Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutDSHW-2005-005313 - 0901a06880158181ATK ALLIANT TECHSYSTEMS ATK Thiokol Inc. Tel 435 863-3511 P.O. Box 707 Fax 435 863-2234 Brigham City, UT 84302-0707 4August2oo5 HAND DELIVERED 8200-FY06-ST018 05^-0<^^5S AUG 0 h 2005 Utah Department of Environmental Quality Division of Solid and Hazardous Waste UTAH DIVISION OF 288 North 1460 West ^OLID & HAZARDOUS WASTE P. O. Box 144880 Salt Lake City, Utah 84114-4880 Attention: Jeff Vandel Subject: ATK Thiokol Inc. Promontory Facility Risk Assessment Process Description and Waste Characterization Dear Mr. Vandel Attached are the ATK Thiokol Promontory Facility Risk Assessment Process Description and Waste Characterization. This is a response based on the meetings that have been held with the Division of Solid and Hazardous Waste, and the comments that were received from you department on our Risk Assessment Protocol that was previously submitted. Please contact Blair Palmer at (435) 863-2430 if you have any questions conceming these documents. My telephone number is (435) 863-2018. Sincerely G. E. Gooch, Manager Environmental Compliance ATK THIOKOL INC. PROMONTORY FACILITY PROCESS DESCRIPTION The ATK Thiokol Inc. Promontory facility is located in a remote area of east Box Elder County, Utah, approximately 30 miles northwest of Brigham City, and approximately 11 miles north of the Great Salt Lake (See Figure 1). The facility was purchased by Thiokol in 1956 and, with the exception of a 1,500- acre tract that was sold to the U.S. Air Force in 1958 and then repurchased in 1995, has been held in its entirety since purchase. A drawing showing fhe Thiokol property boundary, the location of the M-136 and M-225 treatment units, and the on-site meteorological monitoring station are shown in Figure 2. Also located within the boundary of the Promontory facility and shown on Figure 2 is the Autoliv facility (formerly Morton, Inc.). This facility produces activators for automobile air bag restraint systems. Autoliv operates as an independent commercial business and is not associated with ATK Thiokol Inc. However, explosive and propellant waste materials generated at Autoliv, are treated by the Promontory facility at the M-136 treatment unit. 1 FACILITY OPERATIONS Both hazardous and non-hazardous solid wastes are generated and managed at the facility. Hazardous wastes generated at the facility include waste such as solvents, metals (primarily aluminum and silver), and reactive wastes including 1.1 propellant, 1.3 propellant, propellant contaminated waste, reactive laboratory waste, waste solid rocket motors, propellant ingredients such as nitroglycerin, ammonium perchlorate, aluminum, cyclotetraethylenetetranitramine (HMX), and similar propellant, explosive and pyrotechnic ingredients. Reactive wastes are subjected to open burning treatment at the M-136 Unit and open burning or open detonation at the M-225 Unit. The location of the M-136 and M-225 treatment units is shown in Figure 2. 2 TERRAIN AND SITE DESCRIPTION The Promontory facility is located in the Blue Spring Valley (whioh, is bounded on the east by the Blue Spring Hills and on the west by Engineer Mountain) and the Promontory Mountain ranges respectively (see Figure 2). Within the Blue Spring Valley, the terrain is characterized by topography that slopes down from the mountain crest at an elevation of approximately 6,050 feet above mean sea level (AMSL) toward the center of the Blue Creek Valley at an elevation of 4,250 feet AMSL. As a result, the surrounding environment-extending out to 10 kilometers (km) from each treatment unit can be characterized as complex terrain. OB/OD Process Description Page 1 of 7 Blue Creek is the only perennial stream in the valley drainage basin and is the closest water body to the M-136 treatment unit. Blue Creek, originates some 15 miles north of the Promontory facility, flows along the western boundary of the facility (see Figure 2). The Promontory area is characterized as very sparsely populated rural region, with primarily dry farms and ranching activities. Low growing perennial grasses and shrubs characterize the vegetation in the area. The ecological habitat found at the Promontory facility includes many head of mule deer and large populations of various birds, rabbit, and predator species. 3 TREATMENT UNIT LOCATIONS Open burning of reactive wastes is conducted at two facilities. One, at the main facility M-136 located centrally to the two main manufacturing sites. Two, at M-225 located in a remote development location called Plant III. The location of these two treatment units (in relationship to the Promontory facility boundary) is shown in Figure 2. Detailed drawings of the M-136 and M-225 treatment units are shown in Figures 3 and 4, respectively. A description of the treatment activities that are conducted at each unit is presented in Sections 3.1 and 3.2 3.1 M-136 Treatment Activities M-136 is the primary treatment unit for conducting open burning at the Promontory facility. M-136 is a secured fenced facility within the main facility fence. The layout of the M-136 treatment unit (showing all burn stations) is provided in Figure 3. The M-136 Burn Grounds is comprise of 14 burn stations. The burn stations are located in three general areas and are aligned in an east-west direction across the treatment unit. The change in elevation between the three general areas is relatively minor (less than 20 feet per area). Burn Stations 1 through 12 are located in one treatment area that measures approximately 250 x 175 meters, are located within a 120-meter radius of the center of the area represented by the active burn stations. Burn Station 13 is located approximately 250 meters due east. Burn Station 14 is located approximately 250 meters due east of Burn Station 13. The ATK Thiokol Promontory facility conducts OB treatment at ground level in burn trays. Burning trays are constructed in several different sizes such as, 4X10, 5X16, 8X8, and 8X20. These trays are constructed from steel plate A36 grade steel ranging thicknesses of 3/8, 1/2, 3/4, and 1 inch. Lids for the burn trays are used during the wet weather months to keep moisture out of the trays. If the trays are empty, they are usually turned upside down to avoid the collection of moisture in the empty trays. If OB/OD Process Description Page 2 of 7 excess water exists in the burn trays, a sump truck is used to remove the water and then taken to the M- 705 wastewater treatment facility. The trays may be lined with soil to facilitate burning operations, however, most trays do not contain soil during the burn event. The number of trays at each burn station varies. Burn stations 1 through 12 typically have a maximum of 15 trays. Burn Station 13 typically has a maximum of 6 trays. Burn station 14 is used to open burn motors and does not have a burn tray. Operation of this station is described below. Trays may be moved between stations as needed. The M-136 Burn Grounds also has three specially designed disposal units that are used to handle the disposal of rocket motor igniters, small rocket motors, and other items that have the potential to become propulsive. These disposal units are the clamshell disposal tray, sandbox disposal tray, and small motor disposal vaults which are used to contain the propulsive force of the igniters and small rocket motors, but allow for safe disposal. The Clamshell Disposal tray is used for the disposal of closed end rocket motor igniters, and other items that have the potential to be propulsive. It is a square welded box 1-inch thick, A36 steel plate with a vented lid that enables the igniters to be burned, while safely containing the propulsive energy. The Sandbox Disposal tray is used for the disposal of open-end rocket motor igniters, and other items that have the potential to be propulsive. It is constructed of 1-inch thick A36 steel plate welded into a square box that is filled with sand, and has four 1-inch thick steel tubes sitting on end in the sand. The rocket motor igniters are placed in the tubes allowing the exhaust to vent out of the open end of the steel tubes. Steel bars are then slid into the end of the exposed tubes to safely contain the igniters. The two Small Motor Disposal Vaults are constructed from a concrete 10x10 foot sump filled with sand. The small rocket motors such as the STAR motor are placed into the sand with the aft end exposed perpendicular to the ground. The motors are then burned with the propulsive force directed into the concrete sump and the sand. These small motor disposal vaults are located in burn station 9. Large-scale obsolete rocket motors are open burned at Burn Station 14. The rocket motor is positioned near Station 14 and offloaded by a mobile crane. The obsolete motor is placed on sand or wooden blocks in station 14. Systems of Linear Shaped Charges (LSC) are then placed on the rocket motor to split the rocket motor case, rendering it non-propulsive allowing the open burning of the rocket motor while it is still being burned within the existing rocket motor case. This also allows the rocket motor case to act as the "burn tray" for the burning propellant. OB/OD Process Description Page 3 of 7 The firing stanchions electrical circuits for each burn station are buried underground throughout the Burning Grounds. Burn Stations 1 through 12 contain a multiple firing stanchions (firing posts) for each burn station. Burn Stations 13 and 14 have a single firing stanchion for each burn station. The electrical components for the relays, power supply, etc. are located in Bunker M-136. A heavy steel pylon is located in each firing stanchion containing the ignition wire. This steel pylon is to protect the electrical equipment from the intense heat generated during the open burning event. An electrical igniter is placed in a minimum of one tray for each firing stanchion for the burn event. Several safety interlocks are in place to prevent inadvertent ignition of the system while operators are in the Burning Grounds. Ignition of all the burning pans is completely remote and controlled by a system of switches in the M-136 control bunker. Before initiating a burn, the resistance of each circuit is tested to ensure all of the connections have been made properly. Pressing the System Activation button activates a warning siren. A siren will sound for approximately 40 seconds and the ignition system is then armed and ready to fire. The ignition switches located in the control bunker can then ignite the rows and stanchions that are selected. Generally, all firing stanchions that contain waste to be burned are ignited consecutively with only a few minuets delay between ignitions of firing stanchions. The burn is observed and recorded in the control bunker via a closed circuit television system. No entrance is allowed into the M-136 Burn Grounds during the burning process. After a burn, a 12-hour waiting period is normally required prior to entering the Grounds. Entrance is then permitted and a thorough check for abnormalities that may have occurred during the burn is done. This check is done looking for reactive material that was not completely treated and may have left the burn trays during the burn event, or resulted from an unplanned detonation. Any unbumed reactive material is collected and placed in the nearest tray to be re-burned. A forklift is then used to carry and dump the trays containing the burn ash to the Industrial Waste Trench (IWT) located in the far east end of the M-136 Burn Grounds. If a burn event occurs at the end of the working week such as Thursday, the ash generally is not transported to the IWT until the beginning of the next workweek. A forklift or a backhoe is used to carry the large-scale obsolete rocket motor cases for disposal in the IWT. The maximum allowable treatment quantity limits per burn station per event at Burn Stations 1 through 13 are: (1) HMX and/or RDX = 500 pounds, (2) neat 1.1 propellant/contaminated materials = 20,000 pounds, and (3) neat 1.3 propellant/contaminated materials = 50,000 pounds. The maximum limit for treating motors at Burn Station 14 is 50,000 pounds per event. The maximum quantity of waste that may be burned at M-136 is 106,500 lbs/day. The Utah Division of Air Quality (UDAQ) established this limit based on HCl emissions. OB/OD Process Description Page 4 of 7 Open burning at M-136 can occur once a day, five days a week (Tuesday through Saturday). However, treatment usually takes place 3 days a week (Tuesday through Thursday) during the afternoon hours when dispersion parameters are most favorable. When wind velocity exceeds 15 miles per hour, disposal by burning cannot occur. No treatment activities are conducted on Sunday or Monday unless a significant safety issue is present. Disposal operations are normally conducted between the hours of 1000 and 1800 hours. Waste material is delivered to the Burn Grounds and packaged in a variety of containers and sizes including but not limited to super sacks, conductive/static dissipative bags, and buckets. The Bacchus waste is received in conductive/static dissipative bags and cardboard/wood containers. Autoliv waste is received in high-density polyethylene bags and cardboard containers. Some waste materials are desensitized prior to transporting to the M-136 Burn Grounds with shingle oil, diesel fuel, or triacetin. The requirement to desensitize is identified in the waste profile system. This is done to ensure the safe handling of static sensitive materials. Material delivered to M-136 may be offloaded from the vehicle into the burn trays by hand, knuckle-boom- crane, or by forklift. The vehicle is parked next to the receiving tray, then the appropriate side rails on the trailer are lowered and the web belts are removed if necessary allowing the material to be offloaded and placed into the burn tray. Typical waste treated at M-136 include but are not limited to 1.1 propellant, 1.3 propellant, propellant contaminated waste, reactive laboratory waste, waste solid rocket motors, propellant ingredients such as nitroglycerin, ammonium perchlorate, aluminum, cyclotetraethylenetetranitramine (HMX), and similar propellant, explosive and pyrotechnic ingredients. Similar wastes are also received from Autoliv, ATK Thiokol Bacchus, and on rare occasion from other Department of Defense/government facilities. All wastes received from off-site such as Autoliv and Bacchus waste are burned within 24 hours. Open burning of reactive waste can be conducted at any station identified 1-13. However, our operating convention is to open burn reactive laboratory waste at station 13, although some laboratory wastes such as propellant test loafs may be burned at stations 1 through 12. Operation of station 14 has been described previously. Reactive wastes with listed EPA waste numbers are identified, and isolated from other material enabling the ash to be collected and shipped offsite for disposal. F003 Contaminated Ash is not required to be collected and shipped, as it is exempted under the Hazardous Waste Identification Rule. OB/OD Process Description Page 5 of 7 3.2 M-225 Treatment Unit The M-225 treatment unit receives small amounts of the reactive waste materials from the Plant III propellant development area. These materials are treated via open burning or open detonation. M-225 is surrounded with an 8-foot high chain link fence. The open burning treatment quantities are limited to 500 pounds per tray of neat propellants, and 1000 pounds per tray of propellant contaminated material. The maximum quantity of waste that may be treated is 1500 lbs/day. The open detonation treatment quantity is limited to 500 pounds per event. The layout of M-225 is shown in Figure 4. Within the M-225 Burn Grounds are four burn stations with one burn stanchion in each station, and one tray per station. Unlike M-136 operations the trays at M-225 are not moved from one burn station to another. Burn tray construction is comparable to those used in the M-136 Burn Grounds. There are two soil lined burns trays and two unlined burn trays that are used for open burning at M-225. The two soil lined burn trays are for treatment of high-energy wastes and composite propellant waste. The other two trays are for treatment of listed and miscellaneous reactive wastes. Treatment activities at M-225 are very similar to the operations at M-136 with only a few differences. Usually, treatment takes place only once or twice per month and involves small quantities (600 pounds or less) of waste materials. During the burn event a burn tray is ignited and allowed to burn down, and then the next tray is ignited. This routine is followed until all the trays have been burned completing the monthly burn event. The re-entry waiting time following a burn event at M-225 is 16 hours. Open detonation is conducted at one location within the M-225 fenced area. Detonation pits are prepared by using a backhoe or other equipment. Soon after, the reactive wastes are then placed into the pit and detonated. The M-225A building is the control bunker that contains the system for firing the igniters that are placed in the burn trays. The firing system functions the same as the M-136 process that was previously described. The reactive wastes treated by open burning at M-225 include neat double base (1.1) propellants and composite propellants (1.3), as well as, reactive contaminated materials such as cloth and paper wipes, metal containers, plastics, and propellant ingredients. Reactive wastes are collected in a variety of containers and sizes including but not limited to super sacks, and buckets lined with conductive/static dissipative bags that may contain desensitized ingredients that are the same as those used for wastes at M-136. OB/OD Process Description Page 6 of 7 Ash resulting from the treatment of reactive wastes with listed EPA waste numbers is collected and shipped for offsite disposal. All other ash is sent for disposal in the M-136 IWT. The burn tray that contains the reactive wastes with listed EPA waste numbers remains covered except when a burn event is occurring. Accumulation of water in the burn trays at the M-225 burn grounds has not been an issue since two of the trays contain soil, one tray is covered, and the other tray receives sufficient evaporation. OB/OD Process Description Page 7 of 7 ATK Thiokol Promontory Plant OB/OD Waste Characterization The wastes open bumed at M-136 and M-225 are classified into company-defined reactive categories, delineated in Table 1. In order to facilitate the safe handling ofthese reactive wastes, we fiirther characterize these materials into waste profiles. Each waste profile is addressed with specific, in-house handling and disposal instructions in order to avoid potential accidents fi'om mishandling ofthese highly energetic materials. Table 2 contains the profile reference number and waste characterization for each reactive category. A description ofthe acronyms used in this table is found in Table 4. TABLE 1 Reactive Waste Categories A i Class 1.3 Composite Propellant Without HMX, RDX, or CXM-3 B ! Class 1.3 Composite Propellant With HMX, RDX, or CXM-3 C i Class 1.1/1.3 Nitrate Ester Containing Materials D j High Explosive Materials I— E Class 1.3 Pyrotechnic, llluminants. Metal Powders, or Autoliv ASP Products ' F ' Oxidizers (Does Not hiclude High Explosives Such as HMX, RDX, or CXM-3 G • Development Material - R&D Lab Use Only / Indicate Suspected Category A-F H ! Unique Waste - Indicate Disposal Profile Number Below: PR15 Aziridine cured aluminized HC polymer HC (CTPB) Polymer with Antioxidants/Chelating agents/Peroxide or acid scavenger additives; Aziridine curatives; Plasticizers: DOA, DOS, IDP, Polybutene; Ammonium Perchlorate; Aluminum powder; Bum rate catalysts: Iron oxide, aluminum oxide, iron linoleate; epoxy additives OB/OD Waste Characterization Page 1 of22 TABLE 2 Waste CharacterizatioD Reac^vity Groiqp A A A A A A FroIHe Nwnjber PR17 PRI 9 PR21 PR22 PR23 PRS6 Geaeral DescriptJon GAP KP boron propellant Aluminized HB, HC or HA polymer - propellant Aluminized HTPB, isocyanate (with catocene) - propellant Aluminized HTPB, isocyanate (no catocene) - propellant Low smoke HTPB propellant without nitramines AP melt pour, no RDX or aluminum, (PAX- 24 and similar) Materials GAP (Glycidal Azide Polymer); Isocyanate Curatives or Processing aids: IPDI, DDI, N-100, TMXDI, ODI; Boron; Potassium Perchlorate HB (PBAN), HC (CTPB) Polymer or HA (PBAA) Polymer with Antioxidants; Epoxy curatives; Plasticizers: DOA, DOS, IDP, Oleic Nitrile; Ammonium Perchlorate; Aluminum powder; Bum rate catalysts: Iron oxide, aluminum oxide; Thixotropic Powder; Stabilizers: PBNA (phenyl-beta-napthylamine), TDPA (thiodiphenylamine), DPPDA (N, N'-Bis(l,4-dimethyl pentyl) para- phenylenediamine), MNA (n-methyl p-nitroaniline); Cure Catalysts: Chromium Octoate HTPB Polymer with Antioxidants/Chelating agents/Peroxide or acid scavenger additives; Isocyanate Curatives or Processing aids: IPDI, DDI, N-100, TMXDI, ODI; Cure catalysts; TPB, MA, TPTC; Ammine based bonding agents (TEP ANOL, TEP AN, TET); Plasticizers: DOA, DOS; Ammonium Perchlorate; Aluminum powder; Bum rate catalysts: Catocene, Ferrocene HTPB Polymer with Antioxidants/Chelating agents/Peroxide or acid scavenger additives; Isocyanate Curatives or Processing aids: IPDI, DDI, N-lOO, TMXDI, ODI; Cure catalysts: TPB, MA, TPTC; Bonding agents: difunctional aziridines (HX-752, PFAZ-752), ammine based bonding agents (TEPANOL, TEP AN, TET); Plasticizers: DOA, DOS, IDP, Oleic Nitrile, DOZ; Ammonium Perchlorate; Aluminum powder; Bum rate catalysts: Iron oxide, aluminum oxide; Epoxy resin additives HTPB Polymer with Antioxidants/Chelating agents/Peroxide or acid scavenger additives; Isocyanate Curatives or Processing aids: IPDI, DDI, N-100, TMXDI, ODI; Cure catalysts: TPB, MA, TPTC; Bonding agents: difunctional aziridines (HX-752, PFAZ-752), ammine based bonding agents (TEPANOL, TEP AN, TET); Plasticizers: DOA, DOS, IDP, Oleic Nitrile; Ammonium Perchlorate; Aluminum powder, carbon black, zirconium carbide; Bum rate catalysts: Iron oxide, aluminum oxide. Ferric Floride; Bum rate suppressant: oxamide 2-,4-dinitoanisole; n-methyl p-nitroaniline; Ammonium Perchlorate OB/OD Waste Characterization Page 2 of 22 TABLE2 Waste Characterization ReMivity Grenp A A B B B B ihtim» Nnmber PRS 8 PR50 PR12 PR24 PRS 7 PRS 9 General Descr^rtion R & D lab use only Talley Defense Systems Aluminized HTPB with nitramines & isocyantes Low smoke HTPB propellant with nitramines AP&RDX/HMX (PAX 2 land similar) R & D lab use only(HMX, RDX, CL-20) Matoials Oxidizers (AP, AN, KP, NaNOS, KNOS, ADN, KDN); Inert or energetic class 1.3 polymer (Butadiene family, GAP, oxetanes); Curing agents (isocyanates, epoxies, aziridines); Bonding agents (ammine based, aziridine based); Metal fuel and other fuel (aluminum, magnesium, alum/mag alloys, carbon, ZrC); Inert or energetic class 1.3 plasticizers (DOA, DOS, DOZ, IDP, GAP, polybutene); Cure Catalysts (TPB, TPTC, DBTDL, MA); Ballistic Catalysts (Fe203, A1203, Iron Linoleate, Catocene, Ferrocene); Antioxidants, chemical stabilizers Cariiflex IR-S09; Ammonium Nitrate; DOZ; Pepton65; Carbon Black; p-Quinone dioxime; Iron Blue; Sulfer HTPB Polymer with Antioxidants/Chelating agents/Peroxide or acid scavenger additives; Isocyanate Curatives or Processing aids: IPDI, DDI, N-100, TMXDI, ODI; Cure catalysts: TPB, MA, TPTC; Bonding agents: difunctional aziridines (HX-752, PFAZ-752), ammine based bonding agents (TEPANOL, TEP AN, TET); Plasticizers: DOA, DOS, EDP, Oleic Nitrile; Ammonium Perchlorate; Aluminum powder; Bum rate catalysts: Iron oxide, aluminum oxide. Ferric Fluoride; Nitramines: RDX, HMX HTPB Polymer with Antioxidants/Chelating agents/Peroxide or acid scavenger additives; Isocyanate Curatives or Processing aids: IPDI, DDI, N-100, TMXDI, ODI; Cure catalysts: TPB, MA, TPTC; Bonding agents: difunctional aziridines (HX-752, PFAZ-752), ammine based bonding agents (TEPANOL, TEP AN, TET); Plasticizers: DOA, DOS, IDP, Oleic Nitrile; Ammonium Perchlorate; Aluminum powder, carbon black, zirconium carbide; Bum rate catalysts: Iron oxide, aluminum oxide. Ferric Fluoride; Bum rate suppressant: oxamide; Nitramines: RDX, HMX HMX; RDX; 2-,4-dinitoanisole; n-methyl p-nitroaniline; Ammonium Perchlorate Oxidizers (AP, AN, KP, NaNOS, KN03, ADN, KDN); Inert or energetic class 1.3 polymer (Butadiene family, GAP, oxetanes); Curing agents (isocyanates, epoxies, aziridines); Bonding agents (ammine based, aziridine based); Metal fuel and other fiiel (aluminum, magnesium, alum/mag alloys, carbon, ZrC); Inert or energetic class 1.3 plasticizers (DOA, DOS, DOZ, IDP, GAP, polybutene); Cure Catalysts (TPB, TPTC, DBTDL, MA); Ballistic Catalysts (Fe20S, A1203, Iron Linoleate, Catocene, Ferrocene); Antioxidants, chemical stabilizers; Nitramines (HMX, RDX, CXM-3, CL-20) OB/OD Waste Characterization Page 3 of22 TABLE2 Wiffite Charactai3»tion Reactivity Gronp B B C C c c c TrttOe NuBber PR40 PR51 PR7 PR29 PRSO PRSl PR32 General Descrqrtion R & D lab use only Aluminized HTPB Class 1.3 Propellants, with nitramines, isocyanate cured. NG based lacquers NG crosslinked double based, depleted MNA NG crosslinked double based - nitramines Nitramines & AP, NG double based NG contaminated waste Materials Oxidizers (AP, AN, KP, NaNOS, KNOS, ADN, KDN); Inert or energetic class 1.3 polymer (Butadiene family, GAP, oxetanes); Curing agents (isocyanates, epoxies, aziridines); Bonding agents (ammine based, aziridine based); Metal fuel and other fuel (aluminum, magnesium, alum/mag alloys, carbon, ZrC); Inert or energetic class 1.3 plasticizers (DOA, DOS, DOZ, EDP, GAP, polybutene); Cure Catalysts (TPB, TPTC, DBTDL, MA); Ballistic Catalysts (Fe20S, A120S, Iron Linoleate, Catocene, Ferrocene); Antioxidants, chemical stabilizers; Nitramines (HMX, RDX, CXM-3, CL-20) HTPB Polymer with Antioxidants/Chelating agents/Peroxide or acid scavenger additives; Isocyanate Curatives or Processing aids: IPDI, DDI, N-100, TMXDI, ODI; Cure catalysts: TPB, MA, TPTC; Bonding agents: difunctional aziridines (HX-752, PFAZ-752), ammine based bonding agents (TEPANOL, TEP AN, TET); Plasticizers: DOA, DOS, EDP, Oleic Nitrile; Ammonium Perchlorate; Aluminum powder; Bum rate catalysts: Iron oxide, aluminum oxide. Ferric Fluoride; Nitramines: RDX, HMX Methylene Chloride; Acetone; NG (Nitroglycerin); PEG polymer; NC (Nitrocellulose); Stabilizers (MNA, 2-NDPA, 4-NDPA) NG (Nitroglycerin); Stabilizers (2-NDPA, 4-NDPA); Isocyanate Curatives or Processing aids: IPDI, HDI, N-100, N-3200 ; Cure catalysts: TPB; NC (Nitrocellulose); Polyether/Polyester Polymers ; Ammonium Perchlorate; Aluminum powder; Carbon Black; Nitramines (HMX,RDX); Mixed acid; Soda Ash NG (Niti-oglycerin); Stabilizers (MNA, 2-NDPA, 4-NDPA); Isocyanate Curatives or Processing aids: IPDI, HDI, N-100, N-S200; Cure catalysts: TPB; NC (Niti-ocellulose); Polyether/Polyester Polymers; Ammonium Perchlorate; Aluminum powder; Carbon Black; Nitramines (HMX,RDX); Mixed acid; Soda Ash NG (Nitroglycerin); Stabilizers (2-NDPA, 4-NDPA); Inert Plasticizers (triacetin); Resorcinol; NC (Nitrocellulose); Ammonium Perchlorate; Aluminum powder; Nitramines (HMX,RDX) Triacetin; NG (Niti-oglycerin); Methylene Chloride; Acetone OB/OD Waste Characterization Page 4 of22 TABLE 2 Waste Characterization Reactivity Gveqp c c c c Nimber PR41 PR42 PR47 PR55 General Description R & D lab use only R & D lab use only Pelletized nitrocell.(PNC) heptane wetted Developmental Material - R&D Lab use only / suspected group C Class 1.3 Materials Oxidizers (AP, AN, KP, NaNOS, KNOS, ADN, KDN); Niti-amines (HMX, RDX, CXM-3, CL-20); Inert polymer (Polyethers, Polyesters); Energetic polymers (GAP, PGN, Oxetanes); Energetic Gel Polymers (NC, PNC, CDN, nih-ated carbohydrates); Isocyanate Curatives or Processing aids: IPDI, ODI, HDI, N-100, N-3200, DDI, PAPl; Metal fiiel and other fliel (aluminum, magnesium, alum/mag alloys, carbon, aluminum trihydride [Alane]); Energetic plasticizers (nitrate esters, NENAs); Inert plasticizers (Polybutene, Triacetin); Cure Catalysts (TPB, TPTC, DBTDL, MA); Ballistic Catalysts and stabilizers (TPB, carbon black); Chemical stabilizers (MNA, 2-NDPA, 4-NDPA) and antioxidants Oxidizers (AP, AN, KP, NaNOS, KN03, ADN, KDN); Nitramines (HMX, RDX, CXM-3, CL-20); Inert polymer (Polyethers, Polyesters); Energetic polymers (GAP, PGN, Oxetanes); Energetic Gel Polymers (NC, PNC, CDN, nitrated carbohydrates); Isocyanate Curatives or Processing aids: IPDI, HDI, N-100, N-S200; Metal fuel and other fuel (aluminum, magnesium, alum/mag alloys, carbon); Energetic plasticizers (nitrate esters, NENAs); Inert plasticizers (Polybutene, Triacetin); Cure Catalysts (TPB, TPTC, DBTDL, MA); Ballistic Catalysts and stabilizers (TPB, carbon black); Chemical stabilizers (MNA, 2-NDPA, 4- NDPA) and antioxidants PNC (Pelletized Nitro cellulose); Heptane Oxidizers (AP, AN, KP, NaNOS, KNOS, ADN, KDN); Nitramines (HMX, RDX, CXM-S, CL-20); Inert polymer (Polyethers, Polyesters); Energetic polymers (GAP, PGN, Oxetanes); Energetic Gel Polymers (NC, PNC, CDN, nitrated carbohydrates); Isocyanate Curatives or Processing aids: IPDL HDI, N-lOO, N-3200; Metal fuel and other fuel (aluminum, magnesium, alum/mag alloys, carbon); Energetic plasticizers (nitrate esters, NENAs); Inert plasticizers (Polybutene, Triacetin); Cure Catalysts (TPB, TPTC, DBTDL, MA); Ballistic Catalyst - containing lead; Chemical stabilizers (MNA, 2-NDPA, 4-NDPA) and antioxidants OB/OD Waste Characterization Page 5 of22 TABT,F, 2 Waste Charactoization ««w#p|ty Gnuf D D D D D D D D D D D D Nnndier PR4 PRS PR9 PRM PRI 6 PR20 PRS3 PR35 PR43 PR44 PR48 PR49 General Description TATB& intermediate ADN contaminated Aluminum/teflon CL-20 recrystalization ETPE gun propellant Nitramines (HMX, RDX CL-20) Nitroguanidine HMX & RDX (PAX -2A and similar) HMX or RDX (PAX-S or similar) R & D lab use only Primary explosive (no lead) Primary explosive (with lead) Materials TATB (l,3,5-ti-iamino-2,4,6-tinniti-obenzene); TETNB (l,S,5-triethoxy-2,4,6-tinitrobenzene) Intermediate 2; TNPG (1,3,5-trinitrophloroglucinol) Intermediate 1; Methanol; Ethanol; TEOF (Triethyl-orthoformate); Hydrochloric Acid; Sodium Nitrite; Sodium Nitrate; Sodium Chloride; Phloroglucinol (Benzene-1,3,5-triol ADN Teflon (PTFE); Aluminum Isopropanol; Ethyl Acetate; Benzyl formate; Stan Plas-100; CL-20 Acetone; Ethyl Acetate; Niti-amines (RDX, HMX, CL-20); Energetic Binders (CE-BAMO, BAMO/GAP, BAMO/AMMO, BAMO/NMMO); Nitiro guanidine; Carbazole dioxazine violet; TEX Nitramines (HMX, RDX, CL-20) Nitroguanidine HMX; RDX; BDNPA/F; CAB; Zonyl fluoroadditive (chemical makeup similar to Teflon) Niti-amines (HMX or RDX); BDNPA/F; CAB; Zonyl fluoroadditive (chemical makeup similar to Teflon); Aluminum Niti-amines (HMX, RDX, CXM-3, CL-20); Nitro aromatics (TNT, HNS, nitro anisoles & phenols); PETN; Oxidizers (AP,AN, KP, NaNOS, KNOS); Inert binders/fillers (plastics, rubbers, waxes, carbon); Metal fuels (aluminum, magnesium, alum/mag alloys, Zirconium, Titanium); Energetic plasticizers (A/F, niti-ate esters); Energetic Binders (nitrocellulose, BAMO/AMMO); Chemical stabilizers (MNA, 2-NDPA, 4-NDPA) and antioxidants Water/Glycol mixture; Non-lead containing primary explosives (DDNP, Tetracene, Styphnic Acid, Sodium Picramate); Non-lead containing metal styphnate complexes; Non-lead containing metal picramate complexes; CL-20 based primary explosive formulations that do not contain water reactive metals Lead containing primary explosives (Lead Styphnate [44% Pb], Lead Azide [71% Pb]); Metallic Fuels (Zirconium, Titanium, Aluminum, Magnesium); Oxidizers (AP, AN, KP, KNOS, NaNOS); Inert Binders/fillers (plastics, rubbers, waxes, carbon) OB/OD Waste Characterization Page 6 of22 TABLE2 Waste Characterization RMCttvj^ Gr^p D D E E E E E E E E E lumber PR52 PR54 PRI PR5 PR6 PRll PRIS PR26 PR27 PR28 PR45 G^wral Description Magnesium Teflon and Viton or thermoplastic Primary Explosives that do not contain lead but contain water reactive metals Tin, indium, bismuth based reactives Moisture resistant black powder llluminants - Mag, KCL, strontium nitrate Boron potassium niti-ate (BKNOS) Cesium & potassium based llluminants Mag & AP based llluminants Magnesium, potassium perchlorate, strontium niti-ate - illuminant Magnesium & sodium nitrate illuminant R & D lab use only Materials Acetone; Teflon (PTFE); Viton A; Thermoplastic (poly- styrene, PVC, etc.); Magnesium; Dimethyl phalate (DMP); Iron Oxide; Graphite Kerosene; Diesel fuel; Shingle Oil; MIC based primary explosive formulations that contain water reactive metals; CL-20 based primary explosive formulations that contain water reactive metals Tin; Indium; Bismuth; Potassium Perchlorate; Ethanol; Potassium Nitrate; Potassium Perchlorate; Phenolphthalein; Poly(Vinyl Acetate); Ethyl Cellulose Magnesium; Potassium Perchlorate; Strontium Nitrate; Hexachlorobenzene; Polyvinyl Chloride; Asphaltum; Linseed Oil; Dextrin; Caster Oil Boron; Potassium Nitrate; Nylon; Graphite CsNOS; KNOS; Witco Resin; Iron Oxide; Hexamine; Silicon; Boron; ERL0510; MgCOS Magnesium; Ammonium Perchlorate; R45M; IPDI Curative; TPB; DOA; Anthracene; Iron Oxide Magnesium; Potassium Perchlorate; Strontium Nitrate; Hexachlorbenzene; Polyvinyl Chloride; Asphaltum; Linseed Oil; Dextrin; Caster Oil Magnesium; Sodium Nitrate; Witco Polyester Resin; Epoxy Curative; Iron Linoleate; Succinic Acid Oxidizers (AP, AN, KP, NaNOS, KNOS, (SrN0S)2, metal peroxides, oxides, Cu2(OH)3NOS, Teflon); Inert or energetic class 1.3 Polymers; Curatives: IPDI, HDI, N-100, N-S200, Epoxies; Metal fuels (aluminum, magnesium, alum/mag alloys, Zr, B, Si); Other fuels (sulfur, carbon, phenolphthalein, organic nitrates, tetrazoles, metal hydrides); Inert or energetic plasticizers; Cure Catalysts (TPB, TPTC, DBTDL, MA); Ballistic Catalysts and stabilizers (TPB, carbon black); Chemical stabilizers (MNA, 2-NDPA, 4- NDPA) and antioxidants OB/OD Waste Characterization Page 7 of 22 TABLE 2 Waste Characterisation Reactivi^; Qrmp E F G G G G H H Profile PR46 PRIO PR2 PRI 8 PRS4 PR5S PRS PR25 General Desaiption Various metal powders < 15 micron AP ETPE energetic thermo Glycidal Azide Oxetanes Peroxide forming chemicals Poly Oxetane Iron linoleate contaminated cotton Materials Calcium powder; Magnesium powder; Lithium powder; Strontium powder; Zirconium powder; Zinc powder; Titanium Dibromide powder; Cupric oxide and Aluminum powder Ammonium Perchlorate (AP) Methanol; Teti-ahydrofurane (THF); Poly (1,3-Bis- (azidomethyl)-methyl Oxetane) (Poly(BAMO), PB); Poly(l- azidomethyl-S-methyl Oxetane (AMMO)) (Poly(AMMO), PA); Poly(l-nitromethyl-3-methyl Oxetane) (Poly(NMMO), PN); Glycidal Azide Polymer (GAP-multiftinctional); Toluene Diisocyanate; Di-butyl-tin-di-laurate; 1,4-Butane- diol; ETPE (Various hardblock-softblock); Xylene; Toulene; Ethyl Acetate; Glycidal Azide Polymer (GAP) Acetone; Ethyl acetate; Toluene; Methylene chloride; Methyl chloroform; Oxetanes: AMMO (S-azidomethyl 3- methyl oxetane), BAMO (3,3-bis (azidomethyl) oxetane), NMMO (S-Niti-ato methyl, 3-methyl oxetane), PolyAMMO, PolyBAMO See Table 3 Methanol; Methylene Chloride; 1 ,S-Bis-(azidomethyl)- methyl Oxetane (BAMO); 1-azidomethyl-3-methyl Oxetane (AMMO); l-nitromethyl-3-methyl Oxetane (NMMO); Poly(BAMO); Poly(AMMO); Poly(BAMO-co-AMMO); Poly(BAMO-co-NMMO); Poly(NMMO); Diphenyl-tin- dichloride; 1,4-Butane-diol Iron Linoleate or Linseed Fatty Acid TABLE 3 Reactive Group G, Profile Number PR53 Reactive & Unstable lab waste chemicals / Burned List 2,4,6-Trifluoronitrobenzene CAS #315-14-0 2-Nitroethanol CAS # 625-48-9 Tetranitromethane CAS # 509-14-8 Acryloyl Chloride 96% CAS # 814-68-6 4-Nitrobenzenediazcnium Tetrauoroborate CAS # 456-27-9 OB/OD Waste Characterization Page 8 of 22 TABLES Reactive Group G, Profile Number PR53 Reactive & Unstable lab waste chemicals / Burned List Iron Pentacarbonyl CAS # 13463-40-6 lodotrimethylsilane 97% CAS # 16029-98-4 Nitrosylsulfuric Acid, CA 95% CAS # 7782-78-7 1,4-Dioxane, 99+% CAS # 123-91-1 4-Nitroaniline CAS # 100-01-6 Sec-Butyllithium, 1.3M Solution In Cyclohexane CAS # 598-30-1 6,6-Dimethylfulvene, 99% CAS 2175-91-9 lodotrimethylsilane, 97% CAS # 16029-98-4 Methyllithium, low Chloride, 1.6 M CAS # 917-54-4 In Diethyl Ether CAS # 60-29-7 Isoprene, 99% Cas # 78-79-5 Propargyl Alcohol 99% CAS # 107-19-7 Butyllithium, 2.5M Solution In Hexanes CAS # 109-72-8 Lithium Aluminum Hydride, Powder, 95% CAS # 16853-85-3 Sodium Hydride, 60% in Mineral Oil CAS # 7646-69-7 Cyanuric Chloride, 99% CAS # 108-77-0 Succinyl Chloride, 95% CAS # 543-20-4 Sodium Peroxide CAS # 1313-60-6 Diethlyzinc, 15 wt. % (1.1m) Solution In Toluene CAS # 577-20-0 Silver Perchlorate Hydrate CAS # 14242-05-8 Ethylmagnesium Bromide, 3.0m Soiurion In Diethyl Ether CAS # 652-90-6 2,4-Dinitroanisole, 98% CAS # 119-27-7 2,4-Dinitrophmol CAS #51-28-5 2-4-Dinitrophenylhydrazine, 97% Moistened With Water CAS # 119-26-6 Lithium Borohydride, 95% CAS #16949-15-8 Sodium Ethoxide, 96% CAS # 141-52-6 Triethyloxonium Tetrafluoroborate, 1.0m Soiurion In Dichloromethane CAS # 386-39-8 Boron Trifluoride Ethylamine Complex CAS # 75-23-0 Collodion, Flexible, U.S.?. CAS # 9004-70-0 ( Niri-ocellulose) CAS # 60-29-7 ( Diethyl Ether) Aluminum Iodide, Anhydrous, Powder, CAS # Aluminum 7429-90-5 CAS # Iodide 7553-56-2 Potassium Borohydride, 98% CAS #13762-51-1 Calcium Hypochlorite CAS # 7778-54-3 Potash, Sulfurated CAS # 39365-88-3 Dodecaoyl Peroxide CAS # 105-75-8 Decahydronaphthalene, Anhydrous, 99+% CAS #91-17-8 Sodium Hypophosphite CAS #7681-53-0 Acrylic Acrylate CAS # 3667-52-5 Ammonium Iodide CAS # 12027-06-4 Potassium Iodide CAS # 7681-11-0 Potassium Tert-Butoxide CAS # 856-47-4 Ethyl Ether CAS # 60-29-70 Barium Azide CAS # 18810-58-7 Iminodiacetonitrile CAS # 628-87-5 OB/OD Waste Characterization Page 9 of 22 TABLE 3 Reactive Group G, Profile Number PR53 Reactive & Unstable lab waste chemicals / Burned List Phosphours Trichloride CAS # 7719-12-2 2,5-Dimethyl-2,5-di-(benzoylperoxy) Hexane CAS #2618-77-1 PSAN CAS # 33363-00-7 ( Zinc Diammine Dinin-ate) CAS # 6484-52-2 (Ammonium Nitrate) Nickle (II) Perchlorate, Hexahydrate CAS # 13520-61-1 2,2'-Azobis(2-methylpropionitrile), 98% CAS # 78-67-1 Borane-tetrahydrofuran Complex CAS #14044-65-6 Titanium (IV) Chloride, 99.9 % CAS # 7550-45-0 Trigonox ( Organic Peroxides / Alkyl Peroxides) CAS # 995-33-5 VUL-CUP 40KE ( Organic Peroxide) CAS # 25155-25-3 Hydrogen Peroxide 30% CAS # 7722-84-1 Lupersol 231 (Organic Peroxide) CAS # 6731-36-8 l,l-Di-(tert-butylperoxy)cyclohexane CAS # 3006-86-8 Varox DBPH 50 CAS # 78-63-7 ( Peroxide) Tert-Butyl Perbenzoate CAS # 614-45-9 Di-Cup 40KE CAS # 80-43-3 ( Organic Peroxide) Vamox 130 XL CAS #1068-27-5 ( Organic Peroxide) MEK Peroxide CAS #1338-23-4 Dibenzyl Peroxide CAS # 94-36-0 TABLE 4 Acronym List Acronym AND /iMMO Description Ammonium Dinitramide 1-azidomethyl-3-methyl Oxetane AN /VP BAMO Ammonium Nitrate BDNPA/F CL-20 Ammonium Perchlorate 1,3-Bis-(azidomethyl)-methyl Oxetane bis-(2,2-dinitropropyl) acetal/formal gun propellant (trade secret) CXM-3 RDX + Dioctyl Maleate DBTDL DDI Dibutyl Tin Dil urate Aliphatic Diisocyanate OB/OD Waste Characterization Page 10 of 22 1 1 1 1 i Acronym DDNP DMP DOA DOS DOZ DPPDA ERL0510 ETPE GAP HA (PBAA) Polymer HB (PBAN) HC (CTPB) Polymer HDI HMX HTPB Polymer IDP IPDI KDN KNOS KP MA MNA N-100 N-S200 TABI Acrony LE4 mL ; i 1 i OB/OD Waste Cha Page 11 0 ist Description Diazodinitrophenol Dimethyl phalate Dioctyl Adipate Dioctyl Sebacate i 2-Ethyl-4-methylimidzaoIe N, N'-Bis( 1,4-dimethyl pentyl) para- ' phenylenediamine AralditeMY0510 ! 1 Energetic Thermoplastic Elastomer Glycidal Azide Polymer Polybutadiene Acrylic Acid Polymer Polybutadiene Acrylic Acid Acrylonitrile Polymer HYCAR CTPB 2000X172 Polymer 1,6-Hexamethylene Diisocyanate cyclotetramethylene tetranitramine Hydroxyl Temiinated Polybutadiene Isodecyl Pelargonate Isophorone Diisocyanate Potassium Dinitramide Potassium Nitrate Potassium Perchlorate Maleic Anhydride 1 racte F22 n-methyl p-nitroaniline CyanamerN-100 Polyacrylamide Methylene Chloride N-S200 Solution rization , 1 i Acronym NaNOS NDPA NMMO ODI PBNA R45M RDX TDPA TEPAN TEPANOL TET THF TMXDI TPB TPTC TABLE 4 Acronym List 1 Description Sodium Nitrate Nitrodiphenylamine l-nitromethyl-3-methyl Oxetane Octadecyl isocyanate Phenyl-beta-napthylamine Poly BD R45M Cyclotrimethylene h-initramine Thi odiphenylamine j Partially cyanoacrylated tetraethylenepentamine TetraethylenepPentamine acrylonitrile glycidol reaction product TMXDI Triethylenetetramine Tetrahydrofurane (meta) Aliphatic Isocyanate Triphenyl Bismuth Triphenyl Tin Chloride Nearly all buming is conducted at M-136. During calendar years 2003 and 2004, the total waste bumed at M-225 was 17,000 pounds, while at M-136 nearly 5 million pounds was bumed during the same period. M-225 activity represents less than one percent of the total open buming conducted at our Promontory plant and is not significantly different fi-om the type of waste bumed at M-136. Accordingly, we will focus the remainder ofthis discussion upon further characterization ofthe waste bumed at M-136. Charts 1 through 8 compare the total waste bumed at M-136 (excluding contaminated trash, which is approximately 5% ofthe total bumed) with the amount of each reactive category bumed. The charts show the date each bum was conducted and the amount of waste bumed that day. The period charted is fi-om January 2003 through June 2005. Data prior to 2003 was excluded from this analysis due to the questionable categorization of waste bumed. OB/OD Waste Characterization Page 12 of 22 < a. 3 2 CD T- t « 1> ^ -) cu n S 1^ O 0. B o 1-I o 'C !> is <N (J r2 =0 CO ^ OH Q o o (0 6 CD 3 o 3 CQ OJ .o \ _o cfl _N 'C <u ^ ° « Cfl ^^ a o m o u c N . .—I Ul ID Cfl <N tfl cfl Q O o o c oo o o CO o o o o •>*• Q C!> CM o o c-l o Q o oo o e—1 CO O o o o •* o o c^ CM ra CL T3 E m D. UJ Q. 3 .o \ C _o "cfl N •c IU ^ <.i-i ^^ uo 00 t^ cfl Q O o Q Q 00 0 0 0 0 (D ^ 0 ^ 0 0 0 0 CM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 Q Q CO 0 0 0 •t 0 in r m o _o Cfl 'C <U Cfl (N 52 <>o W cfl Q m o ooo ooo ooo ooo 00 CO •* ' • . I • E '*&.;' S002/8/9 n o 3 CO Q. UJ Q. s o !i e o cfl N Ul <U Cfl cfl c; <u .4—* ") cfl i^ Q P ffl 0 fN fN 0 00 (U hi) fn CU h- •c Ch a o O. o 6 T3 <D E 3 m CL LU OL ro b 1- \ C o cfl N u, U r. Cfl u Cfl JZ o (U Cfl Cfl -< <N CN 'i 1 O Os (1> w Cfl OH Q O ffl O 00 t: o I— il c o cfl N Ul O r) cfl u cfl U (U cn cfl ^ Q O ffl O fN fN 'i , O o <N ID nn cfl OL, o o o o oo o o o o to o o o o o o o o CM o o o o o o o o o 00 ooo ooo ooo ooo CO •* CM As can be seen from the charts. Reactivity Group A accounts for the vast majority of the waste bumed and will dominate the risk assessment. The contribution of other reactivity groups to the risk assessment will be limited to specific toxic concems that are not already addressed by the Group A category. Additionally, the impact from open buming the heavy metals listed in Table 5 will be addressed. These metals have either been bumed in the past or may be bumed in the future. Molybdenum was intentionally left off the list because its open buming is prohibited under a consent decree. Table 5 Potential Metals Arsenic Barium Cadmium Cesium Chromium Cobalt Lead Mercury Selenium Silver The relative amount bumed at each M-136 bum station is shown in Chart 9. This chart illustrates the percentage of total material bumed at each of the 14 bum stations for the five-year period beginning in January 2000 and ending in December 2004. OB/OD Waste Characterization Page 21 of 22 ra in o> ** o t 3? f^ J E o "^§ CQ c., 'w c .2 n g I u cfl CN • <« O Ea U CN CN c« Cfl o •.^ iS CO 3=; (D CM C o ra ^p &^ CO CO CO g ^ CO B CO cfl Q O g