HomeMy WebLinkAboutDSHW-2018-004921 - 0901a06880834592„,,, Linagement
and Raciation Controi
Stantec Stantec Consulting Services inc.
3995 South 700 East; Ste 300 Salt Lake City, UT 84107
Tel: (801) 261-0090 Fax: (801) 266-1671
tv1AY 3 1 2018
V-HIAF201 0-0045)2 /
May 25, 2018
Mr. Hao Zhu
Utah Department of Environmental Quality
Division of Waste Management and Radiation Control
195 North 1950 West
Salt Lake City, UT 84114
RE: Phytoremediation Pilot Study Work Plan
Former Varian Facility, 1678 Pioneer Road, Salt Lake City, Utah 84104
Dear Mr. Zhu,
On Behalf of Varian Medical Systems (Varian), Stantec Consulting Services, Inc. (Stantec), has
prepared the following Phytoremediation Pilot Study Work Plan (Work Plan) for the Former Varian
Facility property (now Varex Imaging) at 1678 Pioneer Road, Salt Lake City, Utah (the Site). Site
preparation, tree plantings, and irrigation system installation were completed at the Site the week
of May 30, 2018. The installation of additional monitoring wells and performance monitoring will be
initiated following Utah Department of Environmental Quality, Division of Waste Management and
Radiation Control's (DWMRC's) approval of the Work Plan.
Should you have any questions or comments on the Work Plan or to set up a conference call
following the DWMRC's review of the Work Plan, please call me at (801) 230-6646.
Sincerely,
----rif7014144 `iktatrz/
Tom Fendler
Senior Geologist
Stantec
3995 South 700 East Suite 300, Salt Lake City UT 84107-2540
Phone: (801) 743-4843
Cell: (801) 230-6646
Tom.Fendler@stantec.com
Design with community in mind
5
Mr. Hao Zhu
February 21, 2018
Page 2 of 2
C: Scott T. Anderson UDEQ (2 copies)
John Buchanan VMS (by email)
H. Michael Keller VanCott. Bagley and McCarthy (by email)
Angus McGrath Stantec (by email)
Design with community in mind
PHYTOREMEDIATION PILOT STUDY
WORK PLAN
Former Varian Medical Systems Facility
1678 Pioneer Road
Salt Lake City, Utah
May 25, 2018
Prepared for:
Hao Zhu
Division of Waste Management and
Radiation Control
Utah Department of Environmental Quality
195 North 1950 West, Second Floor
Salt Lake City, Utah
Prepared by:
Stantec Consulting Services, Inc.
3995 South 700 East, Suite 300
Salt Lake City, Utah
Sign-off Sheet
This document entitled Phytoremediation Pilot Study Work Plan was prepared by Stantec Consulting Services Inc.
(“Stantec”) for the account of Varian Medical Systems (the “Client”). Any reliance on this document by any third party is
strictly prohibited. The material in it reflects Stantec’s professional judgment in light of the scope, schedule and other
limitations stated in the document and in the contract between Stantec and the Client. The opinions in the document are
based on conditions and information existing at the time the document was published and do not take into account any
subsequent changes. In preparing the document, Stantec did not verify information supplied to it by others. Any use which
a third party makes of this document is the responsibility of such third party. Such third party agrees that Stantec shall not
be responsible for costs or damages of any kind, if any, suffered by it or any other third party as a result of decisions made
or actions taken based on this document.
Prepared by
(signature)
Anna Skinner, EIT
Engineering Staff
Reviewed by
(signature)
Thomas Fendler, PG
Senior Geologist
Reviewed by
(signature)
Angus McGrath
Principal Geochemist
PHYTOREMEDIATION PILOT STUDY WORK PLAN
Table of Contents
1.0 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................ 1
1.1 SITE HISTORY .............................................................................................................. 1
1.2 SITE SPECIFIC CONDITIONS ....................................................................................... 1
1.3 PILOT STUDY OBJECTIVES ......................................................................................... 2
2.0 DESIGN ......................................................................................................................... 2
3.0 IMPLEMENTATION ....................................................................................................... 3
3.1 SITE PREPARATION ..................................................................................................... 3
3.2 TREE PLANTINGS......................................................................................................... 3
3.3 IRRIGATION SYSTEM ................................................................................................... 3
3.4 OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE ............................................................................... 4
4.0 SCHEDULE.................................................................................................................... 4
5.0 PERFORMANCE MONITORING ................................................................................... 4
6.0 REPORTING .................................................................................................................. 5
7.0 MAINTENANCE OF SITE MANAGEMENT OBJECTIVES ............................................ 5
LIST OF TABLES
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1 – Site Vicinity Map Figure 2 – Phytoremediation Pilot Study Area Groundwater Monitoring Wells
LIST OF APPENDICES
Appendix A – Utah Department of Environmental Quality, Division of Waste Management and Remediation Control,
Electronic Correspondence
Appendix B – Sand-Creek Consulting, Inc. Phytoremediation Pilot Study Design and Planting Plan
PHYTOREMEDIATION PILOT STUDY WORK PLAN
Former Varian Medical Systems Facility
1
1.0 INTRODUCTION
This Phytoremediation Pilot Study Work Plan for the Former Varian Medical Systems (Varian) Facility located at 1678
Pioneer Road in Salt Lake City, Utah (the Site, Figure 1) was prepared in accordance with the remedial objectives
described in electronic communication with the Utah Department of Environmental Quality (UDEQ) Division of Waste
Management and Radiation Control (DWMRC) included as Appendix A. This work plan describes the remedial
objectives and methods for the implementation and evaluation of a phytoremediation pilot study at the Site.
1.1 SITE HISTORY
The first documented construction on the Site took place in 1941 as a Department of Defense facility which was known
as the Utah Ordnance Plant. The current Varex Imaging (Varex) building is used to manufacture X-ray products; its
footprint is the result of several additions with the most recent completed in 2016.
Initial soil and groundwater investigations at the Site were conducted between 1983 and 1991 by JH Kleinfelder and
Associates. Additional investigations and a risk assessment were completed by Montgomery Watson between 1991
and 1997. In April 2009 and October 2010, vapor intrusion studies were conducted to evaluate the potential risk of
vapors from volatile organic compounds (VOCs) to migrate into the Varian building as well as five buildings located on
the adjacent US Construction property, north of the property. In 2013, Stantec conducted additional characterization of
the Northern and Western Plume areas (see Figure 2).
Remediation activities began at the Site in 1994 with an interim remedial measure to initiate groundwater extraction
and treatment of the trichloroethene (TCE) plume; a full-scale groundwater extraction and treatment system was
implemented in 2000. In late 2007, a dual phase extraction and soil vapor extraction system was installed immediately
adjacent to the west side of the Varian building to address a TCE "hot spot". Semiannual groundwater monitoring is
ongoing.
A complete site history is presented in the Third Five-Year Review Report, July 2010 – June 2015 document dated
March 23, 2016.
1.2 SITE SPECIFIC CONDITIONS
Soils observed in the Western Plume pilot study area generally consist of poorly and well graded sands with occasional
silty sand or silt lenses to approximately 13 feet below ground surface (bgs). Clay with sandy and silty clay lenses are
observed from approximately 13 to 18 feet bgs, and a highly, plastic, dense clay with silty sand lenses are observed
from approximately 18 to 30 feet bgs.
Two distinct hydrogeological groundwater zones exist: an unconfined, "shallow" zone in the deposits above the silty
clay which extend from approximately 13 to 18 feet bgs and a semiconfined, "intermediate" zone in the sand beneath
the silty clay which extends from approximately 18 to 30 feet bgs. A relatively strong upward vertical gradient exists
between the shallow and intermediate zones. Horizontal flow in the shallow groundwater is generally to the north-
northwest. The static water level is approximately seven to 12 feet bgs.
PHYTOREMEDIATION PILOT STUDY WORK PLAN
Former Varian Medical Systems Facility
2
Two separated TCE plumes are present including the on-Site Western Plume and the off-Site Northern Plume located
on the US Construction Property (Figure 1). A Utah Power and Light right-of-way is located west of the Site and is
downgradient of the Western Plume. The US Construction and Shimizu properties are located north of the Site. The
US Construction property is occupied by several businesses, including automobile and truck maintenance shops, a
reconditioning shop for wooden pallets, general storage buildings, and an automobile impoundment lot run by the Salt
Lake City Police Department. The Shimizu property is located downgradient from the Northern Plume and is primarily
utilized for truck maintenance activities. Hydraulic containment of the TCE plume on the west side of the site is
controlled by the West Extraction Trench and a slurry wall which protects the flood control ditch located on the western
property boundary between the Site and the Utah Power and Light right-of-way. Hydraulic containment of the TCE
plume to the north of the site is controlled by the North Extraction Trench.
1.3 PILOT STUDY OBJECTIVES
The two main objectives of the Phytoremediation Pilot Study are to evaluate:
1) relative performance (growth, health, and water uptake) of the six varieties of hybrid cottonwood trees given
the Site-specific conditions, and
2) overall performance of phytoremediation at reducing concentrations of TCE in groundwater and reducing the
mass flux of TCE (all volatile organic compounds, VOCs) through the phytoremediation area.
Phytoremediation will be considered a successful technology for the Site if full scale implementation is proven capable
of replacing the Western Trench by preventing the off-Site migration of the TCE plume.
2.0 DESIGN
The pilot study area is located in the distal portion of the Western Plume and is approximately 80 feet wide by 250 feet
long (Appendix B – Figure 2). Six varieties of hybrid cottonwoods will be planted, each with 15 replicates (90 total
trees to be planted). These six varieties include:
• one pure eastern cottonwood, Populus deltoides, variety siouxland;
• one pure western cottonwood Populous fremontii;
• two varieties of P. deltoides X P. trichocarpa crosses: 15‐029 and 50‐197; and
• two varieties of P. deltoides X P. nigra crosses: OP367 and DN21.
The siouxland and Western cottonwood trees will all be males and will not produce cotton. The remaining varieties are
sterile species crosses. Each variety will be planted in one row (six rows of 15 trees) with approximately 15 feet
between the centerlines of each tree; the centerline of each row will be spaced 15 feet apart (see Appendix B – Figure
3). A complete design package for the phytoremediation pilot plantation is included in Appendix B.
PHYTOREMEDIATION PILOT STUDY WORK PLAN
Former Varian Medical Systems Facility
3
3.0 IMPLEMENTATION
The following section provides a description of the planned implementation.
3.1 SITE PREPARATION
Existing asphalt and asphalt grindings will be removed from the pilot study area leaving bare ground for implementation.
Under the supervision of Sand-Creek Consulting, Inc. (Sand-Creek) 90 individual tree wells will be installed. ET
Technologies will drill and backfill boreholes under the supervision of Sand-Creek. Stantec will provide two technicians
to aid with installation. An excavator mounted solid-stem auger will be used to advance 12-inch diameter boreholes to
a minimum depth of 15 feet bgs up to a maximum completion depth of 20 feet bgs, as soil conditions allow, with the
intent of installing the borehole terminus into the confining clay layer beneath the shallow saturated zone (see Appendix
B – Figure 4). Borehole spoils will be distributed around each boring and leveled (it is assumed the spoils will not
contain VOCs above regulatory limits). The tree wells will be backfilled with a mix of three parts sand to one part yard
waste compost. The yard waste compost will be sourced from the Salt Lake Valley Landfill. During backfill, three to
ten gallons of water will be added to eliminate bridging and void space in the backfill material.
A single one-half inch diameter by 3 to 6 foot long section of Schedule 80 PVC pipe will be installed along the side of
each borehole (see Appendix B – Figure 4); final pipe length will correspond with the length of tree cutting placed in
each borehole. This drop pipe will be used to provide irrigation water at depth in order to encourage deeper root
propagation towards contaminated groundwater instead of root growth near the soil surface.
3.2 TREE PLANTINGS
Both cottonwood varieties (Siouxland and fremonti) will be planted as 1 to 3-foot long rooted stock. The deltoides x
trichocarpa (DT) varieties will be planted as 2 foot long cuttings, and the deltoides x nigra (DN) varieties will be planted
as 5 to 7 foot long cuttings. Each planted tree will be completed with a 3‐foot square of weed‐stop fabric installed
around its base. The fabric will be held in place with steel sod staples.
Sand-Creek will remove and replant any trees that have not sprouted within three to four weeks after the initial planting.
3.3 IRRIGATION SYSTEM
Following planting, LLDPE irrigation lines will be buried in a shallow 2 to 4 inch deep trench along each tree row. As
needed, sod staples will be used to anchor the irrigation lines prior to burial by surrounding soil.
Appropriately sized drip emitters will be installed on the irrigation lines at each tree location. The discharge volume
and number of drip emitters will be determined based on the available water source or irrigation pump. One quarter‐inch
diameter drip lines will be used to discharge water from the drip emitters into the previously installed Schedule 80 PVC
drop pipes or to the ground surface depending on the planting depth of the tree stock. As the smaller tree stock matures
the drip lines will be transferred from surface irrigation to the drop pipes. Each irrigation line will connect to a 1.25‐inch
polyethylene pipe (see Appendix A – Figure 5).
PHYTOREMEDIATION PILOT STUDY WORK PLAN
Former Varian Medical Systems Facility
4
An irrigation header including air relief valve, filter, and flow meter will be installed on the south-central edge of the pilot
study area within a treated plywood or plastic box. The upstream and downstream ends of the irrigation header will be
fitted with cam‐lock connectors to allow for easy removal for maintenance at the end of the irrigation season. A
matching cam‐lock connector will be provided for the water supply or irrigation pump outlet. Irrigation water will be
provided by a deep irrigation well located in the southeast corner of the Site. The irrigation system layout is shown in
Appendix B – Figure 3 and details of the irrigation system are presented on Appendix B – Figure 5.
3.4 OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE
The trees composing the Phytoremediation Pilot Study will require extra care, especially throughout the first two growing
seasons. Maintenance will include: mowing; monitoring trees for proper growth, removal of competing species, and
pests; and monitoring operation of the irrigation system. The irrigation system will be connected to a timer which will
initially be programmed to water the trees twice per night for a period of 45 minutes per watering. The watering schedule
may increase or decrease as needed to maintain optimal growth. The intent is that over time the root system penetrates
the saturated zone and the trees are self-sustaining and do not need regular watering. The trees will be inspected
during weekly operation and maintenance (O&M) events which Suburbia performs for the groundwater extraction and
treatment system.
4.0 SCHEDULE
Installation of the plantation was completed during the week of April 30, 2018. The planting schedule was chosen in
order to ensure that cuttings have a higher success and lower mortality rate. Installation of three monitoring wells as
detailed in Section 5, will proceed following UDEQ approval of this work plan.
5.0 PERFORMANCE MONITORING
Three groundwater monitoring wells will be installed after tree planting has been completed. The locations of the
monitoring wells is shown on Figure 2. The monitoring wells will be installed to 20 feet bgs and will be completed with
2-inch diameter PVC, fifteen feet of 0.01 inch slotted well screen, PVC riser, and a stick-up well completion anchored
with an approximate 18-inch diameter concrete well pad.
Two soil samples will be collected during the installation of each monitoring well and submitted for analysis of VOCs.
During the June or December 2018 semi-annual groundwater monitoring event, baseline groundwater samples will be
collected from the three new monitoring wells collocated with tree wells.
Performance monitoring will be performed on the new monitoring wells to evaluate diurnal drop in groundwater elevation
in the immediate vicinity of the co-located trees. Monitoring wells EW-39R, MW-37, MW-17, PZ-10 and PZ-11 in
addition to the three new monitoring wells will be evaluated for changes in water elevation and a reduction in TCE
concentrations. Subsequent groundwater samples will be collected annually during the regularly scheduled Spring
PHYTOREMEDIATION PILOT STUDY WORK PLAN
Former Varian Medical Systems Facility
5
semi-annual sampling events and during the Winter semi-annual events once trees have become established and
water levels indicate signs of groundwater containment.
6.0 REPORTING
An installation letter report will be prepared and submitted to the UDEQ-DWMRC which summarizes the as-built
completion details of the pilot study and the monitoring and maintenance plan approximately 6 weeks after completion
of tree planting and performance monitoring well installation. The results of monitoring and maintenance will be reported
in semi-annual monitoring and maintenance reports.
A final pilot study letter report will be prepared after approximately 1 to 2 years dependent on the rate of tree growth
and evidence of TCE attenuation and/or hydraulic containment. The report will include:
• Summary of activities after installation;
• Descriptions of tree growth, health, and establishment of the rooting zone in the perched zone;
• Evaluation of groundwater elevation, TCE concentration trends, and evidence for biodegradation; and
• Recommendations for full-scale implementation.
7.0 MAINTENANCE OF SITE MANAGEMENT OBJECTIVES
Containment of the VOC Western Plume will continue to be achieved through hydraulic containment of shallow
groundwater throughout the Phytoremediation Pilot Study in accordance with the Site Remediation Plan which requires
operation of the Western Trench. Pilot study data will be evaluated to assess reliability of hydraulic containment with
full-scale phytoremediation implementation.
FIGURES
MW-02R MW-06MW-10 MW-12
MW-13
MW-20
MW-24
MW-29
MW-32
PZ-05
PZ-07
PZ-08
PZ-09PZ-10
PZ-11
PZ-12
MW-37
MW-38
D-2
D-3
BM
Varian MedicalSalt Lake CityFacility
D-B
MW-15A
MW-16
MWD-2
MW-19
SVE-3
SVE-2
SVE-1
SVE-4
West Trench Sump
MW-36MW-34
D-C
D-D
MW-04
MW-35 MW-17
MW-41
MW-31PZ-06
MW-25
MW-26R
NorthTrenchSump
MW-30
MW-40
MW-33
MW-14
MW-27MW-28PZ-01
PZ-03
MW-44
MW-42
MW-43
MW-05
MW-18
PZ-17
PZ-16
Shimizu Truck Maintenance Building
D-A
EW-39R
D-1
Pioneer Road
1700South
µ
0 70 140
Scale in Feet
EXPLANATION
G (A
TE
TE !@
#Ç
Ditch sample
Piezometer
SVE well
Slurry wall
Monitoring well
Extraction well
Trench sump
Extraction trench
SlurryWall
WestExtractionTrench
26 Apr 2018
Building 3
US Construction Properties
Shimizu Property
VarexImagingProperty
C:\Data\MWH\VARIAN\Fig 1_SiteMap_26Apr2018.mxd
Building 2
Building 5
Building 4
Building 1
EnvironmentalTreatmentSystem
NorthExtractionTrench
EnvironmentalTreatmentSystem
DRAWN BY D. Severson
Aerial Photography: 8 July 2016 FIGURE 1
SITE MAP
PhytoremediationPilot Study Area(SEE FIGURE 2)
MW-20
PZ-08
MW-37
MW-38
MWD-2
PZ-17
EW-39R
PZ-10
PZ-11
µ
0 20 40
Scale in Feet
Aerial Photography: 15 Jun 2017
26 Apr 2018
C:\Data\MWH\VARIAN\Fig 2_Phytoremediation Pilot Study_26Apr2018.mxd
DRAWN BY D. Severson
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
PZ-09
MW-17
FIGURE 2
PHYTOREMEDIATION PILOTSTUDY AREA GROUNDWATERMONITORING WELLS
Siouxland hybrid cottonwood (all males)
OP367 hybrid cottonwood (sterile)
15-029 hybrid cottonwood (sterile)
DN21 hybrid cottonwood (sterile)
50-197 hybrid cottonwood (sterile)
Western cottonwood (all males)
Proposed monitoring well
Monitoring well
Piezometer
Extraction well
Slurry wall
Extraction trench
(A
TE
#Ç
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
nm
15' TYP
End of 0.710"OD LLDPE lines
From watersource
1.25" SDR21 PE
#*#*
1.25"flushvalve
1.25" to 0.710"OD LLDPE lineconnections
End of 0.710"OD LLDPE lines
15' TYP
TE
(A
MW-45(P)MW-46(P)
MW-47(P)
APPENDIX A
Utah Department of Environmental Quality, Division of Waste Management and
Remediation Control, Electronic Correspondence
From:Hao Zhu
To:Fendler, Thomas
Cc:John Buchanan (John.Buchanan@varian.com); McGrath, Angus; Brad Maulding
Subject:Re: Varian Phytoremediation Pilot Study
Date:Thursday, March 01, 2018 2:31:25 PM
Tom, it appears that the research paper supports a pilot test of phytoremediation at the Varexsite. We encourage implementation of innovative technologies that may be cost effective and
expedite the long term site management obligations. A work plan for the pilot study shouldconsider the following:
1) A sound and reliable performance monitoring should be designed.
2) The site specific conditions that are not presented in the research paper may vary at theVarex site.
3) Any innovative approaches to be applied the Varex site must not compromise the overallsite management objectives that ensure effective groundwater containment and acceptable risk
to all receptors.
Given the anticipated implementation schedule, please let me know when you would submit awork plan. Please contact me if you have any questions.
Thanks,Hao
On Wednesday, February 28, 2018, Fendler, Thomas <Tom.Fendler@stantec.com> wrote:
Hao,
Thanks for taking time out of your day to discuss this Pilot Test with me. As discussed we would
like your feedback on a pilot study to evaluate 1) the effectiveness of Phytoremediation and
2) the most successful poplar tree varieties at the site. For this to be a successful application it
is essential for the installation happen by early May in order for the trees to develop roots prior
to the onset of high temperatures in the summer. We have already completed a good bit of
planning and have a Phytoremediation vender lined up to assist with the project.
Attached are a research paper and presentation which describes an approach which is very
similar to what we are proposing. I also attached Stantec’s proposal which provides somedetails of the scope and execution for the pilot study.
Please get back to us today or tomorrow with any feedback you might have. We are
planning to send you a work plan which would provide design plans for the project.
Let me know if you’d like additional literature and I can see if our subcontractor has more
information.
Feel free to call me on my cell phone if you have any questions on this pilot study.
Tom Fendler
Senior GeologistStantec3995 South 700 East Suite 300, Salt Lake City UT 84107-2540Phone: (801) 743-4843Cell: (801) 230-6646Tom.Fendler@stantec.com
The content of this email is the confidential property of Stantec and should not be copied, modified, retransmitted, or used for any
purpose except with Stantec's written authorization. If you are not the intended recipient, please delete all copies and notify usimmediately.
ü Please consider the environment before printing this email.
--
Hao Zhu | Engineer, P.E.801.536.0249 (office) | 801.536.0222 (fax)
195 North 1950 West, Salt Lake City, UT 84116hzhu@utah.gov
Disclaimer:
Statements made in this e-mail do not constitute the official position of the Director of the Division of
Waste Management and Radiation Control. If you desire a statement of the Director's position, please
submit a written request to the address below, on paper, including documents relevant to your request. Director, Division of Waste Management and Radiation Control, P.O. Box 144880, Salt Lake City, Utah84114-4880.
APPENDIX B
Sand-Creek Consulting, Inc.
Phytoremediation Pilot Study Design and Planting Plan
Sand Creek Consultants, Inc. Page 1 of 3
March 29, 2018
Mr. Tom Fendler
Stantec, Inc.
3995 South 700 East, Suite 300
Salt Lake City, UT 84107
Re: Former Varian Facility
1678 Pioneer Road
Salt Lake City, Utah
Subject: Phytoremediation Pilot Study Design and Planting Plan
Dear Mr. Fendler:
The following text and enclosures constitute our design document for the plant‐based remediation pilot
study at the Former Varian Facility located at 1678 Pioneer Road in Salt Lake City, which is shown on
Figure 1. The location of the pilot planting on the parcel is shown on Figure 2.
The pilot study will be a trial planting of 6 varieties of hybrid cottonwood trees. The purpose of the pilot
study is to determine what varieties will grow best at this location which has somewhat saline
groundwater.
The pilot will include a sub‐surface drip irrigation system that can provide supplemental water during
the first year or two of growth while the trees are establishing root systems down to the capillary fringe.
Required Site Preparations
Existing asphalt and asphalt grindings will need to be removed from the pilot study planting area. The
surface can be gravel and/or mineral soil and should be leveled.
Tree Plantings
Tree plantings will consist of six varieties of hybrid cottonwoods including one pure eastern cottonwood
Populus deltoides, variety Siouxland; one pure western cottonwood P. trichocarpa or fremontii; two
varieties of P. deltoides X P. trichocarpa crosses: 15‐029 and 50‐197; and two varieties of P. deltoides X
P. nigra crosses: OP367 and DN21.
The Siouxland and western cottonwoods will all be males and will not produce cotton. The remaining
varieties are sterile species crosses.
Each tree variety will be replicated 15 times, with a total of 90 trees planted.
Prior to planting, a 12‐inch diameter by 15‐ to 20‐foot deep borehole will be advanced with a solid‐stem auger
mounted to an tempexcavator. Attempts will be made to drill boreholes up to 20 feet in depth; however, final
boring depths will be determined in the field based upon the capabilities of the operator to reach the target
Mr. Tom Fendler/Stantec, Inc.
Phytoremediation Pilot Study Design and Planting Plan
Salt Lake City, Utah March 2018
Sand Creek Consultants, Inc. Page 2 of 3
boring depths will be determined in the field based upon the capabilities of the operator to reach the target
depths and soil conditions such as the ability for the borehole to remain open. Spoil from each boring will be
distributed around the borehole and leveled by tillage.
Each borehole will be backfilled with a mix of 3 parts sand to 1 part yard waste compost. The yard waste
compost will be sourced from the Salt Lake Valley Landfill. During backfilling, 3 to 10 gallons of water
will be added to eliminate bridging and void space in the backfill material.
A single ½‐inch diameter by 3‐ to 6‐foot long length of Schedule 80 PVC pipe will be installed along the
side of each hole, depending on cutting length. This pipe will be used to provide irrigation water at
depth.
The cottonwoods will be planted as 3‐ to 4‐foot long rooted stock. The deltoides x trichocarpa (DT)
varieties will be planted as 2‐foot long cuttings and the deltoides x nigra (DN) varieties planted as 5‐ to
7‐foot long cuttings.
All trees will have a 3‐ by 3‐foot square of weed‐stop fabric installed around its base. The fabric will be
held with steel sod staples.
The proposed planting layout is presented on Figure 3 and planting details are shown on Figure 4.
Three to four weeks after the initial tree planting, Sand Creek will remove and replant any trees that
have not sprouted.
Irrigation System
After tree planting is completed, 0.710‐inch OD LLDPE irrigation lines will be laid along each tree row
and buried in a shallow 2‐ to 4‐inch deep trench. As needed, sod staples will be used to anchor the
irrigation lines prior to burial by local spoil.
Appropriately sized drip emitters will be installed on the line at each tree location. The discharge
volume and number of drip emitters will be determined based on the available water source or
irrigation pump. One‐quarter‐inch diameter drop lines will be used to discharge water from the
emitters into the ½‐inch x 3‐ to 6‐foot lengths of Schedule 80 PVC pipe.
Each 0.710‐inch irrigation line will connect to a 1.25‐inch polyethylene pipe using a Blazing Saddles
12500 connection. The end of each irrigation line will be closed with a plastic figure‐eight fitting.
An irrigation header including air relief valve, filter and flow meter will be installed on the south central
edge of the pilot planting within a treated plywood box. The upstream and downstream ends of the
irrigation header will be fitted with cam‐lock connectors to allow for easy removal for maintenance and
at the end of the irrigation season. A matching cam‐lock connector will be provided for the water supply
or irrigation pump outlet.
Irrigation water can be provided via a hose from the building or a mobile tank using an electric or gas
powered pump. Water supply flow and pressure requirements will be 1.5 gpm at 20 to 40 psi.
The irrigation system layout is shown on Figure 3 and details of the irrigation system are presented on
Figure 5.
Mr. Tom Fendler/Stantec, Inc.
Phytoremediation Pilot Study Design and Planting Plan
Salt Lake City, Utah March 2018
Sand Creek Consultants, Inc. Page 3 of 3
Operations and Maintenance
Living systems require extra care, especially over the first two growing seasons. This includes mowing,
monitoring trees for proper growth, competition, and pests, and monitoring the irrigation system for
proper operation. Annual start up and shutdown instructions will be provided for the irrigation system.
Conclusion
Thank you for your time and consideration of this plan. If you have any questions or concerns, please
contact me via phone at 715.365.1819 or by email at bart.sexton@sand‐creek.com. Your questions on
this matter will receive my prompt response.
Sincerely,
SAND CREEK CONSULTANTS, INC.
Bart Sexton, MS, PSS
Project Manager
Enclosures: Figures 1 through 5
Via email only
DRAWN BY:NRB
APPROVED : BTS
DATE: MARCH 2018
SCALE: 1"=2000'
20001000
SCALE IN FEET
0
SCALE:
DATE:
1"=130'
MARCH 2018
PHYTOREMEDIATION
TRIAL PLANTING SITE DRAWN BY: NRB
APPROVED BY: BTS
FORMER VARIAN FACILITY
1678 PIONEER ROAD
SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH
13065
SCALE IN FEET
0
LEGEND
SCALE:
DATE:
1"=20'
MARCH 2018
PLANTING
LAYOUT
DRAWN BY:NRB
APPROVED :BTS
2010
SCALE IN FEET
0
DETAIL 1
HYBRID POPLAR
DEEP PLANTING
DETAIL 3
PLAN VIEW
SCALE:
DATE:
AS NOTED
MARCH 2018
PLANTING DETAILS
DRAWN BY: NRB
APPROVED BY: BTS
FORMER VARIAN FACILITY
1678 PIONEER ROAD
SALT LAKE CITY, UTAH
DETAIL 2
DRIP LINE TO 1.25" 100 PSI CONNECTIONS
DETAIL 4
END OF DRIP LINES
DETAIL 3
END OF DRIP LINES
DETAIL 1
IRRIGATION SYSTEM HEADER
SCALE:
DATE:
NOT TO SCALE
MARCH 2018
IRRIGATION
DETAILS
DRAWN BY:NRB
APPROVED :BTS