DDW-2024-006004

October 13, 2023
Andrew Clark Beecher
Cinnamon Creek Rec Area
50 E North Temple St, RM 1205
Natural Resource Services
Salt Lake City, UT 84150-6320
Subject:MPA Result Notification, Spring #2 (Upper) (WS002);
Cinnamon Creek Rec Area, System #03105, File #13495
Dear Andrew Beecher:
The Division of Drinking Water (Division) suspects Spring #2 (Upper)(identified as WS002 in
the Division’s database) to be under the direct influence of surface water (UDI) based on E. coli
positive samples taken at the source.
Therefore, an initial Microscopic Particulate Analysis (MPA) sample was collected from Spring
#2 (Upper) (WS002) on September 19, 2023. The sample scored 10, which indicates a moderate
risk for being UDI. As a result,a follow-up MPA sample needs to be collected during high
surface-water runoff conditions in 2024 to determine whether Spring #2 (Upper) is UDI. Please
work with the Division to make arrangements for the follow-up MPA sampling in the spring of
2024.
Please note that:
●The Division protocol requires two consecutive low-risk MPA samples for this source to
be considered not UDI.
●This source will be classified as UDI if the result of the follow-up MPA sample in 2024
indicates moderate or high risk. Ongoing source assessment monitoring results will also be
considered in the determination.
The Division can re-evaluate this source at any time if there are circumstances that affect its
susceptibility to surface water influence. For information about UDI and MPA sampling, see the
attached UDI Definition and Possible Causes.
195 North 1950 West • Salt Lake City, UT
Mailing Address: P.O. Box 144830 • Salt Lake City, UT 84114-4830
Telephone [phone] • Fax [phone] • T.D.D. [phone]
www.deq.utah.gov
Printed on 100% recycled paper
Andrew Clark Beecher
Page 2 of 3
October 13,2023
Take one bacteriological sample per month at water source Spring #2 (Upper)(identified as
WS002 in the Division’s database)prior to treatment.The purpose of this source sampling
requirement is to gather data to evaluate the quality of this source.This source sampling
requirement shall begin November 2023 and extend at least 12 months for each month the spring
is in operation and accessible,sufficient to cover two peak (or summer)operating seasons.The
Division may evaluate the source sampling requirements after 12 months based on the data
available at that time.
Label all source samples with Spring #2 (Upper)(WS002)as the sampling location and facility
code.In a result of an E.coli positive sample,please contact Sitara Federico at [phone] or
[e-mail] within 24 hours of notification from the lab.Also,contact Sitara Federico for
any related questions to this source sampling requirement.
If you have any questions regarding this letter,please contact Sarah Page at [phone] or
Brian Pattee at [phone].
Sincerely,
Mark Berger
Monitoring and Standards Section Manager
Enclosure:Laboratory Report of MPA Sample Taken on September 19,2023
cc:Ben Harker,Bear River Health Department,[e-mail]
Cameron Draney,P.E.,Division of Drinking Water,[e-mail]
Jake Moss,System Operator,[e-mail]
Andrew Clark Beecher,Cinnamon Creek Rec Area,[e-mail]
Division of Drinking Water VSA Team,[e-mail]
DDW-2023-038776
UDI Definition and Possible Causes
A groundwater source that is Under the Direct Influence of surface water (UDI)is vulnerable to
contamination by pathogens found in surface water.This vulnerability could be because the
sub-surface formation is not sufficiently filtering water as the water percolates through the
formation or because the groundwater collection infrastructure is poorly constructed and allows
surface water to directly contaminate the groundwater.The Division of Drinking Water ’s protocol
determines and classifies a groundwater source as UDI based on one or more of the following
factors:
1.Physical evidence of source deficiencies that allow,or have the potential to allow,surface
water contamination of the source
2.MPA sampling results indicating surface water influence:
a.One high-risk MPA sample result
b.Two consecutive moderate-risk MPA sample results
c.Inconclusive MPA sample results,such as alternating low-risk and moderate-risk
results,along with other water quality data or observations of the source that
indicate potential contamination by surface water
3.Water quality data indicating contamination by surface water,for example,Escherichia
coli positive source sample results not caused by physical deficiencies,detection of
Cryptosporidium or Giardia in the source water,etc.
An MPA test (Item #2)consists of running the source water through a spiral-wound filter for a
period of time.Particles collected by the filter are extracted in a laboratory,examined under a
microscope,and identified.Particles that are expected to be found only above ground or in surface
water indicate a risk of surface water contamination.Such indicators include chlorophyll-bearing
algae,parts of flying insects,plant debris,Cryptosporidium,Giardia lamblia,etc.Some of these
indicators are not pathogens,but their presence in the source water means the source water is
susceptible to contamination by pathogens found in surface water.
An MPA sample is rated as having a low,moderate,or high risk of UDI if the score is 0-9,10–19,
or 20 and above,respectively.When basing the classification of a groundwater source on MPA
results,the Division protocol classifies a source as UDI if any MPA sample is high risk or if any
two MPA samples are moderate risk or above.
The path that surface water takes as it flows to a groundwater source can and usually does vary
with season and hydrogeological conditions.It is common for the flow path to be directly
influenced by surface water under some conditions,such as during a high surface runoff during
spring,but not to be directly influenced under others.So a surface-water-influenced water source
may have MPA sample results of various risk levels,depending on the timing of the sampling.A
true groundwater source that is not under the direct influence of surface water will always have
only low-risk MPA results.