9:05 5 1.1 1.6 2 24.1 2405 1050 252.5 3.2 0.013 2.8 3.47 16.1
9:17 9:38 6 1.1 1.6 1.91 24.9 2438.3 1050 256 2.2 0.009 2 2.39 16
9:49 10:10 7 1.1 1.6 1.95 24.5 2419.6 1050 254.1 2.5 0.01 2.2 2.69 16.1
10:21 10:42 8 1.1 1.6 1.94 24.9 2444.4 1050 256.7 2.5 0.01 2.2 2.67 16
11:03 11:24 9 1.1 1.6 1.93 24 2401.4 1050 252.2 3 0.012 2.7 3.25 16.1
11:35 11:56 10 1.1 1.6 1.94 24.4 2411.8 1050 253.2 2.8 0.011 2.5 3.01 16
12:07 12:28 11 1.1 1.6 1.92 24 2395.1 1050 251.5 2.9 0.012 2.6 3.12 16
12
13
14
15
16
Gadsby Unit 4 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-28-2024)
Division of Air Quality
NSPS Relative Accuracy Performance Specification Test - CEMS Certification
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 4
SO2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
CO2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Acquisition System: Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:
Test Date SO2 Dry SO2 Dry SO2 Test Date % CO2 Dry
8/28/2025 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff 8/28/2025 RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm @ % O2 lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr. Run#
Start
Time End Time %c %c
1 6:35 6:56 1 6:35 6:56
2 7:07 7:28 2 7:07 7:28
3 7:39 8:00 3 7:39 8:00
4 8:12 8:33 4 8:12 8:33
5 8:44 9:05 5 8:44 9:05
6 9:17 9:38 6 9:17 9:38
7 9:49 10:10 7 9:49 10:10
8 10:21 10:42 8 10:21 10:42
9 11:03 11:24 9 11:03 11:24
10 11:35 11:56 10 11:35 11:56
11 12:07 12:28 11 12:07 12:28
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
Average = Average =
Sd Standard Deviation = Sd Standard Deviation = Sd Standard Deviation = Sd Standard Deviation =
Confidence Coefficient = Confidence Coefficient = Confidence Coefficient = Confidence Coefficient =
RA - Relative Accuracy = RA RA RA - Relative Accuracy =
n = 0 0 0 n = 0 or RA of 1%
t0.975 = t0.975 =
E.L. Relative Accuracy =
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;0
c Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 2 For SO2 and NOx Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
13.2 Relative accuracy Performance Specification. The RA of the CEMSS must be not greater than 20 percent when RM is used in the denominator of Eq. 2-6
(average emissions during test are greater than 50 percent of the emission standard)or 10 percent when the applicable emission standard is used in the
denominator of Eq. 2-6 (average emissions during test are less than 50 percent of the emission standard).
Up dated January 17, 2006
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 3 For O2 and CO2 Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
13.2 CEMS Relative Accuracy Perfromance Specification.
The RA of the CEMS must be no grater than 20 percent of the mean value of the reference method (RM) data. 1 percent O2 or CO2.
The results are also acceptable if the absolute value of the difference between the mean RM value and the mean CEMS value is less than or equal to 1.0 percent O2 (or CO2).
Up dated September 14, 2016
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 6 For Continuous Emission Rate Monitoring Systems (CERMS)
13.2 CERMS Relative Accuracy. The RA of the CERMS shall be no greater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM's test data in terms of the nits of the emission
standard, or 10 percent of the applicable standard, which err is greater.
Up dated January 17, 2006
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Gadsby Unit 4 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-28-2024)
Division of Air Quality
Relative Accuracy Test Audit of
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 4
NOX Analyzer:Serial No.:
O2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Acquisition System: Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:5.00 22.20
Date NOx Dry NOx Dry NOx Test Date % O2 Dry
8/28/2025 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff 9/30/2014 RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm @ 15% O2 lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr. Run#
Start
Time End Time %c %c
1 6:35 6:56 1.5 2.14 0.006 0.008 1.42 2 1 6:35 6:56 Y 16.0 16.1 -0.100
2 7:07 7:28 1.8 2.27 0.006 0.008 1.62 2.1 2 7:07 7:28 Y 16.2 16.1 0.142
3 7:39 8:00 Y 2.2 2.62 -0.4 Y 0.008 0.01 -0.002 Y 2.07 2.4 -0.33 3 7:39 8:00 Y 16.3 16.1 0.195
4 8:12 8:33 Y 1.1 1.4 -0.3 Y 0.004 0.005 -0.001 Y 1.04 1.3 -0.27 4 8:12 8:33 Y 16.2 16.1 0.104
5 8:44 9:05 Y 3.1 3.47 -0.4 Y 0.011 0.013 -0.002 Y 2.85 3.2 -0.35 5 8:44 9:05 Y 16.2 16.1 0.137
6 9:17 9:38 Y 2.4 2.39 0.0 Y 0.009 0.009 0.000 Y 2.29 2.2 0.09 6 9:17 9:38 Y 16.2 16 0.207
7 9:49 10:10 Y 2.4 2.69 -0.3 Y 0.009 0.01 -0.001 Y 2.27 2.5 -0.23 7 9:49 10:10 Y 16.2 16.1 0.115
8 10:21 10:42 Y 2.4 2.67 -0.3 Y 0.009 0.01 -0.001 Y 2.24 2.5 -0.26 8 10:21 10:42 16.2 16
9 11:03 11:24 Y 3.0 3.25 -0.3 Y 0.011 0.012 -0.001 Y 2.74 3 -0.26 9 11:03 11:24 Y 16.2 16.1 0.081
10 11:35 11:56 Y 2.8 3.01 -0.3 Y 0.010 0.011 -0.001 Y 2.58 2.8 -0.23 10 11:35 11:56 Y 16.2 16 0.220
11 12:07 12:28 Y 3.0 3.12 -0.1 Y 0.011 0.012 -0.001 Y 2.77 2.9 -0.13 11 12:07 12:28 16.3 16
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
Average = 2.5 2.7 0.256 0.01 0.010 0.001 2.32 2.53 0.22 Average = 16.200 16.070 0.122
Sd Standard Deviation = 0.14 Sd Standard Deviation = 0.001 Sd Standard Deviation = 0.132 Sd Standard Deviation = 0.10
Confidence Coefficient = 0.105 Confidence Coefficient = 0.000 Confidence Coefficient = 0.101 Confidence Coefficient = 0.074
RA - Relative Accuracy = Relative Accuracy =11.10%Relative Accuracy = RA - Relative Accuracy =1.20%
n = 9 9 9 n = 9 or RA of 1%0.13%
t0.975 = 2.306 t0.975 = 2.306 t0.975 = 2.306 t0.975 = 2.306
E.L. Relative Accuracy = 50% 7.22% EMRA EMRA 10% 1.43%
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;
c Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 2 For SO2 and NOx Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
4. Performance and Equipment Specifications
4.3 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS shall be no grater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM test data in terms of the
units of the emission standard or 10 percent of the applicable standard, whichever is greater
For SO2 emission standards between 0.30 and 0.20 lbs./MMBtu use 15 Percent of the applicable standard;
For SO2 emission standards below 0.20 lbs./MMBtu use 20 Percent of the emission standard;
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 3 For O2 and CO2 Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
12. Calculate the arithmetic difference between the RM and the CEMSS output for each run. The average of the nine (of more) data sets constitute the RA.
13.2 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS must be no grater than 1 percent O2 or CO2.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 6 For Continuous Emission Rate Monitoring Systems (CERMS)
13.2 CERMS Relative Accuracy. The RA of the CERMS shall be no greater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM's test data in terms of the nits of the emission
standard, or 10 percent of the applicable standard, which err is greater.
Up dated January 17, 2006
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
PassedPassedPassedPassed
412Thermo 42C
Servomex 1440D 411
Gadsby Unit 4 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-28-2024)
Division of Air Quality
Relative Accuracy Test Audit of
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 4
CO Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:
Acquisition System: Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:10.00 26.90
Date CO Dry CO Dry CO
8/28/2025 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm @ 15% O2 lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr.
1 6:35 6:56 Y 1.11 1.97 0.86 0.002 Y 0.63 1.1 0.47
2 7:07 7:28 Y 1.23 2.15 0.92 0.003 Y 0.69 1.2 0.51
3 7:39 8:00 1.23 2.23 0.003 0.69 1.3
4 8:12 8:33 Y 1.24 2.14 0.90 0.003 Y 0.72 1.2 0.48
5 8:44 9:05 Y 1.07 2 0.93 0.002 Y 0.60 1.1 0.50
6 9:17 9:38 Y 0.99 1.91 0.92 0.002 Y 0.57 1.1 0.53
7 9:49 10:10 Y 1.02 1.95 0.93 0.002 Y 0.58 1.1 0.52
8 10:21 10:42 1.01 1.94 0.002 0.58 1.1
9 11:03 11:24 Y 1.03 1.93 0.90 0.002 Y 0.58 1.1 0.52
10 11:35 11:56 Y 1.06 1.94 0.88 0.002 Y 0.60 1.1 0.50
11 12:07 12:28 Y 1.07 1.92 0.85 0.002 Y 0.60 1.1 0.50
12
13
14
15
16
Average = 1.09 1.99 0.90 0.62 1.12 0.50
Sd Standard Deviation = 0.03 0.018
Confidence Coefficient = 0.023 0.01
RA - Relative Accuracy =
n = 9 0 9
t0.975 = 2.306 2.306
E.L. Relative Accuracy = 11%9.22%2% 1.92%
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;
c Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 4 For Carbon Monoxide (CO) Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
applicable emission standard is used to calculate RA.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 4A For Carbon Monoxide (CO) Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
13.2 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS must be no greater than 10 percent when the average RM value is used to calculate RA, 5 percent when the applicable
emission standard is used to calculate RA, or within 5 ppmv when the RA is calculated as the absolute average difference between the RM and CEMSS plus the 2.5
percent confidence coefficient.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 6 For Continuous Emission Rate Monitoring Systems (CERMS)
13.2 CERMS Relative Accuracy. The RA of the CERMS shall be no greater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM's test data in terms of the nits of the emission
standard, or 10 percent of the applicable standard, which err is greater.
Up dated January 17, 2006
13.2 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS must be no grater than 10 percent when the average of the RM value is used to calculate RA or 5 percent when the
Passed Passed
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Thermo 48C
Gadsby Unit 4 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-28-2024)
Division of Air Quality
NSPS Relative Accuracy Performance Specification Test - CEMS Certification
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 4
SO2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
CO2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Acquisition System: Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:
Test Date SO2 Dry SO2 Dry SO2 Test Date % CO2 Dry
8/28/2025 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff 8/28/2025 RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm @ % O2 lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr. Run#Start Time End Time %c %c
1 6:35 6:56 1 6:35 6:56
2 7:07 7:28 2 7:07 7:28
3 7:39 8:00 3 7:39 8:00
4 8:12 8:33 4 8:12 8:33
5 8:44 9:05 5 8:44 9:05
6 9:17 9:38 6 9:17 9:38
7 9:49 10:10 7 9:49 10:10
8 10:21 10:42 8 10:21 10:42
9 11:03 11:24 9 11:03 11:24
10 11:35 11:56 10 11:35 11:56
11 12:07 12:28 11 12:07 12:28
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
Average = Average =
Sd Standard Deviation = Sd Standard Deviation = Sd Standard Deviation = Sd Standard Deviation =
Confidence Coefficient = Confidence Coefficient = Confidence Coefficient = Confidence Coefficient =
RA - Relative Accuracy = RA RA RA - Relative Accuracy =
n = 0 0 0 n = 0 or RA of 1%
t0.975 = t0.975 =
E.L. Relative Accuracy =
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;
c Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 2 For SO2 and NOx Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
13.2 Relative accuracy Performance Specification. The RA of the CEMSS must be not greater than 20 percent when RM is used in the denominator of Eq. 2-6
(average emissions during test are greater than 50 percent of the emission standard)or 10 percent when the applicable emission standard is used in the
denominator of Eq. 2-6 (average emissions during test are less than 50 percent of the emission standard).
Up dated January 17, 2006
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 3 For O2 and CO2 Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
12. Calculate the arithmetic difference between the RM and the CEMSS output for each run. The average of the nine (of more) data sets constitute the RA.
13.2 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS must be no grater than 1 percent O2 or CO2.
Up dated January 17, 2006
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 6 For Continuous Emission Rate Monitoring Systems (CERMS)
13.2 CERMS Relative Accuracy. The RA of the CERMS shall be no greater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM's test data in terms of the nits of the emission
standard, or 10 percent of the applicable standard, which err is greater.
Up dated January 17, 2006
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Gadsby Unit 4 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-28-2024)
Division of Air Quality
Relative Accuracy Test Audit of
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 4
NOX Analyzer:Serial No.:
O2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Acquisition System: Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:5.00 22.20
Date NOx Dry NOx Dry NOx Test Date % O2 Dry
8/28/2025 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff 8/28/2025 RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm @ 15% O2 lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr. Run#Start Time End Time %c %c
1 6:35 6:56 1.5 0.006 1.42 1 6:35 6:56 16.0
2 7:07 7:28 1.8 0.006 1.62 2 7:07 7:28 16.2
3 7:39 8:00 2.2 0.008 2.07 3 7:39 8:00 16.3
4 8:12 8:33 1.1 0.004 1.04 4 8:12 8:33 16.2
5 8:44 9:05 3.1 0.011 2.85 5 8:44 9:05 16.2
6 9:17 9:38 2.4 0.009 2.29 6 9:17 9:38 16.2
7 9:49 10:10 2.4 0.009 2.27 7 9:49 10:10 16.2
8 10:21 10:42 2.4 0.009 2.24 8 10:21 10:42 16.2
9 11:03 11:24 3.0 0.011 2.74 9 11:03 11:24 16.2
10 11:35 11:56 2.8 0.010 2.58 10 11:35 11:56 16.2
11 12:07 12:28 3.0 0.011 2.77 11 12:07 12:28 16.3
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
Average = Average =
Sd Standard Deviation = Sd Standard Deviation = Sd Standard Deviation = Sd Standard Deviation =
Confidence Coefficient = Confidence Coefficient = Confidence Coefficient = Confidence Coefficient =
RA - Relative Accuracy = Relative Accuracy = Relative Accuracy = RA - Relative Accuracy =
n = 0 0 0 n = 0 or RA of 1%
t0.975 = t0.975 = t0.975 = t0.975 =
E.L. Relative Accuracy = EMRA EMRA
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;
c Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 2 For SO2 and NOx Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
4. Performance and Equipment Specifications
4.3 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS shall be no grater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM test data in terms of the
units of the emission standard or 10 percent of the applicable standard, whichever is greater
For SO2 emission standards between 0.30 and 0.20 lbs./MMBtu use 15 Percent of the applicable standard;
For SO2 emission standards below 0.20 lbs./MMBtu use 20 Percent of the emission standard;
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 3 For O2 and CO2 Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
12. Calculate the arithmetic difference between the RM and the CEMSS output for each run. The average of the nine (of more) data sets constitute the RA.
13.2 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS must be no grater than 1 percent O2 or CO2.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 6 For Continuous Emission Rate Monitoring Systems (CERMS)
13.2 CERMS Relative Accuracy. The RA of the CERMS shall be no greater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM's test data in terms of the nits of the emission
standard, or 10 percent of the applicable standard, which err is greater.
Up dated January 17, 2006
Thermo 42C 412
Servomex 1440D 411
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Gadsby Unit 4 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-28-2024)
Division of Air Quality
NSPS Relative Accuracy Performance Specification Test - CEMS Certification
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 4
Average Emission
Dry SO2 NOX CO
lbs./MMBtu 0.009 0.002 Average % concentration
lbs./hr.2.17 0.62 CO2 O2
ppm corrected for %O2 2.33 1.10 16.21
Run 1 Enter O2 or CO2
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)5.64E-03 2.49E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 1.519E-07 6.708E-08
lbs./hr.1.42 0.63 16.00
ppm corrected for %O2 1.53 1.11 16.02
Run 2
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)6.44E-03 2.76E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 1.647E-07 7.065E-08
lbs./hr.1.62 0.69 16.24
ppm corrected for %O2 1.75 1.23 16.31 Raw Value
Run 3
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)8.26E-03 2.77E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 2.090E-07 7.000E-08
lbs./hr.2.07 0.69 16.29
ppm corrected for %O2 2.24 1.23 16.35 Raw Value
Run 4
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)4.01E-03 2.79E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 1.036E-07 7.194E-08
lbs./hr.1.04 0.72 16.20
ppm corrected for %O2 1.09 1.24 16.23 Raw Value
Run 5
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)1.13E-02 2.39E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 2.888E-07 6.120E-08
lbs./hr.2.8472 0.60 16.24
ppm corrected for %O2 3.06 1.07 16.23 Raw Value
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Raw Value
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
O2
CO2
Clear
lbs./MMBTU
Gadsby Unit 4 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-28-2024)
Division of Air Quality
NSPS Relative Accuracy Performance Specification Test - CEMS Certification
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 4
O2
CO2
Clear
lbs./MMBTU
Run 6
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)8.94E-03 2.23E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 2.305E-07 5.751E-08
lbs./hr.2.2896 0.57 16.21
ppm corrected for %O2 2.43 0.99 16.17 Raw Value
Run 7
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)8.95E-03 2.30E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 2.304E-07 5.911E-08
lbs./hr.2.27 0.58 16.22
ppm corrected for %O2 2.43 1.02 16.16 Raw Value
Run 8
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)8.72E-03 2.26E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 2.249E-07 5.840E-08
lbs./hr.2.24 0.58 16.21
ppm corrected for %O2 2.37 1.01 16.13 Raw Value
Run 9
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)1.09E-02 2.31E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 2.821E-07 5.983E-08
lbs./hr.2.74 0.58 16.18
ppm corrected for %O2 2.95 1.03 16.08 Raw Value
Run 10
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)1.02E-02 2.38E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 2.615E-07 6.111E-08
lbs./hr.2.58 0.60 16.22
ppm corrected for %O2 2.76 1.06 16.06 Raw Value
Run 11
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)1.10E-02 2.39E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 2.806E-07 6.096E-08
lbs./hr.2.77 0.60 16.26
ppm corrected for %O2 2.99 1.07 16.07 Raw Value
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Gadsby Unit 4 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-28-2024)
Calibration Error Test
Test Date August 28, 2025 O2
CS - Cal. Span 22.57
Units %
Cylinder No. Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level 0.00 0.10 0.10 0.44% Passed Cal.
Mid-level 10.51 10.53 0.02 0.09% Passed Cal.
High-level 22.57 22.55 0.02 0.09% Passed Cal.
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of CS - Cal. Span Low-Level 0.00%
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level 46.57%
100% of Cal. Span High-level 100.00%
Test Date CO2
CS - Cal. Span
Units %
Cylinder
No.
Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level
Mid-level
High-level
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of Cal. Span Low-Level
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level
100% of Cal. Span High-level
Test Date SO2
CS - Cal. Span
Units ppm
Cylinder
No.
Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level
Mid-level
High-level
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of Cal. Span Low-Level
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level
100% of Cal. Span High-level
Test Date August 28, 2025 NOx
CS - Cal. Span 9.02
Units ppm
Cylinder
No.
Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level 0.00 -0.01 0.01 0.111% Passed Cal.
Mid-level 5.00 4.95 0.05 0.599% Passed Cal.
High-level 9.02 9.02 0.00 0.033% Passed Cal.
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of Cal. Span Low-Level 0.00%
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level 55.50%
100% of Cal. Span High-level 100.00%
Test Date August 28, 2025 CO
26.9 CS - Cal. Span 10.02
10 Units ppm
Cylinder
No.
Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level 0.00 0.08 0.08 0.798% Passed Cal.
Mid-level 4.90 5.00 0.10 1.018% Passed Cal.
High-level 10.02 10.04 0.02 0.200% Passed Cal.
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of Cal. Span Low-Level 0.00%
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level 48.88%
100% of Cal. Span High-level 100.00%
Gadsby Unit 5 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-28-2024)
Reference Methods 2, 3A, 6C, 7E, 10, & 19
Source Information
Company Name PacifiCorp Gadsby
Company Contact:Joseph Betenton
Contact Phone No.(801) 220-7708
Stack Designation:Unit 5
Test & Review Dates
Test Date:8/28/2024
Review Date: 4/4/2025
Observer:Not Observed
Reviewer:Rob Leishman
Emission Limits Emission Rates
SO2 NOX CO SO2 NOX CO
lbs./MMBtu
lbs./hr. 22.2 26.9 3.371 1.016
ppm 5.0 10.00 3.459 1.712
%O2 Correction as a whole #15.00 15.00
Test Information
Stack I.D. inches
As ft^2 Y Dl H @ Cp Pbar Pq (static)
Ps
Stack Pressure
132.50 95.754 0
Contractor Information
Contact:Andrew Bruning
Contracting Company: Montrose Air Quality Services
Address: 990 W 43rd Avenue, Denver, CO 80211
Phone No.: 303-810-2168
Project No.:
8710
Division of Air Quality
Instrumental Reference Methods - Gaseous Measurements
Round
Method 19 - F factors for Coal, Oil, and Gas
Fd Fw Fc
dscf/MMBtu wscf/MMBtu scf/MMBtu Diluent
F factor used
O2
CO2
Anthracite 2
Bituminous 2
Lignite
Natural
Propane
Butane
10100
COAL
OIL
GAS
9780
9860
9190
8710
8710
8710
10540
10640
11950
320
10610
10200
10390
1970
1800
1910
1420
1040
1190
1250
Wet CEM
Correct For O2
CO2 Interference w/CO
Yes
Yes
Yes
Gadsby Unit 5 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-28-2024)
Company PacifiCorp Gadsby
Point Source Unit 5
Test Date 8/28/24
Start
Time
End
Time Run
CO
lb/hr
CO
ppm
CO
ppm@15
% O2
Unit Load
MW
Gas Flow
HSCFH
Heat
Btu/SCF Heat Input
MMBtu/hr
NOx
lb/hr
NOx
lb/MMBtu
NOx
PPM
NOx
PPM
@15% O2
O2
%
6:35 6:56 1 1.3 1.7 2.12 24 2506.4 1050 263.2 3.3 0.013 2.7 3.39 16.2
7:07 7:28 2 1.3 1.7 2.19 24.1 2496.1 1050 262.1 2.9 0.011 2.3 2.99 16.3
7:39 8:00 3 1.3 1.8 2.32 24 2490.6 1050 261.5 2.8 0.011 2.3 2.95 16.3
8:12 8:33 4 1.4 1.8 2.34 24.9 2562.8 1050 269.1 2.5 0.009 2 2.58 16.2
8:44 9:05 5 1.2 1.6 2.07 24.1 2514.3 1050 265 3.2 0.012 2.6 3.29 16.2
9:17 9:38 6 1.2 1.6 2 24.9 2535.4 1050 266.2 3.4 0.013 2.8 3.51 16.2
9:49 10:10 7 1.1 1.5 1.94 24.5 2519.8 1050 265.6 3.4 0.013 2.8 3.57 16.2
10:21 10:42 8 1.2 1.5 1.93 24.9 2547 1050 267.4 3.1 0.012 2.5 3.19 16.2
11:03 11:24 9 1.1 1.5 1.9 24 2511.1 1050 263.7 3.2 0.012 2.6 3.29 16.2
11:35 11:56 10 1.1 1.5 1.87 24.4 2519.5 1050 264.5 3.1 0.012 2.6 3.21 16.2
12:07 12:28 11 1.1 1.5 1.88 24 2504.9 1050 263 2.8 0.011 2.3 2.88 16.2
12
13
14
15
16
Gadsby Unit 5 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-28-2024)
Division of Air Quality
NSPS Relative Accuracy Performance Specification Test - CEMS Certification
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 5
SO2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
CO2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Acquisition System: Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:
Test Date SO2 Dry SO2 Dry SO2 Test Date % CO2 Dry
8/28/2024 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff 8/28/2024 RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm @ % O2 lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr. Run#
Start
Time End Time %c %c
1 6:35 6:56 1 6:35 6:56
2 7:07 7:28 2 7:07 7:28
3 7:39 8:00 3 7:39 8:00
4 8:12 8:33 4 8:12 8:33
5 8:44 9:05 5 8:44 9:05
6 9:17 9:38 6 9:17 9:38
7 9:49 10:10 7 9:49 10:10
8 10:21 10:42 8 10:21 10:42
9 11:03 11:24 9 11:03 11:24
10 11:35 11:56 10 11:35 11:56
11 12:07 12:28 11 12:07 12:28
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
Average = Average =
Sd Standard Deviation = Sd Standard Deviation = Sd Standard Deviation = Sd Standard Deviation =
Confidence Coefficient = Confidence Coefficient = Confidence Coefficient = Confidence Coefficient =
RA - Relative Accuracy = RA RA RA - Relative Accuracy =
n = 0 0 0 n = 0 or RA of 1%
t0.975 = t0.975 =
E.L. Relative Accuracy =
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;0
c Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 2 For SO2 and NOx Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
13.2 Relative accuracy Performance Specification. The RA of the CEMSS must be not greater than 20 percent when RM is used in the denominator of Eq. 2-6
(average emissions during test are greater than 50 percent of the emission standard)or 10 percent when the applicable emission standard is used in the
denominator of Eq. 2-6 (average emissions during test are less than 50 percent of the emission standard).
Up dated January 17, 2006
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 3 For O2 and CO2 Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
13.2 CEMS Relative Accuracy Perfromance Specification.
The RA of the CEMS must be no grater than 20 percent of the mean value of the reference method (RM) data. 1 percent O2 or CO2.
The results are also acceptable if the absolute value of the difference between the mean RM value and the mean CEMS value is less than or equal to 1.0 percent O2 (or CO2).
Up dated September 14, 2016
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 6 For Continuous Emission Rate Monitoring Systems (CERMS)
13.2 CERMS Relative Accuracy. The RA of the CERMS shall be no greater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM's test data in terms of the nits of the emission
standard, or 10 percent of the applicable standard, which err is greater.
Up dated January 17, 2006
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Gadsby Unit 5 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-28-2024)
Division of Air Quality
Relative Accuracy Test Audit of
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 5
NOX Analyzer:Serial No.:
O2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Acquisition System: Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:5.00 22.20
Date NOx Dry NOx Dry NOx Test Date % O2 Dry
8/28/2024 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff 9/30/2014 RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm @ 15% O2 lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr. Run#
Start
Time End Time %c %c
1 6:35 6:56 4.2 3.39 0.015 0.013 4.02 3.3 1 6:35 6:56 Y 16.3 16.2 0.060
2 7:07 7:28 3.4 2.99 0.013 0.011 3.28 2.9 2 7:07 7:28 Y 16.4 16.3 0.064
3 7:39 8:00 Y 3.2 2.95 0.2 Y 0.012 0.011 0.001 Y 3.07 2.8 0.27 3 7:39 8:00 Y 16.3 16.3 -0.028
4 8:12 8:33 Y 2.6 2.58 0.1 Y 0.010 0.009 0.001 Y 2.61 2.5 0.11 4 8:12 8:33 Y 16.2 16.2 -0.001
5 8:44 9:05 Y 3.5 3.29 0.3 Y 0.013 0.012 0.001 Y 3.44 3.2 0.24 5 8:44 9:05 Y 16.2 16.2 0.009
6 9:17 9:38 Y 3.8 3.51 0.3 Y 0.014 0.013 0.001 Y 3.70 3.4 0.30 6 9:17 9:38 Y 16.2 16.2 -0.044
7 9:49 10:10 Y 3.8 3.57 0.2 Y 0.014 0.013 0.001 Y 3.69 3.4 0.29 7 9:49 10:10 Y 16.1 16.2 -0.072
8 10:21 10:42 Y 3.4 3.19 0.2 Y 0.012 0.012 0.000 Y 3.32 3.1 0.22 8 10:21 10:42 16.1 16.2
9 11:03 11:24 Y 3.5 3.29 0.2 Y 0.013 0.012 0.001 Y 3.43 3.2 0.23 9 11:03 11:24 Y 16.1 16.2 -0.097
10 11:35 11:56 Y 3.5 3.21 0.3 Y 0.013 0.012 0.001 Y 3.44 3.1 0.34 10 11:35 11:56 16.1 16.2
11 12:07 12:28 Y 3.2 2.88 0.3 Y 0.012 0.011 0.001 Y 3.08 2.8 0.28 11 12:07 12:28 Y 16.2 16.2 -0.046
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
Average = 3.4 3.2 0.227 0.01 0.012 0.001 3.31 3.06 0.25 Average = 16.200 16.220 0.017
Sd Standard Deviation = 0.08 Sd Standard Deviation = 0.000 Sd Standard Deviation = 0.065 Sd Standard Deviation = 0.06
Confidence Coefficient = 0.061 Confidence Coefficient = 0.000 Confidence Coefficient = 0.050 Confidence Coefficient = 0.042
RA - Relative Accuracy =8.50%Relative Accuracy =8.30%Relative Accuracy = RA - Relative Accuracy =0.36%
n = 9 9 9 n = 9 or RA of 1%0.02%
t0.975 = 2.306 t0.975 = 2.306 t0.975 = 2.306 t0.975 = 2.306
E.L. Relative Accuracy = 68% EMRA EMRA 15% 1.37%
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;
c Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 2 For SO2 and NOx Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
4. Performance and Equipment Specifications
4.3 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS shall be no grater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM test data in terms of the
units of the emission standard or 10 percent of the applicable standard, whichever is greater
For SO2 emission standards between 0.30 and 0.20 lbs./MMBtu use 15 Percent of the applicable standard;
For SO2 emission standards below 0.20 lbs./MMBtu use 20 Percent of the emission standard;
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 3 For O2 and CO2 Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
12. Calculate the arithmetic difference between the RM and the CEMSS output for each run. The average of the nine (of more) data sets constitute the RA.
13.2 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS must be no grater than 1 percent O2 or CO2.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 6 For Continuous Emission Rate Monitoring Systems (CERMS)
13.2 CERMS Relative Accuracy. The RA of the CERMS shall be no greater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM's test data in terms of the nits of the emission
standard, or 10 percent of the applicable standard, which err is greater.
Up dated January 17, 2006
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
PassedPassedPassedPassed
512Thermo 42C
Servomex 1440D 511
Gadsby Unit 5 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-28-2024)
Division of Air Quality
Relative Accuracy Test Audit of
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 5
CO Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:
Acquisition System: Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:10.00 26.90
Date CO Dry CO Dry CO
8/28/2024 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm @ 15% O2 lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr.
1 6:35 6:56 Y 1.80 2.12 0.32 0.004 1.07 1.3
2 7:07 7:28 Y 1.87 2.19 0.32 0.004 Y 1.10 1.3 0.20
3 7:39 8:00 1.92 2.32 0.004 Y 1.13 1.3 0.17
4 8:12 8:33 Y 2.08 2.34 0.26 0.005 Y 1.26 1.4 0.14
5 8:44 9:05 Y 1.71 2.07 0.36 0.004 Y 1.01 1.2 0.19
6 9:17 9:38 Y 1.65 2 0.35 0.004 Y 0.99 1.2 0.22
7 9:49 10:10 Y 1.58 1.94 0.36 0.004 Y 0.94 1.1 0.16
8 10:21 10:42 Y 1.62 1.93 0.31 0.004 0.97 1.2
9 11:03 11:24 1.53 1.9 0.003 Y 0.90 1.1 0.20
10 11:35 11:56 Y 1.53 1.87 0.34 0.003 Y 0.91 1.1 0.20
11 12:07 12:28 Y 1.54 1.88 0.34 0.003 Y 0.91 1.1 0.19
12
13
14
15
16
Average = 1.71 2.04 0.33 1.02 1.20 0.19
Sd Standard Deviation = 0.03 0.022
Confidence Coefficient = 0.024 0.02
RA - Relative Accuracy =
n = 9 0 9
t0.975 = 2.306 2.306
E.L. Relative Accuracy = 17%3.53%4% 0.75%
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;
c Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 4 For Carbon Monoxide (CO) Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
applicable emission standard is used to calculate RA.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 4A For Carbon Monoxide (CO) Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
13.2 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS must be no greater than 10 percent when the average RM value is used to calculate RA, 5 percent when the applicable
emission standard is used to calculate RA, or within 5 ppmv when the RA is calculated as the absolute average difference between the RM and CEMSS plus the 2.5
percent confidence coefficient.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 6 For Continuous Emission Rate Monitoring Systems (CERMS)
13.2 CERMS Relative Accuracy. The RA of the CERMS shall be no greater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM's test data in terms of the nits of the emission
standard, or 10 percent of the applicable standard, which err is greater.
Up dated January 17, 2006
13.2 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS must be no grater than 10 percent when the average of the RM value is used to calculate RA or 5 percent when the
Passed Passed
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Thermo 48C
Gadsby Unit 5 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-28-2024)
Division of Air Quality
NSPS Relative Accuracy Performance Specification Test - CEMS Certification
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 5
SO2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
CO2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:
Test Date SO2 Dry SO2 Dry SO2 Test Date % CO2 Dry
8/28/2024 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff 8/28/2024 RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm @ % O2 lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr. Run#
Start
Time
End
Time %c %c
1 6:35 6:56 1 6:35 6:56
2 7:07 7:28 2 7:07 7:28
3 7:39 8:00 3 7:39 8:00
4 8:12 8:33 4 8:12 8:33
5 8:44 9:05 5 8:44 9:05
6 9:17 9:38 6 9:17 9:38
7 9:49 10:10 7 9:49 10:10
8 10:21 10:42 8 10:21 10:42
9 11:03 11:24 9 11:03 11:24
10 11:35 11:56 10 11:35 11:56
11 12:07 12:28 11 12:07 12:28
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
Average = Average =
Sd Standard Deviation =Sd Standard Deviation =
Confidence Coefficient =Confidence Coefficient =
RA - Relative Accuracy =RA - Relative Accuracy =
n =0 n =0 n =0 n =0 or RA of 1%
t0.975 =t0.975 =t0.975 =t0.975 =
BAF =No Bias
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;Alterative RAc Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
RATA Semiannual Test Annual
SO2 RA < 10% RA < 7.5% OR < 12ppm
ppm
CO2 - The relative accuracy for CO2 monitors shall not exceed 10 percent. See Alternative Below
Pt. 75, App. A 3.3.3 The relative accuracy for CO2 monitors shall not exceed 10 percent. Alternative - If the mean difference of the CO2
monitor measurements and the corresponding reference method measurement, calculated using Equation A7
Up dated September 25, 2017
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 6 For Continuous Emission Rate Monitoring Systems (CERMS)
13.2 CERMS Relative Accuracy. The RA of the CERMS shall be no greater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM's test data in terms of the nits of the emission
standard, or 10 percent of the applicable standard, which ever is greater.
Up dated January 17, 2006
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Gadsby Unit 5 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-28-2024)
Division of Air Quality
Relative Accuracy Test Audit of
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 5
NOX Analyzer:Serial No.:
O2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:5.00 22.20
Date NOx Dry NOx Dry NOx Test Date % O2 Dry
8/28/2024 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff 8/28/2024 RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm @ 15% O2 lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr. Run#
Start
Time
End
Time %c %c
1 6:35 6:56 4.2 0.015 0.013 4.02 1 6:35 6:56 Y 16.3 16.2 0.060
2 7:07 7:28 3.4 0.013 0.011 3.28 2 7:07 7:28 Y 16.4 16.3 0.064
3 7:39 8:00 3.2 Y 0.012 0.011 0.00073 3.07 3 7:39 8:00 Y 16.3 16.3 -0.028
4 8:12 8:33 2.6 Y 0.010 0.009 0.00070 2.61 4 8:12 8:33 Y 16.2 16.2 -0.001
5 8:44 9:05 3.5 Y 0.013 0.012 0.00104 3.44 5 8:44 9:05 Y 16.2 16.2 0.009
6 9:17 9:38 3.8 Y 0.014 0.013 0.00088 3.70 6 9:17 9:38 Y 16.2 16.2 -0.044
7 9:49 10:10 3.8 Y 0.014 0.013 0.00094 3.69 7 9:49 10:10 Y 16.1 16.2 -0.072
8 10:21 10:42 3.4 Y 0.012 0.012 0.00041 3.32 8 10:21 10:42 16.1 16.2
9 11:03 11:24 3.5 Y 0.013 0.012 0.00102 3.43 9 11:03 11:24 Y 16.1 16.2 -0.097
10 11:35 11:56 3.5 Y 0.013 0.012 0.00100 3.44 10 11:35 11:56 16.1 16.2
11 12:07 12:28 3.2 Y 0.012 0.011 0.00072 3.08 11 12:07 12:28 Y 16.2 16.2 -0.046
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
Average = 0.012 0.012 0.00083 Average = 16.2 16.222 0.017
Sd Standard Deviation =Sd Standard Deviation =0.000 Sd Standard Deviation =Sd Standard Deviation =0.06
Confidence Coefficient =Confidence Coefficient =0.000 Confidence Coefficient =Confidence Coefficient =0.042
RA - Relative Accuracy =RA =6.60%RA =RA - Relative Accuracy =0.36%
n =0 n =9 n =0 n =9 or RA of 1%0.02%
t0.975 =t0.975 =2.306 t0.975 =t0.975 =2.306
Use BAF 1.07
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;
c Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
RATA Semiannually Annual NOx Multipliers
NOX RA < 10% RA < 7.5% Old Multiplier New Multiplier
Alternative RA
For units where the average of the monitoring system measurements of NOX emission rate during the RATA
is less than or equal to 0.20 lb./MMBtu, the mean value of the NOX continuous emission monitoring system
For SO2 emission standards between 0.30 and 0.20 lbs./MMBtu use 15 Percent of the applicable standard;
specification of 10.0 percent is not achieved.
di (Rmi - CEMSi)0.001
Alterative RA Passed
Passed
Thermo 42C 512
Servomex 1440D 511
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Gadsby Unit 5 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-28-2024)
Division of Air Quality
NSPS Relative Accuracy Performance Specification Test - CEMS Certification
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 5
Average Emission
Dry SO2 NOX CO
lbs./MMBtu 0.013 0.004 Average % concentration
lbs./hr.3.37 1.02 CO2 O2
ppm corrected for %O2 3.46 1.71 16.18
Run 1 Enter O2 or CO2
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)1.53E-02 4.05E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 3.896E-07 1.032E-07
lbs./hr.4.02 1.07 16.26
ppm corrected for %O2 4.15 1.80 16.08
Run 2
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)1.25E-02 4.19E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 3.116E-07 1.043E-07
lbs./hr.3.28 1.10 16.36
ppm corrected for %O2 3.39 1.87 16.11 Raw Value
Run 3
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)1.17E-02 4.32E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 2.983E-07 1.097E-07
lbs./hr.3.07 1.13 16.27
ppm corrected for %O2 3.18 1.92 16.14 Raw Value
Run 4
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)9.70E-03 4.67E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 2.506E-07 1.207E-07
lbs./hr.2.61 1.26 16.20
ppm corrected for %O2 2.63 2.08 16.09 Raw Value
Run 5
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)1.30E-02 3.84E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 3.361E-07 9.905E-08
lbs./hr.3.4437 1.01 16.21
ppm corrected for %O2 3.54 1.71 16.09 Raw Value
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Raw Value
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
O2
CO2
Clear
lbs./MMBTU
Gadsby Unit 5 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-28-2024)
Division of Air Quality
NSPS Relative Accuracy Performance Specification Test - CEMS Certification
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 5
O2
CO2
Clear
lbs./MMBTU
Run 6
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)1.39E-02 3.70E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 3.618E-07 9.645E-08
lbs./hr.3.6957 0.99 16.16
ppm corrected for %O2 3.77 1.65 16.08 Raw Value
Run 7
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)1.39E-02 3.55E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 3.655E-07 9.308E-08
lbs./hr.3.69 0.94 16.13
ppm corrected for %O2 3.78 1.58 16.15 Raw Value
Run 8
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)1.24E-02 3.62E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 3.275E-07 9.561E-08
lbs./hr.3.32 0.97 16.10
ppm corrected for %O2 3.37 1.62 16.14 Raw Value
Run 9
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)1.30E-02 3.42E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 3.432E-07 9.015E-08
lbs./hr.3.43 0.90 16.10
ppm corrected for %O2 3.53 1.53 16.16 Raw Value
Run 10
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)1.30E-02 3.42E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 3.444E-07 9.061E-08
lbs./hr.3.44 0.91 16.08
ppm corrected for %O2 3.53 1.53 16.12 Raw Value
Run 11
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)1.17E-02 3.46E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 3.056E-07 9.015E-08
lbs./hr.3.08 0.91 16.15
ppm corrected for %O2 3.18 1.54 16.13 Raw Value
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Gadsby Unit 5 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-28-2024)
Calibration Error Test
Test Date August 28, 2024 O2
CS - Cal. Span 22.57
Units %
Cylinder No. Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level 0.00 0.06 0.06 0.27% Passed Cal.
Mid-level 10.51 10.54 0.03 0.13% Passed Cal.
High-level 22.57 22.61 0.04 0.18% Passed Cal.
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of CS - Cal. Span Low-Level 0.00%
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level 46.57%
100% of Cal. Span High-level 100.00%
Test Date CO2
CS - Cal. Span
Units %
Cylinder
No.
Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level
Mid-level
High-level
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of Cal. Span Low-Level
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level
100% of Cal. Span High-level
Test Date SO2
CS - Cal. Span
Units ppm
Cylinder
No.
Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level
Mid-level
High-level
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of Cal. Span Low-Level
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level
100% of Cal. Span High-level
Test Date August 28, 2024 NOx
CS - Cal. Span 9.02
Units ppm
Cylinder
No.
Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.000% Passed Cal.
Mid-level 5.00 4.96 0.04 0.488% Passed Cal.
High-level 9.02 8.88 0.14 1.519% Passed Cal.
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of Cal. Span Low-Level 0.00%
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level 55.50%
100% of Cal. Span High-level 100.00%
Test Date August 28, 2024 CO
26.9 CS - Cal. Span 10.02
10 Units ppm
Cylinder
No.
Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level 0.00 0.11 0.11 1.098% Passed Cal.
Mid-level 4.90 5.08 0.18 1.816% Passed Cal.
High-level 10.02 10.07 0.05 0.499% Passed Cal.
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of Cal. Span Low-Level 0.00%
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level 48.88%
100% of Cal. Span High-level 100.00%
Gadsby Unit 6 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-29-2024)
Reference Methods 2, 3A, 6C, 7E, 10, & 19
Source Information
Company Name PacifiCorp Gadsby
Company Contact:Joseph Betenton
Contact Phone No.(801) 220-7708
Stack Designation:Unit 6
Test & Review Dates
Test Date:8/29/2024
Review Date: 4/7/2025
Observer:Not Observed
Reviewer:Rob Leishman
Emission Limits Emission Rates
SO2 NOX CO SO2 NOX CO
lbs./MMBtu
lbs./hr. 22.2 26.9 2.208 0.764
ppm 5.0 10.00 2.336 1.328
%O2 Correction as a whole #15.00 15.00
Test Information
Stack I.D. inches
As ft^2 Y Dl H @ Cp Pbar Pq (static)
Ps
Stack Pressure
132.50 95.754 0
Contractor Information
Contact:Andrew Bruning
Contracting Company: Montrose Air Quality Services
Address: 990 W 43rd Avenue, Denver, CO 80211
Phone No.: 303-810-2168
Project No.:
8710
Division of Air Quality
Instrumental Reference Methods - Gaseous Measurements
Round
Method 19 - F factors for Coal, Oil, and Gas
Fd Fw Fc
dscf/MMBtu wscf/MMBtu scf/MMBtu Diluent
F factor used
O2
CO2
Anthracite 2
Bituminous 2
Lignite
Natural
Propane
Butane
10100
COAL
OIL
GAS
9780
9860
9190
8710
8710
8710
10540
10640
11950
320
10610
10200
10390
1970
1800
1910
1420
1040
1190
1250
Wet CEM
Correct For O2
CO2 Interference w/CO
Yes
Yes
Yes
Gadsby Unit 6 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-29-2024)
Company PacifiCorp Gadsby
Point Source Unit 6
Test Date 8/29/24
Start
Time
End
Time Run
CO
lb/hr
CO
ppm
CO
ppm@15
% O2
Unit Load
MW
Gas Flow
HSCFH
Heat
Btu/SCF Heat Input
MMBtu/hr
NOx
lb/hr
NOx
lb/MMBtu
NOx
PPM
NOx
PPM
@15% O2
O2
%
6:40 7:01 1 1 1.4 1.84 24.9 2421.8 1050 154.3 2.5 0.01 2.1 2.78 16.3
7:08 7:29 2 0.9 1.2 1.56 25 2429.4 1050 255.1 2.1 0.008 1.7 2.22 16.3
7:37 7:58 3 0.9 1.2 1.59 25 2421.1 1050 254.2 2 0.008 1.7 2.15 16.3
8:07 8:28 4 0.9 1.2 1.54 25.3 2458.9 1050 258 2.3 0.009 1.9 2.4 16.3
8:36 8:57 5 0.9 1.3 1.66 25 2446.3 1050 256.9 2.3 0.009 1.9 2.38 16.3
9:05 9:26 6 1 1.3 1.72 25 2440.3 1050 256.2 2.4 0.009 2 2.55 16.3
9:35 9:56 7 0.8 1.1 1.43 24.9 2435.7 1050 255.7 2.3 0.009 1.9 2.38 16.3
10:04 10:25 8 0.8 1.1 1.36 25 2444 1050 256.6 2.4 0.009 2 2.51 16.3
10:34 10:55 9 0.8 1.1 1.37 25.1 2466.1 1050 258.9 2.3 0.009 1.9 2.45 16.2
11:03 11:24 10 0.8 1.1 1.35 25 264.4 1050 258.8 2.4 0.009 2 2.56 16.2
11
12
13
14
15
16
Gadsby Unit 6 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-29-2024)
Division of Air Quality
NSPS Relative Accuracy Performance Specification Test - CEMS Certification
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 6
SO2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
CO2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Acquisition System: Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:
Test Date SO2 Dry SO2 Dry SO2 Test Date % CO2 Dry
8/29/2024 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff 8/29/2024 RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm @ % O2 lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr. Run#
Start
Time End Time %c %c
1 6:40 7:01 1 6:40 7:01
2 7:08 7:29 2 7:08 7:29
3 7:37 7:58 3 7:37 7:58
4 8:07 8:28 4 8:07 8:28
5 8:36 8:57 5 8:36 8:57
6 9:05 9:26 6 9:05 9:26
7 9:35 9:56 7 9:35 9:56
8 10:04 10:25 8 10:04 10:25
9 10:34 10:55 9 10:34 10:55
10 11:03 11:24 10 11:03 11:24
11 11
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
Average = Average =
Sd Standard Deviation = Sd Standard Deviation = Sd Standard Deviation = Sd Standard Deviation =
Confidence Coefficient = Confidence Coefficient = Confidence Coefficient = Confidence Coefficient =
RA - Relative Accuracy = RA RA RA - Relative Accuracy =
n = 0 0 0 n = 0 or RA of 1%
t0.975 = t0.975 =
E.L. Relative Accuracy =
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;0
c Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 2 For SO2 and NOx Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
13.2 Relative accuracy Performance Specification. The RA of the CEMSS must be not greater than 20 percent when RM is used in the denominator of Eq. 2-6
(average emissions during test are greater than 50 percent of the emission standard)or 10 percent when the applicable emission standard is used in the
denominator of Eq. 2-6 (average emissions during test are less than 50 percent of the emission standard).
Up dated January 17, 2006
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 3 For O2 and CO2 Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
13.2 CEMS Relative Accuracy Perfromance Specification.
The RA of the CEMS must be no grater than 20 percent of the mean value of the reference method (RM) data. 1 percent O2 or CO2.
The results are also acceptable if the absolute value of the difference between the mean RM value and the mean CEMS value is less than or equal to 1.0 percent O2 (or CO2).
Up dated September 14, 2016
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 6 For Continuous Emission Rate Monitoring Systems (CERMS)
13.2 CERMS Relative Accuracy. The RA of the CERMS shall be no greater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM's test data in terms of the nits of the emission
standard, or 10 percent of the applicable standard, which err is greater.
Up dated January 17, 2006
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Gadsby Unit 6 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-29-2024)
Division of Air Quality
Relative Accuracy Test Audit of
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 6
NOX Analyzer:Serial No.:
O2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Acquisition System: Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:5.00 22.20
Date NOx Dry NOx Dry NOx Test Date % O2 Dry
8/29/2024 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff 9/30/2014 RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm @ 15% O2 lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr. Run#
Start
Time End Time %c %c
1 6:40 7:01 Y 2.6 2.78 -0.2 Y 0.009 0.01 -0.001 Y 2.40 2.5 -0.10 1 6:40 7:01 Y 16.5 16.3 0.151
2 7:08 7:29 Y 2.2 2.22 0.0 Y 0.008 0.008 0.000 Y 2.09 2.1 -0.01 2 7:08 7:29 16.6 16.3
3 7:37 7:58 Y 2.1 2.15 0.0 Y 0.008 0.008 0.000 Y 2.00 2 0.01 3 7:37 7:58 Y 16.6 16.3 0.255
4 8:07 8:28 Y 2.3 2.4 -0.1 Y 0.009 0.009 0.000 Y 2.22 2.3 -0.08 4 8:07 8:28 Y 16.4 16.3 0.110
5 8:36 8:57 Y 2.3 2.38 0.0 Y 0.009 0.009 0.000 Y 2.21 2.3 -0.09 5 8:36 8:57 Y 16.4 16.3 0.118
6 9:05 9:26 Y 2.5 2.55 -0.1 Y 0.009 0.009 0.000 Y 2.34 2.4 -0.06 6 9:05 9:26 Y 16.5 16.3 0.165
7 9:35 9:56 Y 2.4 2.38 0.0 Y 0.009 0.009 0.000 Y 2.22 2.3 -0.08 7 9:35 9:56 Y 16.5 16.3 0.241
8 10:04 10:25 2.3 2.51 -0.2 0.009 0.009 2.21 2.4 8 10:04 10:25 Y 16.3 16.3 -0.042
9 10:34 10:55 Y 2.2 2.45 -0.2 Y 0.008 0.009 -0.001 Y 2.13 2.3 -0.17 9 10:34 10:55 Y 16.2 16.2 -0.031
10 11:03 11:24 Y 2.4 2.56 -0.2 Y 0.009 0.009 0.000 Y 2.25 2.4 -0.15 10 11:03 11:24 Y 16.2 16.2 -0.012
11 11
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
Average = 2.3 2.4 0.102 0.01 0.009 0.000 2.21 2.29 0.08 Average = 16.380 16.270 0.106
Sd Standard Deviation = 0.09 Sd Standard Deviation = 0.000 Sd Standard Deviation = 0.056 Sd Standard Deviation = 0.11
Confidence Coefficient = 0.063 Confidence Coefficient = 0.000 Confidence Coefficient = 0.043 Confidence Coefficient = 0.086
RA - Relative Accuracy = Relative Accuracy =0.00%Relative Accuracy = RA - Relative Accuracy =1.17%
n = 10 9 9 n = 9 or RA of 1%0.11%
t0.975 = 2.262 t0.975 = 2.306 t0.975 = 2.306 t0.975 = 2.306
E.L. Relative Accuracy = 47% 3.30% EMRA EMRA 10% 0.56%
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;
c Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 2 For SO2 and NOx Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
4. Performance and Equipment Specifications
4.3 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS shall be no grater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM test data in terms of the
units of the emission standard or 10 percent of the applicable standard, whichever is greater
For SO2 emission standards between 0.30 and 0.20 lbs./MMBtu use 15 Percent of the applicable standard;
For SO2 emission standards below 0.20 lbs./MMBtu use 20 Percent of the emission standard;
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 3 For O2 and CO2 Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
12. Calculate the arithmetic difference between the RM and the CEMSS output for each run. The average of the nine (of more) data sets constitute the RA.
13.2 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS must be no grater than 1 percent O2 or CO2.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 6 For Continuous Emission Rate Monitoring Systems (CERMS)
13.2 CERMS Relative Accuracy. The RA of the CERMS shall be no greater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM's test data in terms of the nits of the emission
standard, or 10 percent of the applicable standard, which err is greater.
Up dated January 17, 2006
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
PassedPassedPassedPassed
612Thermo 42C
Servomex 1440D 611
Gadsby Unit 6 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-29-2024)
Division of Air Quality
Relative Accuracy Test Audit of
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 6
CO Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:
Acquisition System: Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:10.00 26.90
Date CO Dry CO Dry CO
8/29/2024 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm @ 15% O2 lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr.
1 6:40 7:01 1.30 1.84 0.003 0.74 1
2 7:08 7:29 Y 1.33 1.56 0.23 0.003 Y 0.76 0.9 0.14
3 7:37 7:58 Y 1.35 1.59 0.24 0.003 Y 0.77 0.9 0.13
4 8:07 8:28 Y 1.31 1.54 0.23 0.003 Y 0.76 0.9 0.14
5 8:36 8:57 Y 1.33 1.66 0.33 0.003 Y 0.77 0.9 0.14
6 9:05 9:26 Y 1.37 1.72 0.35 0.003 Y 0.79 1 0.21
7 9:35 9:56 Y 1.41 1.43 0.02 0.003 Y 0.81 0.8 -0.01
8 10:04 10:25 Y 1.31 1.36 0.05 0.003 Y 0.75 0.8 0.05
9 10:34 10:55 Y 1.26 1.37 0.11 0.003 Y 0.73 0.8 0.07
10 11:03 11:24 Y 1.31 1.35 0.04 0.003 Y 0.76 0.8 0.04
11
12
13
14
15
16
Average = 1.33 1.51 0.18 0.77 0.87 0.10
Sd Standard Deviation = 0.13 0.069
Confidence Coefficient = 0.097 0.05
RA - Relative Accuracy =
n = 9 0 9
t0.975 = 2.306 2.306
E.L. Relative Accuracy = 13%2.75%3% 0.57%
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;
c Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 4 For Carbon Monoxide (CO) Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
applicable emission standard is used to calculate RA.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 4A For Carbon Monoxide (CO) Continuous Emission Monitoring Systems
13.2 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS must be no greater than 10 percent when the average RM value is used to calculate RA, 5 percent when the applicable
emission standard is used to calculate RA, or within 5 ppmv when the RA is calculated as the absolute average difference between the RM and CEMSS plus the 2.5
percent confidence coefficient.
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 6 For Continuous Emission Rate Monitoring Systems (CERMS)
13.2 CERMS Relative Accuracy. The RA of the CERMS shall be no greater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM's test data in terms of the nits of the emission
standard, or 10 percent of the applicable standard, which err is greater.
Up dated January 17, 2006
13.2 Relative accuracy. The RA of the CEMSS must be no grater than 10 percent when the average of the RM value is used to calculate RA or 5 percent when the
Passed Passed
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Thermo 48C
Gadsby Unit 6 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-29-2024)
Division of Air Quality
NSPS Relative Accuracy Performance Specification Test - CEMS Certification
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 6
SO2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
CO2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:
Test Date SO2 Dry SO2 Dry SO2 Test Date % CO2 Dry
8/29/2024 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff 8/29/2024 RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm @ % O2 lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr. Run#
Start
Time
End
Time %c %c
1 6:40 7:01 1 6:40 7:01
2 7:08 7:29 2 7:08 7:29
3 7:37 7:58 3 7:37 7:58
4 8:07 8:28 4 8:07 8:28
5 8:36 8:57 5 8:36 8:57
6 9:05 9:26 6 9:05 9:26
7 9:35 9:56 7 9:35 9:56
8 10:04 10:25 8 10:04 10:25
9 10:34 10:55 9 10:34 10:55
10 11:03 11:24 10 11:03 11:24
11 11
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
Average = Average =
Sd Standard Deviation =Sd Standard Deviation =
Confidence Coefficient =Confidence Coefficient =
RA - Relative Accuracy =RA - Relative Accuracy =
n =0 n =0 n =0 n =0 or RA of 1%
t0.975 =t0.975 =t0.975 =t0.975 =
BAF =No Bias
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;Alterative RAc Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
RATA Semiannual Test Annual
SO2 RA < 10% RA < 7.5% OR < 12ppm
ppm
CO2 - The relative accuracy for CO2 monitors shall not exceed 10 percent. See Alternative Below
Pt. 75, App. A 3.3.3 The relative accuracy for CO2 monitors shall not exceed 10 percent. Alternative - If the mean difference of the CO2
monitor measurements and the corresponding reference method measurement, calculated using Equation A7
Up dated September 25, 2017
40 CFR 60 Performance Specification 6 For Continuous Emission Rate Monitoring Systems (CERMS)
13.2 CERMS Relative Accuracy. The RA of the CERMS shall be no greater than 20 percent of the mean value of the RM's test data in terms of the nits of the emission
standard, or 10 percent of the applicable standard, which ever is greater.
Up dated January 17, 2006
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Gadsby Unit 6 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-29-2024)
Division of Air Quality
Relative Accuracy Test Audit of
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 6
NOX Analyzer:Serial No.:
O2 Analyzer:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Acquisition System:Serial No.:
Equivalent Emission Limit:5.00 22.20
Date NOx Dry NOx Dry NOx Test Date % O2 Dry
8/29/2024 RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff RM CEMS Diff 8/29/2024 RM CEMS Diff
Run#Start
Time
End
Time ppm @ 15% O2 lbs./MMBtu lbs./hr. Run#
Start
Time
End
Time %c %c
1 6:40 7:01 2.6 Y 0.009 0.01 -0.00055 2.40 1 6:40 7:01 Y 16.5 16.3 0.151
2 7:08 7:29 2.2 Y 0.008 0.008 0.00019 2.09 2 7:08 7:29 16.6 16.3
3 7:37 7:58 2.1 Y 0.008 0.008 -0.00011 2.00 3 7:37 7:58 Y 16.6 16.3 0.255
4 8:07 8:28 2.3 Y 0.009 0.009 -0.00042 2.22 4 8:07 8:28 Y 16.4 16.3 0.110
5 8:36 8:57 2.3 Y 0.009 0.009 -0.00039 2.21 5 8:36 8:57 Y 16.4 16.3 0.118
6 9:05 9:26 2.5 Y 0.009 0.009 0.00012 2.34 6 9:05 9:26 Y 16.5 16.3 0.165
7 9:35 9:56 2.4 Y 0.009 0.009 -0.00033 2.22 7 9:35 9:56 Y 16.5 16.3 0.241
8 10:04 10:25 2.3 Y 0.009 0.009 -0.00038 2.21 8 10:04 10:25 Y 16.3 16.3 -0.042
9 10:34 10:55 2.2 0.008 0.009 2.13 9 10:34 10:55 Y 16.2 16.2 -0.031
10 11:03 11:24 2.4 Y 0.009 0.009 -0.00029 2.25 10 11:03 11:24 Y 16.2 16.2 -0.012
11 11
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
Average = 0.009 0.009 0.00024 Average = 16.4 16.278 0.106
Sd Standard Deviation =Sd Standard Deviation =0.000 Sd Standard Deviation =Sd Standard Deviation =0.11
Confidence Coefficient =Confidence Coefficient =0.000 Confidence Coefficient =Confidence Coefficient =0.086
RA - Relative Accuracy =RA =2.80%RA =RA - Relative Accuracy =1.17%
n =0 n =9 n =0 n =9 or RA of 1%0.11%
t0.975 =t0.975 =2.306 t0.975 =t0.975 =2.306
No Bias
a For steam generators;b Average of three samples;
c Make sure that RM and M data are on a consistent basis either wet or dry.
RATA Semiannually Annual NOx Multipliers
NOX RA < 10% RA < 7.5% Old Multiplier New Multiplier
Alternative RA
For units where the average of the monitoring system measurements of NOX emission rate during the RATA
is less than or equal to 0.20 lb./MMBtu, the mean value of the NOX continuous emission monitoring system
For SO2 emission standards between 0.30 and 0.20 lbs./MMBtu use 15 Percent of the applicable standard;
specification of 10.0 percent is not achieved.
di (Rmi - CEMSi)0.000
Alterative RA Passed
Passed
Thermo 42C 612
Servomex 1440D 611
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Ac
t
i
v
a
t
e
R
u
n
?
Gadsby Unit 6 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-29-2024)
Division of Air Quality
NSPS Relative Accuracy Performance Specification Test - CEMS Certification
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 6
Average Emission
Dry SO2 NOX CO
lbs./MMBtu 0.009 0.003 Average % concentration
lbs./hr.2.21 0.76 CO2 O2
ppm corrected for %O2 2.34 1.33 16.40
Run 1 Enter O2 or CO2
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)9.45E-03 2.91E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 2.310E-07 7.119E-08
lbs./hr.2.40 0.74 16.45
ppm corrected for %O2 2.57 1.30 16.27
Run 2
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)8.19E-03 2.99E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 1.937E-07 7.077E-08
lbs./hr.2.09 0.76 16.59
ppm corrected for %O2 2.22 1.33 16.34 Raw Value
Run 3
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)7.89E-03 3.02E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 1.883E-07 7.218E-08
lbs./hr.2.00 0.77 16.55
ppm corrected for %O2 2.14 1.35 16.34 Raw Value
Run 4
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)8.58E-03 2.95E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 2.117E-07 7.272E-08
lbs./hr.2.22 0.76 16.41
ppm corrected for %O2 2.33 1.31 16.30 Raw Value
Run 5
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)8.61E-03 2.98E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 2.119E-07 7.336E-08
lbs./hr.2.2108 0.77 16.42
ppm corrected for %O2 2.34 1.33 16.30 Raw Value
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Raw Value
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
O2
CO2
Clear
lbs./MMBTU
Gadsby Unit 6 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-29-2024)
Division of Air Quality
NSPS Relative Accuracy Performance Specification Test - CEMS Certification
PacifiCorp Gadsby
Unit 6
O2
CO2
Clear
lbs./MMBTU
Run 6
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)9.12E-03 3.07E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 2.223E-07 7.470E-08
lbs./hr.2.3380 0.79 16.47
ppm corrected for %O2 2.48 1.37 16.26 Raw Value
Run 7
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)8.67E-03 3.16E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 2.077E-07 7.561E-08
lbs./hr.2.22 0.81 16.54
ppm corrected for %O2 2.35 1.41 16.28 Raw Value
Run 8
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)8.62E-03 2.94E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 2.199E-07 7.489E-08
lbs./hr.2.21 0.75 16.26
ppm corrected for %O2 2.34 1.31 16.06 Raw Value
Run 9
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)8.23E-03 2.84E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 2.138E-07 7.370E-08
lbs./hr.2.13 0.73 16.17
ppm corrected for %O2 2.23 1.26 16.04 Raw Value
Run 10
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)8.71E-03 2.95E-03 E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft 2.254E-07 7.631E-08
lbs./hr.2.25 0.76 16.19
ppm corrected for %O2 2.36 1.31 16.04 Raw Value
Run 11
Dry SO2 NOX CO CO2 O2
Atomic Weight 64 46 28
lbs./MMBtu (O2)E=Cd x Fd x (20.9/(20.9-%O2d))
lbs./MMBtu (CO2)E=Cd x Fc x (100 / % CO2d)
lbs./cu.ft
lbs./hr.
ppm corrected for %O2 Raw Value
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Corrected For Cal. Drift
Gadsby Unit 6 RATA RM 3A, 7E, 10, & 19 - (tested 8-29-2024)
Calibration Error Test
Test Date August 29, 2024 O2
CS - Cal. Span 22.57
Units %
Cylinder No. Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level 0.00 0.03 0.03 0.13% Passed Cal.
Mid-level 10.51 10.58 0.07 0.31% Passed Cal.
High-level 22.57 22.59 0.02 0.09% Passed Cal.
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of CS - Cal. Span Low-Level 0.00%
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level 46.57%
100% of Cal. Span High-level 100.00%
Test Date CO2
CS - Cal. Span
Units %
Cylinder
No.
Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level
Mid-level
High-level
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of Cal. Span Low-Level
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level
100% of Cal. Span High-level
Test Date SO2
CS - Cal. Span
Units ppm
Cylinder
No.
Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level
Mid-level
High-level
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of Cal. Span Low-Level
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level
100% of Cal. Span High-level
Test Date August 29, 2024 NOx
CS - Cal. Span 9.02
Units ppm
Cylinder
No.
Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.000% Passed Cal.
Mid-level 5.00 5.15 0.15 1.619% Passed Cal.
High-level 9.02 8.95 0.07 0.743% Passed Cal.
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of Cal. Span Low-Level 0.00%
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level 55.50%
100% of Cal. Span High-level 100.00%
Test Date August 29, 2024 CO
26.9 CS - Cal. Span 10.02
10 Units ppm
Cylinder
No.
Expiration
Date Cal. Gas CV- Certified
Concentration
CDir or CS -
Measured
Concentration
Difference
ACE Eq. 7E-1
Analyzer Cal.
Error
Status
Low-level 0.00 0.09 0.09 0.898% Passed Cal.
Mid-level 4.97 4.95 0.02 0.240% Passed Cal.
High-level 10.02 9.97 0.05 0.499% Passed Cal.
% of Span Sec. 8.2.1 Cal Gas Verification
0 to 20% of Cal. Span Low-Level 0.00%
40 to 60% of Cal. Span Mid-level 49.64%
100% of Cal. Span High-level 100.00%