Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutDERR-2024-012256 Stantec Consulting Services Inc. 2890 East Cottonwood Parkway; Ste 300 Salt Lake City, UT 84121 Tel: (801) 617-3200 December 24, 2020 2196 Pink Coral Circle Cottonwood, UT 84121 RE: Indoor Air Investigation Dear : As you are aware, Stantec Consulting Services Inc. (Stantec) has been retained by Praxair Distribution, Inc. (PDI) to conduct semi-annual testing of indoor air quality within your basement, as well as the sub-slab soil gas mitigation system’s off-gas emission, as directed by and coordinated with the Utah Department of Environmental Quality (UDEQ). I am writing to provide you with a summary of the most recent test results. On November 18, 2020, Stantec collected an indoor air sample from your basement using one (1) 6-liter, stainless-steel, laboratory-certified, SummaTM-type canister, equipped with a 24-hour flow rate controller provided by the Utah-certified, analytical laboratory, ALS Environmental. After a sampling timeframe of approximately 24 hours, Stantec returned to your home to close the canister valve and retrieve the canister for delivery to the laboratory. Likewise, we also collected an air sample representative of off-gas emissions associated with the sub-slab soil gas mitigation system that discharges to the atmosphere atop your residence’s roof. Immediately upon sample collection, the air samples were labeled and hand-delivered to the laboratory for quantitative analyses. All sampling activities and delivery of the samples to the laboratory were conducted under strict Chain-of-Custody (CoC) and Quality Assurance/Quality Control (QA/QC) protocol. Copies of the actual laboratory result reports are submitted to the UDEQ and are available upon request to Stantec. INDOOR AIR SAMPLING RESULTS The following table presents a summary of laboratory results for historical indoor air samples collected within your basement and analyzed by Method EPA TO-15 for Trichloroethylene (TCE, aka trichloroethene). The laboratory utilizes a Single Ion Mode (SIM) analysis for the indoor air samples to ensure that the Method Detection Limit (MDL) for TCE is below the US EPA's Residential Indoor Air Vapor Intrusion Screening Level (VISL) concentration of 0.48 micrograms per cubic meter (µg/m3). The TCE VISL serves as the UDEQ Action Level and may be used as a benchmark, indicating that supplemental investigation and/or possible mitigation might be warranted, if exceeded. Sample Name Date Collected TCE Concentration (µg/m3) Basement A 12/3/12 < 0.16 Basement A 1/24/13 0.24 Basement A 4/9/13 < 0.27 Indoor A 8/13/13 < 0.27 Indoor A 11/8/13 < 0.27 Indoor A 3/28/14 < 0.27 Indoor A 10/25/14 < 0.27 December 24, 2020 Page 2 of 3 Indoor A 5/1/15 < 0.27 Indoor A 11/13/15 <0.27 Indoor A 6/1/16 < 0.27 Indoor A 1/31/17 < 0.27 Indoor A 8/30/17 < 0.27 Indoor A 3/1/18 < 0.27 Indoor A 9/21/18 <0.27 Indoor A 3/8/19 <0.27 Indoor A 9/17/19 < 0.27 Indoor A 5/7/20 <0.27 Indoor A 11/18/20 <0.27 US EPA VISL* 0.478 *VISL = Residential Vapor Intrusion Screening Level for Indoor Air THQ=1 (µg/m3) 3.2 MITIGATION SYSTEM - ATMOSPHERIC OFF-GAS, AIR SAMPLING RESULTS The following table is a summary of laboratory results for TCE concentrations in the outside off-gas, air emission samples analyzed by Method EPA TO-15: Sample Name Date Collected TCE Concentration (µg/m3) Outflow A 12/4/12 130 Outflow A 1/7/13 40 Outflow A 2/6/13 25 Outflow A 5/3/13 27 Outflow A 8/9/13 37 Outflow A 11/8/13 30 Outflow A 3/27/17 30 Outflow A 10/24/14 30 Outflow A 5/1/15 23 Outflow A 11/13/15 24 Outflow A 6/1/16 23 Outflow A 12/6/16 24 Outflow A 8/30/17 31 Outflow A 3/1/18 14 Outflow A 9/21/18 23 Outflow A 3/8/19 11 Outflow A 9/17/19 15 Outflow A 5/7/20 18 Outflow A 11/18/20 7.8 December 24, 2020 Page 3 of 3 UDAQ Toxic Screening Level (TSL)* 597 *TSL = Toxic Screening Level for TCE Hazardous Air Pollutant (HAP) According to the UDEQ, the TSL for TCE does not constitute a standard or Action Level which a source's emissions to the atmosphere cannot exceed. Rather, TSLs are screening levels above which the UDEQ has determined that additional information should be obtained to substantiate that the model-predicted concentration would not expose sensitive individuals, animals, or vegetation to unnecessary health risks. SUMMARY CONCLUSIONS TCE was not detected during the most recent sampling event (the Method Detection Limit concentration <0.27 µg/m3 is well below the US EPA VISL 0.478 µg/m3). Data to date indicate that continued use of the sub-slab soil gas mitigation system beneath your residence should provide continued, appropriate protection to indoor air within your residence. If you have questions or concerns, please contact me at (801) 703-1927 or the UDEQ Project Manager, Mr. Joseph Katz, at (801) 536-4100. Respectfully Stantec Consulting Services Inc. John G. Russell, III, CPG Sr. Hydrogeologist, Environmental Risk Manager c. J. Katz/UDEQ J. Pacuska/PDI R. Pratt/R. Foye/Stantec V:\2037\Active\203708160\05_report_deliv\deliverables\Tenant Letters\2020\nov2020 Stantec Consulting Services Inc. 2890 East Cottonwood Parkway; Ste 300 Salt Lake City, UT 84121 Tel: (801) 617-3200 December 24, 2020 2202 Pink Coral Circle Cottonwood, UT 84121 RE: Indoor Air Investigation Dear As you are aware, Stantec Consulting Services Inc. (Stantec) has been retained by Praxair Distribution, Inc. (PDI) to conduct semi-annual testing of indoor air quality within your basement, as well as the sub-slab soil gas mitigation system’s off-gas emission, as directed by and coordinated with the Utah Department of Environmental Quality (UDEQ). I am writing to provide you with a summary of the most recent test results. On November 18, 2020, Stantec collected an indoor air sample from your basement using one (1) 6-liter, stainless-steel, laboratory-certified, SummaTM-type canister, equipped with a 24-hour flow rate controller provided by the Utah-certified, analytical laboratory, ALS Environmental. After a sampling timeframe of approximately 24 hours, Stantec returned to your home to close the canister valve and retrieve the canister for delivery to the laboratory. Likewise on this date, we also collected an air sample representative of off-gas emissions associated with the sub-slab soil gas mitigation system that discharges to the atmosphere atop your residence’s roof. Immediately upon sample collection, the air samples were labeled and hand-delivered to the laboratory for quantitative analyses. All sampling activities and delivery of the samples to the laboratory were conducted under strict Chain-of-Custody (CoC) and Quality Assurance/Quality Control (QA/QC) protocol. Copies of the actual laboratory result reports are submitted to the UDEQ and are available upon request to Stantec. INDOOR AIR SAMPLING RESULTS The following table presents a summary of laboratory results for historical indoor air samples collected within your basement and analyzed by Method EPA TO-15 for Trichloroethylene (TCE, aka trichloroethene). The laboratory utilizes a Single Ion Mode (SIM) analysis for the indoor air samples to ensure that the Method Detection Limit (MDL) for TCE is below the US EPA's Residential Indoor Air Vapor Intrusion Screening Level (VISL) concentration of 0.478 micrograms per cubic meter (µg/m3). The TCE VISL serves as the UDEQ Action Level and may be used as a benchmark, indicating that supplemental investigation and/or possible mitigation might be warranted, if exceeded. Sample Name Date Collected TCE Concentration (µg/m3) Basement B 12/3/12 1.3 Basement B 1/7/13 0.62 Basement B 4/4/13 0.39 Indoor B 8/13/13 < 0.27 Indoor B 11/8/13 0.40 Indoor B 3/28/14 < 0.27 Indoor B 10/25/14 < 0.27 December 24, 2020 Page 2 of 3 Indoor B 5/1/15 < 0.27 Indoor B 11/13/15 < 0.27 Indoor B 5/27/16 < 0.27 Indoor B 12/13/16 < 0.27 Indoor B 8/30/17 < 0.27 Indoor B 3/1/18 < 0.27 Indoor B 9/21/18 <0.27 Indoor B 3/8/19 <0.27 Indoor B 9/17/19 < 0.27 Indoor B 5/7/20 <0.27 Indoor B 11/18/20 <0.27 US EPA VISL* 0.478 *VISL = Residential Vapor Intrusion Screening Level for Indoor Air THQ=1 (µg/m3) MITIGATION SYSTEM - ATMOSPHERIC OFF-GAS, AIR SAMPLING RESULTS The following table is a summary of laboratory results for TCE concentrations in the off-gas, air emission samples analyzed by Method EPA TO-15: Sample Name Date Collected TCE Concentration (µg/m3) Outflow B 12/4/12 48 Outflow B 1/7/13 17 Outflow B 2/6/13 7.5 Outflow B 5/3/13 12 Outflow B 8/9/13 19 Outflow B 11/8/13 12 Outflow B 3/27/14 7.3 Outflow B 10/24/14 13 Outflow B 5/1/15 6 Outflow B 11/13/15 8.9 Outflow B 5/27/16 6.9 Outflow B 12/13/16 4.0 Outflow B 8/30/17 11.0 Outflow B 3/1/18 4.2 Outflow B 9/21/18 6.4 Outflow B 3/8/19 2.0 Outflow B 9/17/19 4.6 Outflow B 5/7/20 4.2 Outflow B 11/18/20 3 December 24, 2020 Page 3 of 3 UDAQ Toxic Screening Level (TSL)* 597 *TSL = Toxic Screening Level for TCE Hazardous Air Pollutant (HAP) According to the UDEQ, the TSL for TCE does not constitute a standard or Action Level which a source's emissions to the atmosphere cannot exceed. Rather, TSLs are screening levels above which the UDEQ has determined that additional information should be obtained to substantiate that the model-predicted concentration would not expose sensitive individuals, animals, or vegetation to unnecessary health risks. SUMMARY CONCLUSIONS TCE was not detected during the most recent sampling event (the Method Detection Limit concentration <0.27 µg/m3 is well below the US EPA VISL 0.478 µg/m3). Data to date indicate that continued use of the sub-slab soil gas mitigation system beneath your residence should provide continued, appropriate protection to indoor air within your residence. If you have questions or concerns, please contact me at (801) 703-1927 or the UDEQ Project Manager, Mr. Joseph Katz, at (801) 536-4100. Respectfully Stantec Consulting Services Inc. John G. Russell, III, CPG Sr. Hydrogeologist, Environmental Risk Manager c. J. Katz/UDEQ J. Pacuska/PDI R. Foye/R. Pratt/Stantec V:\2037\Active\203708160\05_report_deliv\deliverables\Tenant Letters\nov2020